Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

"My Place" by Sally Morgan: an Analysis.

Good Essays
1398 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
"My Place" by Sally Morgan: an Analysis.
Sally Morgan's 'My Place' is an autobiographical account of three generations of Aboriginals, which illustrate the social history of Aboriginals from the point of view of an Aboriginal and marks its development as society evolves. Two aboriginals, Gladys and Daisy Corruna, of the Stolen Generations describe the Paternalism which led to their shame of being Aboriginal and forced them to hide the truth of their past from their children. Paternalism also led to the creation of a new identity caused by the loss of culture and heritage experienced by the Stolen Generation and the unacceptance of the white population. Another of the Stolen Generation, Arthur Corruna, tells of the hardships involved with being a half-caste and trying to get ahead in life. The fourth, Sally Morgan, the author, describes what it was like to grow up with a false sense of identity. She records the events in her life which signify the time when she knew nothing of her heritage and was struggling to understand herself and the different mannerisms of her family.

White society established their dominance over the indigenous people of Australia by exercising social and political control such as the paternalism involved with institutions. Half-caste children were sent to institutions in the hope that the 'white' part of their blood would allow them to be trained and educated as white. These children are often referred to as stolen, something of which Gladys, Sally's mother, identifies with as she was taken from her family at the age of four, to live at the Parkerville institution. "I always thought of myself as a stolen child," (pg. 246) represents the animosity with which many half-caste children felt during their stay at institutions like Parkerville. Gladys' mother Daisy was never institutionalized but was taken into Perth under the pretext of becoming educated. "They told all the people I was goin' to school," (pg. 332) but was instead taken to serve the Drake-Brockman family and "she thought I was coming back" (pg. 332) highlights the deceit of the white people in the methods they used to separate aboriginal children from their families. Daisy's distrust for most white people stemmed from the many lies the Drake-Brockman family had presented her with during her working years and this distrust developed into a feeling of shame, "People looked at you funny 'cause you were black. I kept my eyes down" (pg. 336). 'My Place' presented the opportunity for Sally to finally delve into the family history which her Nan had always hidden from her and her siblings and finally brought about the admission that her Nan had been ashamed. "I wanted to be white you see...It'd be the best thing" (pg. 336) represents the feelings of many older Aboriginals who experienced both the sexual assault by their bosses and the subsequent loss of their half-caste children to institutions as well as being condemned to a life of servitude.

The consequences of being taken away from their Aboriginal mothers meant the subsequent loss of language, culture and displacement from both the white and black societies. After Arthur was taken from his Station, he was forced to speak only English which brought about a loss of Aboriginal status, and prevented communication between non-English speaking parents and other Aboriginals. The status of half-caste prohibited children from entering into white society because of their black blood and the removal of half-caste children to institutions and their ability to speak English prohibited them from taking part in initiation rights and ceremonies of the indigenous society. Sally's Nan claimed that their status as half-caste had them classified as being "too black for the whites and too white for the blacks" (pg. 336).

Arthur, Daisy's brother, was also taken to an institution, but ran away after being beaten and started a life as a farmer, determined to make a future for himself. At first, "men teased [Arthur]...they didn't want a blackfella movin' in," but he aspired to look after his family as well as any white man. After the Depression in the 1920's, he became "the first farmer in the district to have a truck and the first to buy a header" (pg. 208). Arthur recounts events of white people stealing his crops and sheep, and taking every opportunity to try and buy him out of the farm or send him in to debt. This served to give Arthur the knowledge that he was "a black man ahead of everybody else," (pg. 209) and instilled in himself the pride of being a successful black man when everything was against him. Gladys "wondered what was wrong with being Aboriginal" (pg. 279) and remembered an instance where her mother had said, "never tell anyone what [you] are" (pg. 279). She became even more confused and, looking back, she says she didn't know much about the way Aboriginals were treated but also tells of the foretold future for any Aboriginal, no matter how white they were or how much white blood they contained, "we had no future, I'd never be accepted, never be allowed to achieve anything" (pg. 279). This suggests the white persons' fear of being overshadowed by a black person, whom they considered less human and inferior. The end of Gladys' story invokes a hope of further Aboriginal expression, "maybe other Australians will see that we are a people to be proud of" (pg. 306).

Sally must also be considered a stolen child, for she is a descendant of stolen children, whose heritage was stolen by the white Australians. Her history has been hidden because of the shame instilled in her Nan and mother because of the actions of the whites. Sally's confusion began as a child, when people at school asked her where she came from. The shortness of Gladys' answer, "tell them you're Indian," (pg. 38) implies the intensity with which her mother, Gladys, sought to end the conversation and continue to forget. As Sally became older, she became even more confused and curious about her heritage; she wasn't satisfied with her mother's claims of being Indian, and her Nan's behaviour when it came to authority. She applied for an Aboriginal scholarship when she was at University and encouraged her sister, Jill, to declare their heritage and take pride in it. Sally's pride in her heritage and her Nan's unwillingness to divulge her past lead Sally to the production of the book which, in the end, freed her mother and her Nan from the secrets and fears and sufferings they had endured over the years.

Sally confronts the injustices experienced and exposes the treatment Aboriginals have been subjected to throughout white settlement of Australia while including emotional elements of love, suffering, displacement, racism and feelings of identity crises. The removal of half-caste children by white people created an unnecessary new identity for Australia, which further isolated families and societies. Autobiographies like Morgan's create opportunities for Aboriginals who have felt oppressed to express their thoughts and feelings and gain acknowledgement for their suffering from the white population through a medium other than traditional Aboriginal art. They also represent a site for those to record their protests and objections to past versions of colonial history which often tended to forget or distort the truth. This is similar to the Japanese, who controlled history books so they could hide the truth of World War II and their involvement. Apartheid and segregation associate themselves with the White Australia Act through the similarity of containing hegemonic views that whites are better and superior to all other races therefore they reserve the right to control inferior beings. The events of this book and now many others now available cause people to rethink the reliability of the declaration of Australia as centrally unified and the candour to which the majority of the world claims equality.

'My Place' was one of the first Aboriginal recounts of oppression under colonialism and paved the way for many more accounts of oppression and the experiences many Aboriginals had. Morgan's book confronts issues of displacement and the subsequent feelings of shame and self-loathing instilled while leading up to an Aboriginal consciousness which originated from the tentative search for knowledge of a single, determined Aboriginal woman. This woman developed a pride in her family's history and led to a spiritual and emotional pilgrimage for the entire Milroy/Corruna family which allowed to celebrate a heritage which previously had brought shame and suffering.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Laura Hillenbrand’s Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption follows the story of Louie Zamperini, a rebellious child who grew up to become one of the fastest runners of the 1930s. He competed as an Olympic track runner in the 1936 Berlin Olympics. The future was looking bright for Zamperini before World War II began, which resulted in the Olympics being cancelled and Louie being drafted into the Army Air Forces as a bombardier. Midway through 1943, his B-24 crash landed in the Pacific Ocean. For weeks, Louie and two other men drifted westward across a seemingly endless ocean, accompanied by a pack of sharks and surviving on scraps of bird and fish meat and the occasional rainfall. Eventually, he arrived in Japanese…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel “the She “ by Carol Plum-Ucci is based on the main character , Evan Barret Evan is just getting over the death of his parents and beginning to push the mysterious occurrences surrounding the event to the back of his mind. And his big brother (now guardian) is helping. Eight years of repressing memories and avoiding belief in a sea man's superstition known only as "The She". But one school project has the power to change all that. When Evan must help a mean girl of the first degree he discovers that they might have more in common than he'd thought and that there might be more to the disappearance of his parents than anyone had ever dared admit, who is living with his older brother Emmett, a philosophy graduated student. Also, eight years before, his parents were lost at sea. Evan’s parents died in a tragic…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the novel, My Sister's Keeper was made into a movie different characters are the focus and the ending and its plot twist is changed. Jodi Picoult wrote this novel in a special format. All her chapters were divided by each character in the novel and they would narrate their feelings upon central problem which was Kate’s Sickness. Jodi Picoult worked at several of different jobs throughout her life. One of her major goals was becoming a writer. For Picoult, My Sister's Keeper was a big accomplishment. Jodi Picoult made Kate’s sickness and Anna's lawsuit a central issue which allowed the main character's to share their stories and feelings about it.She also received an honorary Doctor of Letters degree from Dartmouth College in 2010 and another…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many immigrants describe their initial experience of Australia to be one of struggles and displacement. This is likely due to a lack of attachment to the rugged Australian landscape and unfamiliar people. Raimond Gaita in his memoir Romulus, My Father, and Sobonfu Some in his short story A Place to Belong both explore the immigrant experience of struggle and displacement through contrasting views of the natural surroundings and a sense of foreign place acting as…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Despite being the “traditional custodians of the land”, Aboriginal people greatly suffered from lack of human rights, especially between 1901 and the 1960’s. In 1962, NSW was the only state in Australia that gave Aboriginals the right to have control over their children. This meant that government organisations were given the authority to take children away from Aboriginal families. The Aboriginal Protection Board is an example of a government organisation that used this authority to breed out Aboriginals in Australia. The Protection Board would infiltrate Aboriginal communities and take away half-caste children because they could be taught the “white ways.”…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The autobiography “Coming of Age in Mississippi,” by Anne Moody is the story of her life as a poor black girl growing into adulthood. Moody chose to start at the beginning - when she was four-years-old, the child of poor sharecroppers working for a white farmer. In telling the story of her life, Moody shows why the civil rights movement was such a necessity, she joined the NAACP to be a rebel, an also showed the depth of the injustices they suffered.…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the past decade there may have been an increase in homelessness due to the struggles of daily life. People have many ideas on ways that the government or communities can help improve these situations. It is not easy to help the homeless but any help can improve their lives and our streets. It may not take them completely off our streets but it can help them to get back on their feet.…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the essay How to Mark a Book the author, Mortimer J. Adler, brings up the idea and topic of what makes a book worthy of being ‘marked up’ and what he considers to be a light read. He uses examples such as Paradise Lost and Gone with the Wind; The latter being deemed not as worthy. The reason being because it simply does not make you think quite as hard as say, something such as the Bible would. It does not require as much thought and conversation with the author. With that being said, what determines if a book is light? If an easy read of fiction could simply fall into this category, perhaps a book such as The Giver would not require as much thought in comparison to Shakespeare’s Hamlet, therefore not worthy of being marked up. The purpose of this essay will be to determine whether or not…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Housekeeping, the tragic story of two sisters, Ruthie and Lucille, struggling through their teenage years as they experience turmoil within their family. Through the story the girls bond stretches and eventually snaps but they both arrive at the same moral and thematic conclusion. Due to differences in beliefs and personality they make different decisions and this leads to a sudden separation. The book Housekeeping by Marilynne Robinson shows that if your problems seem too big too handle it’s okay to run away from them. This is exhibited by the author’s tone when talking about events, the events themselves, and the mood that these events transfer to the reader.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The memoir, Romulus, My Father, portrays the ways in which immigrants in 1950’s rural Victoria struggled to be accepted in a foreign society, exploring both Romulus and Gaita’s personal experiences with Belonging. The tone of the narrative is retrospective; Gaita makes himself vulnerable to his responder by inviting them to observe Australian society from the perspective of a migrant. Romulus’ experience is typical of a first generation migrant, he is displaced, separated from his homeland, conveyed through the metaphor of his disconnection to the Australian landscape: “He longed for European society, saying that he felt like a ‘prisoner’ in Australia.” Romulus is an example of stoicism displayed through typically male qualities, defined by his work ethic and strong European morals. Romulus’ European values are echoed by Hora and among the intolerance and alienation of Australian society, they find connection. The setting at the isolated Frogmore provides the Europeans with the opportunity to establish their own values away from mainstream Australia. This draws attention to their emotional need to belong; they group together through shared experience and background.…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 'Stolen Generations' are the generations of Aboriginal children taken away from their families by governments, churches and welfare bodies to be brought up in institutions or fostered out to white families. The Governments, churches and welfare bodies controlled the aboriginal people from where they could live, where they could work, and what kinds of jobs they could do, who they could associate with and who they could marry. The indigenous children were often forced from their parents and adopted into white families or taken to missions. Children as young as babies were stolen from their families to be placed in girls and boys homes, foster families or missions. At the age of 18 they were ‘released’ into white society, most scarred for life by their experiences.…

    • 517 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Questions & Answers

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In this scene, Gladys reveals her ‘dreamer’ side as she drifts in and out of thoughts about meeting the Queen whereas Nan Dear shows her ‘closed minded’ side as she constantly reminds them throughout the scene of reality through the revelation of her history. We find out that Nan Dear was born on the Murray River and was forced to leave due to the difference between the importance of the ‘white’ and Aboriginal races at the time in that area. Jane Harrison is using this contrast to show the reader how much of an impact that time was and to educate the reader of the thoughts and feelings of those who were put through those circumstances.…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rainbows End Essay

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Gladys another one of the main characters has a much softer attitude to white society and longs to participate in community activities. Nan dear tries to discourage her from doing so. She distrusts the whites as she was forced to leaver Cummeragunja, her place of belonging, because of the descrimination she was shown from the whites. Gladys never having experienced such things, and see’s nothing but opportunity in the white society, and strongly believes that her ethnicity shouldn’t hold…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I want to start off by saying how excited I am to be joining A Place for Mom!! I started my career in health care nine years ago, originally working in nursing. I have worked in a variety of health care settings; Independent/Assisted Living, Memory Care, Long Term Care, Skilled Care, and the Hospital. I always knew I wanted to help people, seniors in particular. As a child I grew up living next door to my grandparents and did everything with them, this is where my love for seniors began. While working in the Hospital I came to the conclusion that nursing was not the way I was going to help people. I began working at an Assisted Living Community in Ames, Iowa as the Sales Director. I quickly learned that, that was how I was going to help people. For three years I got the pleasure of not only helping many families relieve their stress and fears for their loved ones care and safety, but I was also able to ensure their loved ones were able to live out their final years thriving. It was truly the most rewarding job, which brought me to A Place for Mom. At A Place for Mom I won't be limited to helping just the families that…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reading the first part of Sherry Turkle’s book Alone Together has brought some interesting questions to my mind. I have often joked about friends of mine who play Massively Multi-player Online Games, such as World of Warcraft and Second Life, being addicted to their “game of choice”. And after reading & discussing this book, while also dealing with personal issues that closely relate to this subject matter, I wonder if there isn’t actually some truth in those jokes. This line of thought has lead me to formulate a couple of questions on the subject of technology addiction, and its affect on the real world lives of its users.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays