Preview

Stereotypes Of A Jury Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
955 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Stereotypes Of A Jury Essay
The foremost goal of every legal system is justice. This holds especially true in America as every precaution is taken to make sure each person accused of a crime receives the fairest trial possible. There is extensive screening before every jury is produced to make sure that there is no potential bias in any of the members that would hinder the objectivity and integrity of the case. Additionally, judges are intensely trained and sworn to carry out justice as impartially as possible. With that being said, time and time again juries and judges are frequently dispensing differing prison lengths for the same crime. While judges and juries may try to be as fair as they can, there are sometimes certain factors that can have an effect on their decision …show more content…
Beautiful or very attractive, attractive, about average, unattractive, and ugly or unattractive. (Mocan and Tekin, 2010). In society today, the benefits of being physically attractive or beautiful are countless. Beauty is an active stereotype not just in today’s society, but since the beginning of time that cannot be ignored. Beauty is naturally associated with all things good (Papenbrook, 2013). Take cinema as an example. The actors casted to be the heroes in movies are typically attractive and beautiful while the actors casted to play the villains are typically the opposite and portrayed to be ugly and unattractive. This stereotype of beauty plays a huge effect in society on the day to day basis. When someone sees another person that they deem attractive or beautiful they see that person as desirable. As a result, they innately assume that the other characteristics of that person such as intelligence for example are also desirable and at a high level (Frevert and Walker, 2014). Essentially, even though attractiveness may have no role in the task at hand, it still subliminally plays a …show more content…
A study done by Naci Mocan and Erdal Tekin concluded that, “unattractive individuals are more likely to commit crimes and attractive individuals are less likely to commit crimes in comparison to average-looking individuals” (Mocan and Tekin, 2010). Fundamentally, what this indicates is that being beautiful or very attractive decreases a person’s chance of committing crimes, such as robbery, burglary or selling drugs. While the opposite proved true for people deemed unattractive or ugly. This study expounded upon the socioeconomic factors behind attractiveness to explain this phenomenon. Attractive individuals, it states, have better communication skills than unattractive individuals. These enhanced communication skills, says Mobius and Rosenblatt, stem from preferential treatment from their teachers in school as children. These enhanced communication skills correlate directly with higher wages making attractive people more likely to stay out of trouble. The ramifications of this is that unattractive people tend to be less successful than attractive people and more likely to commit crimes as a result (Mobius and Rosenblatt, 2006). Consequently, the judge or jury may see potential in this physically attractive person to bounce back from this incident and be successful giving them even further reason to grant leniency (Sigall and Ostrove,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Summary: Mock Juries

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The characteristics of the defendant have also been shown to influence judges and juries, which include physical attractiveness and ethnicity. People hold stereotypes that criminals have a certain type of facial appearance, which is believed to be unattractive. Attractive people are likely to be thought of as happy, intelligent and truthful individuals not capable of being criminals. Evidence comes from Saladin et al who conducted an experiment and found that unattractive men were considered more likely to commit crimes such as murder and armed robbery than attractive men. Futhur, Downs and Lyons investigated 1500 real defendants and found attractiveness and amount of fine to be negatively correlated, so perhaps looks do play a part in the sentencing and verdict. This study has quite a large sample of defendants so improving the reliability of the findings of attractiveness. However, it is also a correlational study so it only shows a relationship between attractiveness and influence on juries and does not establish cause and effect. Even though many studies provide evidence that physical attractiveness can reduce sentencing, it has been found that if a criminal is perceived as using their attractiveness in the crime for their own gain e.g. Fraud, jurors would penalise them for…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Generally, the America public doesn't know what factors go into a judge’s decision when sentencing offenders. Keep in mind, judges have life experiences before becoming a judge such as how they were raised as an individual. Furthermore, they could have had experience with a particular crime, either a family member or someone close to them and personal feeling toward the offender. Yet, judges still have human tendencies but have to abide by some guidelines to determine their sentencing.…

    • 170 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Decision Making of Juries

    • 4552 Words
    • 19 Pages

    It does seem to be the case that attractive people are less likely to be considered guilty of crime and that they are often also judged to be more intelligent, confident, happy and truthful than their less attractive counterparts.…

    • 4552 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Voters Persuasion Analysis

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Although beauty often has no logical connection to the trustworthiness of a candidate’s campaign, attractive communicators are usually more likely to promote attitude change through the superficial route of persuasion. Generally, people like and trust physically attractive people, making them more likely to endorse the attitudes they communicate. This is especially true for people whom the candidate’s message is not important and who have little knowledge of the message’s domain. Furthermore, research has shown that people of cross-cultural differences are attracted to similar physical characteristics and features, which is an important factor to be aware of in America given the population’s wide range of diverse racial and ethnic groups. According to the work of Cunningham, Roberts, Barbee, Druen, Wu (1995), people tend to be specifically attracted to female features that are neonate, sexually mature, expressive, and well-groomed. The combination of neonate and sexually mature features suggest desirable qualities of youthfulness, vivaciousness, post-pubescent status, and competency while expressive and grooming features, such as smiling often and shiny, well-kept hair, suggest happiness and group membership status, respectively. Their studies show that Hispanics, Whites, Asians, and Blacks perceive these features, including lighter skin tones, as…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Jefferson describes the jury as “the only anchor ever yet imagined by man, by which a government can be held to the principles of its constitution.”( Dialogue on the American Jury: We The People in Action, 1) The purpose of juries is to ensure that no government is able to convict innocent people, or to give unreasonably cruel punishment. Although the juries we see today are very different from the first juries, they have always served the same purpose, to keep things fair for citizens.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Everyday attractiveness is measured on an unconscious level depending on an individual’s surroundings. By developing an experiment to test this theory using student-teacher preferences based on looks, it is possible to better understand how perceived attractiveness is used in everyday lives. When given a choice between professors, a student should give priority to a professor’s teaching methods and credentials over attractiveness. However, the constant exposure to the repetitive school environment has created a dull, everyday cycle. The only aspect in a student’s academic environment which continuously changes is the professors. Due to this continuous cycle, perhaps, students have unconsciously decided to focus more readily in a classroom when an attractive professor is teaching the class rather than an unattractive professor. Therefore, in theory, if a student is presented with a stimulus, such as a picture, it is more likely that the attractive professor will be chosen.…

    • 2166 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Other researchers have demonstrated that both men and women assume that attractive people are more sensitive, kind, and sexually responsive than unattractive people. And they were thought to lead more exciting lives and have more prestigious careers. “This is a stereotype that’s held by virtually everyone-men and women, young…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, Judges have sole discretion in finding a defendant guilty or not guilty. They also maintain the discretion other what charges are able to stick to the defendant at the preliminary hearing level. There has been cases where the Judge felt that certain charges weren’t applicable to a certain defendant and the Judge dismissed the charges. Though the prosecution is able to object to the decision that the Judge made, the Judge’s ruling still stands. Along with this, Judges have full discretion over a defendant’s sentence except for those cases where there are established mandatory minimums. Some cases that have mandatory minimums are drug cases, rape cases and gun cases. Other than mandatory minimum cases, Judges exercise the right to impose sentencing based on the defendant’s prior criminal history, the likelihood of the defendant to benefit from diversionary programs and the recommendation of the prosecution and defense attorneys. There has been cases where the prosecution disagreed with a sentence that the Judge gave but he felt that he made the right decision for the defendant and the…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Sidney Katz’s summary of “The Importance of being Beautiful”, she suggests that more attractive people can advance faster and easier in life than their less appealing peers. Katz explains her theory with different examples. One example is person perception, which is a branch of psychology that examines many ways in which physical attractiveness, or lack of it, affects all aspects of life. This helps explain the halo and horns effect. The halo effect is perceived as being beautiful, more generous, trustworthy, sociable, modest, and interesting. Whereas the horns effect people are perceived to be physically unattractive, there for they are mean, sneaky and dishonest. Katz also talks about how being physically attractive can help advance your career. If a man is six feet or taller, he will succeed in his career. If women are glamorous, they get higher pay and promotions. She also explains how old age and beauty has its advantages. Katz’s theory explains at nursing homes and hospitals doctors and nurses give better care to the beautiful. The doctors and nurses feel that beautiful patients are more likely to respond to treatment. Everyone judges people on either their looks or simply by what they wear. It is human nature for people to do this. The world shouldn’t be like this but unfortunately it is. Hopefully one day the human population can change the way people perceive one another.…

    • 1404 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Module 5 Notes

    • 1811 Words
    • 8 Pages

    a predisposition to attribute positive qualities to physically attractive people; if we are dressed good, people will think we are good…

    • 1811 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jury Nullification Essay

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages

    unless the existence of strong guarantee for present of impartial duties, that illustrate possibility of facts that is appropriate decision for society. For example, in the case of Latimer the juries found the latimer guilty and they recommend one year of imprisonment. The trial did not become unfair because the trial judge undermined the jury’s foundation of the case…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should pretty or ugly decide good or bad? Unfortunately, more times than not, one’s judgment on the appearance of others can greatly influence or even completely determine his initial treatment of the individual. Recent studies have proved “that physically attractive individuals are thought to possess more sociably desirable personalities and higher moral standards than those who are physically unattractive” (Kong, Yan, Hong). This very common phenomenon would not raise issues if everyone was able to choose their physical features. Considering that in reality, physical traits are given by parents and completely out of the hands of the receiver, a standard of beauty seems irrational; although, the beauty ideologies of many nations is characterized by certain features. The negative effects and positive privileges associated with certain appearances unjustly impacts the lives of the public and remains a controversial conflict in society.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If the public believes a defendant is guilty of murder, for example, and should not be shown any sympathy, the judge is more likely to find the defendant guilty and impose a life sentence or even the death penalty. Another factor that influences decision-making is the judge’s demographic characteristics, such as race and sex. Some studies conclude that…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Sidney Katz’s summary of “The Importance of being Beautiful”, she suggests that more attractive people can advance faster and easier in life than their less appealing peers. Katz explains her theory with different examples. One example is person perception, which is a branch of psychology that examines many ways in which physical attractiveness, or lack of it, affects all aspects of life. This helps explain the halo and horns effect. The halo effect is perceived as being beautiful, more generous, trustworthy, sociable, modest, and interesting. Whereas the horns effect people are perceived to be physically unattractive, there for they are mean, sneaky and dishonest. Katz also talks about how being physically attractive can help advance your career. If a man is six feet or taller, he will succeed in his career. If women are glamorous, they get higher pay and promotions. She also explains how old age and beauty has its advantages. Katz’s theory explains at nursing homes and hospitals doctors and nurses give better care to the beautiful. The doctors and nurses feel that beautiful patients are more likely to respond to treatment. Everyone judges people on either their looks or simply by what they wear. It is human nature for people to do this. The world shouldn’t be like this but unfortunately it is. Hopefully one day the human population can change the way people perceive one another.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Debevec, K., Madden, T. J., & Kernan, J. B. (1986). Physical attractiveness, message evaluation, and compliance: A structural evaluation. Psychological Reports, 58, 503–508.…

    • 2207 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics