Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Social Status and Tax Warfare

Better Essays
1216 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Social Status and Tax Warfare
Since the beginning everything has been a power struggle, the ones who possesses the most resources dominated over those with the lesser amount. In this day and age, money reigns over the social class and those without it are struggling against the government who controls the majority of it all.As stated by Dee Dee Myers in her article, “What Class Warfare Really Means,” “the same folks who have seen their incomes and wealth skyrocket in recent decades – would take the biggest hit.” (Myers) With this issue, UTA students are directly affected because the problem of the current financial difficulties is tied to their friends, family, and themselves. The levels of taxes cripples the middle and lower class, keeping them within their social class, and gives them no hope of further succession Here, Myers explains how the higher and lower classes are virtually unaffected, while the working top brackets of the middle class are taxed to no end.Though many say there is not any difference between classes, I believe that the middle class is treated unequally in terms of taxation versus the other class’s because the government’s inability to distribute tax equally amongst the three classes,the boundaries being the gap in income which keep one classing from rising to another, and the nation’s obliviousness in realizing the unevenly distributed money. For several decades the democratic and republican parties have been in debate over tax preference, resulting in this tax warfare. Students at UTA and virtually any other colleges are forcibly introduced into the world of economy as we take are big leap into debt and taxation. As the majority falls into the middle class due to their loans, students are herded into an unfairly taxed bracket that they will possibly spend the rest of their lives in. In Dee Dee Myers’s essay she lays out the facts that states, “The 400 Americans with the highest adjusted gross income saw their effective tax rates plummet from 30 percent” (Myers) and that, “the bottom 40 percent of earners would be virtually unaffected.” (Myers) As explained, you can tell she is pointing out how the high and low class receives the tax break while the middle class is left in the ditch with taxes to pay. Students would find this important because they can never be accurate in determining which bracket of the economy they will fall into. “They expect to have their own shot at getting rich. But increasingly, they are seeing that the game is rigged.” (Myers) I, like countless other students, began to realize this as I journeyed into adulthood and discovered that success into the “good life” of high income will be limited as long as the government restrains us from growth.
In relevance to that statement, a tremendous gap between those of low class incomes and those of the high class is clearly stated, “the wealthiest percentile has seen its income grow by a robust 17 percent, while the middle class has seen its real income fall.” (Norton) Though in different articles, similar thoughts are shared as they state unbelievably informative facts stating the gap between the rich and poor. Having this large gap between classes, one can only be left with the belief that the lower and middle class have no hope to gain any possibilities of greater success.Though many still believe that if they persevere through college and earn their degree, they will be able to jump into the high class and make hundreds of thousands of dollars, but in reality many will realize the difficulties, “More Americans than twenty years ago believe it possible to start out poor, work hard, and become rich.” (Scott and Leonhardt) as stated in Scott and Leonhardt’s essay, it seems that they are arguing that the lower and middle class are losing hope in rising to higher classes.
With this all said the main issue can be seen as America’s obliviousness over the topic as a whole. A professor from Harvard named Michael Norton discussed in an interview over how Americans has unnoticed or underestimates “what the actual level of wealth inequality is in the United States right now.” (Norton) In Scott and Leonhardt’s novel, they saw class as, “seeming more elusive than ever” I would agree only to a certain point because they are unaware of “the top 20 percent, as I said, have 85 percent of the wealth.” (Norton) Also with the fact that “the bottom 40 percent of the people in the United States have basically zero wealth,” as stated by Norton. In that statement, it exemplifies how unevenly the money is distributed in the United States. As students of UTA, we remain uninformed or have no desire to learn about the current state of America’s wealth. Also for students whose income is transferred from generation to generation is, “so money that goes from generation to generation to generation is very flat. So it tends to perpetuate a great deal over time.” In other words, all will be affected. The poor to the rich, in the end, it can only be solved by today’s students or the “future of America” to be properly be informed in order to solve our financial issues for the better.
Though I know people will argue against my opinions, it will not hide the truth and the citizens of America will come to realize it sooner or later. In Scott and Leonhard’s novel, they stated, “The income of the middle class rose by just 17 percent, to $43,700, and the income of the poorest fifth rose only 9 percent.” (Myers) Which could be consider “a large increase” that the rich could argue, trying to state the point that the lower classes has gained some income. But in reality, “the top 20 percent of Americans is that they have 85 percent of the wealth in America.” (Norton) which cannot be overlooked. Those who oppose my idea might also say, “we worked for all this, why can’t you?” But in the interview with Michael Norton, he states, “But it 's much, much rarer than people believe, and especially wealth transmission,” which shows the difficulty imposed among the lower classes, and making them hopeless for any effort in succeeding. Social warfare will seem endless, as it has been here for several centuries. Many come up with an argument to speak their thoughts in unfairness to the irregularly balanced economic levels, in effort to make the public realize these issues. I, myself have argued in an informative point of view to help educate our future of America, the students of UTA, hoping my thoughts will expand from them knowing our variety of wealth levels from rich to poor. Hoping to end the obliviousness of this country, I informed the students, working hard for their future, so that they can at least scratch the surface of this issue as they grow and realize the hardships of inequality that come before them.

Works Cited Myers, Dee Dee. "What Class Warfare Really Looks like" ["What Class Warfare Really Looks like"]. Politco. POLITICO, 11 July 2011. Web. 28 Nov. 2012.
Norton, Michael. Interview by Steve Inskeep.Morning Edition. Natl. Public Radio, 7 Oct. 2010.
Web. 11 July 2011.
Scott And Leonhardt. “Class Matters”. New York, NY: Time Novels, 2005.1-26. Print.

Cited: Myers, Dee Dee. "What Class Warfare Really Looks like" ["What Class Warfare Really Looks like"]. Politco. POLITICO, 11 July 2011. Web. 28 Nov. 2012. Norton, Michael. Interview by Steve Inskeep.Morning Edition. Natl. Public Radio, 7 Oct. 2010. Web. 11 July 2011. Scott And Leonhardt. “Class Matters”. New York, NY: Time Novels, 2005.1-26. Print.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As a guest editor I was asked to review and analyze Dee Dee Myers article “What class warfare really looks like”, and either recommend it or not for publishing in The Shorthorn. After considering all rhetorical appeal in Myers’ writing, I concluded that it should not be read at large by the UTA community. Therefore I must recommend that it should not be published in The Shorthorn, due to the fact that Myers states the gap between the super-rich and everyone else has steadily grown. The rich are getting richer while the poor are getting poorer. I am sure everyone knows the strength of money. Myers raises a question here- are super wealthy people much smarter and productive than the rest of us? Everybody knows the answer…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Frank Too Big Too Ignore

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Robert Frank, a professer at Cornell University, published an article for the New York Times on October 16, 2010. The title of the article was "Income Inequality: Too Big to Ignore". In "Income Inequality: Too Big to Ignore", Frank argues that there are differences in the social classes of the American people and that it is having a negative effect on our economy's growth. Frank explains that middle class citizens are in a struggle to maintain a good financial position. Meanwhile, the upper class citizens are spending copious amounts of money which makes it increasingly more difficult for the middle class to meet their basic needs. He says that the middle class are looking toward upper class citizens, comparing their posesions as well as their financial positions which makes the middle class feel financially unstable.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bernie Sanders Tax Model

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Sanders idea of providing aid to people who cant afford higher education isn’t exactly benefiting the poor or lower class as much as he intended. In the article Mitchell references Brookings contributor Mathew Chingos ideas and he says, “Mr. Chingos’s explanation is simple. The Sanders plan would relieve students of paying any tuition at public colleges and universities, both at more-selective schools that tend to be more expensive, and less-selective schools that tend to be cheaper’… ‘At public four-year colleges, dependent students from higher-income families tend to attend more expensive institutions,’ he writes. As a result, they would get most of the aid if college tuition were free (Mitchell 1).” Given these circumstances the wealthy are the ones benefiting most from the free tuition not the lower class or the people sanders intended to help. Michel touches on this when he writes, “The benefits of the Sanders plan, in dollar terms, rise as household income rises. Among all public institutions, dependent students in the bottom quarter of earners would get, on average, $3,678 in tuition relief. Students in the top quarter would get $5,308 (1).” The problem that typically arises when a tax plan generalizes like this and doesn’t target a specific group the wealthy typically reaps the benefits. Chingos says, “ ‘There are…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For as long most people can remember, the middle class has been the economic majority in the United States. In Edward McClelland's article "RIP, the Middle Class: 1946-2013", McClelland argues the sooner than later, the middle class will be merely nonexistent and the economy will only consist of rich and poor. He casually explains to middle class American citizens what the past middle class looked like, how the middle class stands now, and some hardships that people of the recession experienced. Growing up in the 1970's, McClelland describes how someone didn't need to graduate high school to obtain a job that could support a family, but now, in the twenty-first century, even with a high school diploma and four years of college education, no well paying jobs are promised. In this article,…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mr. Burd argues that the federal government is not doing enough to help working-class college-goers pay for school. He plays up the argument that working class college- goers are being punished for being nontraditional while downplaying the argument that “standards for admission” are a necessary component of higher learning.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Borstelmann notes, “The gap between rich and poor grew wider, startlingly so at times, and the bulk of the vaunted American middle class saw its economic security begin to slip away” (Borstelmann, 306). With the U.S. economy during the time period placing a premium on education, college graduates and those with advanced degrees saw their income rise. At the same time, due to globalization, lower numbers of unionized workers, and higher divorce rates, workers with high school diplomas saw a drop in their income while political leaders sat by and did nothing to mitigate this growing trend toward inequality. The U.S. had the most uneven distribution of wealth of any industrialized nation, where poverty rates reached 15 percent in 1994 and remained at 13 percent in 2008. Borstelmann notes “the rate was 18 percent for minors; nearly one in five American children were growing up in poverty in the new millennium” (Borstelmann, 308).…

    • 1719 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Our intent with The rich and the rest of us is to make [people] think about the pervasiveness of poverty, its real causation, and the threat it poses to our democracy. We want to raise awareness about poverty and discuss how best to end it- in out lifetime. “(Excerpted from the introduction, page 10-11)…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Draut then correlates this inability to succeed with how the government supports its citizens. She makes a contrasts this generation to earlier generations when “if you wanted to go to college, it wasn’t that expensive and grants were widely available.”(493) This along with other economic changes in society had brought Draut to the conclusion that “Government no longer has our back….”(493) Although she does address that the federal government is spending more than ever before on student aid, she believes that this is not enough. In the end, she explains how this generation could have a better time succeeding if student loans weren’t as punishing and lowered their interest rates (492).…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paul Krugman

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Within this social system, the author tells us of how desirable school districts are decreasing in number and are becoming much more expensive to live in, making it so that children with low-income parents get a “bad start” in their education. Krugman also states that corrupt politics are a direct result of the difference between the 1% and rest of the country. Using that point as fuel he argues for the removal of tax cuts for the wealthy. Krugman shows us that the Urban-Brookings Joint Tax Policy Center estimated that if Bush tax breaks expired in 2010 for those who have an income of over $200,000 then the money gained from taxes could fund a universal healthcare system for the entire nation.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The choice to attend college is a personal one. Earning a college degree involves a great deal of personal commitment. Ultimately, while the individual attainment of a college degree may benefit the greater society, the overwhelming benefit is to the individual. In contrast, a public road or sidewalk benefits the many. Road and sidewalks are integral to many peoples’ daily lives. Government should seek to benefit the many; however, the Denver City Council seeks to benefit individuals through the imposition of a sales tax for scholarships. In an era of limited incomes and higher taxes, the question becomes, “Which is more more beneficial-- taxing Peter to benefit Paul only or taxing Peter to benefit all?” This question was addressed in…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Class Matters

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Leonhardt , David and Janny Scott; ed. bell hooks. (2005).“Shadowy Lines that Still Divide,” Class Matters, Times Books, New York.…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The economic gap in America is growing, causing many colleges to recruit students from upper class families. This way they would not have as many students in their financial…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sadly, further research into poverty indicates that “ many children face the prospect of having lower living standards than their parents” (Boffey, 1). As a society, many Americans are disregarding the future that children in the middle class were supposed to have. Since the middle class are receiving lower income, the middle class children will have never have the opportunity to proceed to college without being in debt afterwards. When they graduate, they will be living paycheck to paycheck solely because of the low income their parents received. In order to prevent the death of the middle class, we must provide higher positions in society to those who work harder to secure the future of America’s…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over a 9-year period between 1989 and 1998, “[...] the proportion of net worth owned by the top 1 percent [...] rose from 30 percent to more than 34 percent [while...] those in the bottom 90 percent declined from 33 percent to just over 30 percent” (Ciment). Wealth is gradually shifting towards the few and affluent at the expense of the numerous poor due to the increased power of corporations and the rich. The rich and their corporations are able to influence the way money circulates, allowing more money to be diverted to them from the lower and middle classes. This creates the basis as to why the rich continue accumulating wealth while the rest of the populace loses it. Additionally, the rich earn money faster than everyone else, giving them an advantage after recessions.“93 per cent of the income gains in the first official year of economic recovery went to the top one per cent [in terms of wealth] in the US” (Jones). Despite the recent economic gains, most of the population is not benefited by them, with the rich having the largest gains. The poor and middle classes’ incomes remain stagnant or even decrease, highlighting the great disparity between the rich and everyone else. When economic gains are made, money only goes to certain groups, leaving others the same or worse…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Classless Society

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In addition, one of the biggest dilemma that's produced as a result of our socioeconomic system is its own reincarnation. The duplication on a mass level of norms, roles, careers, health, wealth, and lifestyle as generations pass results in the rich getting richer, and the poor getting poorer. However, this is the not the image that is portrayed in the popular image of America’s class structure. One of the four biggest myths veiling the reality of class is that the U.S is “fundamentally a classless society,” and aside from a few minor distinctions everyone is uniform under the law. Likewise, the second myth, derives from the fact that since we are a “classless” society, we’re all in general, the same or in this case middle-class; as a majority…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays