Kakutani's Outliers

Kakutani is correct in her claim that Gladwell’s writing style and arguments in the book Outliers are ineffective due to his inadequate evidence and overly optimistic approach. She is also correct in arguing that Gladwell’s story-like style of writing makes the tragic events that he describes seem significantly less severe than they truly are. Kakutani describes Gladwell’s books as full of, “colorful anecdotes and case studies that read like entertaining little stories. Both use PowerPoint-type catchphrases [...] to plant concepts in the reader’s mind” (Kakutani). Kakutani describes the evidence that Gladwell uses as “entertaining little stories”, which has a very condescending tone, implying that she believes that the case studies used by