To “pledge” something is to make a solemn promise. Most students I know use the time set aside for the pledge to screw off. No promises there, let alone solemnness. They don’t care as they solemnly promise their allegiance; their loyalty and devotion. They don’t care because the words are just an insincere series of syllables. Some people say that reiteration helps students feel a sense of unit and nationalism. Repetition teaches memorization not understanding. The pledge doesn’t promote patriotism for the simple reason that students don’t feel patriotic when they repeat the same intonation over and over again.
One of the main points of controversy about the pledge comes from two little words in the middle of the pledge. “Under God,” this little tidbit was added only relatively recently, in nineteen-fifty-four, as a way to separate the pious Americans from the godless Soviets. This change propagandized the pledge into a deliberate criticism of our rivals and their way of life. It is also argued that this phrase discriminates against students who don’t believe in one god or a God at all. While these claims do have merit, one key fact disrupts those arguments. Any and all parts and portions of the pledge are completely voluntary. If a student disagrees with that detail of the pledge they can remain silent without repercussions. As a firm believer in the separation of church and state myself, I do not say this phrase, and I have never experienced any consequences, positive or negative. “With liberty and justice for all;” for all meaning that the pledge is as much mine as it is yours and you should say whatever you are comfortable with.
The main point that I am trying to make is that the pledge is a special, serious, and personal promise you make; not only to the flag or the United States of America but to yourself. It is so much more than some meaningless mantra for you to repeat day-in and day-out. It should only be said in its entirety by people who believe in every word and even then only when they feel that way. Citizens should, and do edit the pledge to make it accommodating to them and their individual dogmas.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In 1954, Congress amended Title 36 of the United States Code by adding “under God” to the Pledge of Allegiance. California Education Code section 52720 requires appropriate patriotic exercises to be practiced in every public elementary school every day. Elk Grove Unified School District’s policy required the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance every day pursuant to section 52720 of the California Education Code. Michael A. Newdow’s daughter attended a public school in the Elk Grove Unified School District in California. Each day, teachers at the school led the students in a voluntary recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance, which included the words “under God.” Newdow, being an atheist and divorced with “shared physical custody” of his daughter, challenged the constitutionality of Elk Grove Unified School District’s requirement that teachers lead their classes in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance. Newdow filed suit in federal district court in California claiming that Elk Grove’s recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance violated the 1st Amendment Establishment Clause to the Constitution due to the words “under God” being included and thus, his daughter was being subjected to religious indoctrination. The district court dismissed Newdow’s claim on the ground that he lacked legal standing because he was divorced from Sandra Banning, the mother of his daughter, and that he did not have legal custody of his daughter. The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the lower court’s ruling, deciding that Newdow did have holding as a parent to sue and that the school district’s policy violated the establishment clause. The school district appealed the decision to the Supreme Court, which granted review.…
- 1101 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In 1962, the New York Law approved a prayer that sent the country into chaos. It all began when the New York Board of Regents authorized a short prayer that students would recite along with the Pledge of Allegiance. According to the school, the prayer was voluntary and non-denominational. The prayer read, "Almighty God, we acknowledge our dependence upon Thee, and beg Thy blessings upon us, our teachers, and our country." Many parents revolted and argued that the voluntary prayer was against their religious beliefs. One group of parents, lead by Steven Engel, took the case to court, claiming that the prayer violated the Establishment Clause in the First Amendment.…
- 1065 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
I found this interesting because I have two students in my classroom that do not say the pledge. The first boy is Muslim and it is against his religion. I am not sure why the second boy does not say the pledge, but they both stand when the rest of the class says it and they are very respectful.…
- 289 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Society changes daily, even to a point in which the Constitution’s relevance is currently questioned. Although the Pledge is important to the majority of Americans, it should not be required in consideration of others. The American students who do choose to say the morning pledge should be respected by those who do not. Teachers should enforce no talking or distractions during the Pledge of Allegiance.…
- 1397 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
I see school prayer as a moral issue because although it does state in the constitution the separation of church and state, I believe that this issue is just a conflict between religious people and liberal people that don’t believe in religion. I think it is morally wrong to force someone into a religion but I don’t see how prayer does that, if you don’t believe then don’t do the prayer and that is all. B. It is not proper for one religion to impose its morality and doctrine on another if and when they are doing it out of legal bounds, besides that I believe it is acceptable to say what you…
- 806 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Some think that it was part of something far and unknown. No, actually it is and forever will be a big part in American history. Trying to remove it now is thoughtless, we shouldn't have to relearn to whole pledge because of some small percentage of who either don't believe in God or don't believe in "forcing" students to say it. Removing the words "under God" from the pledge, is going to hurt our belief in traditions. In the same article it says, " 'Most Americans have recited the pledge hundreds of times and are not inclined to memorize a different pledge', he says. 'Changing it may just feel wrong. Most Americans they believe in God or a higher being and feel comfortable having "under God" in the pledge.' " In other words barley anyone wants to learn a different pledge and the current one makes sense to the majority. Furthermore, our nation was built up on religious principles, shouldn't it stay that way? Why should we change it? Also, in an article called "Trump: 'Under God' in the Pledge of Allegiance Is 'a Great Thing' it says, " 'Because that's what we are and that is what we will always be, and that is what our people want', he said." Trump says that we thought of ourselves as living under God, and we think the same way…
- 1154 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The pledge of allegiance has remained an important part of the American legacy and culture. It takes part in the American school system, in American sports, and in many other areas. Many say that the pledge holds a place in their hearts, where it allows them to show their pride for their country. But in this pledge there are two words that have a tendency ring in the ears of many Americans, “under god.” In a country that is proud of the separation of church and state, we leave these words in a pledge that is said everyday by millions of Americans who believe and trust the right of separation of church of state yet we fail to do this for a major component in American culture. The words “under god” hold little meaning and should not be placed in the pledge of allegiance, they should be removed permanently.…
- 813 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
My choice of writing for the Rogerian essay is on the topic of the Pledge of Allegiance in School. “In a decision that stunned the nation, a federal appeals court in June ruled that reciting the Pledge of Allegiance in public schools is unconstitutional because the pledge contains the words "under God" “ (Chmielewski). The banning of the Pledge of Allegiance is a very large controversial topic because one side believes that while the foundation of our country is religion, the other side believes that the reciting of the Pledge of Allegiance is an infringement on our First Amendment right. The Pledge of Allegiance began in 1892. It was a way of showing a sense of celebration for being an American. Since 1892…
- 397 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
What I learn is that it is unconstitutional to stand for the pledge. Therefore, I agree with that statement. One time, in school there was a student who did not wanted to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. So the teacher forced him to stand. That means it is not mandatory.…
- 175 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
I think that all the schools in America should have a flag of the U.S on display. It’s good to have a flag at your house. If anyone does have a flag, they should take it down in bad weather like snow, rain, or windy weather. If you do have a flag, you need to all ways take it down at night unless there is a light shining on it. You should always sing the National Anthem at sporting events and say the pledge of Allegiance at political events because it is a good way to show that you love and support your country.…
- 407 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In addition, our Party controls family structure by teaching the children to become Junior Spies, which brainwashes and encourages them to eavesdrop on their own parents and tattle-tale their thoughtcrimes. Therefore, not only adults are obliged to make the pledge, children are obliged to do so as well, and it takes a lot less effort to convince the kids than the adults. As The Party, we invent enemies who are responsible for their misfortunes. The citizens build up emotions and anger to hate these made-up enemies, so they unite by having a common enemy just as the Party had planned.…
- 343 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The Pledge of Allegiance was written to fit any person in any country but the in 1945 the U.S. adopted it and changed it twice to fit our country but it wasn’t used in the morning to start the day for fifty-five years. In 2004 a student named Michael Newdow argued that “under God” challenged the right to freedom of religion and violated the prohibition on the establishment of religion in the First Amendment of the United States…
- 233 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
‘The Star Spangled Banner’ is the national anthem of the United States of America, and has been since 1931. It is a timeless iconic anthem and in a somewhat clichéd manner, I love how this one song, consisting of just 4 stanzas has the power to unite every American, regardless of differing socio-economic status, political views and religious belief in love for ‘the land of the free and the home of the brave’ that they live in.…
- 541 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Having a distinct national anthem just like a unique national flag as a form of national identity is one thing that is common to virtually every country or nation of the world. An anthem according to the Encyclopaedia Britannica is a song or a hymn expressing patriotic sentiment that is either governmentally authorized as an official national song/hymn or holding that position in popular feelings. However, the national anthems of many nations are not just mere songs of praises but hymns of allegiance to nations sung or recited with utmost respect at important occasions or ceremonies as a sign of honour or symbol of loyalty and patriotism. They are usually carefully, emotionally, and meaningfully worded to reflect the ideologies, politics, philosophies, cultures etc of given nations. They therefore, easily appeal to the emotion, arouse feelings or captivate the attention of patriotic citizens when sung or recited.…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
* “We pledge the loyalty of faithful friends…we pledge our word…we pledge our best efforts…” * Emphasises the…
- 505 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays