Preview

My Brother Sam Is Dead By James Lincoln Collier And Christopher Collier

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
510 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
My Brother Sam Is Dead By James Lincoln Collier And Christopher Collier
War brings death and destruction, merciless slaughter and butchery, disease and starvation, poverty and ruin in its wake. Although war may not always be the first answer or the most beneficial, it is an inescapable evil because war has brought the world peace and prosperity while banding people together to fight for a cause. It leads to national growth and solves domestic problems between countries; Injustice and tyranny can be quelled as the aftereffect of war. On the contrary, war includes loss of human life, spreads of diseases, and induces a feeling of anxiety and dismay among communities. The brutal sacrifices that innocent people undergo may not be worth the outcome. In My Brother Sam is Dead, written by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier, Tim must choose whether to be a Patriot, Loyalist, or neutral. The reality of war and the inhuman acts committed induce and instigate his end decision; …show more content…
145. The injustice and discrimination Tim beheld induced him to take neither Patriot or Loyalist. The British soldiers showed no mercy on Neb as they shouted, “ ‘ There are some damned blacks in here, what shall we do with them?’ ‘Kill them’ ” pg 144. The way Ned was being treated showed misuse of power, discrimination toward blacks, and injustice towards civilians. This sways Tim to become neutral because of the cruelty and disgust shown towards Ned. How ironic it is that the purpose of the war is to fight for freedom, yet there is still racism present; the soldiers fighting in the war were only fighting for the freedom of rich, white men. Tim ultimately realizes that he didn’t want to stand for either side because of the violent and shameful way they treated

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    He had to drive the cart from Verplancks home, and the British attacked Redding. Tim was confused because he thought that Sam was fighting for a good cause but after this his mind began to change a bit. With all of the drama and madness going on Tim had to decide which side he was for, this was a major part of the book and a very important decision. But instead of choosing a side, he chooses to not choose, to become anti-war. When the book is slowly but gradually coming to an end, Sam gets falsely accused of stealing cows. Tim and his mother tried desperately to save Sam from getting killed but all of their attempts failed, so on one awful day Sam gets…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O'Brien feels a great deal of guilt when he thinks about dodging the Vietnam draft. They physical and emotional aspects of dodging the draft made O`Brien fear fleeing the United States to avoid going to Vietnam. Ultimately he made the decision to go to Vietnam and honor his country. The people in O'Brien's life, and the opinions they possessed influenced his overall decision and later added to the shame and guilt he felt. “It was as if there was an audience to my life, that swirls of faces along the river and in my head I could hear people screaming at me” (O`Brien 57) O'Brien was guilted into staying in the United States because of the opinions of his peers, but at the end of the day the guilt ate away at him to honor the draft and serve his home…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “I would not be brave. That old image of myself as a hero, as a man of conscience and courage, all that was just a threadbare pipe dream.” The impasse reached by Tim O’Brien as mentioned in “On The Rainy River” was between his moral stance on the war and the preservation of his reputation. Rather than the blatantly obvious external conflict of the war this retelling emphasises the internal conflict and angst felt by the young men sentenced to fight in it. The personal battle mainly stems from the conflicting emotions of Tim O’Brien as if he stays true to his morals then he faces exiled, losing the respect of his parents or being subjected to ridicule. Whereas if he goes then he will be going against his own morals which are telling him to run for the sake of his family, his friends and most importantly, his sanity.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading the book My Brother Sam is Dead, I realized the plot of the book wasn’t what I expected. Judging by the title, you’d think the book is about a guy named Sam, but it’s really about his brother, Tim. The story takes place during a period of war, and Tim, as the narrator, has to witness his father and brother disagree over which side they are on, the Loyalists or the Rebels. Disobeying his father, Sam goes to war to fight the Loyalists, and Tim is stuck at home worried about his brother, but also admires his brother for his bravery. The war had a huge effect on Tim’s personality. As the book goes on, Tim grows up due to the situations war put him through. Tim has grown up immensely throughout the book by gaining responsibilities,…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The majority of the people will feel guilty when they do bad stuffs like lying and cheating. They will feel even guiltier when their friend dies because of them and when they kill somebody. Tim is like that way; he felt guilty when he experiences the death of his friends and enemies. In Vietnam, people are dying everywhere, including their friends. Rat Kiley’s friend, Curt Lemon, dies while they were playing catch with a smoke grenade. Although, the grenade did not kill Lemon and he dies when he stepped on a mine: which blew him everywhere. Kiley blamed himself for Lemon’s death and felt guilty for it. Comparatively, Kiowa dies in the poop field when he was hit by a mortar. Tim and Lieutenant Cross blamed themselves for Kiowa’s death. Tim thinks if he never pulled his flashlight out and show a picture of his girl then the mortar will not have any target to hit.…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O’Brien felt like he had to be at the war because of people in his community and would have felt ashamed if he didn’t go to war. The war in some of the people of the communities eyes felt like the war was a privilege not a right to go to war, so that means that Tim has to think that the war is an immunity granted to him. He says about the man he killed, “He would have been taught to defend the land was man’s highest duty and highest privilege. He had accepted this...He could not picture himself doing the brave things his father had done, or his uncles, or the heroes of the stories.” (119) This shows how Tim O’Brien had the same complications as this young man he had killed. He had felt like he himself and the soldier could have been so much more and followed their dreams. The soldier and him felt the expectations of his community and family. When he said in the text that he had to do the brave things his family and the heroes had done that he had to follow the tradition and put his whole dream to the side just to fit into the communities expectations, which leads to the stereotypical pressure put on them to follow…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    my brother sam is dead

    • 1365 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Tim explains the religious background of the town of Redding. People built their houses according to the church they attended, either Anglican or Presbyterian. Tim's family lives in Redding Ridge, which signals that they are Anglicans and therefore loyalist. Tim does not feel he is particularly tied to the loyalist or Rebels, which worries him. Tim speaks of the effects of the war on his home life. He had thought the war would bring battles and great change to his quiet Connecticut village, but it has not. There are no marching armies, no cannons, and no food shortages. There are just lots of talk about the war, as there always was. Occasional the arguments get heated, as when Father throws a man out of the tavern for subversion, by which he means criticism of the British army. Betsy often stops by to listen to conversations, but Tim's mother always shoos her along.…

    • 1365 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Brother Sam Is Dead

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the beginning of the book, Tim is dependent and has yet to grow up. At first, Tim wants to be exactly like Sam and do everything that he does. In the book Tim tell us, “I just wanted him (father) to shut up until dinner was over and we could go up to the loft where we slept, and I could lie in the dark snuggled up next to him to keep warm and let him tell me stories about Yale and the pretty girls he knew in New Haven…” Page nine. This shows that Tim still idolizes his brother. This is shows that Tim uses the stories that he hears as a way to avoid growing up.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea of war brings up many questions about life and death, suffering, and consequences. While many people may see war as something that affects people as a whole, such as nations or a persecuted group, war further impacts every individual, whether or not they are directly involved. War limits freedoms and individualism, and in most cases people find themselves with less rights than during peacetime. People base their choices not on what they feel, and more on what they have to do to survive. Soldiers and civilians alike are influenced by war in different ways, however, these tie together when the overall effects of war are examined.…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A boy dressed as a patriot fighting for his freedom wondering what would have happened if he stood home, would that be better. In the book My Brother Sam is Dead the authors wrote about a boy named Tim in between the American Revolution with his family, Sam, Susannah, and Eliphalet Meeker. The oldest son,Sam, has come back from Yale in a patriot uniform. There is one problem the head of the house, Eliphalet, is a loyalist and disagrees with war especially if his son is fighting in it. In the book although both sides of the war are shown the authors Collier and Collier ultimately argue war is futile.…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To conclude, there is no doubt that the conflict of war is a useless encounter that affects many innocent people’s lives, the economic stability and physiological wellbeing of soldiers. It is evident that in some circumstances society makes war to ensure peace, and on the surface this seems rational, even plausible. However, in reality throughout the journey there is a great human and economic cost…

    • 66 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “At night, when I couldn’t sleep, I’d sometimes carry on fierce arguments with those people…” (O’brien). Tom describes the people as blind, thoughtless and simple minded. He felt the people who were sending him off to war should go, not force him to go. Tom’s thoughts were to put your own flesh and blood on the line before you put someone else. These people did not understand his perspective on the subject, his civil rights or the governments postcolonial effect.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These decisions don’t come easy. Although Tim and Kamau receive different degrees of support, both of them are able to resolve their situations. As Tim attempts to make his choice about going to the war, he is greeted with unexpected help from a man named Elroy. Elroy provides Tim with a safe way to discuss his choices and their possible outcomes.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I agree with Tim because it's better to go to war for your country then run away from the law the rest of your life. I do believe if you support the war then you should sacrifice yourself not others. He states this when he says, "If you support the war, if you think it's worth the price, that's fine,but put your own precious fluids on the line." What this quote is saying is if you support the war then you should go enlist in the army yourself. Tim is forced to join the army by his community and family, he states this when he says," I felt paralyzed. All around me the options seemed to be narrowing, as if I was hurtling down a huge block funnel, the whole world squeezing in tight" he had no other option and was pushed into this…

    • 145 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    War Movies

    • 2475 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The concept of war is a very interesting area that needs to be examined. This is due to the fact that the concept indicates that it is the war which makes nations great. For instance, the countries which are powerful ion the economic front are the countries which are ahead of the others on the war front. This discussion indicates the fact that the war has a national importance and the different parties will have different ideas about it. However, over the long term it is clear that the results of war are not positive on the human society. While there are many discussions on the war based on the movies, it is clear not all the movies depict war in the same light. This indicates the different points of views that the people have on the wars.…

    • 2475 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays