Many psychologists believe that unconscious repression of traumatic experiences such as sexual abuse or rape is a defense mechanism which backfires (Carroll 1). These experiences are slowly bought back to memory, sometimes taking all the way up to 40 years for vivid details. Researchers have attempted to uncover the mystery behind repression. Are these memories false memories, or are they repressed memories? Can horrifying episodes be forgotten? Does a theory of this nature stand a chance in court? These questions will be attempted to be answered and if not answered, provide one with more knowledge on the topic.
What are repressed memories? Repressed memories are actual memories that have been pushed out of consciousness because they are emotionally forewarned (Kosslyn & Rosenberg). Why does something …show more content…
like this take place? Researchers have attempted to uncover the mystery behind this theory. Are these memories false memories, or are they repressed memories? Can horrifying episodes be forgotten? Does a theory of this nature stand a chance in court? Researchers have attempted to answer these and many other questions that have emerged. What really happens during repression? "Something happens that is so shocking that the mind grabs hold of the memory and pushes it underground, into some inaccessible corner of the unconscious. There it sleeps for years, or even decades, or even forever-isolated from the rest of mental life. Then, one day, it may rise up and emerge into consciousness (Loftus 518)." These experiences are slowly bought back to memory, sometimes taking all the way up to 40 years for vivid details. There have been some instances as to where memory of the incident never returns.
However, the debate is centered around the question of whether or not these memories are real or false (Sevelj 1). "If a memory is recovered that is not authentic, where would it come from? Ganaway (1989) proposed several hypotheses to explain memories of a repressed past. If not authentic, the memories could be due to fantasy, illusion or hallucination-mediated screen memories, internally derived as a defense mechanism (Loftus 524)." Some who are uncertain about the authenticity of the memories of abuse do so in part because of the severity and sincerity of the accused persons who deny the abuse (Loftus 524). Sometimes the story of how the incident happened changes every time, which leads people to believe that the person is lying. People are forced to do the impossible, choose between believing (believer) and not believing(nonbelieiver). Which one are you? Can a traumatic experience be forgotten?
"Most people do not forget traumatic experiences unless they are rendered unconscious at the time of the experience (Carroll 1)." On the other hand, "studies have shown that people routinely fail to remember significant life events even a year after they have occurred. One study consisted of interviews with 590 persons known to have been injury-producing motor vehicle accidents during the previous year. Approximately 14% did not remember the accident a year later (Loftus 522)." People may forget the experience but only for a short period of time. "An estimate was obtained in a study of 100 women in outpatient treatment for substance abuse in a New York City hospital. More the one half of the women in this sample reported memory of childhood sexual abuse. The vast majority of them remembered the abuse their whole lives. Only 18% claimed that they forgot the abuse for a period of time and later regained the memory (Loftus
522)." Does a theory of this nature stand a chance in court? George Franklin Jr. was convicted for murder of 8 year-old-Susan Kay Nason( who was killed September 22, 1969) in November of 1990 (Loftus 518). This was said to be the first time that an American citizen had been tried and convicted of murder on the basis of a newfangled uncovered repressed memory. Franklin's daughter, Eileen, provided the major evidence against her father. Eileen's memory of the murder had been repressed for more than 20 years. "Juries and judges are learning about repression of memory and about newly emerged memories of molestations not only in the United States but also in Canada, Great Britain, and other parts of the world (Loftus 520)." What else is there to discover about repressed memories? From the information above, you are informed about what it is and how it affects someone physically, emotionally, and legally. What will be done in the future toward repression? Like all other scientific theories, repression is still up for debate. However, you should be enlightened about the topic enough to have an understanding of repressed memories.