2.Tan uses anecdotes to give a clear example of her situation and feelings. This can relate to readers lives as well as demonstrate a point of frustration in Tan's life. The impact of omitting one of these anecdotes would be to take away from the story because it would take away from different emotions. For example, taking away the CAT scan story would not show the seriousness of the effects of the mother's broken English. If the SAT story was taken out, it would not show how Tan's mother's broken English affected Tan.
3.By quoting Tan's mother you personally can attempt to decipher the language. You get to see the difficulty of understanding Tan's mother by this example rather than just assuming what it would be like if there wouldn't have been a direct quotation. The quote also shows how it may sound like Tan's mother doesn't know what she's talking about, but her speech does not reflect her intelligence or comprehension.
4.Tan believes that envisioning a reader helps create a story that the reader is more able to relate to and understand. While doing this, she uses her mother as an example of her experience with the difficulties of understanding other languages. Miscommunication could easily be related to by foreigners of the U.S. because so many are misunderstood and taken advantage of. Using her envisions, Tan creates stories easily understood by all.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The essay “Mother Tongue” describes a writer who grew up with a mother of Asian origin and the limitations created by her mother’s speech. The author, Amy Tan, defines her mother’s English as “broken” and that it created communication barriers. For example, when Tan’s mother would need to call her boss about work, she would rely on her daughter to make the phone call and use proper english. When Tan decided to go into English in college, it seemed foolish since she was more skilled in math and science. The author also mentions how not everyone’s speech is the same, but that is not a bad thing. Tan decided to start writing fiction, and write a book in a way her mother would comprehend. Though the writing was harshly critiqued, Tan knew she…
- 227 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Melissa Duffy’s essay titled, “Inspiration” is an excellent example of how an individual’s attitude toward a certain subject, in this case, writing, influences the way the preform. As I read, it dawned on me that the approach our teacher take in teaching us have an immense impact on our attitude towards it. Duffy tells her story of “Inspiration” in a periodical format to lay out the moments in time that shaped her as a writer.…
- 398 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In this story, Tan shows that assimilation occurs gradually through understanding. She had to experience feeling degraded daily with her mother because people judged the way her mother spoke broken English. For instance, Tan explains the incident, she had with a stockbroker in New York. The stockbroker would evade every question Tan’s mother would ask about her stock and would treat her unfairly. But when Tan herself begin to speak perfect English to the stockbroker, he sees her as the normal people of society and answers to her adequately. Tan was embarrassed by the way her mother spoke, but learns to assimilate from her own experiences that not everything has to be perfect about her mother. Assimilation needs to be gradual and can not always be…
- 569 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In this essay “How to Read Like a Writer” Mike Bunn, claims that college students should distinguish choices the writer made and decide whether they want to implement them in their writing; enhancing their level of writing. Bunn explains that reading like a writer is a strategy that questions, analyses and criticizes a text to make readers look at the structure, the style, the word choice in regards to several factors like: the purpose, the audience, and the genre. The author concludes that this strategy will also signal the writer’s argument. The essay ends by providing a step-by-step example to obtain structural analysis and familiarize students with this strategy.…
- 109 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
This essay can relate best with reader from a Hispanic background, being that they come from a different country and they are not fluent English speakers. They can also relate to Cisneros’s family experiences. In contrast, Tan’s audience is Asian-Americans, because they can identify to the type of speech or fragmented or “broken language” like Tan mentions in “Mother Tongue.” The simplification of certain concepts that Tan practices in her writing allows her writing to be grasped by a wide range of readers. However, both pieces of writing deal with two female writers that are writing to immigrants from whom English is a second…
- 1111 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
With the use of examples from personal as well as her friends’ and family’s experiences, her argument is considered more credible and trustworthy. In paragraph 30, Prose describes her experience being taught how to deeply analyze the meaning of a Shakespeare play, and how she loved it after being able to deeply understand it. This gives the audience a different perspective, one of a student who received the education Prose argues for. This consequently supports her proposal that the reason english class has become such a useless chore to students is as a result of the straightforward and fruitless examinations of literature. Along with the narration of her and her friend’s children’s experiences, found in paragraphs 5 and 23, the audience may relate to the description of a poorly taught english class that uses unoriginal reading choices or cursory lesson plans, which in turn inspires them to invoke change in the education…
- 506 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Amy Tan’s essay “Mother Tongue” Tan grew up in a home with her Chinese mother who spoke English that she considered “broken”. It was difficult for others to understand what her mother was saying. Tan then realized that when she was with her mother that she spoke English differently than she did. She was trying to figure out how her background affected her life, such as her education; but she eventually learned to except her background. At the same time Tan wanted to become a writer and she found that by spending time with her mother who again spoke “broken” English. Even though she was told that writing was her worst skill by her boss, she was determined to make it work.…
- 197 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In most English classes, stories are interpreted through a LITERARY PERSPECTIVE. By analyzing literary elements like mood, tone, imagery, etc., we come to understand the author’s purpose for writing. We also come to understand the universal meaning of the text.…
- 1251 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
“Never compromise your culture because you are your culture”. In the short story “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan, The Red Headed Hawaiian by Chris McKinney, and The Biography of Frida Kahlo by Hayden Herrera, Jing Mei, Rudy Puana, and Frida Kahlo reveals how culture informs the way you view others and the world because it defines their perspectives, boundaries, and life experiences.…
- 1296 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
For ethos, or credibility, Tan makes personal references to her mother and factual events, as well as a description of her own accomplishments, which give credibility to her and her work. Her mother proved to her that she could understand people when they spoke perfect or regular English as well as when she read in English. The logic behind this validates her point that if she can comprehend English perfectly while still speaking in broken English, then perhaps other people who are treated as if they cannot understand actually do. Pathos, or emotion, is demonstrated through the depiction of the struggle of Tan’s mother with broken English. The story brings out emotions of sympathy toward her and her family as well as awareness, and almost anger, towards the people who are ignorant towards the people who have had to make a major change in their lives and try to speak a second language although it isn’t always perfect. Emotions of pride and happiness, even if it is not for you, are felt at the end with the success of Tan’s novel and the fact that her mother did in fact understand it. It is somewhat fulfilling when reading although it does not directly impact you in any…
- 903 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
4. Tan relatively gives much meaning behind her argument with her mother. That many foreigners are judged for their limited English and that American’s may have that problem with the judgment. That this is an issue that can open the eyes of anyone, whether they experience it or not.…
- 462 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the essay “Mother Tongue” by Amy Tan (1990), which discusses her mother’s way of speaking through “broken English”, Tan explores the different “Englishes” that she has come into contact with in her everyday life; these variations have presented struggles in her mother’s life. Tan illustrates this to her audience by giving examples of the struggles her mother was faced with due to “her” English and the many versions of English that surrounds Tan. Tan examines the different versions of English people use in order to make the reader realize that English takes many different forms which leads to difficulty and confusion to those who are attempting to learn and speak the language like her mother. This work of literature is directed towards those who do not have an understanding of the variations of languages and the complications that come along with trying to learn a new language like English.…
- 691 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I now feel, after being a student of this class, being successful in business or school requires the ability to organize, arrange, and compose thoughts into a logical format. Without these skills it is impossible to communicate thoughts and emotions grammatically. Reflecting on the past three months, I notice that our English 1A class has learned skills necessary to develop personal, informative, and persuasive essays. These are essential points needed to become successful in today's society. In previous English courses that I have participated in, I never realized that essay-writing skills were so important. Because of this class, my attitude toward writing has matured into an understanding of what it takes to be a good writer. Without the knowledge of why writing skills were important, I was concerned about "just getting by". Now, I enjoy the challenge of composing an interesting and thought provoking essay. I find myself developing an essay with my reader in mind, and thinking what might stimulate them to read my work. This class has developed my senses and stimulated my curiosity in the literary world and I feel I have made significant progress in my writing process. The most important of which being how, by the proper use of commas, transitions, and supportive quotes, I transform my average essay into a well composed, interesting literary work, well at least I think it’s interesting.…
- 639 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
After I read the sample personal narrative essay packet 1, the essay title “Nancy” is an interesting essay that I want to keep reading it. This essay starts with a speech of a teacher. It is not a boring introduction for a narrative essay and makes the essay more like an interesting story. For example, “Class, I would like you to meet our new student, Nancy. She just moved here from Baton Rouge.” (1). Moreover, the writer used a lot of specific descriptions to show the details of Nancy’s appearance. For instance, “Her sweater’s sleeves reached only halfway down her forearms, and the listless faded yellow mixed oddly with her sallow skin and greasy blond hair (10). The example indicates how the person exactly looks like, and it is a good way to help readers to build an image of the narrative essay. And the writer used words very flexible, “While everyone seemed to talk about her, no one bothered to actually talks to her.”(19). The word “talk” has two different meaning in this sentence.…
- 340 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
There is a scene in The Horse and His Boy, one of C. S. Lewis’ Narnia chronicles, in which the fugitive, Aravis, explains why she fled her homeland. As she begins, she switches to a style of speaking that is florid, poetic and quite captivating – for in her country, children are taught how to tell stories, just like English children are taught how to write essays. “The difference”, Lewis tells us, “is that people want to hear the stories, whereas I never heard of anyone who wanted to read the essays.”It is hard to disagree with Lewis that, as a medium for communicating ideas, the traditional student essay is fundamentally unexciting. One issue is the requirement for “formal” language at all times – even though academic writers who succeed in engaging with their readers often do so by writing texts that are lively, enthusiastic and frequently irreverent, encompassing the odd anecdote, colloquialism and venture into the personal.…
- 664 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays