Preview

Pickett's Charge Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1978 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Pickett's Charge Analysis
On July 1 1864, two opposite forces of an idea met head to head in the beginning of the Battle known as the Battle of Gettysburg. It ran for 3 days and on the last day only one side was known to be the victors and the other was known to be the losers, The victors consisted of soldiers and generals alike of the Union. The losers were known as the Rebels. Again consisting of soldiers and generals, but less soldiers than what was hoped to be the outcome. The Rebels faced their fatality on the 3rd day with an order known as Pickett's Charge. It was a suicide mission to go with a full frontal attack, yet it still was played out, and still many soldiers died. The main man to order Pickett's Charge was General Robert E. Lee, and it was a foolish idea …show more content…
“ Longstreet decided to move to New Orleans after the war” (History.com Staff 3). This proves that even though they lost Gettysburg and the Civil War itself, Longstreet can be considered successful because he worked hard and did his job. Sadly, the fact that he had let the south down was one of his regrets. This is shown in the text, “Politics and personal animosity fed the controversy and longstreet became known as the man who lost the war for the wouth” (History.net Staff). This helps prove the previous point that this was a failure to the war, but it is in fact a success for his job in the war and battle because he did what any other Lieutenant would have done in his position. Longstreet then became known as the one who let down the south and was repeatedly the scapegoat in the conversation. This is shown in, “Longstreet would spend much of his later life defending himself against repeated attacks from these critics” (History.com Staff 2). This proves that he was indeed the scapegoat, but he really was successful. That of which because he put up with the critics and the harsh comments about the 3 days, but all in all, he success was due to the fact that he followed orders. He, himself, knew that and he pushed to defend himself because he knew what really happened during those days. This can be shown in the text, “But his failing were not isolated- the confederate effort at Gettysburg revealed an army plagued with command problems and an extended, five mile-long battle line. Lee’s incomparable infantry could not overcome the crippling handicaps” (History.net Staff). This prove that the loss was not a failure on Longstreet's behalf but rather on the whole confederacy. The job of a general is to command given higher orders and carry them out. He was a success, but the confederacy needed someone to be their scapegoat. Yet Longstreet was also successful in moving on. “Longstreet later

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Robert E. Lee instructed Stuart’s troops to protect Rappahannock river and make sure it was clear of spies. Gen. Stuart decided to organize a distraction on the other side of the river because that’s where the Union troops where. Pleasanton added many men and had to have two attacks. The Union ended up killing Col. Benjamin Davis. Buford charged the arsenal but they took the guns before they could get to them. The troops at Kelly’s Ford where told to march around the opponent but Stuart’s office was there. Both sides added more troops and fought for 5 hours. Learning another Confederate militia was coming Pleasanton withdrew.…

    • 107 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    General Robert E. Lee was considered to be one of the finest military strategists in American history. However, he had several disadvantages at Gettysburg that greatly impacted the fate of the Confederate Army in the American Civil War, and eventually led to the surrender of the Confederacy. General Lee’s main disadvantages at Gettysburg included a deficiency of information from the calvary due to General J.E.B. Stuart’s absence and Pickett’s Charge being miscalculated and an act of desperation.…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Longstreet fought in the Cvil War under Joseph E Johnston. Joseph E Johnston was wounded during battle so he put Longstreet under Robert E. Lee. During the Seven Day battle Longstreet earned Lee's trust. Lee referred Longstreet to an "old war-house" , a few months after assuming army command. His actions at the Battle of Gettysburg haunted Longstreet after the war. The beginning problems within the army's high command started in Gettysburg. Lee refused to fight defensively in Pennsylvania, but Longstreet disagreed and behaved bitterly at Gettysburg. On July 2nd, his assault virtually destroyed the Union army of the Potomac's III Corps. In the fall of 1863 he transferred to the West and played a defensive role in the Confederate victory in…

    • 126 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Man. The killer angel. [1] Since the dawn of civilization humanity has fought to protect what they hold dear. Whether that be freedom, religion or land, the body politic has been at war, even within their own borders. Civil War is defined as a war between regions of the same country.[2] Throughout the course of the four and a half year Civil War, many battles were fought, but none quite as pivotal as the Battle of Gettysburg. Had Lee obliged Longstreet in his persistence of a defensive strategy, the Confederate Army very well could have won the war. Instead, the Union succeeded in holding their ground atop a hillside and thus defeating the Confederate Army and ultimately winning the war. One contemplates the motivations of both the Confederates and the Union soldiers in the United States Civil War. Was it money? Power? Dominance? Michael Shaara, author of The Killer Angels suggests alternative motives. In his novel about the pivotal battle, he suggests that even though it was commonly perceived that soldiers were fighting solely…

    • 1531 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Historians have argued inconclusively for years over the prime reason for Confederate defeat in the Civil War. The book Why the North Won the Civil War outlines five of the most agreed upon causes of Southern defeat, each written by a highly esteemed American historian. The author of each essay does acknowledge and discuss the views of the other authors. However, each author also goes on to explain their botheration and disagreement with their opposition. The purpose of this essay is to summarize each of the five arguments presented by Richard N. Current, T. Harry Williams, Norman A. Graebner, David Herbert Donald, and David M. Potter. Each author gives his insight on one of the following five reasons: economic, military, diplomatic, social, and political, respectively.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Killer Angels Reflections

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The Civil War was one of the nation’s bloodiest wars in history, and there is so much more to it than the average person knows. “Killer Angels” by Michael Shaara does a fantastic job of ‘opening the doors’ into the true struggles of the Civil War. The book begins from a spy’s perspective, on his way to Longstreet to inform him of the Union Army’s position. The news caught Longstreet off guard because General Stuart was supposed to be on the lookout for the Union Army. It takes a while for him to convince his colleagues that they need to trust this spy because most of them want do not believe that Stuart would leave them blind as he gallivants around, getting publicity in the north. Longstreet decides to trust the spy and moves towards Gettysburg. At this point, the generals have no idea of the violent battle that is about to take place in Gettysburg. Meanwhile, Colonel Chamberlain is informed that men disbanded from the Old Second Maine. These men have decided not to fight in protest. Chamberlain delivers a very inspiring speech, and great detail is given describing his excellent speech giving skills. All but six of the men decide to join Twentieth Maine. Longstreet is completely astounded by this, but grateful. On the morning of July 1st, Stuart is still nowhere to be found. Stuart is very important to the Confederate Army; he is their eyes when it comes to knowing the location of the Union Army. Meanwhile, the battle at Gettysburg begins when the Confederates attack Buford’s men. Day one at Gettysburg ends with the Union retreat into the hills. This makes Longstreet anxious; hills are very good defensive positions. Though they should swing around to attack from behind, he knows that is not what General Lee wants to do. The next day, Chamberlain wakes up and his regiment begins moving towards Gettysburg. They run into an escaped slave on the way, and Chamberlain ponders his feelings towards the war and race. Chamberlain’s regiment is put on Little Round Top as…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    They had hoped to weaken the Union’s infantry and Cannon’s but many of the Confederates own cannon balls missed Union troops. The Union returned cannon fire but stopped so they had enough ammunition for the upcoming Confederate attack. After the cannon attack stopped the Confederates began their charge. It is known today as Pickett’s charge. The rebels suffered devastating losses during the charge because they had to march three- quarters of a mile straight into a dug in Union force that was on higher ground and had cannons.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Essay On Killer Angels

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the book Killer Angels by Michael Shaara, he analyzes the roles of two important men in Civil War history. One is Robert E. Lee, the commander of the Confederate army, and the other is James Longstreet, a Confederate general. Both men play key parts in the battle of Gettysburg and their choices help direct the course of the whole war, both in their favor and against. While they are fighting on the same side, there are differences that distinguish them and cause conflict between them, and these differences will determine major turning points in the war.…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Longstreet was a successful man that is still well known today for his defensive tactics during the Civil War. He transitioned from fighting with the nation during the Mexican War to fighting against it during the Civil War, and joining the country again to execute many different careers before his retirement. Although Longstreet faced criticism from many southerners about his service during the Civil War, his reputation has been restored and his legacy as a successful confederate general during the Civil War lives…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This resulted in the deaths of two-thirds of Pickett’s men. In result, Lee had to retreat and unfortunately, the Confederates lost the Battle of…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    James Longstreet is one of the most talked about figures in the American Civil War. As Robert E. Lee’s right hand man he fought at Second Bull Run, Fredericksburg, Chickamauga, Seven Days Battles, Antietam, Battle of the Wilderness, and the most controversial at Gettysburg. Often referred to as Lee’s “old war horse”, Longstreet played a major role in the outcome of the Civil War. Longstreet is blamed for the Confederate loss of the Civil War primarily because of his performance at Gettysburg and his role during reconstruction as well as his friendship with Ulysses S. Grant. After the first day of fighting at Gettysburg Longstreet did not want to reengage and warned Lee of the consequences. One of Longstreet’s subordinates, George Pickett, lead one of the most famous military actions in American history called Pickett’s charge. During the charge on the third day of fighting Pickett’s division was completely wiped out causing the South to lose at Gettysburg and become the turning point the North needed to win the war. Lee was such a god like figure, that if you argued with him it was like arguing with the South’s god. Also because Pickett was under Longstreet, Longstreet is blamed for the loss at Gettysburg. Even though you could argue that Longstreet orchestrated the attack at Gettysburg you must know that all Longstreet was doing was following orders given to him by Lee. I believe that Longstreet is not to blame for the Confederate loss of the American Civil War because everything he did during and after the Civil War was to help the Confederacy, he always followed Lee’s orders, and his reputation was tarnished by the Lee cult.…

    • 1602 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Killer Angels Shaara

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Is an excellent poker player but has not played since the death of his children. He is a stubborn, bad tempered, kind of slow man. Concerned with the lack of information about the enemy he sends his spy, Harrison to Gettysburg to see what information he could find out. Longstreet considers the men in his command family. In Longstreet’s unit some of his men he commanded where Europeans and somewhere Southerners. The Europeans thought the war is about slavery. While the southerners thought the war was about the Constitution. During the battle Longstreet recognizes that the men they are fighting against are not enemies but instead old friends. Later during the battle Longstreet wants Alexander to take command and responsibility of the unit. He cannot order his men to their deaths; a death that he feels is preventable and an attack he in which he disagrees with. Longstreet what to resign but cannot leave Lee alone or with this attack in the hand of Hill. Longstreet also feels there are not enough men to do this…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    McClellan may be one of the most underrated generals in history. He was committed to saving his country AND his soldiers, which is also why he was so beloved by his men. He matched Lee battle for battle and destroyed him in Antietam (that battle was unquestionably a Union victory, it wasn't even close. If you wish to argue that point, first, name the different phases of the battle, then tell me which of those phases the South won. Second, running away in defeat doesn't count as a win when the enemy has the power to destroy you utterly, but doesn't because he is a good person). There are many battles which are claimed to be Southern victories, because they held the field - meanwhile the Union armies marched around them and took a meaningful objective. McClellan was the best commanding general of the war and most feared by Lee. The reason McClellan is hated today is because he…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Who Won the Civil War?

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Even with all the advantages the union had in their position at the time of the war, although the union still almost lost to the rebellious southern states. Before the death of Stonewall Jackson the southern states had the upper hand in the war even without the man power and weaponry or the union. The southern states a new found province did not have the money or the industry to support a war. I believe the death of Stonewall Jackson in chancellor’s Ville changed the outcome of the war. Lee without his right hand man makes careless mistake which leads to his surrender to grant at Appomattox Court House, Virginia. The Civil War was inevitable the north and south where doomed to battle over slavery issue sooner or later. Not because the north was worried about the rights or miss treatment of the slaves in the south but because of the power the south had in congress. This is explainable, because if slavery was the big picture then why didn’t Lincoln emancipate the slave in the northern states? If Lincoln would have freed the slaves in the northern states the union would have lost those states as well and indefinitely lost the war. “Antietam, though hardly the victory he had hoped for, gave Lincoln the excuse he needed to take a step that changed the character of…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lee believed his men had been on the edge of victory and decided to send three divisions against the union center on cemetery ridge. All together there were less than 15000 troops led by George Pickett. They would have to march 3 quarters of a mile across open fields to attack the union’s positions. Lee was determined and the attack later known as “Pickett’s Charge” was put into action around 3pm, after a bombardment by 150 confederate guns. The union opened fire on the advancing rebels from behind stone walls.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays