Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The "Oranges and Apples" narative from the book "Friend Of My Youth" By Alice Munro. Why did Victor Refuse Barbara?

Good Essays
1161 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The "Oranges and Apples" narative from the book "Friend Of My Youth" By Alice Munro. Why did Victor Refuse Barbara?
c

Alice Munro's narrative "Oranges and Apples" is based on the two main characters Victor Sawicky, the golden palomino and Barbara Zeigler, the looker. Barbara is a married woman who is having an affair with the best friend of her husband named Victor Sawicky. She is married to Murray Zeigler, the crown prince of Walley, who is also another main character in our story. However Victor refuses Barbara afterwards because she was his kind and he feels guilty for having such a relationship with her and he can not stick with one girl. We will see these in the following paragraphs.

Firstly, Victor Sawicky turns down Barbara for the reason that she is like him. Victor is splendid man but he is very disturbing. He scattered the clerks when he walked into the store owned by Murray (Munro, 114). Victor is a foreigner and people of his class were never welcomed in the city of Walley but when Victor arrives they receive him with a lot respect because of his looks (Munro, 114). Barbara, in the other hand is a looker. She is splendid and disturbing (Munro, 114). Victor and Barbara are the same class of humans. Murray is waiting for Barbara and Victor to meet so that he could introduce them to each other, almost show them off to each other (Munro, 118). This is the main cause why Victor rejects Barbara since she resembles him as she belongs to the same group.

Secondly, Victor Sawicky refused Barbara because he feels guilty that he had an affair with his best friend's wife. Murray Zeigler, Barbara's husband and also Victor's best friend helped Victor a lot of times. For example Murray gave him the caretaker's apartment when he didn't have a place to live (Munro, 124). Even though Murray is worried about his spouse Barbara, he still offers help to Victor. Murray let his wife to clean the place where he is supposed to reside. (Munro 125). After seeing all this, Victor discovers the true side of Barbara's husband; he is a man with good heart. Victor feels culpable and responsible therefore he refuses Barbara. In addition, Victor wouldn't want to keep a woman who is a mother of two young children. (Munro, 108).

At Last, Victor refused Barbara because Victor is a male prostitute. Victor picks up women easily with his stirring wave of attention, misgiving and excitement (Munro, 116). Victor is attractive to everybody even Murray. "Victor drew his attention as a sleek and princely animal might, say, a golden palomino" (Munro, 114) Barbara, does not care about anything, all she does is reading books after books. Victor even got her to notice him. And to get to know Barbara it is very hard because she does not care about anything and if someone does get to know her then it is an achievement (Munro, 109). Since, Victor got stately Barbara and Murray Zeigler attracted to him he can get any women attracted to him. And Victor traveled a lot to pick up women. He didn't even stay with his wife Beatrice. So, at last he was going to Montreal. Montreal is a place where there are a lot of French women and since Murray is also French speaking man then he goes there so, he feels comfortable with a women he is going to go out with.

To conclude, Victor Sawicky refused Barbara because she was his kind, because he felt guilty and because he is a male prostitute who picks up women.

Alice Munro's narrative "Oranges and Apples" is based on the two main characters Victor Sawicky, the golden palomino and Barbara Zeigler, the looker. Barbara is a married woman who is having an affair with the best friend of her husband named Victor Sawicky. She is married to Murray Zeigler, the crown prince of Walley, who is also another main character in our story. However Victor refuses Barbara afterwards because she was his kind and he feels guilty for having such a relationship with her and he can not stick with one girl. We will see these in the following paragraphs.

Firstly, Victor Sawicky turns down Barbara for the reason that she is like him. Victor is splendid man but he is very disturbing. He scattered the clerks when he walked into the store owned by Murray (Munro, 114). Victor is a foreigner and people of his class were never welcomed in the city of Walley but when Victor arrives they receive him with a lot respect because of his looks (Munro, 114). Barbara, in the other hand is a looker. She is splendid and disturbing (Munro, 114). Victor and Barbara are the same class of humans. Murray is waiting for Barbara and Victor to meet so that he could introduce them to each other, almost show them off to each other (Munro, 118). This is the main cause why Victor rejects Barbara since she resembles him as she belongs to the same group.

Secondly, Victor Sawicky refused Barbara because he feels guilty that he had an affair with his best friend's wife. Murray Zeigler, Barbara's husband and also Victor's best friend helped Victor a lot of times. For example Murray gave him the caretaker's apartment when he didn't have a place to live (Munro, 124). Even though Murray is worried about his spouse Barbara, he still offers help to Victor. Murray let his wife to clean the place where he is supposed to reside. (Munro 125). After seeing all this, Victor discovers the true side of Barbara's husband; he is a man with good heart. Victor feels culpable and responsible therefore he refuses Barbara. In addition, Victor wouldn't want to keep a woman who is a mother of two young children. (Munro, 108).

At Last, Victor refused Barbara because Victor is a male prostitute. Victor picks up women easily with his stirring wave of attention, misgiving and excitement (Munro, 116). Victor is attractive to everybody even Murray. "Victor drew his attention as a sleek and princely animal might, say, a golden palomino" (Munro, 114) Barbara, does not care about anything, all she does is reading books after books. Victor even got her to notice him. And to get to know Barbara it is very hard because she does not care about anything and if someone does get to know her then it is an achievement (Munro, 109). Since, Victor got stately Barbara and Murray Zeigler attracted to him he can get any women attracted to him. And Victor traveled a lot to pick up women. He didn't even stay with his wife Beatrice. So, at last he was going to Montreal. Montreal is a place where there are a lot of French women and since Murray is also French speaking man then he goes there so, he feels comfortable with a women he is going to go out with.

To conclude, Victor Sawicky refused Barbara because she was his kind, because he felt guilty and because he is a male prostitute who picks up women.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The best friend of the man’s father was the father of Caroline Beaufort. When Caroline’s father died, Victor’s father took care of Caroline and then married her when she was of legal age to get married. Their “duty from heaven” was to raise Victor is be good and their guidance is responsible for all his future happiness or misery.…

    • 5394 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    26. Why does Victor come to believe that his monster is responsible for William’s death?…

    • 3236 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    104. What are the marriage plans? How does Victor prepare for what he fears will happen?…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1) Why was the South slow to industrialize after the Civil War? How did industrialization affect the South? Pages 544 and 545…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Smoke signals

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages

    After Victor hears about his dad’s death he decides to go to Phoenix to get his dad’s remains. But he don’t have enough money so Thomas offers him help in one condition that he will be allowed to go with him too. This way Thomas helps him with the money for the travel and they head towards phoenix by the bus. One thing I noticed about Victor was the he shows he is tough through out the movie and he has a belief that if he has to get respected by the white people, he has to be serious and be a warrior which he tells Thomas to do too. When they reach to phoenix, the lady named Suzy gives the remains of Victor’s dad and tells him what kind of good man his father was even though at that stage victor still has the same impression he…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main character trait between Victor and the creature is their love of nature. For example, “My country, my beloved country! Who but a native can tell the delight I took in again beholding thy streams, thy mountains, and, more than all, thy lovely lake” (Shelley 52). Even though Victor is grieving over William’s death, he still finds peace and tranquility through nature. The creature also indulges in the beauty of nature and he also finds peace. “Soon a gentle light stole over the heavens, and gave me a sensation on pleasure” (Shelly 75). When Victor left the creature right after he created him, the creature had no one to care for him so he fled to woods and found that nature enlightens him just as it does for his creator. “The sky became clouded; but the air was pure, although chilled by the north-east breeze that was then rising. But it refreshed me, and filled me with such agreeable sensations…” (Shelly 134). When Victor through the female creature in…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Apple Of My Eye: A Summary of Michael Pollan's 'The Apple' from The Botany of Desire…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Billy is voluntarily in the hospital, as he is afraid of the outside world due to his Mother trapping him and not allowing him to grow as a young male. Billy didn’t have the courage to stand up for himself in the beginning until McMurphy came along and helped expand his growth as a man. Billy finally decides to stand up to Ms. Ratched and have no shame in his actions by sleeping with Candy but ends up backfiring on him. Ms. Ratched threatens to tell Billy’s Mother which leads him to being powerless and vulnerable. Both women held him back from growing up and the fact he’s failed his mother and her envision of him is too much to handle. With all the stress, disappointment, and pressure from the threat given, Billy ends up committing suicide. When McMurphy realizes what has happen he tells Ms. Ratched, “First Charles Cheswick and how William Bibbit! I hope you’re finally satisfied. Playing with human lives—gambling with human lives—as if you thought yourself to be a God!” (Kesey 266). It was all too overwhelming and unbearable for him and at this point it was too late for Billy. Kesey is telling his readers that by Billy holding himself back from sticking up for himself earlier, he most likely wouldn’t have resulted in ending his own life due to the amount of stress and pressure put on him from those who over powered him in his…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Soon after Victor’s recovery he receives a letter from his father telling him to return home immediately because his brother William has been murdered. This is the turning point for Victors realization that the monster was a real presence and a threat not only to him but to his family, because up till now the monster has been pushed to the back of Victor’s mind and now he is asserting himself into Victors’ life as a child might when they are tired of being ignored. The monster is not only responsible for the death of Victor’s brother but for the death of the Frankenstein’s beloved servant Justine, who is accused of the murder. Victor is now suffering for the consequences of his actions as are those around him. Haunted by the thoughts of how he ruined so many lives, he sinks into a deep depression. He tries to escape to the Swiss mountains but the monster finds…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Instead of standing up and taking the blame for creating the monster which ultimately led to the death of his brother, he lets the trial go on and lets Justine die for a crime she did not commit. Victor is more accountable for this death than Justine is because of everything he did to the monster to lead up to this moment. He created the creature and then left it all alone in the wild. The monster could obviously reason and wanted to harm his creator for his abandonment. As he was walking he heard that this man was related to Victor, killed him, and then planted evidence so that it looked like Justine had committed the crime. Victor refuses to take charge of his own actions and instead casts a gloomy fate on all of those close to him. His wife, Elizabeth, is killed later in the story right after they get married. Victor thought that the monster would kill him so he gets away from his wife. He then realizes the creature meant that he would kill his wife but he is too late and she has already been killed. He could have prevented Elizabeth from dying if he had informed her about his secret and given her knowledge that she could have protected herself…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Murder and Victor

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Victor is a very self-centered person, and he is dedicated to his experiment. He becomes obsessed with creating the fiend that he doesn’t communicate with his family. He lets Justine get convicted because he doesn’t want to admit to what he has done. He thought the fiend would kill him on his wedding night, so he protects himself instead of protecting Elizabeth. The fiend is kind-hearted and very lonely. He went out at night, and brought back fire wood for the family. He learned to care about the family, and he hadn’t even talked to them. He would just observe them every day. Everybody is scared of him because he looks different, so he doesn’t have any friends. He finally gets the courage to talk to De Lacey, but when Felix finds him in the house he hits him with a stick. In the end the fiend becomes set on the revenge of mankind. He kills William, Clerval, and Elizabeth to make Victor know what it feels like to be lonely. When Elizabeth dies his father dies of grief. Elizabeth had a positive outlook on life. She cared for the poor, respected all classes of people, and was there for Justine when she was accused of murder. She believes in Justine’s innocence and speaks on her behalf. When Caroline dies Elizabeth takes over the motherly duties of the family. Her feelings for everybody and everything were strong and deep. Alphonse is very supportive of Victor. He takes Victor into the mountains when he is grieving over Justine’s death and his own guilt. He travels to visit with Victor when he is in prison for the death of Henry. 275…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    he back domestic rapidly after receiving a letter from his soon to be wife, elisabeth. even though victor become still laid low with a few emotional misery, he became nonetheless able to go back home, not like the creature who had no one to love and couldn't be frequent with the aid of any ordinary human, hence having no manner of escaping his isolation. the creature's want for interest led him to the murders of the human beings closest to victor. he instructed victor that he "will revenge my accidents: if i can't encourage love, i can motive worry, and mainly towards you my archenemy, due to the fact my writer, do i swear inextinguishable hatred"(139) homicide became the creature's way of receiving interest. the more he killed victor's loved ones, the more interest the creature received from victor. in the end he had killed all people near victor and had received victor's complete attention, whilst victor vowed to do everything inside his "power to capture the monster."(a hundred ninety) now each victor and the creature had nobody to love, best one individual to are seeking for revenge…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On her deathbed, Victor's mother expresses her desire for the ultimate union of Victor and Elizabeth. The fate of Elizabeth is thus utterly dependent upon Victor's, and Victor's relationship with his fellow humans is forever grossly twisted due to his near ownership of Elizabeth. The arrangement of their odd marriage…

    • 1871 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Victor begins his life as an only child constantly being doted on by his parents. He connects this solitude to a sense of power that develops into antisocial behavior in which he indulges in by concentrating solely on his studies and consequently the…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Readers are able to sympathize with Victor because he never intends on harming humanity or have negative effects follow-up his actions and as a result of this Victor strives to warn society about the horrendous beast that lives. Throughout the novel Victor lost hope on numerous occasions but he repeatedly achieved it back and never gave up even in the toughest of times. His determination and triumphant success helped to keep Victor humble at heart. His creation may not be as handsome as to what pleasures the human eye but it is the idea of bestowing life upon the human race that attracts real beauty. It is now in the hands of Walton to decide whether to share or hide the monster from the rest of the…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays

Related Topics