Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Marx' Alienation and Durkheim's Anomie

Good Essays
1012 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Marx' Alienation and Durkheim's Anomie
Section one: Explain Marx ’concept of alienation.

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the two concepts of alienation and anomie and to show their similarities and differences. One of the most important Marx’ theories is the concept of ‘alienation’. By the concept of alienation Marx claimed that people are using their ability to control their life under the capitalistic conditions. Created in the middle of the 19th century, it is a form of dehumanization. Marx’ theory of alienation is represented in the book Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts. For Marx, alienation depicts a ‘’socio-psychological condition describing the separation of individuals from their natural and social environments’’. (www.academia.edu) Marx typifies four main types of alienation.
1. Alienation of the worker from the product of his labor: 'The worker places his life in the object; but now it no longer belongs to him, but to the object ' (1844b: 324); The worker cannot control the conditions in which he is working.
2. Alienation of the worker from the act of producing: 'His labour is [...] not voluntary, but forced; it is forced labor ' (1844b: 326); The worker becomes a servant of what he produces. The object is not in the worker’s control and it is not his production.
3. Alienation of the worker from himself, as a producer: 'estranged labour [...] tears away from him his species-life, his true species-objectivity ' (1844b: 329); The workers are alienated from themselves. Their work takes from their humanity because they cannot realise their true humanity in creating the object they produce.
4. Alienation of the worker from other workers: 'each man [...] regards the other in accordance with the standard and the situation in which he as a worker finds himself ' (1844b: 330); The conditions of work also alienate the worker from other men. They are no longer a team of creative workers. Moreover, the conditions of their work put them in competition with each other. They should work faster and harder, they should produce more. They become an enemies rather than to be team. According to Marx, capitalism alienates people from their nature and humanity. They cannot show their potential in the communication with the others, in the connection with what they produced and in this way they cannot show them as human beings.
Section two: Explain Durkheim’s concept of ‘anomie’. The French sociologist Emile Durkheim introduced the concept of anomie in his book The Division of Labor in Society, published in 1893. The term anomie means social disorder and is also used by Durkheim in his studies about suicidal behavior - in 1897 in his study on Suicide. Anomie is usually translated as normlessness, but it best understood as insufficient normative regulation. (www.brooklinsoc.org) The concept was explained as a condition where the activities of the members in a society are no longer controlled by a norms. It refers to a ‘breakdown of the social norms’. (www.criminology. fsu.edu) Anomie refers to an environmental state where society fails to exercise adequate regulation or constraint over the goals and desires of its individual members (Durkheim, 1951: 241—276). Individuals sometimes experience alienation from values and group goals during times of fast change in the society. This leads to conflicts and dissatisfaction. Industrialization with the division of labor affiliated anomie. In the process of producing, which is repeated, workers are losing their sense to feel their role in the production. The anomic suicide is taking place when the individuals are not regulated sufficiently by the society. This kind of suicide is more likely to happen of there are times when the economy is fluctuating. As one of the important functions of a social order Durkheim pointed the social solidarity: there is defined place for every individual in the world that was created and reinforced by the social values of morality, religion, and patriotism. His observation was that these strands of solidarity are stronger or weaker in different societies. But he also observed that there are some forces in the modern society that are opposite to these moral ‘strands of social cohesion’ (www. understandingsociety.blogspot.dk). In his theory of suicide, he explains differences in suicide rates across societies as the result of different levels of solidarity and its opposite, anomie. Durkheim highlights the situation of "anomie" to refer to the circumstance of individuals whose relationship to the social whole is weak. ( www.understandingsociety.blogspot.dk)
Section three: How the two concepts are alike or different? The two theories are exposed by the authors as a essential problem of modernity as moving to a industrial state in Durkheim’s view and moving to a capitalist state in Marx’s view. Another important similarity between the two theories is that they both arose in the 19th century when analysing the nature of labour – Marx’s concept was based on the labour process and Durkheim’s was written with the division of labour in mind. From these topics, the authors are trying to explain a variable changes, which are taking place in the society.

Marx’s concept of alienation is showing another kind of separation - separation of the person from his/her nature as a free producer and creator, and separation of the person from his/her natural sociality. (www.brooklinsoc.org) Thus, the modern capitalistic society is destructive of true society. In comparison, Durkheim and Marx are diagnosing a similar feature of modernity. But in Marx is comparing the present with the future as a society, full of equal and free producers. On the other hand in Durkheim 's case there is an implicit contrast between a pre-modern world in which individuals have a well-defined social and moral place and the contemporary world in which these strands of solidarity are breaking down. (www.brooklinsoc.org) But in each case the author is grappling with a deficiency in modernity – a lack of moral and social setting that gives the individual a basis for self-respect and sociable cooperation with others.
Bibliography: Marx. Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts 1844 Durkheim. The Division of Labor in Society 1951 www.brooklinsoc.org www.understandingsociety.blogspot.dk
www.academia.edu

Bibliography: Marx. Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts 1844 Durkheim. The Division of Labor in Society 1951 www.brooklinsoc.org www.understandingsociety.blogspot.dk www.academia.edu

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    RA Revision 1

    • 714 Words
    • 1 Page

    clearly highlight the despair and hopelessness that comes from being bound to “servile labor” by…

    • 714 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The middle class’s attitude towards labor was not as strong as the working class’s attitude towards their own work. This is most likely because the working class had many more jobs to do than the middle class. Workers described their occupations as grueling and tiresome due to their long laborious hours. Even family could not provide relief due to their own fatigue (Doc 7). It came to a point where the vocation began to sicken the employees. Some become sick, anemic, or dizzy as a result of all the effort (Doc 9). Some of the poor children suffered from the burden of overworking with little play (Doc 8). Others may believe that the labor did not affect the children too much, but it clearly shows the pain they felt. On the other hand, the middle class never had to endure the terrible feelings of exhaustion. They tended to feel a sense of disgust towards work. It is as if they were perfect role models who performed with great effort and the working class was just lazy and always getting into trouble (Doc 1). But their attitude towards their work is close to nothing compared to their feelings towards each other.…

    • 793 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    2) Estrangement of the worker from the activity of production; work that the worker performs does not belong to him, therefore suggesting a loss of his ‘self’.…

    • 2988 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Karl Marx and Walmart

    • 2109 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Marx, K. (2010). “Estranged Labor.” Pp. 32-38 in Social Theory: The Multicultural Readings (2010) edited…

    • 2109 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Luis

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages

    being a slave to the routine and doing work that was meaningless to him. (Pg.209)…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Alienation and isolation have been apparent in society since the beginning of man. When an individual stumbles outside the realm of social normality they are viewed as degradation to society or a threat to normal society.(“Truthmove” 2012) In the gothic tale of Frankenstein, Mary Shelley frequently displays the many different forms of alienation. Victor Frankenstein and his creation were two of the characters in this book that went through alienation and isolation.…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Although the idea of having a regular paying job was pleasing the conditions of industrial labor were often appalling, and at times life-threatening. Moreover, as the new industrial workers came to discover, they were unable to bargain over salary and working conditions weren't on equal…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bluest Eye Essay

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Alienation. A withdrawing or separation of a person or a person’s affections from an object or position of former attachment (Merriam Webster). Society has ways of alienating people for multiple reasons such as their race, gender, class, or beliefs. In The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison, the character Pecola was alienated not only by society, but by her family as well. Pecola’s alienation was due to the fact that she was raped by her father and carried his baby. This reveals that society has very little to no values, and that they always assume the worse about people.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Capitalists employ workers and they work through putting their efforts and then getting paid for supporting their families. How hard they work, how much degree they lost themselves, the more products they would produce. They always want to manufacture high quality products, as a result, the higher quality the products, the more they consuming themselves, finally, they are not the person they should being themselves anymore, and they are treated badly, and they would become coward and blunt. Consequently, the workers are become slaves of capitalists. In the common condition, it is our instinct to think that the people who put effort to produce, who owns the product of labor; but under society of capitalism, the main force is private ownership, as a result, the workers’ efforts are nothing or meaningless to themselves. It only has significant impacts to the capitalists. Alienation may occur in the form that many industrials have highly specialized functions on the assembly line and none can do the full job. Which reminds me a condition in 19th in china, during 19 to 20 century, since china becomes an important exporter so the country is growing fast and emerges a lot of manufacturing and technologic industries, which means a manufacturing industry may have over ten thousand workers. They work hard and the process of production is complex and enormous. There is a technologic company in Shenzhen named Foxconn has almost eight hundred thousand employees in China, and always occur suicide incidents because of the intense working speed and nervous working environment. I think the workers in this company are overly devoting themselves to the company and finally lost themselves in their own…

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sociology and People

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Paragraph 3 – Employed and unemployed division. Creates fight for jobs which enables the to consume. Unemployed don’t have disposable income so cannot buy into consumer society. Baumen seduced + repressed.…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alienation is a term Freire uses that could be defined as an act of isolating a person of their knowledge and oppressing them of their individuality. Alienation can also be applied to the banking method and study of education. Educators that practice the banking method prevent students from engaging in the process of inquiry. They control what people know and how they think. The students knowledge is limited and can…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alienation is the primary theme in Kafka's The Metamorphosis. Much of early twentieth-century literature makes as its basic premise that man is alienated from his fellow humans and forced to work in dehumanizing jobs in order to survive. There is no choice for most in this matter.…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Industrialized Labor

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages

    With money sanctioning industrialized labor: hired laborers came into play changing this rule of property ownership. Now one adding their labor to what was common no longer granted them ownership over that property as labor was purchasable. Hired labors weren’t the chief benefactors of their own work both in terms of ownership of property or when it came to the utilization of the yield. It was those with talent, efforts, and resourcefulness for whom the yield became open for the taking, which encroached on the previously held natural rights of individuals to own what they had labored for. So individual labor didn’t matter in the same sense any longer, as at least for some it didn’t result in direct ownership of the fruits of their own…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Race Class Gender

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. the alienated labor is when” private property and its owners hires and controls others and defines labor for them” Instead of results of one’s labor benefiting one’s self, the labor becomes a function that benefits the property owners (184). Therefore, capitalist get to hold on to their money by the “means of production”(184). In a capitalist society Owners vs. non-owners, conflict the rises between the “haves” and the “have not’s” are inevitable. Class structure is maintained by 3 mechanisms; State (ruling class asserting their common interest 185), Ideology (Ideas that support and legitimizes the position of capitalist 185) and the capitalist structure itself due to custom an training views the condition of capitalism a normal process and creates a dependency of workers on the system which makes it hard to resist or rebel. For Ma0rx the important issues structure of economic relations that drives everything else(185, 186. His ideology correlates with contemporary society because of the overabundance of productions which then leads to bankruptcy (2009 housing crisis)(188).…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    (To be fair, Schwartz doesn’t mention that many work harder for more money too.) So there is a cost to what Karl Marx called alienated labor. “Too often, instead of being able to take pride in what they do, and derive satisfaction from doing it well, workers have little to show for their efforts aside from their pay.”…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics