workers one by one turned off their machines. I enjoyed watching the film, Norma Rae. She was a very brave woman for standing up to what she believed in. The book explains the movie with a lot of positive and confrontational observations.
The book states, "It confronts viewers with a realistic vision of an exploitive work system, prompting sympathy for the victim" (Toplin p.204). Norma Rae is not the actual name of the woman who took part in the fight for labor unions. Crystal Lee was the woman who had a significant role in the union victories. The movie makes Crystal Lee (Norma Rae) seem as if it was mostly her who took part in the battle for unions. Despite her powerful aggression towards the subject the book describes it being much more complex than the movie portrays. In reality there were many other people who contributed to the union victories, and it was not only one textile mill that fought. This process also took many years to complete, and the movie suggests that it took place over such a short duration of …show more content…
time. The union struggles began in the early 1970's. The movie came out in 1979, and one year after it was released the president of J.P Stevens signed a statement agreeing to allow union representation. All of this happening in our history contributes to other issues such as, race and woman's rights, which both the book and the movie talk about. In the movie I don't think the health issues are shown to the extent of reality. Workers died all the time from various different reasons. Black lung was a main cause of death. Injuries happened constantly and the workers didn't make enough money to pay for hospital bills. In the movie Norma Rae's father is suffering from a heart attack during work, and his manager would not allow him to take a break. This was a clear example of the unfair treatment that went on through out the mills. The story about Crystal Lee was put into production through the movie Norma Rae.
Although the movie was close to the truth it also did a good job with mixing fact with fiction. Lee played a large part in our history and is recognized still to this day. She was a very promiscuous woman, and the movie makes it seem like she was the only women like that. The movie also twists around the story leaving out important details. It is not half as detailed as the book, and it focuses too much on her and her sexual life. The movie leaves out more important facts such as, how other workers felt and the pain people went
through. Before the production of the film in 1979, the producers needed to get an approval from Crystal Lee on the script. After reading it she was angry with the amount of talk about her promiscuity. Filmmakers sent out people to the southeastern states to find a textile mill to produce a movie about. No one wanted them to produce a movie in their mill due to interruptions of their daily operations. Most of the research was done through the two female producers, Tamara Asseyeu and Alex Rose. This all helped shape the evidence to deliver specific conclusions on the story of Crystal Lee and the fight for labor unions. The film suggested messages for the present by showing the victory at the end of the film. It showed how life got to the way it is now. It allowed a clear view of our history with union problems. The movie really helps a person realize the hardships that went on, and the hardworking efforts that were brought upon people. The film sends messages about how unfair our world can be, at the same time tying in religious beliefs, race differences, and sexual differences. A good example from the movie is when Norma Rae first meets Ruben, and she tells him that she has never met a Jew before. That shows how different the past is to the present. The film definitely developed the "great man" perspective on the past. The movie made Norma Rae the hero of the story. It began showing all the problems of our history with textile mills, and then ending with a victory in defeating the dispute about labor unions. A union means to combine into one. One meaning everyone is together no matter what your race or gender. The movie really shows the struggle with convincing people of what that means. The feeling of weakness and powerlessness is overpowered when Norma Rae shows the workers the endless possibilities, which were offered through joining a union.