Preview

Maid In America Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
485 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Maid In America Analysis
In Anayansi Prado’s Maid in America, viewers are able to see examples of the power differentials involved among caretakers in relationship with each other, their families, and their employers. The employers of all three women are shown discussing how they couldn’t have their lifestyle without the care provided by women; yet each of the women at some point discuss the limited pay they receive for the extensive hours of both physical and emotional labor. The women are also shown having to live under the limits of harsh immigration and emigration policies. As an audience, we see the contradictory truth that Martha Gimenez discusses in Global Capitalism and Women From Feminist Politics to Working Class Women’s Politics: care work, though essential to the persisting power of capitalism, is undervalued on an …show more content…
This complex relationship is also tied to immigration and emigration policies in “receiving countries,” to borrow a term Joya Misra and Sabine N. Merz use in Neoliberalism, Globalization, and the International Division of Care (118). Misra and Merz argue that neoliberal economic globalization and state policies reinforce the “hierarchy of womanhood” involved in the system of caretaking (118). They thus look to larger systems and structures of power, like capitalism and the federal government, to explain the power differentials involved in the social relations of care work. This is an important idea that many of the pieces we have read this semester have supported, including each of those by Chandra Talpade Mohanty, Mary E. Hawkesworth, and Stephanie

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Women were overworked, considered “lowest antebellum worker” and segregated based on gender(Stansell 105). Not only did this work segregate and exploit these women, the outside work system, in particular, reinforced women's reliance on their family as a result of the low wages and forms of labor they did. The system of working individually in their homes made it hard to combat unfair treatment from employers, as they could not come together and unite(Stansell 116). Later when factory work became more popular, inside work, especially those that lacked heavy machinery, women began to experience some freedom(Stansell 120). In this piece, we see an economy run by mass production of textile related…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wowen Exploitation

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There is a debate that women around the world in the workforce are exploited more than men. In the essay “Life on the Global Assembly Line” by Barbara Enrenreich and Amrete Fuentes it mentions a woman named Anna in Ciudad Juarez and her struggles as she works in the maquiladoras. She leaves at 4am in the morning to catch the ruteras (a run-down van that squeezes many workers in at one time) to ride from the slum neighborhoods to the industrial parks. This ride may take many hours to arrive to work in the maquiladora and endures horrific working conditions.…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Despite the growth of industry, urban centers, and immigration, America in the 19th century was still very rural. The “Cult of Domesticity” first named and identified in the early part of the century, the beliefs embodied in this “cult” gave women a central role in the family. Women’s god given role, it stated was a wife and mother. Pulling against these “beliefs” was the sense of urgency, movement, and progress in the industrial and political changes affecting the country. Women could not help but see themselves in this growth. Women wanted new options, jobs, education and more. Not many women pursued their dream though because many had little to no support, but that difficulty didn’t stop some women from pursuing their goals. Rosa Cassettari and Luna Kellie were two of the women from the same era that decided to pursue the wishes in order to have a better and prosperous life and be able to provide for their families as best as they could. These two women were great examples of how hard but not impossible it was to gain their own freedom and rights aside of what society believed a women’s role was. Even though the faced many hardships and obstacles these two women found the courage to overcome all the…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through her time spent with Hazel and Zona outside of work, Anglin finds that factory life is not the most meaningful aspect of the mica women’s lives; rather, they are multifaceted people who find meaning in religion, kinship and community (Anglin 2002: 98). In Chapter 6, “Paternalism, Protest and Back Talk,” Anglin uses the research of her previous chapters to argue that the kinship based networks “took the place of formalized dissent and provided the means for women to negotiate the politics of the shop floor” (Anglin 2002: 104). Since women were not able to gain influence through authority positions such as men when the mica industry began to decline, they had to find other means of strategizing and navigating efficiently through the workplace, and they did this by bringing kinship and family life into the factory. Through this, women were able to make factory life more bearable and “contain men’s authority” to an extent (Anglin 2002: 117).…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The process of welfare state restructuring post war was closely associated to changing gender relations, notably the erosion of the man as the breadwinner and the rise of double earners and/or lone parent families. With changing family patterns, this newly generated need for support services like national childcare, has received limited support in Canada by the state which allowed a very uneven development of childcare across the country, in coverage as well as form. Given their emerging roles in society, women and feminists sought to re model childcare arrangements in Canada from a more liberal pattern to a more social regime. However, with the liberal regime being characterized a distinctive male cast, women had to be organized and limited to the institutional terrain of the state with the hopes of achieving goals of equality and simultaneously childcare.…

    • 2037 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    According to Pateman, men consider woman natural dependence, always in need of defending and male protection. In the welfare state, this notion of protection relates to economic stability through non-domestic employment, a form of citizenship. Employment gives employees a stake in the larger society, a feeling of a civic community. In the private sector, the male is the breadwinner and protector of the family’s societal status. In the contemporary era, women hold jobs and professions, but are still excluded from citizenship. Women face high segregation and pay inequity, which occurred because “capitalist economies are patriarchal…[and] are clustered at the lower end of the lower end of the occupational hierarchy.” Women have been excluded from the labor force, but now that they are forced to undertake unskilled and low paying professions or other professions that perpetuate their roles as nurtures or caretakes. Such roles reduce any chance of women enjoying citizens in the traditional path that men do. Pateman made compelling arguments. However, her criticisms of the welfare state seem to discredit the successes it has in alleviating some of the burdens of property. Further, welfare aids individuals without financial or political means to feel as participants in society. Patenam could have used more contemporary examples (1980s) to expand her argument. Whereas Patenam’s piece focused on the…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    She then references many popular and well respected media outlets that have stories that relate to her argument. She ends the piece with more personal accounts from women – including a personal account of her own. The structure of this piece begins with acceptable – almost scientific in tone facts and statistics. Then come more stories and commentaries about the plight of the American housewife as seen by the American media. She uses well respected sources to give society's perspective on the issue. Lastly she uses emotionally appealing personal testimonies – from housewives themselves – giving the end of her paper an especially emotional and visceral feeling that the reader is left with. The structure of her writing is very effective in adding a sense of seriousness and legitimacy- It eases the reader into the argument as it becomes increasingly focused and…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Working seven days a week and twelve hours a day took a toll on Ward. Completing physically challenging chores was typical as was earning minimum wage, at forty-five dollars a month. Maids were treated like dirt during this time period. Although there is about a forty-year gap, Naomi Ward’s story reminds me of the book and movie “The Help.”…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this column, “What Happened to Working Women in America?,” the writer, Gail Collins illustrates the reason why there is a need for women to come into the workforce in America, using a satirical, yet earnest tone throughout the piece. Not as many women are in the workforce, because there are very limited opportunities to alleviate the other obligations, such as raising children, that these women face daily throughout America. To cause an increase of women in the working environments, the US needs to give these women opportunities that are beneficial, to grow into people of the…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Historian Paige Meltzer goes on to say about The Progressive Movement, arguing that its policies are ‘built on Progressive-era strategies of municipal housekeeping.’ In this essay, you will be informed about the changes that women sacrificed so much to obtain. During the Progressive era, feminist used orthodox forms of womanhood, which included all women as housewives, to warrant their acceptance into sisterhood provinces: as "municipal housekeepers," they would refine politics, cities, and oversee the health and wellbeing of their neighbors. Feminist abstrusely examined their provinces needs and used their "maternal" proficiency to lobby, establish, and…

    • 1702 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carol is a ‘working class’ single mother, she works hard to ‘keep us (Carol and her son, Victor) afloat’ after her ex husband ‘shot through’ a few years ago. He left debts that Carol had to pay off, leaving her working everyday ‘in someone else’s grotty shower’ not only to support herself and Victor but also to pay off the debts and send Victor to school. The mistress of the house is condescending. This is ironic because she has book written by ‘the likes of Germaine Greer’ and other feminists. It would be assumed that she is a feminist from looking at her bookshelf, however the way she treats Carol with ‘patronizing notes on floral paper’ it becomes unthinkable. The mistress accuses Carol of stealing ‘five-hundred-dollar earrings’ which Victor and Carol know is not true, because she ‘would only open a draw to put a clean knife or fork away’. Carol is suffering in this household because she must uphold her reputation and not kick up a fuss, so she shows that she is better than the mistress by leaving her final paycheck and the key to the house on a the bench. Carol is trapped by Victor, because she has such high hopes for him and his career in Law that she works everyday ‘on her knees’ to earn money so he can learn what she didn’t have the chance to. It is known that Carol…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In her article she addresses the issue of the glass ceiling, and the many factors trapping women under it. She says that todays famous feminists are not an accurate representation of working women. They are often white and well-educated, unlike the millions of women who are oppressed in todays patriarchy. Jaffe uses data and statistics to show the economic trends that are preserving male dominance. Jaffe’s article can be closely related to the “Conflict theory”. She expressed the constant power struggle between women and men, employer and employees, feminists and the labor movement. She also confronts the socially constructed view that women dominated jobs are demeaning, stating that domestic work is not less important than other jobs.…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jane Addams

    • 1926 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Women who worked in the marketplace suffered from a number of injustices including socialization harmful to their development in the public arena. Trained to respond first to their "family…

    • 1926 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is no secret that for centuries, women have faced years and years of discrimination, inferiority to men, and being viewed as less than human by society. Women have had to fight for their right to vote amongst other legal rights, and for their independence from their husbands. “When American women began to enter the labor force in the nineteenth century, the relatively few jobs open to them were highly segregated by gender” (Spain 1992: 14). The first women’s labor union began to form by the end of the 1930’s. Women’s activism began to increase, leading to a new reform in paid work and the rise in feminism in the midst of a new labor movement (Gregory 2003: 25). By the 1940’s, the transition of the housewife to that of a working woman began to trend. Women began to venture out of the home in search of employment and educational opportunities to help provide for their families, since their…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women as Unpaid Carers

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Caring for the elderly: Middle-aged women have been turned into an army of unpaid carers…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays