Preview

Paternalism In Australia

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
794 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Paternalism In Australia
Neo-liberalism
The underlying problems remains in the ideology that was responsible for the changing perspective of the Australian society towards single mothers. Neoliberal ideology encourages economic participation whereby individuals are expected to fulfil certain responsibilities for the family and community. It also emphasis on individual’s responsibility and independency which is incompatible with care work role single mothers have to do, but yet the policies introduced were fundamentally based on it.
Women as irresponsible or paternalism?
AT the heart of the problem lies with politicians who are depicting mothers as irresponsible for not engaging in employment in order to keep their children away from poverty. This agenda reflects that
…show more content…
Structural and social issues that are present become obstacles that hinders parents from entering and remaining in the workforce. These include the cost of child care, lack of time tow work, health care of themselves and their children, lack of experience, housing issues, mental health etc. Butterworth mentioned that in the current context of welfare it is important that sole parents receive the relevant support to overcome these obstacles if they are expecting to participate in the …show more content…
Infect, research has emerged to suggest for sole mothers, the hob route is not necessarily an effective path to economic independence as predominantly assumed. Harris (1996, a s cited ____) find that single mothers are unable to stay in a permanent employment, with more than half soon returning to payment in a “revolving-door: pattern of welfare dependency rattan than welfare exist, which he blames the labour market (Walter, 2002; McArthur, Thomson, & Wink worth, 2012). this is reinforced by recent research by Bob Gregory (As cited in_____” who finds that single parents quickly return to welfare support after they are involved in part time employment. His research depicts that although single mothers try to search for work, they soon return bac on welfare as they are not able to negotiate a sustainable living under the conditions of poorly pared work, lack of work in there are and child supports (Summerfield, T., Young, L., Harman, J., & Flatau, P.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Best Essays

    The process of welfare state restructuring post war was closely associated to changing gender relations, notably the erosion of the man as the breadwinner and the rise of double earners and/or lone parent families. With changing family patterns, this newly generated need for support services like national childcare, has received limited support in Canada by the state which allowed a very uneven development of childcare across the country, in coverage as well as form. Given their emerging roles in society, women and feminists sought to re model childcare arrangements in Canada from a more liberal pattern to a more social regime. However, with the liberal regime being characterized a distinctive male cast, women had to be organized and limited to the institutional terrain of the state with the hopes of achieving goals of equality and simultaneously childcare.…

    • 2037 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Snitch Line Research Paper

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Single mothers challenge the norm ideology of a nuclear family. A nuclear family viewed as having full responsibility of their own well-being. Historically, the men were the head of the household and were financially responsibility for all needs of the nuclear family. Single mother families challenged this ideology and were seen as deviant and problematic. Because single mothers have no male, the question was then who is financially responsible for her and the children. To address who was financially responsible the elite categorized single mothers into two categories deserving and undeserving. Only single mothers who gained status by widowed were deserving of welfare called Mothers Allowance. Single mothers who gained status out of wedlock or abandonment were undeserving and did not receive welfare. Eventually, all women who cared for children and had no other form of income became eligible for welfare. However, with assistance and the implementation of the snitch line, fraud task force their lives became scrutinized and policed to determine if they were deserving of assistance. Questioning their sexuality and if truly were single was a key part of labeling their eligibility. Extreme measures of the scrutiny included termination of benefits if any male belongings were in the home (Reitsma- Street & Keck, 1996).…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Nickel and Dimed Book Report

    • 2336 Words
    • 10 Pages

    America encourages the value of self-reliance to achieving one’s goals and dreams. There is a common belief that poverty can be defeated with hard work and that the poor are simply too lazy to earn a better living. The idea of self-sufficiency is the cause of controversy for welfare programs. Poor single mothers were looked down upon for having the option to be unemployed and living solely off welfare. When President Clinton’s 1996 Welfare Reform was established, people were taken out of the program and were forced into the working world. Less taxpayer money was taken out of the upper middle classes’ income, and the poor were responsible for their own living. While this may sound ideal, most low-income people are actually unable to provide for themselves in their living conditions. With a full-time minimum wage job, they can work as hard as possible and still be stuck in debt and poverty. Their low-income prevents them from improving their lives and affording basic needs such as nutrition, health care, education, and shelter. The working poor face difficulties not through their own faults but rather because of how our society functions, where wealth is gradually becoming unevenly distributed. Unfortunately, many people are unbeknownst to the stagnant and worsening living conditions when working for minimum-wage pay. In the book Nickel and…

    • 2336 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Yet single mothers struggle to juggle either working or finding a job and care for a child. In Rosanna Hertz's Working to Place Family at the Center of Life: Dual-Earner and Single-Parent Strategies, she talks about single mothers and what they have to go through in order to take care of their children. Women who work are extremely dedicated to family because they work around caring for a family and the primary source of income for the family is through their job. Because these women have no second person or partner to help them raise the child/ children then they must work twice as hard in order to provide their child with daycare or look for other outside sources to help care for the child while at work. "Unlike the dual-earner couples, these single mothers have fewer resources internal to the family to call on in trying to cultivate external resources- in broader kin and friendship networks- to help them put family first" (254, Hertz, FF). Women also work multiple jobs in order to provide for their children and keep family at the center of their lives. Most women who work multiple jobs or extremely long hours hardly get to see their children. "Her child spent four days a week being cared for at her mother's home and three days a week at her own home. Without her mother's help, the cost would have made it impossible to remain employed" (255, Hertz, FF). Long hours or no benefits, women must rely on other people to care for their children and end up losing quality time with their child because of work demands. Because women do not have that second person or partner to help share in the child rearing, they must create external relationships to help fill in that gap left behind by being a single mother. They must create "support networks" to raise a…

    • 1765 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I really enjoyed reading your forum and after reading it I agree with what you had to say on utilitarianism. Both utilitarians would support weak paternalism if a patient was terminally ill and couldn’t decide what kind of treatment they needed to have. This is similar to what I stated in my forum post, I think that if the patient can not make the best decision for themselves then the doctor makes the best decision for them. I also agree that an act utilitarian would be most likely to support strong paternalism because an act utilitarian is a person who would make the most ethical action that is possible and that action will benefit the people. Overall I really liked the example that you used for the act utilitarian, it truly shows…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    After doing this research, I have come to comprehend a lot of things lone parents are going through due to either the policies or being a woman. These are affecting lone parents in many ways, such as, low paying jobs, health, and not able to balance their work place demands and family domain. I discovered that the more single parents and their children age, the more their needs increase. Single parents are often “co-signed” to low paying jobs because of their low level of education and work experience, which I tapped from the previous research paper I did before this. My thought about social policy that surrounds lone parents is the inequality job pay between men and women, and less opportunity given to lone parents seeking employment. This…

    • 247 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eymp 4 2.2 2.3

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Modern day career women can expect to, or would like to, return to work following the birth of their child. Also a lone parent may want to return to work to ensure they have a better standard of living for their child and themselves. To enable them to do this some may have family members who are willing to help with childcare but others may want to take advantage of the services of a crèche, nursery (private or pre/primary school) or childminders.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Such accusations from society are ludicrous; millions of women maintain a balance between work and nurturing their family, but they do so with difficulty. However, with birth rates only increasing annually, it is difficult to prove that working women are not doing their part as mothers. Unfortunately, women have hardly advanced in their fight for equality since "Backlash" was published. Though federal law now requires that all women receive at least eight weeks of maternity leave , mothers are still plagued by the problems of child care affordability. The article points out that the availability of affordable child care for the average working in women is fairly scarce. In 1993, it cost an average of $215-$329 a month to put one preschool-age child into child care. With the need for more child care facilities rising,…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Welfare Reform Hurt

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Education is the way to help people in a broken society, where we have many lost children in the streets and jails, and parents on drugs. Role-models are what’s needed; when a child sees the parents going to school and working, hopefully it will make him or her want to do the same. Also it’s a hard decision for a mother to make, having to leave young children and seek work, but in a society with many single mothers, it’s hard not to have to work. In a mother’s decision to work, she has to have a lot of faith that the morals and values that she instilled in her child at home would help keep them safe and make positive decisions while she’s away from the home working. Education and employment is the only way to empower a society that has been torn down from years of poverty. One of the welfare reforms triumphs was an explosion for never married mothers; who rose from 45 percent in 1995 to more than 60 percent between 2000 and…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Abortion Satire Essay

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There are 2.0 million ‘lone parents with dependent children’ in the UK and 91% of them are ‘single mothers with their dependent children’. These single mothers tend to live in poverty as they find it hard to balance work with childcare. Imagine how hard life must be on these parents and their…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    What the studies do not reflect are the effects that the welfare system may have on families and children. Some people feel that the work requirements placed on single parents could have harmful effects on their children, particularly on adolescents. As single parents join the work force, many teens are left without parental supervision, and many of them have to assume parental responsibilities for their younger siblings. It is feared that the increased lack of supervision, and added stress of parental duties, can lead to poor scholastic performance and an increase of juvenile delinquency. Another concern is that although the number of single mothers receiving welfare has dramatically reduced since the welfare reform act of 1996, the poverty rates among children of single mothers remains very high (Dunifon 2). This may be caused by single mothers leaving the welfare system in order to work at low-paying jobs. Unfortunately, there have been few studies done to accurately evaluate the effects that PRWORA has had on families and children living in…

    • 2290 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    " In 1996, under pressure from many of the same forces, it decided the government should not help support poor single mothers so they could stay home with their children " (Collins 335). Due to the fact that women should only work in the home caused many people to be poor. Whether you are rich, middle class or poor you should still be given the same opportunity to work. Many people in the nation would aid the poor women with no husbands and with children. "Nine million families, virtually all of them composed of single woman and their children, left the welfare rolls (Collins 337) . Many women would go to work but few people's income could get them out of…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    And because their work isn't quantified, they disappear from pictures of the economy. This exposes women to higher risks of poverty in old age or in the event of divorce. These risks are aggravated by the built-in bias of law and policy toward paid employment. In “The Price of Motherhood,” Ann Crittenden said, “Unpaid work in the home does not count, Because unpaid child care is not measured and counted as labor, caregivers earn zero Social Security credits for rising children at home” (2001: 77). The present structure of Social Security often wipes out their contributions. Mothers work in caretaking should be valued as an economic investment because they nourish the next generations. There hard work should not be seen as private contributions. Providing care to the next generations should be also considered a public responsibility and the society should also contribute to the children of the future…

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In our culture, it is still largely the role of women to be the primary caregivers of children, and because the United States still does not guarantee paid family leave, it is often women that must forgo furthering their careers in order to take care of their children. And beyond just being able to further their careers, often women cannot even receive a higher education because of the lack of childcare policies. An account by Maria Cristina Rangel in “Knowledge is Power” talks about how the welfare policies of her state made it extremely difficult for her to attend college, have a job, and be able to take care of her child. She wanted to be able to attend college, but in order to receive the benefits she needed, the state required that she also hold a job. Balancing a job, college, and raising a child is difficult, but if she did not receive a degree, she believed that there was no way to move up “the ladder.” Rangel says that her relationship with her state “embodied our society’s attitude of contempt, hostility, and distrust of toward low-income people.” (Rangel, p. 192) Two-thirds of the recipients of welfare are children and most adults on welfare happen to be single mothers, so welfare politics are a part of “women’s issues” as well. (Aulette and…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, the way the government has provided limited amount of help has been represented by a negative effect of mistrust to single mothers who depend on the welfare system. Pushing the mentality that individuals should work more, but still implementing fear that if they work pass a certain amount of time welfare would have been relinquished. Welfare would introduce a new act called Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF). TANF would be the work regulator that kept single mothers on following the working regiment on not doing to much money (Lee 2009). Jason DeParle’s article provides the case of a single mother who lost her childcare due to earning 50 cents more in her paycheck. Due to 50 cents her childcare was revoked and a domino…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays