Preview

Peter Paul Ruben's Massacre Of The Innocents

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
904 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Peter Paul Ruben's Massacre Of The Innocents
This paper is a formal analysis, treating Peter Paul Rubens’ 1612 masterpiece, Massacre of the Innocents. The oil painting stands at approximately 150 x 200 cm, a size offering the viewer a window-like gaze into a historical scene of twisted, bloody carnage. Formally, there is much cohesion with the overall disastrous theme of human chaos and disorder. On a compositional whole, the anguish and psychological suffering compliments scattered lighting, vivid color, and clustered space. The painting is a good example of how the combination of form and narrative yield a rich transmission of historical, emotional and formal data to the viewer, who does not even need to be literate. A historical renaissance era painting typically is a story that tells …show more content…
In applying visual literacy, connections can be made to help understand what the artist wanted to show us. For example, the peculiar lighting on the small child could be the artist’s way of making this helpless cherub the “star” or protagonist, where a viewer may be inclined to enter the painting through the experience of the unassuming, genderless victim. The child is looking away, which also invites the viewer to more easily be this helpless angelic being. A more sensitive viewer may even feel inescapable pangs of responsibility, confronted with its physicality. It may be noted that this painting’s forms bear resemblance to a stage play. This marriage of the psychological and emotional to the spatial-physical world can be seen as Renaissance paintings great triumphs, as they grew in sophistication at depicting a 3D space, with the development of geometrical perspective. In processing a dramatic scene, one can notice in works, such as these oil paintings, a growing resemblance to strategic compositional tactics employed in theatre. Space, lighting, color can all be used to treat a settings feeling and pull a spectator in. In this group of painted 2D brushstrokes masquerading as 3D people, all characters are corralled to what a director calls “center stage front”: the place for drama, and giving the crowd a sense claustrophobia. Anxiety and intimacy, here are amplified, peaking in unison, as the lights are strong, the colors saturated. The people are in the throes of life, or death, or committing genocide. Massacre of the Innocents is in many ways an overwhelming spectacle, psychologically and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Born into Brothels” by Zana Briski and Ross Kauffman, is a documentary that is overflowing with symbolism. Photography is exposed throughout the documentary; the role of photography is to portray the opportunity that has been granted to these children for them to express themselves. The painting they would engage in was a way for these children to express their emotions through the paintings; Avijit was quoted when he said “I like to draw pictures because I want to express what’s on my mind… I want to put my thought into colors.” Photography and painting was these children’s only way to express their true inner feelings; and that is why it is emphasized throughout the documentary. Briski symbolizes the children’s escape from the Brothels, a brighter future, and the only way out of their misery.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ap Us History Guide

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When the viewer first lays eyes on this painting, they are brought to the center of the photograph. The sharp contrast of Napoleon’s deep red cloak, a symbol of vigor and courage, stands apart from the dark and cloudy background. The eye’s then continue from the cloak, past his face, and up to his outstretched finger, which is pointing to the heavens. This gesture, made by Napoleon, instills in the viewer a notion of the future…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Christopher Hitchens’ New Atheist novel, “God is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything” written in 2007, highlights everything that is wrong with religion, and how its effects are detrimental to society. Hitchens critiques Christianity, Judaism, and even Hinduism and Buddhism, for their atrocities and blasphemous beliefs and makes a very valid point as to why many individuals have turned away from religion. Though quite persuasive in some cases, other times the novel makes points that seem weak or trivial in regards to the “evilness” of religion. Each chapter of Hitchens’ book emphasizes a certain wrongdoing religion has committed, or how religion has poisoned society.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Art 101 Week 1 Assignment

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages

    An artist can create art work through a creative process. An element of this process is critical thinking. Artists’ creativity process begins with seeing. It then goes from seeing to imagining and from imagining to making (Sayre, 2009). This essay will provide an explanation of artists’ roles. The essay will also include two chosen works of art, one of which embodies the role of the artist and the other holds symbolic significance requiring the application of iconography.…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    She specifically painted about the nightmare that lives Dallaire in the massacre. She uses a complex combination of formal and symbolic devices. This work is so exceptional that impact every viewer emotionally and intellectually. These paintings vividly indicate the psychological torment of the General and at the same time shows the chaos of the carnage he witnessed.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Iconography the Scream

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Colours used in the painting are very aggressive. They depict violence in the painting. The man standing in the picture is screaming loud at everything. Colours used in this painting, especially the orange colour of sky, describe a gloomy surrounding. Plus the calmness and normality of two persons behind show the silence of scream; that it is unheard. Some analysts believe that it is “Screaming of nature”.…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When a work transcends into art, it surpasses its cultural restraints and touches us. We are moved; we are transported to a new place that is, nevertheless, strongly rooted in a physical experience, in our bodies. When we focus on works such as Van Gogh’s “Old Man in Sorrow” or Velazquez’s “Christ Crucified” rather than “The Scream” or “Campbell’s Soup Cans”, we become aware of a feeling that may not be unfamiliar to us but which we did not actively focus on before. Unlike popular culture, this transformative experience is what art is constantly seeking. The emotions invoked from a reading of Yeats or Frost pulls the strings of our conscience and heart and most importantly, they inspire and motivate us to change ourselves and/or the world around us. No amount of Meyer or Collins can bring forth the willingness to examine and investigate our lives or the lives of others. The felt feeling of art spurs thinking, engagement, and even action. Only art alone helps people get to know and understand something with their minds and feel it emotionally and physically. By doing this, art can mitigate the almost numbing effect created by modern pop culture and society and motivate people to start thinking and doing.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    100 years ago the first car was made. This created an entirely new form of transportation that was innovative to that generation. Similarly, the 100 year difference between the end of the Medieval Era and beginning of the Renaissance Era showed amazing changes in the form of art. The painting “Madonna the Goldfinch” by Raphael Sanzio was created in c. 1505-1506. This was the very beginning of the Renaissance Era, and the painting strived for perfection unlike any of the paintings created before it. Madonna the Goldfinch portrays a sense intrigued curiosity, but to those who analyze it will find a guiding informative response with a deep understanding of symbolic foreshadowing. This essay will discuss the visual, expressive, and associative responses experience from Raphael’s painting, The Madonna the Goldfinch. The responded will be ordered by when chronologically experienced.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Yet, how was Artaud to translate the transcendental connection he had with this painting to the stage? We can try to understand his ideas by looking at a few of the elements Artaud endowed to this painting. In the second part of his manifesto titled “Metaphysics and the Mise en Scene” Artaud, with his mesmerizing use of linguistic poetics, recounts his sense experience with this work of art. He explains that he derived some “effects of the mind”. One of which was an overall effect of a “thunderous visual harmony”. Translating this onto the stage, he imagined, would come through the manipulation of the physical aspects of theatre. This would be “Everything that occupies the stage”.…

    • 116 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The inception of Dante Alighieri's trilogy, “The Divine Comedy,” stirred thoughts and emotions in thousands of readers over the last hundreds of years. One aspect that makes this book so revered is the fact that each individual reader gains a different, and varied, interpretation of Dante’s work. Consequently, a wide spectrum of depictions, stemming from readers’ provoked feelings, now exist through artist’s visual representations of this book. A great example would be Ary Scheffer and Gustave Dore’s different depictions of Canto V of Book 1 – “The Inferno” – where Dante and Virgil meet Francesca and Paolo. Scheffer and Dore create two separate ideas and emotions felt by the viewer with their use of different artistic details such as focal points, backgrounds and coloring, and expressions. Each paints the same scene, but provoke different emotions and expressions, dependent only on the artist’s visual interpretation of Dante’s words.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Photography Analysis

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The “Roman Amphitheatre, Valencia, Spain” photographed by Henri Cartier-Bresson is taken from the focal/vantage point of a bull and shows an attendant watching the action from a rectangular window. The inside doors of the Valencia Area and the positioning of this photograph makes it clear that Cartier-Bresson has put much thought into this as he has entered the area to take it. The composition of the “Roman Amphitheatre” is extremely complex and this reflects the photographer’s cubism influences. Every major structural element is fractured in this photograph. Some example of the is that the arena doors are ajar, the number seven which is in two abstract forms, the attendant’s circular glasses are awry with one lens catching the light but the other remaining transparent, and the foreground figure’s body is also link to a faceless counterpart wearing identical clothing which give the effect that he has been beheaded by the door. “The picture as a whole illustrates the avant-garde theory of simultaneous multiple vision and is sophisticated critique of the bull’s-eye school of photographic composition. Cartier-Bresson is an excellent photographer as he tries to convey the message of the how “we can never close the door, align the rings. Reconstruct the numeral, or clear the attendant’s vision” via an image that forces the viewer to accept the ‘disjunctive and mysterious as part of the modern experience of the world”.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Research Paper Topic Form

    • 557 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The work is set in a real space and also reflects a real situation that happened during that period. We can see that it is scale, as the sizes of the prisoners and the military are very even, it also has very real characteristics, you can distinguish the facial features on the people being executed. On the other hand the French military are painted as killing machines, their silhouettes are impersonal because they have no face, all in the same approach. In the painting the lines stand out, these are present on the lamp, on the guns of the French military and the silhouette of the buildings that are in the background.…

    • 557 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    I forget that I am looking at a painting and I forget to ask if it is only an observation. According to Panofsky this is due to the power of perspective because it is so different than my psychophysiological space. The perspective created in this painting generates a sense of a sensorial experience of infinity which is why I find it so attractive and capturing. According to Panofsky, a painting demands the viewer to equal the rationality of the space. This painting calls on me to be somebody else. Even though the attention is not on the viewer, it demands of you to be included as if it has been waiting for you. All of the figures in the painting are gazing at one another and not at the viewer. The direction of the gazes seem to be reciprocal and divergent. They mostly seem to be looking upward which gives me a sense of spirituality and does not threaten or provoke the viewer, but accepts me in. I do not see the painting as a silent witness; I am inevitably a part of it. According to phenomenology, the central structure of an experience is its intention as an experience of the object. Looking at this painting demands from the viewer to look at this painting as it is and to experience what is being given. It is almost impossible not to be absorbed into this illusion. Keeping in mind that at the time, the viewing subject would most likely have been a Jesuit worshipper. I think this is the point of the painting, the distinction between our physical world and the miraculous world which brings us into proximity with the divine. It is as if there is a miracle appearing before us and we are having a spiritual vision. This painting is a reminder of how important it was to reassert the catholic’s belief in the higher power. It is a way of breaking down the barrier between our world and…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He, as a master of dynamic, can transform everything to an active drama. His artworks usually depict a fleeting moment, and blur the boundaries between illusionism and reality. Gian Lorenzo Bernini has a unique understanding of art and nature. Hence, he can successfully combine art and reality. When spectators appreciate the beauty of Bernini’s masterpieces, they are easily intoxicated with the artworks because of the ambiguous boundaries between art and reality. One of the most outstanding characteristics is that Gian Lorenzo Bernini can use every part of his figure to express emotion. The viewers can find it from the hands, poses, draperies and faces. Gian Lorenzo Bernini has a very strong ability to depict dramatic narratives. For instance, in his work, David, he successfully shows the intensity of the fleeting moment that David is about to hit the…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Her encounter with the performance of Janiak has generated a transcendental awe in her, as compared to looking at the pictures, images, photographs of 9/11 on the television, or in the newspapers or magazines that would make her “get angry and crazy” (42). If Janiak’s performances stand as a forceful interposition into the discourse of 9/11, “DeLillo’s recurrent use of semi-obscure Italian post-Impressionist seems initially oblique” (210). On first reading of the conversation between Martin and Lianne, where both of them think that they can see the towers in the still life paintings of Morandi, the connection between the still life paintings and the psychological effect of 9/11 seems illogical.…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays