Preview

On the Man vs Machine Financial Advisor Debate

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1256 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
On the Man vs Machine Financial Advisor Debate
In 1998, the prevailing wisdom was that e-retailing made sense for every vertical and that all entrenched businesses would eventually fall to a new category-killer, brick-and-mortar was finished forever. Which turned out to be true for some industries (books, music), half true for others (apparel, autos) and not true at all for a few (supermarkets - anyone seen Peapod lately? Webvan?)

So is financial advice like selling CDs? Or is it, in fact, about relationships and confidence more than anything else?

I firmly believe that wealthy people will always prefer to get financial advice from living, breathing, thinking people rather than software. They are happy to pay so as to have real relationships with their estate planners, financial advisors, CPAs and private bankers. This seems obvious to me and probably to you. But it is not obvious to many others.

I don't know Nick Shalek but he seems really smart and well-intentioned in what he's trying to say here:

Thankfully, Software Is Eating The Personal Investing World (TechCrunch)

The gist of his article, which is very good, is that software is better than 99% of humans who attempt to invest money. His post has spread around my industry like wildfire and the reactions to it are all over the map.

I've been asked three times about what I think of his spiel, so I'll give you some bullet points of my reaction to this argument in its entirety, not just Shalek's rendition:

1. I agree with him that simple is better, all new investors should begin with low cost index funds and set up their accounts to automatically add the same dollar amount to them on a regular schedule - regardless of price or market conditions. They should certainly not begin by following stock picks from gurus or rodeo clowns on TV.

2. I agree with him that machines remove the fear-and-greed cognitive foibles from the equation - but what Shalek doesn't get is that investors actually have to learn these foibles firsthand by

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) are known to register businesses and organisations in order to manage and investment schemes. In today’s society they also make rules to ensure there is honesty in the financial markets. These schemes and rules have come into place over the past fifteen years as customers were not feeling comfortable as well as experiencing non honest financial advisors in the past. There have been many circumstances where consultant firms and employees have been slack with the care of information and or guidance to their clients, especially those within the retirement age as they are less likely to understand the new financial trends or products leaving them to decide anything the advisor suggests. This issue results in a loss of customers as well as the want for reimbursement from the firms due to the experience. This being the reason customers lacked confidence in the financial advising business. However, this has changed as ASIC has come a long way in the past 15 years and has been able to get specific regulations approved by legislations resulting in better financial advice. ASIC released this September, a Future of Financial Advice (FOFA) paper that outlines improvements such as managing conflict on the remuneration ban and building there requirements. Due to ASIC realising that good customer feedback and sureness on the service needs to be managed and improved. The fundamental products ASIC focuses on is to make the relationship between the distribution and advice about products such as managing investments, superannuation, platforms and margin loans within a manner that is acceptable within the ASIC guidelines. Although this paper does suggest improvements, there are some areas which have not been improved and unethical…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Basics: age & income & specific responsibilities in life matter in the mix of assets in one’s portfolio.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Bibliography: Berman, K. and Kremer, C. (2007) ‘Pocket Mentor: Understanding Finance: Expert Solutions to Everyday Challenges’, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, US.…

    • 3119 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Warren Buffet is now ranked as the third richest person in 2015. The first reason for Buffet being my mentor is his intelligence in the stock market. Everyday, I strive to become more familiar with the…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Financial planning will become a more important part of financial advisors' value proposition as regulators in key financial markets draft legislation that requires financial advisors to act as fiduciaries with all clients, and wealth management firms seek to differentiate financial advisors' offerings from those of online brokerages. Emphasis on the client, the benefit…

    • 5146 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1982, Dave Ramsey graduated from the University of Tennessee with a degree in Finance and Real Estate. Following those years Mr. Ramsey went from holding a net worth of over a million dollars, to losing his wealth to debt. He paid his “stupid tax” and began the journey of financial security. Ramsey begun to realize that the money trouble he had acquired had began with his own personal impulses and disciplinary disregard for this finances. He preaches that to win with money, you need to have self control and “live like no one else” now, so you can “live like no one else” later. (Ramsey, np) Discipline and having a plan for the future can help you with your finances today. “Put a name to every dollar,” Dave states, talking…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    author of an excerpt from Steve Jobs share similar views on what makes an effective…

    • 572 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are many people that would love to be involved with investing, but have no idea where to start. One significant problem is distrust of Wall Street professionals stemming from the collapse of Lehman Brothers, large banking firms that made disastrous decisions with mortgage lending that led to the housing market crash, and companies like General Motors who seemingly couldn’t manage their own finances. Few people know someone who made it rich from good investing with even fewer knowing someone that could tell you the tools to be able to get there yourself. When asking someone where to start, the replies should have been, “10-K Forms submitted to the Security Exchange Commission is where to start!”…

    • 1201 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kessler’s credentials are important in supporting his claims yet work against his position. The author has previous work experience in chip design and programming, as well as managing a hedge fund. This shows the audience his knowledge of the workforce and a solid education that makes him credible. Kessler is also a writer for The New York Times making his work well known. His published works in notable journals helps better circulate his message. Beyond his work in writing, Kessler has won the Nobel Prize for economics in 2008 and is a professor of Economics and International Affairs at Princeton University. He has written multiple books, one of which won an award of "Best Business Book”. His perspectives on certain occupations negatively affect the credibility of his work. Kessler lists “creator” jobs that are “important” and wont be taken over by technology. Beginning his “creator” lists are jobs in chip designing and code writing. This displays the ultimate biased on the author’s part. By labeling himself as part of the elite, the author greatly weakens his…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The book, The Four Pillars of Investing, by Paul Bernstein is great guide to investing and how to build a winning portfolio for inexperienced investors. This book offers great tips and lessons without becoming too technical or advanced. Instead, Bernstein tries to explain and teach readers the fundamental concepts so that they can make their own decisions by applying the concepts they’ve learned. Bernstein believes that success in investing is built upon four pillars: knowledge of investment theory, an understanding of the history, understanding the role psychology plays in investing, and an awareness of the business aspects of investing.…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    War Without Heroes

    • 2093 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Photography had been around for over 20 years before the civil war started on April 12th 1861, but became increasing popular just before the conflict broke out, due to the development of new techniques. The photography process was complex and very time consuming, photographers had to mix their own chemicals and prepare their wet plate glass negatives. The negatives has to be prepared, exposed, and developed before the emulsion dried.…

    • 2093 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Aig Scandal

    • 2990 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Imagine that this boys parents’ discover one day with their financial planners that they lost all of their investments and insurances in which they paid dearly. The parents had agreed to make an investment so they and their children could have a secured future protection against market risks. Well, it became a reality for many Americans. This devastating loss left many taxpayers with misappropriated assets along with a burden to pay the “bill” for the bailout of AIG.…

    • 2990 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Personal Finance Notes

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages

    According to the featured speaker, is financial planning advice for everyone? How do you know when you need a financial planner?…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    1. Assessment of the Six-Month Outlook for the Market Only four years prior to Michael’s considerations, there was a significant market crash lowering the average value of the Toronto Stock Exchange by 20%. A steep rise in interest rates prior to 1991 and the Persian Gulf crisis lowered the value of stocks as well. There were conflicting signs between markets rallying and the country remaining in recession. With major deficits in place and the government unable to aid recovery by providing stimulus, the economy was not likely to recover incredibly quickly in the next six months which would be the best case. However, with the resolution of conflict and some positive reports like near average dividend yields point towards an eventual recovery even if it takes more than six months. Michael’s long term stock outlook seems reasonable and likely as it is not too bullish and necessitates precaution on his part via some sort of insurance. This slow recovery scenario would avoid the worst case scenario in which a double dip back into some sort of recession occurs. While after a downturn in his portfolio provided awakening, such insight would have been useful before this point in time. Michael had solid gains before this minor collapse and could have protected said profits using the same methods the downturn scared him into taking. Taking advantage after the dip and buy undervalued stocks showed a decent…

    • 4445 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    strat man

    • 13251 Words
    • 54 Pages

    The late 1990s created an illusion for a lot of people who invested in the markets, including financial advisers, who witnessed extraordinary rates of revenue growth tied to investable assets. This bonanza made many of them feel brilliant, especially those who had the wisdom to convert to a fee-based or fee-only model. However, the market correction at the turn of the century and the modest returns projected for the foreseeable future have made revenue growth— at least organic growth—more of a challenge. Several conditions are conspiring against advisers who still hope for rapid revenue growth:…

    • 13251 Words
    • 54 Pages
    Powerful Essays