Preview

Lack Of Socialist Success In The 19th Century

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
852 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Lack Of Socialist Success In The 19th Century
Another explanation for the lack of socialist success was that with 80% of the population being working class and even with the many reform acts and the third reform act that added 6 million to the electorate they were still far from universal male suffrage. This would have hindered the socialist movement as it meant that there were many numbers of working class and poverty stricken men who could not vote. This is important, as these were the people that the socialist movement would want to appeal to and gain support from. This can be viewed because as male suffrage was improved in the later and early 20th century labour gained votes and became more popular.

Another reason for the limited success of socialism in the 19th century was the inefficiency
…show more content…
They failed to set out their aims clearly like the conservative party did in the later years. The SDF was ‘never clear about priorities or methods’ this meant that they had limited supporters, as it was difficult to know what they were standing for. Throughout the nineteenth century there were various socialist parties such as the Social Democratic Federation (SDF), the Socialist League and the Fabien society. Many of these socialist movements attracted intellectual middle class men but they did little to attract the workers who they were supposedly working to better. The federation was strongly opposed to the liberal party . Another failure was those socialists were too concerned with the idea of ‘making socialist’ rather than making a political party, it did not matter to the socialists what party the members were part of as long as they were members of a Socialist party. This meant that there was a limited impact because the numbers were spread of different parties. The independent labour party was another socialist group. Part of the failure of the socialist movement to unify came when the labour party supported an alliance with the trade unions rather than with the socialist movements. The labour party was gaining votes through trade unions and it is argued by Stanley Pierson that ‘Hyndman …show more content…
Hyndman, leader of the SDF was known for behaving autocratically and he did not want party policy discussion within the party . This caused activists such as John Burns and William Morris who later went on to find the Socialist league. This created a ‘fundamental division’ within socialist movements of the time. Although there were efforts to unify the socialist movement under one political organisation this failed because of the vastly different opinions. There was also the inability of the socialist movements to compromise and provide alternatives to those things that they

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Bread For All Summary

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages

    H. Pelling argue that the reforms were actually unwanted by the working class: “the extension of the power of the state at the beginning of this century, which is generally regarded as having laid the foundations of the Welfare State, was by no means welcomed by members of the working class, was indeed undertaken over the critical hostility of many of them, perhaps most of them”. Pat Thane gives further evidence for this theory. The fact that the more far-reaching of the Liberal reforms only begun in 1908, after Campbell-Bannerman’s resignation, also seems to count against any theory which ascribes sole responsibility for the reforms to Labour and the working class: nothing major changed in terms of Labour MPs or working class opinion in these two years; the major change was a “New Liberal” politician taking over from a Gladstonian liberal. The ideology of individual politicians was arguably more important, and this was influenced by Booth, Rowntree, and T.H. Green. It is also important to consider the timing of the reforms – had they been due entirely to working class enfranchisement and pressure, surely they would have occurred immediately after the 1867 Reform Act, rather than in the early twentieth…

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This lack of progress was also due to a general downturn in the economy: caused by WW1 and the growth of competition abroad. A policy of retrenchment was introduced after a short boom. Retrenchment did not allow the kind of reform people wanted. Lloyd George earned the anger of workers wanting reforms by refusing to nationalize mines and using heavy-handed tactics dealing with a strike in Glasgow. Had Lloyd George not been part of the coalition would he have adopted this policy and lost the sizeable support of the miners? Or was nationalization not practical and fear of revolution justified? Lloyd George's stance and Liberals in general also were confused on issues such as industrial relations. In the polarization of politics that was happening the Liberal party in the middle didn't seem to have an obvious set of principles that were relevant to the unfolding century…

    • 945 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    DBQ: Organized Labor

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One example of a group that was seen as Socialist were the Knights of Labor who worked to gain rights for the workers through legislation, and also believed in Arbitration. As seen in Document F, the Knights of Labor was one of the spoons that contributed to mixing the “Labor Interest Broth.” The Knights of Labor was considered one of the groups that led to the failure of unions because there were too many unions with too many different views and they were unable to get anything accomplished. Another group that was considered unsuccessful was the IWW. The IWW was a union chalked full of Wobblies, immigrants, blacks, and what people considered “radicals.” Document C shows that the public was accusing the unions of sucombing to communism saying that they barred a “red flag” against the United States. The IWW was full of workers who were chasing after the idea of communism, thinking that it would give them the rights that they wanted, but Document C shows that cutting open the duck to get the “golden eggs” wouldn’t show you any profit, it has to stay alive for it to lay more eggs, just like the government would have to continue the way it is for the people to gain any of the working rights that they wanted.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socialism’s failure in the United States during this time period is the biggest sign of the conservatism of American labor. Socialism had formed in other counties during their industrialization; however,…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Liberals made many social reforms which were not necessarily directly helpful to the individual issues at hand but they did create grounds for the welfare estate to be built upon and highlighted the areas which needed attention for a better minimum quality of life. Areas focused on were free meals and health checks at schools, pensions and insurances. For example, the 1906 School Meals Act allowed children to have a free daily meal. This was effective in 1914 as by then, 14 million were receiving the free meals which duly led to a better economy however the negatives outweighed the positives as the issue with having the act voluntary until 1912 meant that over half of the authorities didn’t provide meals. Furthermore, proving eligibility was very difficult so there were many errors which occurred with the system. Rather similarly, Old Aged Pensioners couldn’t receive their money due to identity proofing issues. Household issues were ignored which was one of the Liberal’s negatives however, this is without taking into account that only so many areas could have been focused on. Although the Liberals never catered for the needs of all people, their reforms managed to always bring some improvement into areas of health, education and the future of citizens, no matter how poor in places they were. The Liberal Social Reforms did improve the lives of the British citizens to some extent, the main achievement being that the existence of the reforms themselves allowed to building of the welfare estate which is a factor that makes Britain as strong as it is today.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Winston Churchill thinks that socialism is a philosophy of failure however John Steinbeck author Of Mice and Men & JB Priestly author of An Inspector Calls would say that capitalism creates the failure in society not socialism. Both authors create a microcosm to show us how society was like at the time. This is called social realism. The two texts show how rich people are quick to take advantage of the poor and the vulnerable.…

    • 5703 Words
    • 23 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    This merging of the Social parties led to the creation of the Socialist Party. This merging soon led to the party becoming more popular. For about the first decade of its existence as a party it did not do well. In 1912 the party hit the apex of its membership at 120,000 members. That same year Debs won around six percent of the presidential ticket.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The enfranchisement of the working classes meant the newly formed Labour party together with socialist ideologies were beginning to put pressure on the Government to introduce reform. (2/3)…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The inadequacies of These political figures are only partly to blame, ‘liberalism itself also needed to be reformulated in a sense relevant to a new era’. (Clarke, P 1971 p4.) Part of this need to restructure was actually due to the incredible success of Gladstonian Liberalism, as it achieved the majority of the goals it set out in record time, ‘in short, with the political capital of Gladstonian liberalism fast becoming exhausted, there was need for a new liberalism which could more effectively engage the support of working-class voters’. (Clarke, P. 1971 p4) By the 1900 the Liberal hold on power was growing, in a bid to secure their grasp they formulated the Labour Representation Committee.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Socialists argued for social ownership of the means of production and co-operative management of the economy. Socialism also became associated with its opposition to capitalism. It aimed to improve the life of the working class and to make the distribution of wealth more equitable. Through the writings of the German philosopher Karl Marx socialism also came to be associated with class struggle.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    After two unsuccessful electoral campaigns in the late 19th century and early 20th century, numerous splits in the party after William Gladstone's retirement, and the growing awareness of the issue of poverty within the UK, key figures within the Liberal party realised a change in the direction of Liberalism was required. They pushed for 'New Liberalism', a more modern form of Liberalism that stressed numerous key fundamental values, one of which was that intervention by the state was key in establishing a minimum quality of life for people within the country. Thus from their electoral triumph in 1906, and especially from 1908 onwards, the Liberal government passed a series of social and welfare reforms in an attempt to raise the quality of living standards within the UK. The Liberals based these reforms on three main groups within society, the elderly, the young, and the unemployed. This essay will explore several of the reforms the Liberal government introduced including the National Insurance act, the old age pensions act, a selection of educational acts, as well as acts regarding employment issues; assessing the aims of the acts and arguing how successful they actually proved to be in reducing the issue of poverty in the UK.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Miss

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages

    ‘The record of Labour governments in the years 1964 and 1979 was one of continuous failure.’ Asses the validity of this view. (45 marks)…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Socialist Party was formed in 1900. In 1912, Eugene Debs received 900,000 votes, which was six percent of the presidential votes cast that year. Debs attracted blue collar workers’ craving for better working conditions and higher wages. The party dealt with the country’s problems while having the views of the citizens. 4.…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The problem for the national socialist left is that those two assertions are completely adverse to each other and reality itself. The ‘definition’ of socialism conjured up by the Left has no logical bearing to it’s real definition and is merely a veiled attempt at claiming success for socialism where none has ever existed. While the ‘socialism has never been tried’ claim is blatant attempt at excusing the failure of socialism down through it’s 500 year history.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I am going to show that Labour should not be the party of the working class. The definition of working class has changed over time, as if you were working class a century ago, it would mean that you earnt little money, however, our perception of working class has changed now- Working class is/are a "group of people who do manual work, they do jobs which involve using physical skills rather than intellectual skills. "(https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/working-class).…

    • 1787 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays