Preview

Should an Hiv Positive Person Be Allowed to Work in a Healthcare Facility?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
740 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Should an Hiv Positive Person Be Allowed to Work in a Healthcare Facility?
Should an HIV Positive Person be allowed to Work in a Health Care Facility?

Imagine going to your doctor 's office for a simple checkup. The examination approaches its end and a sample of your blood is needed. As your doctor prepares the needle, he unknowingly pricks himself getting his blood on the needle. A week later, your results come back and show that you prove positive for HIV. It turns out that your doctor is HIV positive and passed it on to you from the needle with a blood sample unseen by the naked eye. In outrage, you sue the hospital taking much-needed funds from the institution. This is an example of the very real-life danger of HIV; all it takes is a drop of blood to infect another. Because of this, HIV positive people should not be allowed to work in a health care facility.
There is not yet a cure for HIV/AIDS. Having an HIV positive worker in a health care facility poses a threat to the healthy, sick, elderly, and feeble patients. In 1991, 22-year-old Kimberly Bergalis came forward to the media and told her story of how she was infected with HIV by her dentist Dr. David Acer. She angrily asked the nation 's law makers to authorize a law that would make it mandatory for any healthcare worker infected with HIV to inform their patients of their condition to prevent what happened to her happen to others. Legislators criticized Dr. Acer 's irresponsibility and ignored her plea for help. It was later found out that Acer also infected six other patients he had treated.
Although doctors should feel obligated to tell a patient that they are HIV positive, they question this idea within themselves. A psychiatric group for HIV/AIDS infected physicians located in Manhattan has had many doctors say they experience the fear of telling employers of their condition. Because most hospitals wouldn 't want to have the risk of HIV infection in their patients, these doctors would be dismissed and out of work. The HIV+ doctor would be so afraid of losing their job



Bibliography: 1. Shernoff, Michael. " Physicians Living with HIV/AIDS." The Body: The Complete HIV/AIDS Resource. November 1996.. 2. United States. The Centers for Disease Control. Fact Sheets. . 3. "AIDS/HIV Infected Health Care Workers: Guidance on the Management of Infected Health Care Workers and Patient Notification." Scottish Executive Consultations. 25 June 2005 . 4. "HIV-Positive Health Care Workers." American Academy of Physician Assistants. 2003. < http://www.aapa.org/policy/HIV_workers.html>.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Sidney Abbott has been tainted with HIV since 1986. At the point when the episodes we present happened, her disease had not showed its most genuine side effects. On September 16, 1994, she went to the workplace of Randon Bragdon for a dental arrangement. She unveiled her HIV disease on the patient enrollment sheet. Bragdon finished a dental examination, found a cavity, and educated Abbot of his arrangement against filling cavities of HIV-tainted patients. He offered to perform the work at a hospital with no included charge for his administrations, however Abbott would be in charge of the expense of utilizing the clinic's offices. Abbott declined. Abbott sued Bragdon under state law and §302 of the ADA, 104 Stat. 355, 42 U.S.C charging separation on the premise of her incapacity. The state law cases are not before us. Segment 302 of the ADA gives: “No individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who … operates a place of public accommodation.”…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    HSA 515 Week 9 Assignment 3 – Legal Ethics, Patients’ Rights, and HIV AIDS – Strayer Latest…

    • 355 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) attempts to address some of the barriers to healthcare coverage and related job mobility impediments facing people with HIV as well as other vulnerable populations. HIPAA has three main goals. The first is to provide persons with group coverage new protections from discriminatory treatment. The second is to enable small groups (such as businesses with a small number of employees) to obtain and keep health insurance coverage more easily. The third is to give persons losing/leaving group coverage new options for obtaining individual coverage. This law provides several protections important to people with HIV/AIDS. The first is it limits (but does not wholly eliminate) the use of pre-existing condition exclusions. It also prohibits group health…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Heath Insurance portability Act (HIPPA) of 1996 is a law designed to protect a patients personal and health information from being disclosed, it allows patients great access and control to his or her information, enhances health care, and creates a national framework for health privacy protection. Everyone in the health care business should be aware of the HIPAA law to protect the privacy and confidentiality of anyone who may be cared for in the facility. The patient must also sign and acknowledge the HIPPA privacy statement that is usually received during visits and prescription pickups. HIPAA protects the patient’s medical and personal information from being released to other staff members in a social manner, the patients workplace unless under workman’s comp, and not released to anyone who is not involved in the patients visit. HIPAA is a very important rule when it comes to HIV and AIDS this disease must be handled in a more sensitive manner than other diseases and HIPAA should protect the patient’s information from entering in the wrong hands. HIV and AIDS do have a large amount of stigma, misconception, and discrimination it can cause many problems for patients diagnosed and there information has been leaked. HIV and AIDS is a very touchy subject amongst many people. This disease is one that a person will most likely not recover from as well as a disease that is deadly if not treated. The HIPAA confidentiality is important for the patients who do not want others to know they have the disease. HIV and AIDS is often a lifestyle disease which some people may look at differently than others or may look down on them. Because HIV and AIDS are usually transmitted through sexual intercourse, semen, vaginal discharge, blood, and drug use some people may think this is bad behavior on that person’s part. HIPAA protects the patient’s personal information and protects his or her medical information such as diagnosis, treatments,…

    • 1442 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bio Ethics

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the patient confidentiality case of Carlos, a 21 year old Hispanic male is being discharged from his hospital stay for a gunshot wound. Carlos is intended to receive nursing care at home from his sister, Consuela. Carlos is secretly a homosexual and is concerned that his secret will be revealed and be disgraced by his family. Carlos pleaded with his physician not to inform his sister that he is HIV-positive. Not informing Consuela would seem to increase her risk of contracting HIV while attending to Carlos’ wounds. The ethical issue is whether Carlos’ physician is justified in breaching confidentiality on the grounds that he has the “duty to warn” Consuela of the risks at hand.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    August 19, 1992, in Salt Lake City, Mary Fisher a woman infected with the deadly disease known as HIV, asked the Republican party, to lift their silence on the epidemic that has struck the US. HIV is an epidemic that strikes all races, genders, and people. She tells that “two hundred thousand Americans are dead or dying” due to this disease. The Republicans like to think that this disease is strictly affecting a certain group of people, they believe the disease only strikes certain people. Specifically, the republicans believe the HIV disease attacks. Fishers main topic on the paper was “if you think you’re safe you’re not” This was Mary Fishers main point, she wanted to prove that everyone has the same chances of contracting the disease. After Fisher got married, she contracted HIV from her husband, although her two children did…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hiv Aids Dbq

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages

    All five men were reported as having been previously healthy and all had indicators that their immune systems were becoming ineffective. By the end of the year, out of the 270 reported cases 121 of them ended in mortality (AIDS.gov). In response, The CDC released the report “Current Trends [...] and Precautions for Clinical and Laboratory Staffs” (CDC, 1982), using the increased inflow of data to sketch an outline of the disease:…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The most serious diseases in history are HIV and AIDS. Approximately 20 years ago doctors found the first case of AIDS in the United States. Today, people living with HIV and AIDS have been estimated to be around 42 million people (Teens Health, 2009). There has been a report of people living with HIV or AIDS to be around 300,000 who are not even aware that they have this disease. There are approximately 40,000 new HIV infections each year and continues to remain the same (The Body, 2001). Information about HIV and AIDS is confidential and will remain that way as long as there is HIPAA to enforce the privacy of patient’s medical information (The Law office of Kendra S. Kleber & Associates PLLC, n.d.).…

    • 1732 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We Were Here David Weber

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages

    David Weissman and Bill Weber recounted gripping testimonies of those who experienced the 1980’s AIDS/ HIV epidemic in the documentary “We Were Here” (Weissman & Weber, 2011). During this documentary several people told of experiences prior, during, and post the AIDs/HIV crisis. This review will illustrate how Weissman and Weber portrayed the AIDs crisis using the documentary title “ We Were Here” and relevance of the documentary to medical professionals.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The early 1980s was when the AIDS crisis was brought to doctors in the United States attention. This “gay-related immune deficiency (GRID)” or “gay cancer” was being seen mostly in gay men. People outside the gay community began to be affected so then it was relabeled as AIDS (acquired immune deficiency system). The videos ‘We Were Here’ and ‘How to Survive a Plague’ let us in on how people were affected during this crisis.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aids – the Duty to Warn

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The AIDS epidemic began in the early to mid-1980’s and since it’s recognition in America it has become a very heated and debated topic among health professionals, the gay community, and most of all for the ones that are carrying the virus. The real debate is not over the virus itself but, rather about the infected individuals and whether or not they should be made morally obligated to tell their sexual partners if they are in fact infected. Both sides of the argument make very valid points. From one standpoint you have the gay community that believe in “safer sex ethic”, which keeps their partners in the dark about their overall health status and feel they are not morally obligated to tell their partners if they are practicing “safe sex”. In contrast to this, the other side of the argument claim that infected individuals is absolutely morally obligated to tell their partners before engaging in sexual activities. One of the major supporters of this are the healthcare professionals who have to assume the position from the “harm principle”; which requires a health professional to warn a third party if they are aware that their infected patient has not informed their partner and they are engaging in sexual relations with intent to harm the other person. I personally agree with this viewpoint and believe that any individual who engages in sexual activity with their partner are ethically and morally obligated to tell them if they are aware that they are in fact carrying the HIV/AIDS virus.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This comprehensive journal article reviews recent HIV testing and prevalence patterns among the U.S. population. The importance of the care continuum for HIV-positive patients is discussed; from prevention and testing, to diagnosis and treatment. Strategies for viral suppression among those infected are also reviewed. The article presents a very thorough overview with an especially useful public health focus on prevention strategies for the future.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    She quotes, “fortunately, as stated in a U.S News and World Report article, contract law forbids insurers from barring newly diagnosed AIDS patients from group health plans (215).” Even though this law may be strictly enforced, a man living in Colorado tested himself for AIDS and did not have it, and was refused based on the assumption that he may be too much of a risk. Discrimination may not only lead to the workplace or insurance companies, but may also lead to his or her personal life. If I had a friend who I knew had AIDS, I would be very cautious in sharing drinks or food with him or…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hiv Ethical Dilemma

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The case related to a diagnosed HIV client who sees a psychologist for psycho-education and psychological support following the diagnosis of his condition. In discussing it becomes apparent that the client is reluctant in telling his partner or practicing protective sex. The client is angry and indicated that he even considers deliberately infecting other potential partners.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    My honest opinion that should have the right not to hire someone with HIV because HIV is a deadly disease and people who have the virus are not as careful as others which does not exclude that fact that those who have to virus may want to give the virus to others because of mental and emotional problems, but by law no, but with the HIPPA law there is no way you will know if a person has any type of disease they are protected by law the legislation states Individuals with HIV are considered disabled and protected by the ADA.…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays