A Nation Aborted By Floro Quibuyen
What was Rizal’s vision?
Rizal’s vision was of the nation as an ethical community, a vision of an inclusive nation without borders, and not of a sovereign nation demarcated by a territory and protected by the armature of the state. He was convinced that the road to national liberation, to freedom and justice, was not via the violent seizure of state power—wherein today’s slaves become tomorrow’s tyrants.
The Historians…
• Agoncillo: Reformists were middle-class intellectuals called illustrados and the true revolutionaries were the masses.
• Constantino: Accepts Agoncillo’s characterization. Furthermore, the illustrados provide the masses the ideology of European liberalism.
• Ileto: texts of Rizal have 2 opposite and irreconcilable meanings– the elite’s modernist discourse on Rizal as the ‘liberal reformist’ and the peasants’ folk perception of Rizal as the “Tagalog Christ”
• According to Quibuyen, the conflict between Rizal and del Pilar is not just a personality conflict. There were more profound political/ideological differences between Rizal and del Pilar, both illustrados, than between Rizal and Bonifacio.
The periods and key events concerning Rizal’s political stand about separatism and the revolution.
• 1861 - 1882: formative years– Calamba, Binan, Ateneo and the Jesuits, GOMBURZA, martyrdom, imprisonment of Teodora Alonzo, literary ventures, encounter with the guardia civil
• 1882 - 1887: European sojourn, enlightenment education, medical studies, patriotism, Noli Me Tangere
• 1887 – 1888: the turning point – The Calamba Hacienda Case
• 1888 – 1892: second sojourn—radicalization of Rizal; historical ethnological, linguistic studies, Los Indios Bravos, conflict within break with del Pilar and La Solidaridad, El Filibusterismo
• 1892 – 1896: the moment of truth – Rizal and the Revolution. La Liga Filipina and the Katipunan, exile to Dapitan, arrest and martyrdom.
• From 1887 to 1892, we can see the inconvertible evidence of a subversive Rizal.
• Even before the Calamba incident, Rizal had expressed the view that independence through peaceful struggle was nothing but a dream and that seeking assimilation to Spain was a mistake.
• A more radical Rizal can be seen after Rizal’s break with del Pilar and the La Solidaridad.
• For del Pilar’s group, the sole problem to work on was the expulsion of the friars, but Rizal had come to realize that the root problem was the Spanish colonialism itself. For Rizal, the illustrados should work for the enlightenment of the Filipinos in the Philippines.
• The Calamba tragedy led Rizal away from del Pilar’s assimilationist program. He then turned to the Philippines to start a more militant, more conciously nationalist movement, La Liga Filipina.
The Calamba Hacienda Case
• Buecamino, removed himself as the legal counsel for the Rizal family, when he realized that Rizal had a more legal agenda in resisting the Dominicans, who after all were willing to come to the settlement but only with the ring leaders.
• Buencamino narrated that Rizal was pushing the people to the brink of a revolution through the simple act of the tenants’ refusing to pay the friars’ canon for their supposed estate.
December 30, 1891(Rizal’s letter to Blumentritt): Rizal’s disillusionment with Spain was complete.
• The Calamba tragedy led Rizal to make a more radical separatist position in the second phase of his political career (1882 – 1892)
• Rizal was viewed as the assimilationist and del Pilar the separatist, which was contrary to the fact.
RIZAL AND THE REVOLUTION
• Apacible: Rizal was not a separatist before he discovered the real situation in the Philippines but when he discovered everything, he had become a complete and wavering separatist.
• Rizal was an antirevolutionary reformist and a deep loyal subject of Spain.
• Zaide: Rizal supported the Revolution from the statements of Pio Valenzuela.
• Manuel: Refuted the evidences of Zaide.
Retana’s Collection all contradicting Pio.
• Rizal’s 12 December 1896 memorandum for his defense in his trial for treason before the Spanish Council of War “Defensa del Dr. Jose Rizal”; and the 15 December 1896 “Manifesto a Algunos Filipinos”
• The final defense of Rizal’s lawyer, D. Luis Taviel de Andrade (“Documento Original de la Defensa de Rizal&rdquo read before the Council of War on 25 December 1896.
• Dr. Pio Valenzuela’s declarations while prisoner of war, to Spanish authorities on 6 September 1896; and his subsequent addendum (“Ampliacion a la Declaracion Indigatoria que Tiene Prestada Pio Valenzuela&rdquo
• Jose Dizon y Matanza’s testimony, while prisoner of war, to Spanish authorities, confirming Valenzuela’s 6 September testimony,
Saan man mautas ay di kailangan
Cipres o laurel, lirio ma’y putungan
Pakikihamok at ang bibitayan
Yaon ay gaon din kung hiling ng Bayan
These crucial lines solve the double puzzle.
First, if Rizal is willing to support the revolution, why did he not join when it finally came?
Second, what was the basis of the popular perception that he was the Tagalog Christ?
Quibuyen: Confronted with the option between revolution and martyrdom, Rizal chose the later.
False premise that Rizal was an assimilationist reformist who “vehemently repudiated” the revolution.
American representation of Rizal as a counterrevolutionary bourgeois intellectual
Filipino – whoever persecuted by the colonizer, regardless of the ethnicity.
Rizal never equated Filipino with Hispanization. In Rizal’s mind, Filipino signifies the nation-in the-making
A theme running through the Noli-Fili is that an oppressed people may be disunited and without a voice, but through enlightened struggle, it can become a nation Batay sa mga talang ito galling sa aklat ni Quibuyen, masasabing si Rizal ay separatist, antirevolutionary at radikal.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Rizal’s appeal for education was not contrary to Spain’s aim at Christianizing the Filipinos. Rizal warned Spain against the possible outcome that may arise from denying the people the benefits of education. The enriching events of Rizal’s study abroad made him see how education could bring social progress. And this he directed toward the development of national sentiment. Rizal’s desire to share with his people what he had learned during his studies in Spain, France, Germany and his observations in London and Belgium became his supreme…
- 2082 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
Majul, Cesar Adib. 1974. “Three thinkers: how they moved men and events.” Archipelago I, 11 (November): 8-13. Hays, H. R. 1958. From Ape to Angel. New York: Capricorn Books. Martinez-Ramirez, Miguel A. 1961. “El Dr. Jose Rizal Glorificado en Cuba.” In Rizal. Manila: Jose Rizal National Centennial Commission. Marx, Karl. 1956. Selected Writings in Sociology and Philosophy. Ed. Tom Bottomore. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company. ----. 1975. Early Writings. New York: Vintage Books. Ocampo, Ambeth. 1990. Rizal Without the Overcoat. Manila: Anvil Publishing. Available at http://www.scribd.com/doc/31825298/Demythologizing-Rizal-by-Ambeth-Ocampo.html -----. 1998. The Centennial Countdown. Manila: Anvil Publishing. Palma, Rafael. 1949. The Pride of the Malay Race. Tr. Roman Ozaeta. New York: Prentice Hall, Inc. Quibuyen, Floro. 1999. A Nation Aborted. Quezon City: Ateneo University Press. Radaic, Ante. 1999. Jose Rizal Romantiko Realista. Tr. Trinidad O. Regala. Quezon City: University of the Philippines Press. Rafael, Vicente. 2003. “Foreignnesss and Vengeance: On Rizal’s El filibusterismo.” In Southeast Asia Over Three Generations,” ed. James Siegel and Audrey Kahin. Ithaca: Southeast Asia Program, Cornell University. Richardson, Jim. 2006. “Academic Anarchy.” Journal of Contemporary Asia : 532-44. Rizal, Jose. 1961. The Rizal-Blumentritt Correspondence. Manila: Jose Rizal National Centennial Commission. ----. 1962. “Mariang Makiling.” In Rizal’s Prose. Volume 3, Book Two. Manila: Jose Rizal National Centennial Commission. ----. 1962. “Mi Retiro,” in Rizal’s Poems. Tr. Encarnacion Alzona. Centennial Edition. Manila: Jose Riaal Centennial Commission, 1962. ----. 1974. “Reflections of a Filipino.” In Filipino Nationalism 1872-1970, ed. Teodoro Agoncillo. Manila: R.P. Garcia Publishing Co. ----.1984. “To the Young Women of Malolos.” In Gregorio Zaide and Sonia Zaide, Jose Rizal. Life, Works and Writings of a Genius, Writer, Scientist and National Hero. Manila: National Book Store. The original Tagalog text is available at: ----. 1993. Letters Between Rizal and Family Members (1876-1896). Manila: National Historical Institute. ----. 2004. El Filibusterismo. Tr. Soledad Lacson-Locsin. Manila: Bookmark. ----. 2004. Noli Me Tangere. Tr. Soledad Lacson-Locsin. Manila: Bookmark. Thomson, George. 1968. Aeschylus and Athens. New York: Grosset and Dunlap. Zaide, Gregorio and Sonia Zayde. 1984. Jose Rizal. Manila: National Book Store. Zizek, Slavoj. 2008. Violence. New York: Picador. Copyright ã 2011 by E. San Juan, Jr. _________[This is the Afterword, in modified form,to the revised edition of my RIZAL IN OUR TIME, published by Anvil Publishing, June 2011]…
- 14050 Words
- 57 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Release Date: November, 2004 [EBook #6885] [Yes, we are more than one year ahead of schedule] [This file was first posted on February 7, 2003] Edition: 10 Language: English Character set encoding: ISO 8859-1 *** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE INDOLENCE OF THE FILIPINO *** Prepared by Jeroen Hellingman THE INDOLENCE OF THE FILIPINO BY JOSE RIZAL ("LA INDOLENCIA DE LOS FILIPINOS" IN ENGLISH.) EDITOR'S EXPLANATION Mr. Charles Derbyshire, who put Rizal's great novel Noli me tangere and its sequel El Filibusterismo into English (as The Social Cancer and The Reign of Greed), besides many minor writings of the "Greatest Man of the Brown Race", has rendered a similar service for La Indolencia de los Filipinos in the following pages, and with that same fidelity and sympathetic comprehension of the author's meaning which has made…
- 18500 Words
- 74 Pages
Powerful Essays -
| – Pío Valenzuela visits and informs Rizal of the impending revolution against the Spanish colonial government…
- 438 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Yabes, Leopoldo. “Rizal, Nationalist and Internationalist.” Rizal as an Internationalist. Manila: National Historical Institute, 1980.…
- 1161 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Boncan, C. (2009). Journey into the Light: Rizal in Europe. PHA Historical Bulletin. Vol. XLIII.…
- 1242 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
* House Bill no. 5561 authored by Cong. Jacobo Gonzales (only a photocopy of the senate bill no. 438)…
- 353 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
* Furious attacks on Rizal by SenatorSalamanca and Vida in the SpanishCortes and by Desengaños (Wenseslao E.Retana) and Quioquiap (Pablo Feced) inspanish newspapers…
- 592 Words
- 3 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The article shares the ideas and opinions in dialogues that usually represent conflicting views about Dr. Jose Rizal. Even though he is our national hero we still feel in need of a continuing dialogue on his ideas, principles and convictions. We know him as a profound thinker and a great doer who love our country and had remarkable patriotism. For that he was called the “First Filipino.”…
- 999 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
8. Why, of all heroes, was Rizal the most venerated in the 19 th century nationalist movement? What was it in Rizal’s life and works that struck a chord in popular imagination? What was Rizal’s nationalist agenda? How was it received by the revolutionaries? Did the people of the 19 th century perceive Liga and the Katipunan as ideologically and strategically opposed political organizations ? Did the revolutionaries perceive Rizal as an assimilationist and therefore opposed revolution ? Did they, for that matter, perceive Reform and Revolution as opposed political agendas?…
- 1083 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
RIZAL ENTERS THE UNIVERSITY April 1877- Rizal who was then nearly 16 years old, matriculated in the University of Santo Tomas, taking the course on Philosophy and Letters. Rizal enrolled in this course for 2 reasons: 1. His father liked it 2. He was “still uncertain as to what career to pursue”.…
- 8472 Words
- 34 Pages
Good Essays -
As the firing of the guns silenced the surroundings, the mourning of the Filipinos present in Bagumbayan was heard, their cries were noticed, and the Katipuneros’ anger sprung out, bursted, leading them into a violent encounter with the opponent. They may have killed hundreds, or maybe thousands; they may have captured and arrested the Friars; and they may have attained liberty in the next two years, but the question is, is this what Rizal wanted?…
- 539 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
One hundred fifty one years hitherto, a substantial Filipino in the illustrious epithet of Jose Protacio Rizal Mercado y Realonda, extricated our predecessors from being slaves by deploying a taciturn yet strapping apparatus. It was for his exertion that we are anon lodging on the snug threshold of freedom. By dint of his literary works −essays, novels and articles. He brawled for our territory’s liberty hostile to the Spanish settlers who subjugated us for three hundred thirty three years.…
- 1230 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
“We travel rapidly in these historical sketches. The reader flies in his express train in a few minutes through a couple of centuries. The centuries pass more slowly to those to whom the years are doled out day by day. Institutions grow…
- 181166 Words
- 725 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Since Rizal, despite the fact that he is a false hero, continues to be venerated by Filipinos, then that veneration is misplaced and that if his countrymen only “understood” Rizal’s motivation, they would drop him like a hot potato.…
- 558 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays