Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Montag vs preston

Good Essays
603 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Montag vs preston
Imagine the U.S censoring what Americans do in their daily lives and putting restrictions and limitations on everything they do. Would Americans obey or would they rebel? In the novel Fahrenheit 451 and movie Equilibrium, both dystopian science fictions, Ray Bradbury and Kirt Wimmer create chaotic worlds where two law enforcers must defy their duties and save the world from their controlling governments. In Fahrenheit 451, Guy Montag is a fireman who burns books and readers but eventually begins reading and turns on his government only to join a group of intellectuals who plan to memorize and redistribute books. Similarily in Equilibrium, John Preston is an officer who kills sense offenders, people who illegally use their emotions, but like Guy Montag he joins the sense offenders to overthrow his government. Even though they were blindly obedient law enforcers, Montag and Preston similarly walk on their path to enlightenment whilst rebeling against their corrupt government.

Montag and Preston are both confronted with individuals who lead them to mental and emotional clarity.
After Montag and Clarisse are walking together, Montag "tilted his head back in the rain, for just a few moments, and opened his mouth"(24). Clarisse's unique personality intrigued him and after meeting her, he began trying new things. In this situation Montag copies what Clarisse previously did to see what it would be like. He is now beginning to think for himself instead of blindly following the government and living his life unhappily. Similarly, when Preston is interrogating Mary, she asks him "why are you alive?" He begins to understand he has a duty and was put on Earth for a reason, and it is not to serve the government. The main reason he was put on Earth is to feel, otherwise he is not really alive. He now understands that anything without feeling is not really anything at all so he takes Mary's advice. Preston and Montag would still be the same people if they had not met Mary and Clarisse.

Additionally, both Montag and Preston have similar turning points in their thoughts toward the government. When leaving the burning woman's house, Montag's "hands had done it... turned thief. Now it plunged the book under his arm, pressed it tight to his sweating armpit"(37-38 Bradbury). Be blames his hands to give the reader an idea of the conflict between his mind and body. He never wanted to take something so badly, but his mind knows the consequences he could be in. Eventually his body wins and his hands, not his mind, end up stealing the book. Likewise in Equilibrium when Preston accidentally breaks his interval of Prozium, he begins to feel and his emotions takeover him when he cries. He is confused as to why he felt the way he did, he is crying but at the same time he is overjoyed. He is feeling a catharsis for the first time and does not know if he is happy, mad, or sad. After this exotic experience, Preston stops taking his interval of Prozium. Without going through these experiences Montag and Preston could still be working for the government.

Montag and Preston's initial beginnings and mindset, their ways of solving their conflicts, their interactions with other characters, and their questioning of authority make it seem as if the two characters are were created solely to be alike in two separate settings. And not only are the two characters similar but almost all aspects of the two stories are alike. If Clarrise was in Equilibrium and Mary was in Fahrenheit 451, the endings would be similar if not exactly the same.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    By asking a simple question like this, it challenged Montag to think beyond his usual capacity, thinking outside of his normal life. He’s began to have thoughts about his definition of true happiness. He starts to realize he’s not truly happy, that’s why it took him a while to respond to her question. This quote by Clarisse is one of the most important quotes throughout the story. Without this quote, Montag wouldn’t doubt himself about his true happiness.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At first, he feels comfortable with his job, but when Mildred tells Montag that Clarisse is “gone”, Montag starts to have thoughts on the questions Clarisse asked him (Bradbury 23). “”How did it start? How did you get into it? How did you pick your work and how did you happen to think to take the job you have?”” Clarisse asks Montag (Bradbury 47). This makes him take a new perspective on his life setting him on his journey to find the truth about his society. While Montag is going through the events, the stress rises within…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Clarisse is very courageous. She questions society and doesn’t follow the unspoken rules and regulations. It takes a lot of courage to stand against an enemy that everyone else follows blindly. Because of this trait, Montag is able to see all the wrongs of society. He begins to see life as it actually is. When she asks Montag if firemen once used to help stop accidental fires, he laughs in reply. “You laugh when I haven't been funny and you answer right off. You never stop to think what I've asked you.” (Bradbury 2) This is the first time Clarisse challenges the way Montag is brought up to think; however, only until later in their meetings does Guy truly understand how incorrect society’s views…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fahrenheit 451 Changes

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages

    He never knew or never paid any attention on what was happening around him but once he met Clarisse that all changed. Montag was walking home after meeting Clarisse, once he got home he kicked an empty bottle of sleeping pills “Montag was cut in half” (13). Before he wouldn’t have cared of what happened to Mildred but now he become…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fahrenheit 451 Analysis

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages

    At the end of Montag’s first meeting with Clarisse, Clarisse asks him, “Are you happy?” Montag then spends the entire night thinking about Clarisse and her question, even though his wife had just overdosed on sleeping pills. Next, when Clarisse rubs a dandelion on her chin, she claims that if it rubs off her chin, then she is in love. However, when Montag tries it, the dandelion does not rub off his chin, which, according to Clarisse, signifies that he is not in love. This prompts him to cry out in outrage, and claim that he is, in fact, in love. However, as the story progresses,…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As the main protagonist of the book, Montag portrays a dynamic character, whereas his perception of society around him changes throughout the book. Not only did he question their actions, but also his own happiness. This showed that he was, in fact, more intelligent than the others. This is significant because society is administered by a single lie that happiness should only exist.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This hints at Montag’s identity crisis early on. In fact, Clarisse’s few lines have sparked the catalyst that will make Montag question his society’s character. As Clarisse acknowledges Montag’s differentness, Montag feels a conflict between his duty towards his society and his subconscious. He starts to sense wrongness in the society. When he feels his body divide into opposites, he begins to realize that although this dismal culture seems content, what meets the eye isn’t always true.…

    • 160 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    He never even thought to mention or think about it until he met Clarisse. Most people in this time prefers to watch tv or have a good time. Clarisse is a very knowledgable 17 year old girl who is interested in other things beyond what the society around her is interested in, or being forced and limited to. She draws Montag into the life she has lived and became so interested in. Montag starts to genuinely become interested in the things that she are saying and starts to question and also wonder what is really going on around him. After the burning of a woman’s books, house, and also herself, he decides to see for himself. After realizing that everyone is on edge about him confiscating the book from the woman’s house, he then realizes that its not only the decreasing use of books in the society that is the issue but the content that they hold. A content that could possibly change lives band change how they…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    So, the imaginary world of Fahrenheit 451 is not so different from ours. However, we are still a lot more fortunate than the people in the novel because we get to read books, think for ourselves and learn quality information without censorship. But what if those rights will be taken from us? Will we fight back for what is right, even if we are being offered an easy way of life? Will we set the boundaries between cleverness and laziness? Will…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We are still the top nation in the world with the most freedoms however; I believe they would be very displeased with the show House of Cards.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Americans express commitment to valued causes through rebellious acts and being against the rules. In the novel 1984 Winston Smith, the main character, goes against the rules and is rebellious. All the rules that Winston goes against leads to committing crimes and puts him at risk of being arrested or being killed by the people in the Party. Winston is not the only one who commits crimes in Airstrip One, the entire society commits crimes. This impacts societal change physically and mentally because citizens are being tortured and manipulated as a punishment.…

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In short, when Montag meets Clarisse, his world begins to change. She leads him to begin to think about everything. In the beginning, Montag just goes with the flow and doesn’t question anything. But as the book goes on, his curiosity expands. He collects books and begins to read. Montag begins to question his line of work and the connection he has with his wife. In the end, Montag ends up in a better state of mind, and is willing to help others learn what Clarisse taught…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    He feels a deep sense of guilt and pain because of the condition of society…

    • 2652 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before he met Clarisse, Montag was an ordinary fireman, doing job. He did not question why, who, or what, he just did what he did. “Are you happy?” she said (14). This question triggered something inside of Montag and started the transformation. He started to think more, and to care more. He was becoming something dangerous. “I’ve tried to imagine,” said Montag, “just how it would feel. I mean, to have firemen burn our houses and our books.” Montag is starting to “defect” from the societal norm and is causing havoc. “Well,” said Beatty, “now you did it. Old Montag wanted to fly near the sun and now that he’s burnt his damn wings, he wonders why. Didn’t I hint enough when I sent the hound around your…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I know this quote is quite long, but I feel like its very important. I feel like Montag is finally expressing his feelings. In this quote you can see how much Clarisse affected him in the long run. Montag has started questioning everything and he has become different from the rest of the population, and also Mildred, she cares more about her 'television family' than she does about Montag. And honestly Mildred doesn't see the point in books, she thinks books are pointless because she can't communicate with the peoples in the book, but she can communicate with her 'family' in the walls. I feel like this quote tells a lot, Montag is getting everything off his chest and he has acknowledged that there is an issue. His society is very impersonal…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays