In the article, “My body, My employer, My abortion” by Loren Clark-Moe, stated the argument that every women is fully capable of making appropriate decisions about their health, their body, and life just as she made for herself.
To give a little background of the article, Loren Clark-Moe, a 29 year old woman who worked with the federal government as a former analyst at the Department of Homeland Security. Loren believed passionately in the importance of public service. Little did it occur to Loren that her employment would put her at an advantage until she came face to face with a law restricting her from her reproductive choices. “I suppose I shouldn’t have been surprised, given increasing attempts across the United States to limit women’s access to reproductive health care”, stated Loren.
Loren is beginning to show us as an audience of women and political voting stand point that she is being put at a disadvantage. With laws starting to restrict what she and many other women like to have control over which is our reproductive choice. This article text is meant for the men and women that read the “Chicago Tribune” to notice that the government is going to take these writes away from women. Later in the article Loren begins to tell us that she has been on birth control for most of her adult life and has always had irregular menstruation timing and this particular missed menstruation wasn’t any different until Loren began to suffer extreme nausea and fatigue, two major symptoms of pregnancy. Loren then bought a pregnancy test and it confirmed she was pregnant. That following Monday Loren had a doctor appointment and was shocked to find out that she was already eight weeks and three days pregnant. As a reader, I would be shocked if I was in Loren’s position with not knowing I had already been eight weeks pregnant.
“Abortion wasn’t an automatic choice for me, it was one I was strongly considering, and the method I preferred, (drug induced abortion) can’t be performed after nine weeks so I only had a few days to consider my choice.” (Loren)
Loren is faced with a decision a lot of girls and women get faced with every day. By keeping an open mind that it is the woman’s choice to be in charge of her body and that many of these decisions are for the better health and wellness of women and a better future also. This is being effective in a way that women get faced with these decisions and to have them taken away from a woman could leave her in deep depression and stress that could take a harmful effect, not only on her but also the baby too. With these harmful effects that can weigh in on a woman can sway in other mothers along with nurses and some men. When someone is faced with a tough choice such as an abortion, it can be a hard decision with life changing altercations that have the good and bad consequences that come with most abortions.
“My doctor and nurses were supportive with the information they presented me with and discussed with me about how as a federal employee, her health care coverage is barred by congress from paying for abortion services except in the case of rape, incest, or life of the women is in danger. “ “I was fortunate enough to pay for the abortion without affecting my ability to honor other financial commitments but years ago I couldn’t have managed that, and now I fear for the women who can neither afford the procedure nor wait for their next payday to take action.” (Loren Clark-Moe)
The article “My body, My employer, My abortion” is getting used now as an influence more towards single women who work two-three jobs just to pay off bills which could leave them in this situation of not knowing how to pay for the procedure on their own. Even men and women who were brought up in less fortunate circumstances knowing that they wouldn’t want to raise a child in a low income bases struggling to provide for their children.
To help present this argument better, Loren could have stated facts about how many women on low income bases tend to get abortions vs how many women struggle just to provide for their family with low income bases. Such statistics as abortions from single women on a low income salary that apply threw abortion agencies for receive help would go to show how many women would struggle to raise a family as a whole considering they were already having a hard time providing enough financial need for an abortion. Also showing a survey and statistics of women raising a child on a low income bases and how much they struggle would help to show that it wouldn’t be fair to not only the mother but also to the child getting raised in a less fortunate home environment can take a toll on the child.
Adding these examples and factual information it would have captured more of an audience for individuals who like to see factual information along with imagery example. It would speak to young adults who have grown up in such life styles that are less fortunate than others knowing they wouldn’t want that life for anyone else. This article is starting to overlook some of the decisions Loren faced and some of the pros and cons she weighed out in her decision of having an abortion. Using some of her reasons why she went ahead with the abortion could help paint an image in the audiences mind about what her life would have been if she would have continued on with the pregnancy. Adding in how she had enough money to pay for an abortion and how much it cost her with no help from other agencies or even with her health coverage to provide an overview for other who do not have insurance.
“I am not ashamed that, as a 29 year old woman, I am sexually active and I have a healthy, functioning reproductive system. I am also fortunate to have an accommodating workplace, supportive family and friends and the financial resources to handle unexpended expenses.” “Abortion opponent often argue that impediments such as the ones I faced lead women to consider more capable of making appropriate decisions on consultation with my doctor, about my health, my body, my life.” Expressed Loren.
This statement stands out to me as an important statement because it is showing women are individuals just like men, where we should always have our own rights especially when it comes to our bodies. Loren stating how she is healthy and sexually active stands out to me the most because most adults and young adults are very sexually active these days and when an unexpected pregnancy comes along, it shows not only the individual is healthy with being active but also that they are able to conceive without complications. It also brings me to a saying many people like to say, “Everything happens for a reason.” Loren’s actions accounted her in a situation that the consequences would lead her to face the decision of what was best for her and that going forward with the abortion is the reason where she is today and how she has grown from it.
An argument that would have helped Loren’s article would have been if she would have stated the opponents view on the situation. Simply stating how she could have went through with the pregnancy and gave the child up for adoption or even continued to raise the child on her own and how that would of be the “Pro-Life” view on the situation, but then came back with a stronger argument on why it wouldn’t of worked out in her best interest. Giving the example that going through with the pregnancy and giving the child up for adoption would be twice as hard on a woman and following through with factual information such as surveys and test that were taking by woman that not only gave up a child for adoption but other woman that could be put into that very particular situation. Another great argument that could support Loren’s decision of not going through with the pregnancy would be by taking test done by children that are in adoption homes or have foster homes and what kind of hardship it has taken on them knowing that their mothers couldn’t raise them. Many readers could then relate to those statistics due to either being a foster child themselves or knowing someone who has been and the struggle it has put them through emotionally and mentally.
“In the end, I would have gotten an abortion with or without the restrictions placed upon me as a federal employee. It was the decision for me. Restricting my access to health coverage didn’t prevent my pregnancy and it certainly didn’t influence my choice. All it did was punish me financially and otherwise for making a responsible, physician-approved health care decision.” “I’ve now left federal government to pursue a master’s degree, and I am proud of the years I have spent working with the federal government to keep American public safe and secure. However, the mission of preserving my health and well-being rest solely with me and my doctors, and it requires no interference from my government or its politicians.”
Loren is now shifting her audience towards voters, public officials, women, men, pro-life committees to show that women should be the only person in charge of their bodies and if they feel it is a better choice to get an abortion for the better of their health and life then they should be able to do so and the government shouldn’t be able to take that right away from a women. It is very important to keep our rights with how we live our future and what we do to protect it. At this moment the Pro-life community would argue saying if we ban abortions in all states women won’t have any choice except follow through with the pregnancy.
Some of the flaws I found that Loren made in her article were the lack of factual information and the ineffective use of emotion. I feel that some readers base their opinions off of either factual information or an emotional story and with adding those key factors it would have grabbed my attention along with other readers. Many of the states are attempting to ban and put a very strict guide line on abortions and if they do succeed like many states are then many women will be faced to raise a child no matter what the circumstances may be. Protestors will say that we should care for a child whether if it has a heartbeat or not but what they don’t tend to put themselves in the place of women who are in need of abortions or having them. Many of us have our own personal opinions but by being open minded with stories and arguments such as this we can come to learn that all cases for abortion aren’t necessarily a bad thing. If we ban abortion in all states and take the privilege away from a woman to decide if going through with a pregnancy is the best solution to the situation, we will come to see we were wrong because women will always find a way to abort a baby or even worse neglect the child and put it into harm’s way.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the article, “Understanding Reproductive Justice: Transforming the Pro-Choice Movement,” the author, Loretta Ross, argues that while the pro-choice movement has achieved great strides in terms of acquiring and protecting legal abortion rights for women, it has done very little to address and/or challenge the structural inequalities that many women, especially women of color and lower class, have to face when simply trying to access and control their reproductive rights and destiny. Because of this, Loretta Ross proposes that we shift from using the term “pro-choice” when it comes to defining our movement to using a term that is more inclusive and representative of the realities that many non-white women have to face—this term being called “Reproductive Justice.” As was beautifully described in the beginning of her piece, Ross defines Reproductive Justice as being “the complete physical, mental, spiritual, political, social, and economic well-being of women…
- 644 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Abortions are now safer than childbirth itself, having an exceedingly less fatality percentage (“Supreme Court Strikes Down Abortion Restrictions in Texas,” 2016). ● Some individuals think that to put such “restrictions” on clinics creates an “undue burden” for women and their ability to receive an abortion legally (“Supreme Court Strikes Down Abortion Restrictions in Texas,” 2016). ● One argument against the regulations is that it would require a multitude of clinics to shut down, leaving countless women without a clinic nearby (“Supreme Court Strikes Down Abortion Restrictions in Texas,” 2016). ● Due to the fact that “approximately 900,000 women would have to drive close to 300 miles round trip” might cause them to go about other ways of…
- 192 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Every woman in the United States has a wide range of accessible contraceptives to chose from for a variety of reasons for little to no cost in the modern era. Unplanned pregnancy isn’t much of a life-changing problem nowadays. Women have more freedom to chose if they want children without the backlash of others compared to decades ago, although there is still progress to be made. However, without the work of Margaret Sanger and her movement, women would have to be more cautious and worried about fertility. Margaret Sanger strongly influenced modern women’s reproductive rights by being the first to suggest women take control of their own fertility and open America’s first women’s health clinics, despite the law’s disapproval, leading to legal…
- 598 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
With the introduction of Birth Control to the public it had its fair share of legal consequences. The case of Griswold v. Connecticut is considered the foundational decision in recognizing the constitutional right of sexual privacy (Stein, 2010, p. 29). In the case of Griswold v. Connecticut it was stated that Estelle Griswold and C. Lee Buxton were arrested for giving “information, instruction, and medical advice to married persons as to the means of preventing conception” (Stein, 2010, p. 29). Griswold was the executive director of the States Planned Parenthood League and C. Lee Buxton was a licensed physician as well as a professor at Yale (Stein, 2010, p. 29). The Connecticut law was that anyone that encouraged or used birth…
- 536 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
NEW YORK, 1920’s – Will wonder never sees? Who would have thought that we would see clinics that offered education services to women of a sensitive nature? Margaret Sanger has done just this. Earlier this year she organized the American Birth Control League (ENotes). Ms. Sanger is an advocate of the education for women. She feels that too many women are left in the dark with lack of pregnancy care and home abortions. This is becoming a debate amongst religious leaders and law offices more than ever lately. Many argue that this is immoral and should not be discussed…
- 839 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Planned Parenthood is a public health clinic that provides sex ed, birth control, abortion, and plenty of other services. The program is constantly under constant attack for being a waste of government funding and supporting abortions which are considered immoral by a large chunk of America. But Joseph E. Potter and Kari White argue that Planned Parenthood shouldn’t be defunded by Congress because of how negative the outcomes are that have been brought about in the past. Potter and White convince others by using rhetorical devices such as statistics and anecdotes.…
- 360 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
For this project, I would like to discuss the case of Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey in 1992. This case was paramount in changing the way our country handles abortions. I think this topic will be very interesting and informative about how increasingly stringent abortion policies have affected the accessibility of abortions in this country for women. Additionally, it would be important to understand the implication this case had on the topic of women’s’ reproductive rights. First, I found this case interesting because before the results of this case were implemented, abortion rates in the United States were slowly on the rise. Right after this case allowed states to regulate abortion policies, the amount of abortions…
- 353 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Baer, Judith A. Historical and Multicultural Encyclopedia of Women's Reproductive Rights in the United States. Greenwood Publishing Group, 2002. EBSCOhost, 0-search.ebscohost.com.library2.pima.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&db=nlebk&AN=86636&site=eds-live&scope=site. Web. 11 Oct 2017…
- 497 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
A choice is a choice; it is as simple as that. Abortion is a huge controversial issue in the United States that many people disagree on. In the essay, “Owning up to Abortion” Ehrenreich believes that women should not keep in the dark about their abortion, but instead own up to it. Although abortion may be frowned upon by some people, no one should be entitled to judge another women because of their choice. No woman should feel ashamed of having an abortion because it is her choice and no one should make her feel like her choice is invalid.…
- 246 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In today’s world, Democrats and Republicans find themselves in heated battles over women’s rights. Abortion is a controversial topic, and leads to a divide within the American people. However, this is not a new concept. A similar fight about birth control took place in the 1920s, in addition to a parallel argument between men and women over gender roles and expectations. With the passage of the 19th Amendment, women gained the right to vote. Thereafter, they became more independent, which led to changes in society. Young Americans more openly discussed and portrayed their sexuality, and as a result premarital sex became more and more common. Having recently gained the right to vote, birth control and the negative light cast on women’s sexuality…
- 1038 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The control of fertility has always been a topic issue for women. Different pre conception and post conception procedures have been practiced since the ancient times. Abortion has become a major topic for everyone in the United States. It became very focused when the Roe Vs. Wade case was passed. This is because many individuals have strong, colliding opinions on abortion and it’s laws. The two main group views of abortion are pro-life and pro-choice. Pro-life are individuals who believe abortion is wrong, and pro-choice are people who believe it is up to the mother to choose what she wants. While one particular view has not been proven to be correct or incorrect, it has brought many persuasions to the table on what should be considered the…
- 1687 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Throughout history, and in current society the world has faced several social problems. One social problem the world is currently facing is the government’s idea in many states to cut the funding to Planned Parenthood and use the funds in other female medical practices. Planned Parenthood has been funded by Medicaid since 1970 when President Richard Nixon signed into the law. According to some statistics provided by the government, Planned Parenthood receives one-half billion dollars a year from the government. This is a huge social problem because this agency offers anonymous services to both adults and adolescents without parental consent for…
- 231 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
As history has shown us, the mid twentieth century was a time for inspirational and instrumental societal change within the United States. Not only did we have the civil rights movement—a movement that peacefully and strategically fought for the rights and equality of African Americans—but we also had other social movements, such as the women’s reproductive rights movement, which was a movement that fearlessly fought for reproductive rights and overall equality for the women of the United States. Unfortunately, however, as will be discussed in the paragraphs that follow, while the reproductive rights that were acquired were originally intended to benefit all women, due to the nation’s (and white feminists’) racial and classed biases at the…
- 1022 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Alex Morris cites her own personal experience as a rationale to persuade the minds of those in favor of defunding Planned Parenthood. Having experienced an abortion as a result of pregnancy complications, she states that these cuts would have the greatest impact on women with low income and the inability to travel who have children of their own (Morris). It is morally unjust to deny healthcare to underprivileged citizens, and reducing funding towards it will evidently cause more harm than…
- 624 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Since the Roe v. Wade decision, women have exercised their “right to choose” more than 53.3 million times (UnBornInTheUSA). The decision of Roe v. Wade is stretched beyond recognition interpretation of the privacy provisions of the Bill of Rights. Where the Constitution is silent, the people get the final say, which is exactly what happened in the case of Roe v. Wade. Recently, an increasingly conservative Supreme Court has put into force numerous restrictions on a woman’s right to choose including waiting periods, education on the dangers of abortions, parental consent laws and bands on public funding for uninsured abortions. These are just a few arguments and views of the repercussions of the Roe v. Wade decision. Many people believe this decision will eventually be overturned. The aftermath of re-illegalizing abortions would be horrendous and likely cause many unwanted deaths, damages, and illegal…
- 3092 Words
- 13 Pages
Better Essays