Preview

Luck Egalitarianism: Similarities Between Option Luck And Brute Luck

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3816 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Luck Egalitarianism: Similarities Between Option Luck And Brute Luck
1. Introduction
It has long been accepted that an equal division of resources in a strict sense is implausible. Several alternative egalitarianism theories have since arisen, with one being luck egalitarianism. Luck egalitarianism deals with the question of when inequalities can be justified, and when they cannot, by appealing to agent responsibility. If inequality is a result of the agent’s choice, then it is justified. If not, then egalitarianism calls for redistribution.
Emphasis on agent responsibility was first made by Ronald Dworkin in ‘Equality of Resources.’ Equality of resources seeks to distribute resources to those affected by inequality that was not of their own doing. Building on this theory was Gerald Cohen in ‘Equal Access to
…show more content…
In doing so, he reiterates that people be held accountable for their choices, but not for occurrences out of one’s control. To illustrate this point, a demarcation is made between option luck and brute luck. Option luck being “a matter of how deliberate and calculated gambles turn out,” whilst brute luck being “a matter of how risks fall out that are not in that sense deliberate gambles.” To illustrate this difference, Dworkin provides an example is given of a person developing cancer. If the person consciously set out to lead a healthy lifestyle, then we can call the cancer a matter of brute luck. Nevertheless, if that person had consciously chosen to smoke, then the cancer is said to be a result of option luck. The person was fully aware of the harm caused by smoking, yet still chose to smoke …show more content…
As such, he adopts a via media approach to this problem; holding that there will be redistribution in the name of equality, yet this will be limited. Dworkin’s mechanism to lessen distribution entails removing talents from the initial auction so they cannot be redistributed. Nevertheless, a marginal method of redistribution is provided by the hypothetical insurance scheme. This scheme requires that redistribution take place on a proportion of actual income and not potential income. In total, the talented will not be forced to excessively redistribute their earnings.
Although Cohen does not explicitly mention this problem in ‘Reallocating Dworkin’s Cut,’ his theory of equal access to advantage can provide some implications. Cohen considers preferences to be part of a person’s pre-determined personality. Therefore, since the preference to have control over your own talents is not something you choose, you are not responsible for it. In other words, this talent and the desire to control it is a matter of brute luck and thus not something you should have to sacrifice earnings

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    1. Identify all the accounting policy changes and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984. Estimate as accurately as possible the effect of these on the company’s 1984 reported profits.…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    aqa AS economics unit 2

    • 7216 Words
    • 28 Pages

    Income Distribution – Lab party argue that large inequalities between rich and poor are unfair and need to be corrected e.g. introducing 50p tax. Can correct by redistributive methods such as higher levels of income tax levied on rich. The rev raised can then be redistributed to poor e.g. spending increased  benefits.…

    • 7216 Words
    • 28 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Page 102. Read the passage where Crooks talks of black families. Why is this relevant?…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    2. Outline the consequences of this – INEQUALITY – and why individualism inevitably leads to inequality…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Thomas Sowell’s article, “The Fallacy of Fair”, he makes it clear that he believes many of the people who utilize the term fair in politics do not truly understand it’s meaning. He urges the idea that society is often blamed for the results of the handicaps that life bestows upon groups or people, leading society to attempt to level out the playing field for those on the bottom end of the totem pole. This concept in itself portrays the real injustice considering it skews the reality of a group's true situation, causing said group to think they are better off than they are. Evidently, this robs them of the incentive to identify the true problem and to improve (Sowell, 2010).…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On Inequality is also the fact, rather than appointed by the author, of different life cycles of consumption, work and recreation. One person can work extra hard in high school, college, and its prime working years, and can save aggressively. with the aim of consolidating large blocks of leisure and retirement savings. Others may choose to enjoy a holiday spread over their entire previous period and found himself working at a later date to make up for it. Think of the famous marshmallow experiment. But how does one define fair, at any point along the timeline of these two lives, what equality between…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Burden and privilege are shared out pretty equally [in Gethen]; everybody has the same risk to run or choice to make" (93).…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his book, Hatzenbuehler’s conception of inequalities is premised on historical injustices and oppressive regimes as well as laws. His views on social inequalities and distributive justices are highly influenced by Robert Nozick’s entitlement theory in his book entitled “Anarchy, State, and Utopia”. In the modern world, social inequalities have become a major concern for the international community. For instance, the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) requires nations to use the Core Minimum Approach in addressing social inequalities, especially those falling under the broad spectrum of social and economic rights. The effect of biases in the process of nurturing a “Virtuous Citizenry” is that they cause hostilities and anti-social behaviors like corruption that are inimical to the development of a nation.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is the duality of Human Nature? The duality of Human Nature is the belief that every human being has a good side and a bad side, and in “ The Lottery” you can see some great examples of this. Just a few characters that are good examples include, Bill Hutchinson, Nancy, Bill Jr, and Davy. Bill Hutchinson is character in the short story “The Lottery” who is a great example to use when it comes to the duality of Human Nature. Bill is the unlucky person who wins the lottery, putting his family at risk of death.…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Before God we are all equally wise and equally foolish.” Albert Einstein. There are no such things as a perfect society. As we see in the book “Harrison Bergeron”, written by Kurt Vonnegut Jr, there is no such thing as a “perfect” world. In Their world was not equally even though they tried to make it seem like it was. Some people had handicaps that made them less equal because they had to carry extra weight. It was causing problems even though people did not know it. In Harrison Bergeron, there was a lot of things wrong with their equal society.…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this paper I will discuss the three philosophies explaining differences of income in America. The three philosophies I will be discussing is Utilitarianism, Liberalism and Libertarianism. These philosophies are important because it help shows what should the government do about economic inequality. For instance, it helps us understand if the government should give to those in need or let the individuals who work hard keep what they earn. Income in America is very important because it helps build society as a whole. It has been many policies to reduce poverty in America and to reduce income inequality.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    William James wrote, “Determinism leads us to call our judgments of regret wrong, because they are pessimistic in implying that what is impossible yet ought to be.” (1) I intend to make an argument against James, on the basis that determinism does not consent human beings to completely neglect moral responsibility.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A crucial controversy of America today is the growing gap between the wealthy and the poor, and the discrepancy is caused by capitalism run wild and only the helping hand of the government can only fix the problem. A question that turns the tables is what if the growing wealth disparity in America is actually caused by the government? For years, the idea that inequality is economically neutral has been the prevailing view not just among traditionalists but also between most Americans outside the further reaches of a political audience. There could be ideological or moral reasons to object to a growing gap between the wealthy and the rest but for economic reasons, there are no such. Furthermore, there are many ways inequality places itself in America. In our society, a good amount of the population is forced to stand up and work for our country while hardly being redeemed for their time and effort, thus the problem of income inequality. An estimate of these people live from paycheck to another, barely coping with life itself, not because they cannot manage their money well, but the reason is that…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Basic Argument Analysis

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Consequently, if we accept that our beliefs, desires, and predisposed psychological structures, inform our actions, then we are not free to choose them. As a result of this inability to choose, it would be impossible to claim that we are morally responsible for the results of the actions that come from these beliefs, desires, and predisposed psychological structures. In order, “To be truly morally responsible for what you do you must be truly responsible for the way you are – at least in certain crucial mental respects.”1…

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Occupy Wall Street Movement

    • 2406 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The economic implications in this statement are specifically defined by the lack of fairness in what they consider to be “The 99%” of the population that are not wealthy. The ethical situation is derived from being the majority of the population, but not having the majority rights to rule; emphasizing a distinct humanitarian variance between the people that should make the rules that govern equality, and those that actually do make those rules.…

    • 2406 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays