Preview

Najmah's Losses In Under The Persimmon Tree

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1907 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Najmah's Losses In Under The Persimmon Tree
(AGG) Losses can affect a person’s life and how they act by the decisions they make. (BS-1) With Baba-jan and Nur gone, Najmah has to step up and be more mature to keep her and Mada-jan safe and alive. (BS-2) Najmah has seen her mother and baby brother die right in front of her and she has to handle herself. (BS-3) Najmah knows that if she goes back to her homeland she has a chance of saving her farmland. (TS) In Under The Persimmon Tree, Najmah’s losses has changed and shaped her throughout the novel which has affected her decisions.

(MIP-1) Najmah has to step up and become more mature in order for Mada-jan and herself to survive. (SIP-A) Najmah has changed and become a mother to Mada-jan because she has witnessed Baba-jan and Nur get
…show more content…
(SIP-A) Najmah’s encounters has led her to this decision because she has been through alot and she knows it would make Baba-jan proud. (STEWE-1) Najmah is alert and ready for whatever happens but she knows that if she doesn't go back home the land will be taken, “I hear footsteps and a man speaking angrily, and I know it is my Uncle. My heart leaps into my mouth. I know Bibi Nusrat will not tell him I am here. But what if he forces his way inside? I turn out the light in my room and slip out into the hallway to listen” (Staples 241). Najmah knows that if she gets caught by her uncle she will have to go back home and he will surely have her forced into marriage. He will take her father’s land and she will be sent away so he can have the land all to himself. (STEWE-2) Najmah and Nur both know that they have to return to Golestan,“‘We have no choice but to return to Golestan,’ says Nur quietly. ‘Uncle or someone else surely will take our land if we don't go back. It was our father’s last wish that we keep our farm from the hands of the Taliban or Uncle”’ (Staples 256). Najmah can’t stay with Nusrat because she has to go back to Golestan and protect their farm land from enemies or other people that will take their land. Her father’s last wish was to keep the land for generations to come, but she can't if she doesn't go back and protect it. This powers her to keep …show more content…
(BS-3) Najmah has decided not to go with Nusrat, and to stay to try and keep her family’s farmland. (BS-2) Najmah’s life will change drastically after the losses that she has gone through especially after Baba-jan and Habib dying. (BS-1) Najmah’s life will become harder from now on because she has to become more mature and take care of Mada-jan. (R) Najmah has to use what's within her to keep her going and not give up, as a famous author once said, “What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us” -Ralph Waldo

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    1-Brief overview about the chapters: In Woomera Najaf is depressed because he is alone and feels isolated. He doesn’t understand why he doesn’t get instant citizenship and is put into a detention centre. He tells the story of when his house blew up and people died. Reflecting on his old life and kinds of things he had to deal with every day in Afghanistan. He is sad because people died.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary Of Saving Sourdi

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages

    She tries to keep the same bond throughout the story. She is selfish because she wants her sister all to herself. She is not happy when Sourdi goes out with Duke because she is scared that someone will take Sourdi away from her. That is one of the reasons she does not like Mr. Chhay because he married Sourdi and they moved away so Nea barely saw her sister. Nea is very controlling. She expected things to go the way they were when Sourdi and she were little. Her life is so complicated; at her young age she has seen a lot that has just confused her. She never understood why her sister married such an old guy. Sourdi was unhappy with her arranged marriage but she never tried to do anything about. Nea was more concerned about it and she voices her opinion to her mother, who does not listen to what she is saying. No one ever took the time to explain to her what was going on so she made her own…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How would it feel waking up to bombings and screams? imagine a world where you wake up hoping the previous day was just a nightmare and realizing it wasn't. This is how the Taliban is portrayed in the book Under the Persimmon Tree by, Susan Fisher Staples. One of the main characters, Najmah, is greatly impacted by the Taliban. These horrible people have destroyed her family by separating them and even killing some of them. The way the Taliban is portrayed in the book is similar to how it is in real life, the presentations showed that the Taliban is a group of people who are extremists.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Woods is obsessed with searching – It focuses on the loss that causes the search, and in particular what that loss is. Many different things are lost in, In the Woods, but no loss is more surprising than when Rob loses Cassie at the end of the novel. Tana French demonstrates the role of what the loss is through Rob’s thoughts, “I never knew, not then, not now, whether Cassie thought she hung up or whether she wanted to hurt me, or whether she wanted to give me one last gift, one last night listening to her breath” (425) the moment he realized he had lost Cassie for good. Through this quote, the author illustrates the loss of Cassie to Rob by exposing Rob’s feelings and emotions to the reader. Rob is shown feeling both longing and confusion. The confusion Rob displays is shown through Rob not recognizing what Cassie’s motives were. Rob displays longing in the last part of the quote “listening to her breathe” (French 425). This is a tie-in to many of the times in the book where Rob talks about being in sync with Cassie and how well they work together. Longing and confusion are often displayed in a period of deep loss to a person and Tana French uses these feelings as a tool to emphasize the loss Rob felt. The repetition of the words “one last” (French 425) in the final sentence also highlight the loss of Cassie. The syntax of the quote places an emphasis on the words one last, revealing that Rob doesn’t want it to be the last gift or the last breath he receives from Cassie. The different desires that are longed for by the character is another tool Tana French uses to show loss throughout the…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Road to Chilfa

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After reading the book written by Michele that is talking about Karim and Maha’s grow-up experience during the age of war, I think everyone who has read the book has different feeling about it. It’s a special story telling us about human nature, death, maturity, dream, challenge and love that we have gone through in everyone’s life journey. As far as I’m concerned, though I haven’t experienced such a long travel like they do, I really enjoy their story and they tought me that accepting responsibility is our first but essential step to our maturity and our original dream. That’s life, right? Only by going through all kinds of hardships can we know the true meaning of how to grow up.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cause Of Najmah Conflict

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages

    (MIP-3) These symptoms that Najmah experiences throughout the book create the conflict of Najmah's inability to connect that is seen in the story. (SIP-A) Najmah's emotional numbing and disconnection from others creates separate conflicts. (STEWE-1) Her emotional numbing leads to her inability to sympathize or experience emotions. This is clearly shown through her reaction to a young boy being pulled from the rubble, in which she "thinks [she] should feel grateful that he survived, even though [her] own baby brother did not" and then goes on to say that "[this] [was] only [a] [thought], with no feelings attached" (Staples 103). This inability to sympathize or experience emotions leads to a man vs. self conflict in Najmah of her inability to…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Country of men

    • 515 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Relationship between friends and family further demonstrates the struggle between loyalty and betrayal. When Najwa’s friend’s salma’s husband is taken away, Najwa withdraws her friendship and even instructs her son that ‘this is a time for walking besides the wall.’ On one hand, this can be seen as a great betrayal between the two friends, as Najawa is effectively abandoning Salma in her time of greatest need, however conversely it illustrates her undying loyalty to her family. Rather than compromising her family safety, she is willing to cease all interaction with the girl for that is described as ‘two lost sisters who had finally found each other’.…

    • 515 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Loss Of Najmah

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages

    (MIP-1)The loss of her mother and baby brother affected Najmah in a behavioral way, not physical. (SIP-A)Najmah is in a state of shock that were caused by the loss of Mada-Jan and Habib. (STEWE-1)After experiencing the loss of Mada-Jan and Habib she feels like she has no point to live anymore because every family member of hers has been taken by the Taliban. “I don't care whether the Taliban find me and kill me” (83). Najmah is feeling hopeless now because she has no family left and no one to take care of her or even cares about her. (STEWE-2)Najmah was forced to dress as a boy and didn’t have any other choice. By dressing as boy Najmah has thrown away her old self and now becoming a new person.”You will be safer dressed as a boy traveling…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Saving Sourdi

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The first time Nea tried to protect her sister was by stabbing a man who was drunk. She thought that Sourdi was in trouble and instead of getting an adult, she tried to become the adult. She became almost furious when her sister or her mom did not back her up in this decision. “I couldn’t believe it. I wanted to take the knife back and stab myself.” (Chai) Nea wanted Sourdi and Ma’s approval for the decisions she made in life. She only wanted to do the right thing.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mariam was living with her mother Nana out of the city. Nana was always sacrificing every little thing for Mirima but she never notice what her mom was doing for her. Until one day when Mariam decides to go looking for her had without caring for what Nana was going to say. Jalil, Mariam’s dad didn’t let Mariam into his house, Mariam was extremely upset and left home but before she went looking for her dad, Nana said to Mariam that if she leaves she was going to kill herself: “ The rope dropping from a high branch, Nana dangling at the end of it” ( Hosseini 36). That day Mariam realizes that Nana kill herself for her, she has just sacrifice her life for her daughter because her daughter was the love of her life. Over the years of not having Nana by her side and she being gone Mariam now knows how much Nana sacrifice. Nana went through many obstacles while having Mariam. She didn’t give Mariam away, Nana endure the shame and she was loving Mariam in her own way. When Mariam was seeing that Laila was sacrificing her life for her baby when she was giving birth Mariam thought “ruefully of Nana of the sacrifices that she too had made”( Husseini 287). Mariam now knew what mothers sacrifice for their…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The culture Nel was born into was full of prejudice. As a result of that prejudice, she was greatly motivated to direct her own life, but she was still faced with obstacles. Her mother was adamant that Nel conform to the same life as other community members, but Nel wanted a path to freedom. Although she had inclination, her ethnicity had a detrimental effect on her dreams. Her marriage to Jude was the end to “any sparkle or splutter she had,” which conformed to all she had been taught (Morrison 83). The black community had put a limit on the potential of Nel. This was an extension of the hardships many African Americans faced as they tried to move up in the world.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Teamwork In Blood Red Road

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages

    There is a moment in life when one has the sensation of having lost everything they hold dearest at heart. Saba, the protagonist of the novel Blood Red Road, experiences the emotion of helplessness and depression. Right before her eyes her father is murdered; her twin brother, Lugh, whose existence means the whole world to her is taken away. Due to these harsh realities striking her all at once, she begins to isolate herself from everyone. Nonetheless, throughout the novel she opens her eyes, seeing the significance of teamwork. Therefore, collaboration with others allows flaws of operating individually to dissipate; the knowledge one may lack can be mended by others, learn new things as well as their presence aid one in difficult times as…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Suffering and loss is a regular situation in the human life cycle, it is vital to learn how to deal with it so that it doesn’t affect the rest of our lives negatively. In Scott Russell Sanders’s Ten Reasons Why We’ll Always Need a Good Story he explains that one of the reasons is to help us deal and become aware of suffering, loss, and death. During our youth we often don’t consider the end of the life cycle. However, in life we will always encounter grieving from a loved one’s death. The first time we experience some sort of grieving it may be very hard to handle and may cause depression. Stories help us prepare for moments of suffering, loss, and death with fictional experiences which show us how to deal with these unfortunate events. In the three short stories we read at least one character in each story is forced to deal with suffering, loss, or death. In the short story Bluffing by Gail Helgason, Liam has an unfortunate accident and experiences physical pain as well as the emotional pain of his deteriorating relationship with Gabriella. In Two Words by Isabel Allende, Belisa Crepusculario is devastated by the death of her entire family due to their impoverished lifestyle and the love between her and the Colonel causes them to miss each other. In The Indisputable Weight of the Ocean by Darryl Berger, Edmund deals with not being able to see his father and deals with the suffering of moving to a suburban area.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The nonchalance of the inciting incident of the play illustrates the commonality of sexual violence, as neither Christian nor Mama Nadi are surprised or deeply effected that Sophie had been so brutally assaulted by the soldiers in her village. As the scene develops, the intentions of the adults became blatantly obvious, as Mama Nadi stresses that she “runs a business, not a mission” (Nottage 11). Even though Mami Nadi is charitable in housing the damaged girls, her real goal in housing the girls are to use them in the brothel and profit off of the civil war ensuing around them. She welcomes both the government soldiers and the rebels in her brothel, and seems to lack any moral compass or side in the war. In her eyes, engaging with both sides will increase her profit and bring more business with the girls. Luckily for Mama Nadi, Salima and Sophie are simply trying to…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The inheritance of loss is the second novel by Indian author Kiran Desai. The novel was first published in 2006 and won man booker prize in 2007. The book has many diverse characters but one can easy relate to all the characters unlike many novels where characters don’t have much real life traits. But I found it annoying that many characters with senseless names keep popping up with no purpose like Uncle Potty (translate: Uncle Shit), and Major Aloo (Major Potato) and Father Booty. Anyways, there are two protagonists: Biju and Sai. And the action of the novel takes place in the year 1986. . The story is set in Kalimpong, and is based on the backdrop of the Gorkha Insurgency Movement, and how different people and families coped with the situation. The author’s description is very vivid, hence the reader can instantly form a picture of the hills, and the people inhabiting them. The story has a number of sub-plots, which can be boring and tend to divert from the main story. At a point of time, it feels that the author has tried to tackle too many issues at the same time. There’s the main issue of Gorkhas fighting for Gorkhaland, and how people from other places have come and settled at Kalimpong, but treat the natives of the place as their servants, and while they enjoy a comfortable standard of living with elitist tastes like imported liquor and books, the natives live in poverty and detest the people who have come to settle at Kalimpong. In between we get to see the past of the Judge, and the reasons for his eccentric ways, and I found this part of the book to be the most boring. Then there’s the sub-plot of the Judge’s servant’s son-Biju, who is an illegal immigrant to the United States, and how he leads a very inhuman and deplorable existence, yet sends letters saying he is having a good time and moving up in life. The sub-plot is a very relevant issue these days, but could have been omitted. The most…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays