Mr. Allen
English 12
1 February 2008
Mozart Effect: Can we enhance our mind just by listening to music? Most people are not intellectually gifted at all, and most people strive to learn to become wiser and more informed about the world around them. Studies show that listening to classical music can have positive effects on learning and attitude. This occurrence is called the Mozart Effect, and it has been experimented by many scientists. Different types of music have different effects on the mind. The earliest stages of learning for young children are the most important. The fundamentals of learning are locked into a child at a very young age and how much importance is placed on these can have dramatic effects on the …show more content…
future of the child's learning. Music, when applied in a productive way, can have positive effects on a child's learning and help them in many ways.
Putting music lessons into a child’s normal activities can make learning easier for a young child. A small study was done two years back involving ten three-year-olds who were tested on their ability to put together a puzzle and the speed at which they could do it (Learning Keys 24). After the first test was taken, five of the children were given singing lessons for 30 minutes a day and the other five were given piano lessons for 15 minutes a week (24). The lessons were conducted over a six-month period of time, and after the six months, all of the kids showed great improvement in the speed they could
put together the puzzle (24). The researchers believe this skill in putting pieces of a puzzle together is similar to the reasoning that engineers, chess players and high-level mathematicians use. In this study of inner-city kids, their first scores were below the national average, but afterwards their scores nearly doubled (24). Abstract reasoning is the term they give to the type of reasoning and thought that goes into putting pieces of a puzzle together. By teaching music, people exercise the same abstract reasoning skills that they use for doing math or some other exercise in which the people have to use their head.
A study of eight months was conducted by Frances H. Rauscher of the University of California at Irvine, in which 19 preschoolers, ages three to five, received weekly keyboard and daily singing lessons while another 15 preschoolers received no musical training at all (Bower 143). At the start, middle, and end of the study, the subjects were tested on five spatial reasoning tasks (143). After only four months, scores on the test to assemble a puzzle to form a picture improved dramatically for the group with the musical training, while the control group didn't, even though both groups started out with the same scores (143). It can be understood that this kind of improvement may not be substantial enough to alter the way people are fundamentally taught, but its results cannot be ignored. Rauscher explains, "Music instruction can improve a child's spatial intelligence for a long time, perhaps permanently" (qtd. in Bower 143). Implementing such changes and improvements into a young child's learning could have great effects on them in the future when dealing with the same spatial reasoning skills.
Because of its results in spatial reasoning, music can also be a very helpful tool when actually using it in the classroom and involving it with learning basic curriculums.
In New York City, a program called Learning through an Expanded Arts Program, LEAP, has been going on for a while now in which music and the arts is implemented into the school curriculum to improve scholastic scores of children at all levels (Dean and Gross 614). One way in which music is implemented is with math. They call it "musical math," where the teacher mixes rhythm with counting and gaining a grasp on the basics of math (618). With the rhythm, they are able to learn basic elements of math like fraction and multiplication. Christine Bard, the LEAP consultant explains, "Music helps teach the precognitive skills. It gives students the capacity to trust themselves by providing internal discipline through a highly repetitive structure" (qtd. in Dean and Gross 618). Students' feeling of self-confidence and accomplishment are great and most importantly, the students' attitude toward math and learning is increased very much (618). Music as a separate and thorough curriculum can have dramatic positive changes in the learning process of young people.
Mary Jane Collett, the Director of the Office of Arts and Cultural Education of the Division of Instruction and Professional Development of New York City Public Schools says: “... a well taught sequential music curriculum not only results in music learning that has inherent value; it also gives students the chance to listen, react, see, touch, and move. Instruction in music skills, appreciation, and theory also provides a wealth of learning strategies that enhance children's analyzing, synthesizing, and evaluating skills. Students learn to process information and transfer knowledge through these concrete, kinetic, and cognitive experiences” (Collett 61). Mary Jane Collett is an advocate for a program called Learning To Read Through The Arts (LTRTA), which makes music and the arts a separate course in the elementary curriculum instead of using it as an aid to different
parts of the curriculum here and there (61). Music is taught through listening to different types of music while talking about the music, trying to understand it and interpret it in different ways and in many ways, imitate it (63). She further explains: These integrated music experiences provide excitement in learning for children and thereby improve students' reading, writing, thinking, and analyzing skills and strategies. Learning through all the senses expands the learning process to accommodate different learning styles. Opportunities for integrating communication arts, literature, science, social studies, and the arts are limited only by the educator's imagination, creativity, and open-mindedness (64).
Music, when involved in the classroom, can have great effects on the early stages of learning for the very young up through elementary age school children. Music can also have significant effects on older people in a learning environment. Music does not have the same effect on older people as it does on younger people, however. It is easily understood that for young children, getting them to do fun musical things like learning to play an instrument is somewhat easy compared to getting an adult to do the same thing. Children will do it because it is something new and exciting whereas adults need to be motivated to do something because they won't do something simply because they can. For adults it is a matter of choice, but when they choose to involve music into their everyday lives, the effects can be just as dramatic, but different when compared with music effects on younger children.
One important aspect that music can have on learning for people of all ages is attitude. It seems logical to assume that it is more helpful for adults who are less likely to want to do a particular job or activity, but music can change this and give a listener a
more positive attitude and motivation.
As we will see, by simply listening to pleasant music in the background while doing an arduous task can make it seem so much easier, or in some cases, music may not increase positive attitude, but will ease the strain of an activity. A study was conducted by Shawn E. Mueske, a graduate student at Mankato State University, to determine the effects of background music on a biology lab. He studied to determine the effects of background music on attitude, achievement, time spent in the laboratory and on task behavior (Mueske 6-7). He used a control group which entailed one lab where no music was present, and one experimental group which listened to popular/soft rock music at an appropriate, soft sound level for background music (14). He found that there was no real difference in attitude or achievement among the two groups, but there was a significant increase in time spent in the laboratory and time spent on task …show more content…
(18-28).
In conclusion, listening to background music can help people when they are thinking, learning, or working, but the music needs to be used correctly. If it is vocal music, it needs to be slightly quiet. If the music is not quiet, it can distract the mind. If the music is instrumental, it can be slightly louder, but not too loud because any music played too loudly can distract the mind. The Mozart Effect has been proven to work but there are still those who doubt it. It has been tested many times and the results are there. If used correctly, this method can dramatically improve studying skills and test scores. The type of music someone listens to has a different effect on the brain, but it is only temporary.
Bush, Carol A.
Healing Imagery and Music. Portland: Rudra Press, 1995. Campbell, Don. The Mozart Effect. New York: Avon Books, 1997. Jaeger, Werner. Paideia: the Ideals of Greek Culture. Volumes I and II. New York: Oxford University Press, 1943. Rauscher, Frances, Ph.D. "Can Music Make Us More Intelligent?" Billboard Magazine. October 15, 1994. Kilpatrick, William. "Music and Morality", American Educator Magazine. Winter 1994- 95. Campbell, Don. The Mozart Effect Resource Center. 2004. Mozart Effect Resource Center. 02 Feb. 2004 <http://www.mozarteffect.com/>.
Carroll, Robert T. The Mozart Effect. 2002. 10 Feb. 2004
<http://skepdic.com/mozart.html>.
Chudler, Dr.. The Musical Brain. 22 Feb. 2004 <http://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/music.html>.
Cromie, William J. "Mozart Effect Hits Sour Notes." The Harvard University Gazette 16 Sept. 1999. 12 Feb. 2004 <http://www.news.harvard.edu/gazette/1999/09.16/mozart.html>.
Elias, Marilyn. "The 'Mozart Effect' is Scaled Back a Few Notes." USA Today 19 Aug. 2003. EBSCO. 21 Feb. 2004. Keyword: The Mozart Effect. <http://search.epnet.com/direct.asp?an=J0E152356330903&db=nfh>