Preview

The Botany Of Desire Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1007 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Botany Of Desire Analysis
Apple Of My Eye: A Summary of Michael Pollan's 'The Apple' from The Botany of Desire
Micheal Pollan begins his bestselling novel, “The Botany Of Desire”, with a question, what is the difference between humans, and the bumblebee? Pollan argues that humans do not have control over nature as we tend to believe, he believes that nature plays an equal or even more dominant role in our relationship. He states, “this book tells a different story of man and nature”(xxv) and he tells this story through the apple. Pollan believes that the apple had much of the control over its destiny; that it is the one that chose its fate, not humans as we are so inclined to believe. He sums up his thoughts up perfectly by stating, “The apple is the hero of its own story”(6)
As Pollan’s thesis states, the apple is the hero. This idea is meant to make the reader uncomfortable, Pollan is trying to make us see the story we have been hearing all our lives in a new light. He wants us to
…show more content…
Pollan continually referenced back to him, for good reason. The apple and John Chapman had a symbiotic relationship, helping each other in ways they could not help themselves. They were equal in their relationship, which Pollan highlights as he discusses the tale of Chapman floating down the Ohio river-side by side, floating in matching catamarans, both essential to the others fate. Chapman owned many nurseries along the frontier and helped spread the apple across America. Pollan credits Chapmans widespread success to his “fanatical devotion to apple planted from seed’ and his ever changing location. His success can also be attributed to the fact that since he only grew apples from seed and not from grafting, as is the preferred way to grow apples, Chapman’s apples were not suited for eating, the only thing suited for his apples was cider, and the American pioneers had a great want for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The image that Alexander presents of "mango trees fruit[ing] in the rough asphalt of upper Broadway" accurately illustrates her conflict. The blossoming tree represents the life that would have been here in India and the asphalt of upper Broadway her present home. The almost impossibility of this event - a tropical tree flourishing in the middle of…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chapman was a traveling salesman who would travel along Pioneer routes in order to trade apple seeds with settlers. Whenever he found a spot that is suitable for orchids, he planted apple seeds and helped to educate farmers about nurseries and orchids (http://www.npr.org/2012/10/20/162862456/the-strangely-true-tale-of-johnny-appleseed). But there was a more complex business scheme involved. During the early 1800’s, the country was expanding westward, and companies buying land in anticipation for settlers to arrive. One company named the Ohio Company of Associates made a deal that offered anyone willing to settle 100 acres of land, but they have to prove that they were willing to stay, they had to plant 50 apple trees.…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jane describes how the “day of the triffids” captured her attention as a child. The book described plants devouring humans although not occurring at this place and time insects do get devoured by plants. The master plan of plants is to reproduce so there can be more plants one way plants do this is to have fruit in hopes that an animal eats the fruit and then speeds the seed through their poop. Kids spread dandelions very unconsciously by picking them up and blowing the dandelions into the wind Jane Goodall makes a good point about this. In the case that these strategies do not work plants are also able to reproduce sexually and asexually, which helps with the plants master plan to spread their seed. This process can work in a way that is unconstructive as well. If the plant produces too rapidly it can clog water ways and lakes starving oxygen to water killing fish such as the water hyacinth. This adaptation of reproduction is not a defense to the predators. However plants have developed defense mechanisms such as poisons, sharpe needles and violates to protect themselves against predators. The plants can communicate with each other through their chemicals and the fungi in the root system. Plants showed the ability to react and remember in stress induced situations, such as animals with central nervous systems. The chapter ends with Jane Goodall and the loving relationship humans have had with plants throughout some of our time…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Capote shows how Herb’s difficult marriage experience in the early innocence of days has had him troubled: “…his attempt to contrive….. a patch of the paradise, the green, apple-scented Eden, he envisioned.”…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book review of, The Social Conquest of Earth by E.O. Wilson, Seth Mnookin critiques E.O. Wilson’s book on, how the Earth came to be inhabited by bees, termites, wasps, ants, and humans. In relation to persona Mnookin is a critic of The Social Conquest of Earth. Mnookin’s intended audience is people who were fans of Wilson’s earlier works. Wilson’s books The Insect Societies, Sociobiology and On Human Nature brought him fame and a Pulitzer Prize. The overall tone of this review is to rebuke and reinforce that The Social Conquest of Earth is a book of nonsense, and is scientifically unsophisticated. Mnookin points out, that Wilson disregards a decade’s worth of scientific research. The review is very detailed and reveals lots of discrepancies.…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author of “Marigolds” shows us that this quote is valid through her characterization of the…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author sits underneath the “branches of a yellowish sycamore.” He exhibits that just as Eve approaches the tree to decide to sin and partake of the fruit, Gary Soto lets the aspiration of wonder affect his actions as he cowardly approaches the tree to partake in his pie. He associates his immorality with stories from the Bible. Soto reveals this by using allusion. The author is worried that “Eve got in deep trouble with snakes, and yet “that didn’t stop me from clawing a chunk from the pie tin and pushing it into the cavern of my mouth.” Adam and Eve did not want the apple for its taste. They were drawn to the fact that it was forbidden. Gary Soto is also mesmerized at the immorality of the prohibited and comes to the conclusion “that the best things in life came…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most pervasive themes in this passage is that of a spreading decay that is taking over the society. This is first expressed in quite a literal sense, as an actual decay of fruit and produce, which spreads like a virus across the American countryside and farming lands. Due to the economic mismanagement of the farming industry, fruit and other produce are left to rot and decay on the trees because they are not picked by the farmers. The text gives many examples of different fruits being left to decay on the farms. We see, for example, the cherries, that are described at first as “full and sweet”, being left to turn into seeds which “drop and dry with black shreds hanging from them”. The purple prunes, which now “carpet the ground”, fill the valley with “the odor of sweet decay”. Pears are left to be devoured by the yellowjackets, and give off a smell of “ferment and rot”. Grapes are not good enough to make good wine, and the wine that is made from them is “the smell of decay and chemicals”. As we can see, the text goes into quite a lot of detail in the description of the different fruits decaying all over the State. Fruits of all sorts are left to decay, and, like a virus, this decay is spreading rapidly. The passage shows this spread quite explicitly as well, using repetition to show the way in which this sense of decay is infecting each and every farm and the fruit it produces. Structurally, the text repeats each paragraph to show how each fruit is similarly decaying, and the same descriptions are used over and over again in each description. The descriptions of fruit “carpeting the ground”, and of the “smell of ferment and rot” are repeated in each paragraph that speaks about the fruit. This has two effects. First, it reinforces the helplessness that is felt by the farmers, as the same thing is happening to each one of the different types of fruit. Each time there is the same cause, and the same effect, but nothing seems to be able to be done.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I believe that there is much that we take for granted in our world today. One of these things we take for granted in the instant “treatment” for plants. We do so without even a second thought or consideration and continue to let it happen year after year. We also take for granted our everyday dependencies that stem from nature. I then question what it would take for us to realize our dependency on nature and to respect it as such. On page 73 of the reading, it discusses the importance of insects. Without insects, plants would not flourish the way they do and we would not be able to use them. Insect life is just as important as plant life and it could even be argued that it is just as important as human life since they allow for things that we need to be sustained. If we see killing of animals and humans as such a wrong doing, why don’t we see killing of insects this way?…

    • 649 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Although Pollan is a gardener, he finds out that there is a difference between mushroom gathering and the gardening we know of. Pollan discusses the mysteries that are behind a mushroom. There are difficulties in studying mushrooms due to the little known about them. Pollan concludes that finding mushroom can be very difficult because mushroom hunters refuse to share the location of mushroom. Pollan points out how little scientists actually know about mushrooms. It’s nearly impossible to cultivate a mushroom. Pollan disputes that mushrooms in a way represent the omnivore’s dilemma of trying and fearing a new food. The chanterelle experience was eye opening to Pollan because he got over the fear of eating chanterelles. With the guide provided…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Sweet to tongue and sound to eye” – appeals to the readers senses, however threatening under tones prevail; there is an unknown element present.…

    • 4695 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the book, The Botany of Desire, the author Michael Pollan describes the relationship between human and apples. John Chapman was well known to people by his nick name Johnny Appleseed. He brought apples to everyone in the 18th century. Apple, as a specie, is heterozygous, which means apple will produce wilder offspring in every generation.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The world is full of natural elements, which can be defined as flowers, trees, and plants. Within the beauty of these elements can hide bigger meanings to the world than just a plant. A vine is a natural element that keeps growing. It surrounds things and can make them captive. This captivity creates a powerhouse for the ruler. In Robert Herrick’s The Vine, his dream explores the psychoanalytical terms of displacement, and power of a sex drive to gain the needs he has of woman in his life.…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    First Deseve, Then Desire

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages

    have no end and they aer innumerable also . Our mind flittrs from one whish to another as a careless bee from one blossom to another, without realing the futility and the foolishness of riding on the wings of fancy . people expect good luck to meet at every turn of life .…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Human Desire

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Human desires are defined as the sexual appetite or a sexual urges of human beings. Since excessive desire always makes people lose themselves, it is considered as one of the root of all evils; with that comes a question: can we human beings control our excessive desires? I find my answer in J.M.Coetzee’s novel “Disgrace”-- human beings can never check their excessive desires. Because instincts and human natures are always used as excuses for wrongful sexual desires. Also, our willpowers are so weak but our animal urges are so easy to be satisfied that the irresistible temptation can break our moral baseline easily. Moreover, the venting of desires can make people feel excited and content, and forget all the troubles, like alcohol or drugs, are hard to be cut off. David Lurie, the protagonist in the novel “Disgrace”, is exactly a man who cannot control his excessive desire. David’s sexual relationships with Melanie Isaacs, Bev Shaw, and the streetwalker exactly showed that human beings couldn’t curb their wrong desire. Although some people may say that they have no sexual desire problem, we cannot say that they have successfully controlled their desire, because they do not have excessive desires or are not tempted, once they sink into the abyss of wrong desires, they also cannot control themselves.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays