Preview

Marriage Will Improve If Wives Submit To Their Husbands Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
931 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Marriage Will Improve If Wives Submit To Their Husbands Analysis
Overview
This paper explores the argument of submissive relationships, meaning the man is the head of the household and the women should submit to him. There are two sides of this argument. the pro, “Marriages Will Improve If Wives Submit to Their Husbands” by Christine McClelland and the con, “Marriages Will Not Improve If Wives Submit To Their Husbands” by Cokie and Steven Roberts. These articles help understand the Role-Learning theory by stating the values and images of women and men in the media. Submitting to husbands encourages both women and men to define women in terms of men. Post modernism also has a part in this argument as the women’s role in society has been ever changing. Each side of the argument has valid reasons as to why
…show more content…
The article begins with a conversation between and man and wife. The husband is telling her she needs to relax while he’s away at work, mainly because that’s what the doctor told her she needs to do. She acknowledges him and lets him know the only thing she has planned is planting a few flowers. After he departs, she does a full day’s work outside and is miserable because of it. The wife then wishes she would only have listed to her husband. McClelland states that listing to her husband and doing what he says are two different things based on her definition of submission: yielding when it is convenient (1998). McClelland strikes me as a very religious person from her constant quotes from Ephesians, a book of the bible. She argues that women should submit to their husbands because that is what God calls us to do. We need to have faith that the Lord will guided their hearts and minds in the right direction to make the best possible decisions for the family. Domination in relationships is a constant battle, especially if the wife is stubborn and independent. McClelland states that if we give the man domination, your marriage will be blessed and you will be happy because of it. In her argument, McClelland begins to talk about our culture. She states, “women feel like they lack respect from men. We fight for respect by ordering equivalent pay and demand to be treated as equals.” …show more content…
The Roberts argue that wifely submission could increase the problem of spousal abuse. With more and more women out in the work force living the same life’s and earing equal salaries as the husbands, the idea of women submission makes less senses. Steven and Cokie begin to give a personal story to argue their point further reporting that Steven once was given a card that read “head of the household”. As a couple, they realized that although they may have made different salaries, all decisions about finances, or anything else, is always shared equally. Their household had two heads. Or none. Not one. (1998). The Roberts point out that “gracious submission”, taken to extreme, can lead to abuse, both physical and emotional. This country has come a long way in terms of making spousal abuse illegal. The Roberts argue that the last thing women need is thinking that their “God given” role is submission to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Malala Yousafzai Quotes

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Conflict -“Our men think earning money and ordering around others is where power lies. They don't think power is in the hands of the woman who takes care of everyone all day long, and gives birth to their children,” Page 116.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Today we have a number of sociological views and approaches, which have agreed changes have taken place in gender roles and relationships within families to make them more equal. However many others sociologist criticise the nature of those changes. Some argue there has been a greater equality within modern family life and others say it is simply exaggerated. In my essay I going to assess these views through domestic labour, paid work, decision making and domestic violence in couples and try to conclude to what extent gender roles and relationships have in reality, become more equal in modern family life.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In her relationship with Jody Starks - her second marriage - she is physically abused many times. Jody saw this as assurance he had control. Today, every one in four women are abused because women have been known to be seen as more of objects than actual people. It was not until 1900 that the New York’s Married Women’s Property Act of 1848 was passed in every state granting married women ‘some’ control and rights to their property and earnings. There is a stereotype for women that still exists today expressing the idea that women are not capable of all of the things men have been said to be.…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    apush ch 29 study guide

    • 2162 Words
    • 9 Pages

    extension of women’s traditional roles as wives & mothers (their “sphere” – the “cult of domesticity”)…

    • 2162 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Girl" by Jamica Kincaid

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Since the late 1970s the gender role has seemed to slightly switch up from where it was. Cooking and cleaning were mandatory house work for wives a few decades ago. In today’s time it really does not matter who does it, as long as everything gets done. Being proper and lady-like was a must and being indiscriminate and “talking to wharf-rat boys”. (Kincaid, 1978 p.352) Nowadays women are thrown into categories based on how they act and present themselves, and it should not be this way. Women have fought their way up to where they stand today, and even though we are still being categorized we stand tall and keep pushing forward.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why I Want A Wife Summary

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The following essay, “Why I Want a Wife,” appeared in Ms. Magazine in 1972 during the feminist movement in the United States. In this essay, Brady takes a satirical and humorous look at what it means to be a wife and mother. Brady was thinking of a longtime friend who appeared on the scene, fresh from a recent divorce and was looking for another wife (263). It was in that moment it occurred to Brady, as a wife and mother, which she also would like to have a wife. She first starts out by saying, “Why do I want a wife?” (263). She lists most of the duties, expectations and demands of the husband and society that are unfairly unjust to women and it is underappreciated and unrecognized.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In this essay I will be assessing the contribution of feminist sociologists to an understanding of family roles and relationships. There are different roles in families such as: Conjugal; where both the partners share task such as housework and childcare, the opposite of this would be segregated roles; where the couples have separate roles, the male is breadwinner and has the instrumental role and the female is the housewife and has the expressive role. A dual earner is a couple…. A single parent is a person who has been divorced or been widowed and has to take care of the children they had with the previous partner. Furthermore there are different types of relationships between families such as equal; where the husband and wife both have an equal say and are treated equally, however it can be one-sided; where the husband or wife are more dominant which can lead to domestic violence, it could also be democratic; where the family all vote for something instead of one person taking the decisions, but it can also be patriarchal; where the male take the main decisions and Is the breadwinner. A feminist is a person that argues that sociology has traditionally taken a ‘male stream’ perspective and ignores female viewpoint; they examine women’s experiences and study society from a female’s perspective. There are different types of feminism: Liberal, Marxists, Radical and Difference Feminism. They all tend to be critical of the nature of a women’s role and relationship inside families because they see them as grossly patriarchal, oppressive and unfair, as mentioned in Item B. On the other hand, the different types of feminist don’t agree with each other’s perspective on ideas of families and households, and they tend to clash.…

    • 1733 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wives as Deputy Husbands

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The author’s thesis of this article is to inform the reader that women had more roles in colonial times than people rarely consider. Ulrich’s contention is that “the husband was in control of the external affairs and of the family, a husband’s decision would incorporate his wife’s opinion, and should fate or circumstance prevent the husband from fulfilling his role the wife could stand in his place” (Paragraph 4.). Women didn’t only depend on their husband. She was not helpless. Her commitment to her husband did allow him to be able to trust her with difficult tasks that a servant couldn’t be trusted with. A wife specialized in housekeeping skills but it also included the responsibilities of being a deputy husband. Ulrich says “Economic opportunities were limited for women; however, female responsibility was a very broad topic” (Paragraph 8.). A woman could do any task as long as it furthered the good of her family and her husband deemed it acceptable. Wives could double as their husbands and became respected companions and shared the spouse’s authority. There was no sharp division between home and work in the colonial time period. Many people worked on a farm which also doubled as their home. This was also true for male and females, their spaces overlapped. While the husband was around her responsibility was…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many men in the early 20th century viewed women as a pedestal by which they relied on for their everyday needs. The sarcasm of the essay shows the reader how a wife feels about how she is treated. Brady states in her closing sentence, “My god who wouldn’t want a wife?”(525), which basically states that wives are unappreciated and over worked in many…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Apworld Essay

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Through out much of history, women have been viewed as the “weaker sex”; women have been seen as less capable physically, socially, intelligently, economically and even religiously. Because of the cruel view that society has on them, women could only perform domestic tasks at home and as such remain obedient to the men their families. During 1450 to 1950, women in various societies around the world were viewed as the “weaker sex” as they are submissive under men’s control in marriage, constrained with an inferior identity, and limited in their daily social activities.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Moreover, the economy has grown over years and has changed the model of rights and expectations within marriage. As women’s connection to work force grows stronger, they have played an important role in influencing and controlling in family decision-making. When those rights are not respected, many women either do not enter into or what they consider insupportable family relationships; in which men do the same.…

    • 259 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Second Shift

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Traditionally men worked and brought home the bacon while women stayed home and took care of the children and the home. This changed when the new liberated independent women became driven towards acquiring a career, caring for the children and balancing domestic work. Thus women started to complain about being exhausted from working, multi-tasking, and solely taking care of the house-hold, while their husbands worked and bring forth a paycheck and think that is efficient enough and his job is pretty much done. ‘’I definitely concur with The Second Shift because this essay most women can really relate to, including me. It filters the contribution of what the husband brings to the house-hold versus the woman. It makes me ponder about why our husbands are letting us become husbands”. The author, Ariel Hochschild demonstrates keen examples and stated factual research from her findings on the percentages of husbands that said they should help out around the house and the ones that actually did, and furious Wives who not only had to work an eight hour shift; but also took care of the house-hold duties and tended to the children. From the author’s eight year research she concluded that failed marriages were not due to alcohol, physical and or mental abuse, infidelity, or financial problems, but due to the lack of domestic assistance from the husband.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this essay I will be talking about how feminist have contributed to our understanding of family roles and relationships. There are several different types of feminist theory, but all of them share certain characteristics in common; there is a fundamental division in society between men and women, that women are to some extent exploited by men and that society is male dominant or patriarchal this means “rule by the father” but is used by feminist to indicate that men have more power than women and the interest of men largely shapes how society is run. They believe that these theories are also critical of existing sociology arguing that it has a pro male bias. They call male-dominated sociology malestream sociology calming that most sociology is written by men, about men and for men as most early studies used all male samples and paid little attention to women’s roles and work within the family such as the role of the mother and the work of mothering and housework. Women now have become more influential in sociology and this was reflected in a growing number of studies of the family from a feminist point of view. However there are important differences between different feminist views.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Intimately oppressed

    • 6058 Words
    • 25 Pages

    status of women, something akin to a house slave in the matter of intimacy and oppression, and…

    • 6058 Words
    • 25 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Roman Empire

    • 2169 Words
    • 9 Pages

    “ If each of us, citizens, had determined to assert his rights and dignity as a husband with respect to his own spouse, we should have less trouble with the sex as a whole; as it is, our liberty, destroyed at home by female violence, even here in the Forum is crushed and trodden underfoot, and because we have not kept them individually under control, we dread them collectively. (Par. 2)…

    • 2169 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics