Parents Keep Child's Gender Secret Analysis
Would keeping your child’s gender secret be a good thing or a bad thing? In this article, Parents keep child’s gender secret by Jayme Poisson, I am going to share with you my thoughts and concerns as well as the truth in this article that I have read. I have mixed feelings about this article and throughout my article I will tell you why. Keeping gender of your child secret can be dangerous to the child’s social life.
This article begins with an example of how people always asking them to revel the baby’s sex. The neighbors ask them each week what Storms gender is. They start to criticize them about how they are raising their other two children, which are boys. They let the boy’s dress how they want with long hair, pink dresses, and they ride pink bikes.
Kathy Witterick and David Stocker, the parents of Storm believe what they are doing is …show more content…
normal. They say “we have decided not to share Storm’s sex for now – a tribute to freedom and choice in place of limitation, a stand up to what the world could become in Storm’s lifetime(a more progressive place?...).”
The grandparent’s outlook on it is they are supportive, but they will not explain the way Storm’s parents choose to raise the baby genderless to their co-workers or to their friends.
They have many concerns about the children being ridiculed and being bullied when they get older. Others can be very cruel to outsiders like the children are becoming.
Diane Ehrensaft , a California-based psychologist, an author of “Gender born, Gender made”, a guide for parents of nonconforming kids, says parents should be supportive of children who are gender creative. On the other hand she worries by not divulging Storms sex; the parents are denying the baby a way to find him or herself in a world where you are either male, female, or in between.
My response to this article would have to me that I believe that the parents did this because they thought that it was going to help Storm. I do not agree nor do I disagree that is was good. What I do believe is that it can hurt the kids severely not only in society but also in a mental way. I believe that the children would have chosen the way they wanted to act male, female, or in
between.
In conclusion my beliefs are that raising a child genderless can have good and bad outcomes. Whether it be the child finds itself on their own or the child gets lost and cannot function in every day social norms. I myself would not have raised my child genderless because I feel it is not a good thing to do to a child by confusing them. So in this conclusion I disagree with the way they parent their children.
Raising a genderless child
Raising a genderless child,
Is it a good thing or a bad one?
Tressa Schob
Zane State College WPTC
This article begins with an example of how people always asking them to revel the baby’s sex. The neighbors ask them each week what Storms gender is. They start to criticize them about how they are raising their other two children, which are boys. They let the boy’s dress how they want with long hair, pink dresses, and they ride pink bikes.
Kathy Witterick and David Stocker, the parents of Storm believe what they are doing is …show more content…
normal. They say “we have decided not to share Storm’s sex for now – a tribute to freedom and choice in place of limitation, a stand up to what the world could become in Storm’s lifetime(a more progressive place?...).”
The grandparent’s outlook on it is they are supportive, but they will not explain the way Storm’s parents choose to raise the baby genderless to their co-workers or to their friends.
They have many concerns about the children being ridiculed and being bullied when they get older. Others can be very cruel to outsiders like the children are becoming.
Diane Ehrensaft , a California-based psychologist, an author of “Gender born, Gender made”, a guide for parents of nonconforming kids, says parents should be supportive of children who are gender creative. On the other hand she worries by not divulging Storms sex; the parents are denying the baby a way to find him or herself in a world where you are either male, female, or in between.
My response to this article would have to me that I believe that the parents did this because they thought that it was going to help Storm. I do not agree nor do I disagree that is was good. What I do believe is that it can hurt the kids severely not only in society but also in a mental way. I believe that the children would have chosen the way they wanted to act male, female, or in
between.
In conclusion my beliefs are that raising a child genderless can have good and bad outcomes. Whether it be the child finds itself on their own or the child gets lost and cannot function in every day social norms. I myself would not have raised my child genderless because I feel it is not a good thing to do to a child by confusing them. So in this conclusion I disagree with the way they parent their children.
Raising a genderless child
Raising a genderless child,
Is it a good thing or a bad one?
Tressa Schob
Zane State College WPTC