Preview

Stanford Prison Experiments Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
688 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Stanford Prison Experiments Summary
Can good, moral, and virtuous people be pushed to do bad things? This article seeks to compare an experiment done in 1971 to a real life military situation during wartime. The article also tries to link the experiment to another horrible act done by someone suffering from various mental illnesses with extremely mixed results. Is there a correlation between these three events as far as the mental states of the participants?

The article starts off telling the story of Sergeant John M Russell taking the lives of 5 American Soldiers on May 11, 2009. After he pled guilty to this appalling act, more detailed, information surfaced about his mental state. Sgt. Russell was on his third deployment in six years without incident. (Hong) Although
…show more content…
I believe the principles of entrapment (Wade, Travis, Garry 261) and situational attribution (Wade, Travis, Garry 263) apply in this case. I, personally, could not blindly comply, but it’s also situational. If I were in the military, I would have to comply or face a possible court martial. I don’t see a correlation between college students being paid to play prison guards (who are taking on an authoritative persona in a campus basement) to American soldiers guarding detainees at Abu Garaib during wartime, knowing that these said detainees more than likely want to kill Americans. U.S. soldiers take an oath to uphold the constitution and protect the homeland and its people. (US Army), whereas, civilians have a little more control over their personal decisions. After just recently having the experience of watching the movie American Sniper, Bradley Cooper’s portrayal of Chief Petty Officer Chris Kyle makes me somewhat empathetic to Sgt. Russell. I don’t agree with what Sgt. Russell did, however his mental state at the time was not in a good way. In a way, I connect his story more to Chris Kyle’s story. Simply, because that is along the lines of how Chris Kyle died. The college students that played the guards in the experiment were “given permission to create boredom, a sense of frustration, fear to some degree, and a notion of arbitrariness”

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Stanford Prison Experiment was an experiment that Philip Zimbardo evented. He wanted to study the human response of captivity, of the prison life. Zimbardo randomly assigned roles to the prisoners and the guards. Each role was uniquely identified. For example, he gave the guards sticks and sunglasses and the prisoners were arrested by the police department and were forced into the basement of the jail which was converted into the psychology department that was converted into a makeshift jail. Zimbardo wanted the experiment to be as realistic as he possibly could have made it, therefore, he assigned each role to help do so. Testing each individual and then assigning them to roles would of gave inconclusive readings and therefore, it was…

    • 164 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Fact, former Helicopter pilot Lawrence Colburn had said he saw captain Earnest Medina kick and shoot an innocent Vietnamese woman.(3) “Captain approached the women looked down at her kicked her with his foot, stepped back and just blew her away.”(3) From this statement alone you can see Lt. Calley isn’t the only guilty one. Another helicopter pilot Hugh C. Thompson also stated that a soldier said “yeah we will help them out of their misery.”(3) The Geneva Convention clearly prohibits violence to a life and person in particular murder of all kinds.(4) These were supposed to be the good guys but their actions say otherwise.…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Some examples of dysfunction during the stanford prison experiment are one of the guys went into the prison experiment. He thought it was going to be an easy way to get money for a summer job and then when he got there he got the role of being a prisoner. He just lost it he started to say that he was going crazy and that something was eating him inside out. He felt like he was going to explode and so the guards reacted by putting him in the hole. Then the guy would still yell and say he wanted out and they wouldn't let him out until he got the chance to go and talk to the guy that was running this whole thing and they let him out.…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Kelman and V. Lee Hamilton wrote about the tragic massacre of Vietnamese civilians by American soldiers. The My Lai Massacre allegedly occurred on March 16, 1968, however, due to military conspiracy and cover ups the issue remained hidden for a full year. Brought to court on charges in 1969 and 1970. Even though 14 of the high ranking officials had charges against them only one was convicted, which issued alarm and questions. The massacre was documented by soldiers and reports The army commanders assumed all the innocent civilians would be at the market and those remaining would be Vietcong related individuals. Orders were given to Charlie Company that summarized told to destroy the village and all in it. The My Lai Massacre was what is described as a sanctioned massacre “acts of indiscriminate, ruthless, often systematic mass violence, carried out by paramilitary personnel while engaged in officially sanctioned campaigns” (Kelman and Hamilton 137). Sanctioned massacres often described by the authors, are massacres ordered by a higher person that are deemed acceptable due to their authority. The article ends with the authors concluding that massacres are due to political forms dehumanizing civilians as just bodies to be…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Stanford Prison Experiment involved 24 male college students from North America who volunteered locally through advertisements in newspapers. The volunteers had to be living or staying in the Stanford area, totally healthy – psychologically, mentally, emotionally and physically – as well as willing to participate in the study for around 1-2 weeks. For their participation, volunteers would receive a $15 per day compensation.…

    • 293 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, the author cites a worker straight from military grounds: “Chelsea Manning, now serving time in prison as a whistle-blower, uncovered multiple incidents of fellow soldiers laughing as they murdered civilians.” Murdering anyone that does not hold a threat over the American troops is a war crime and absolutely heinous. The fact that the soldiers were laughing as they stole the lives of innocent people proves that not all soldiers are honorable, integrous people. Revealing that soldiers “preferred passing the time with the “entertainment” of YouTube videos capturing air raids of Iraq and Afghanistan, often making jokes and mocking the victims of American violence”, Masciotra proves to the readers that unfit behavior in our troops is a real concern. Fully aware that this evidence is disturbing, Masciotra affiliates it in his article to open the eyes of marvelling…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the infamous experiment in the history of psychology was the Stanford Prison Experiment. Its creator, Dr. Zimbardo, main objective was to see what effects would occur when a psychological experiment into human nature was performed. As I began to perform some research of my own, I noticed that my thoughts on the matter were similar to many; that as a scientific research project, Mr. Zimbardo’s experiment it was a complete failure. However, his findings did provide us with something that was much more important that is still being talked about today; insight into human psychology and social behavior.…

    • 176 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A team at Stanford University, led by Phillip Zimbardo, conducted the Stanford Prison Experiment to investigate causes of conflict between military guards and prisoners. Zimbardo and his team were seeking to observe the inherent personality traits of prisoners and guards and see if this was the chief cause of abusive behavior in these settings (Haney, Banks, and Zimbardo, 1973). This study is one that is well know and well-recognized. Zimbardo and his study are often discussed in many psychology courses today, and have even caused reform in prison systems as well as IRB/APA ethical committees.…

    • 1783 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The soldiers who were not participating are just as guilty as those who did. These acts are not what America prides itself on and not what my idea of America is. Strong leadership probably could have prevented the problem or at the least kept it from getting to the point that it did. If the officers in charge of the prison would have recognized that something was going wrong and put an end to it the problem could have been solved there. When a soldier transferred in and saw that the soldiers there were abusing their powers they could have reported it and maybe the abuse would have ended. Strong leadership does not always mean the top person does something sometimes it means that the person at the bottom must step up and fix the problem. At Abu Ghraib, there was not any strong leadership.…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In an experiment by professor Philip G. Zimbardo to view actions by guards and prisoner, ran a semi-realistic type study. Although, the professor felt that in fact that it was unethical to continue as long as it did, he has used the data to help try to reduce the control issues found. The issues were that the guards became power crazy and push more with this new-found power. The prisoners acted poorly in their roles too. The prisoners felt that they could fight back in their roles which let the guards at worse.…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Experiments have been done for many more years than humans can count on the two hands in which they possess. Two experiments, in particular, were written, “The Stanford Prison Experiment” by Philip G. Zimbardo and “The Perils of Obedience” by Stanley Milgram. These experiments can be controversial for many different reasons, but neither of these experiments were completed under conditions of normality. The information collected in these experiments isn’t exactly based off of real life situations, it becomes difficult not to question the relevance of these experiments.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fake prisoners and fake guards in a spurious jail is a peculiar way to determine roles in society. Philip G. Zimbardo was the mastermind of the Stanford Prison Experiment, which was a psychological experiment that determined the roles of members in a society that became a fiasco (“Philip G. Zimbardo” 1). The experiment left emotional and mental scars on mock-prisoner lives. The Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE) illustrates the way a person changes when a label and power is all of a sudden given to hoax guards in order to control fraud prisoners.…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Throughout history, execrable acts of corrupt human behavior have stunned mankind. While one might not see themselves capable of committing acts of torture towards others, and possibly killing another human being, experiments and real historical events have proven that there is a gruesome side within human beings expressed when placed in a position of power or control. Those who are not in that position expect those who are to act with a moral conscience, but it is easier said than done. The Abu Ghraib scandal and Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison experiment demonstrate the powerful role that a situation can play in altering human behavior.…

    • 3039 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Yale psychologist Stanley Milgram created an experiment that attempts to prove that evil can exist in what we would consider "normal" people. Milgram, wanted to see the extreme measures one would go to when a higher power of authority delivered an order. Milgram simulated an electric chair which an actor was told to pretend to act out in pain when a student was told to deliver current in to the chair. The experiment was for the student to shock the actor in the chair every time the actor gave out an incorrect answer. The outcome of two out of three students had obeyed the orders of Milgram to deliver shocks that would have enough volts to kill a grown man.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within the borders of Iraq, KBR’s agents are generally free of the bounding of any laws form both our country and theirs and are using that very fact tp their own benefit. But the truths of their immoral actions are being revealed and should be stopped. Dawn Leamon, who worked for a branch of KBR and had told her excruciating story to The Nation a week before, told them “With my back to the packed room and my voice (mostly) steady—I was being sodomized and forced to have oral sex with a KBR colleague and a Special Forces soldier two months earlier”. When she reported the incident to her KBR supervisors, instead of receiving justice and help, she hit a series of obstacles. She was told to stay quiet about it or they’d tied to make it seem as if she’d brought it on herself or even lied about it.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays