Preview

Summary Of Gee's Misinterpretation Of Literacy

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
252 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Summary Of Gee's Misinterpretation Of Literacy
Is there a misinterpretation of literacy? In Gees chapter the literacy myth and history of literacy he describes that the literacy myth is that being literate makes one smarter, more modern, and civilized. Being able to read and write are the only things that make people smart. In this chapter, Gee explains that being “smart” or literate does not add up to one’s personal value by explaining the differences and similarities between power and literacy, he gives examples of people who are illiterate but very intelligent, and giving us statistics, research and evidence.
Gee tells us he believes that someones value is not at all defined by how well they read or write. “Plato believed that his writings should by and large be restricted to his own


You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Gary Earl Ross's article "Choosing not to read is choosing to be stupid" discusses the debatable topic that the nation is becoming less intelligent due to the decrease of people reading novels, poems and plays. As a University at Buffalo Professor Ross argues that he sees first hand "Slowly but inexorably we, as a nation, are getting dumber." I agree that the nation as a whole is becoming dumber, however it was not the article that persuaded me of this is was my former outside knowledge of this topic. Although I agree with the topic that the nation is becoming dumber I do not support the article because not only is it very harsh, but it also very biased towards his own feelings.…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In “What Is Literacy,” James Paul Gee talks about the definition and the meaning of literacy. While doing so, he uses different keywords to describe literacy as "discourse" and an identity kit. He goes into depth about the characteristics of discourse and giving examples of what they relate to( “discourses are inherently ideological, “discourse-defined positions” function as standpoints, each discourse values certain view points and marginalizes others, discourses are very much integrated in the power structure of society (52-53). While discussing the examples of discourse, Gee then goes to discuss what the cause of the conflicting discourses. He goes on to talk about how we, as individuals are the cause of conflicting discourses.…

    • 249 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    James Paul Gee Literacy

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Page

    In his essay “What is Literacy?” author and linguist James Paul Gee informs us of his definition of literacy by breaking it down for us and giving us examples that we personally encounter on a day to day basis. Gee tries to gives us a better understanding of the way that we as people behave when it comes to talking and interacting with different people.…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Dan Gioia’s essay “Why Literature Matters” he exposes the dangerous connection between America’s lacking literacy rates and decreasing job performance, creativity and understanding of political and societal issues. Gioia exhibits concern for the impact decreasing literacy skills will have on the business world. He argues that even employers “complained that local schools inadequately taught reading comprehension.” This solidifies Gioia’s concern to the reader,as the reader now knows that the businesses directly impacted by lacking literacy also see and recognize the issue Gioia also sets forth an argument for democracy and intelligent political discourse. He worries that due to decreased literacy, the population suffers a lack…

    • 163 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In recent weeks all of us have been introduced to the essay “What is Literacy” written by Linguist James Paul Gee in 1987. Within this document Gee employs his learned skills to provide a “useful” definition for the word literacy. Prior to providing us this insight however, Gee must provide definitions for various other words and ideas as well as numerous theories in an effort to support his final supposition. Words such as discourse and sub-discourse are introduced by Gee who then goes on to characterize them in great detail, going so far as to provide five basic rules and/or guidelines for these discourses. Gee next bestows us with a theory in reference to how individuals obtain knowledge according to cited authors…

    • 1761 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Knoblauch Summary

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages

    It’s Knoblauch’s goal in his essay to show that there isn’t only one definition of literacy. His theory is that there are 4 senses of literacy and he not only defines them, but explains in detail what language is implied by each sense and how the group defining them use these different ways of literacy in everyday life. Knoblauch’s point is that there is no wrong or right way to view literacy but that is more than one way. The groups defining the 4 types are based on their belief system and what they value. The first sense is functional literacy. I would say this is the way most Americans view literacy. It’s basically being able to read and write at a level that makes a person capable to live fine in a society where writing is a big deal. If you have functional literacy, it’s easy to fill out job applications and to participate in activities where you are given writing instructions. It’s basically the low man on the totem pole. People with this literacy have little power in both social and economic groups; you probably wont see someone with only this literacy as a CEO or business owner. The second definition of a literacy being used today is Cultural literacy. This group is more advanced than the functional literacy group because they can not only read and write at a level high enough to survive, they read high culture literature and other types of writing that will help preserve their cultural beliefs and values. They have a more proper language. The next form of literacy would be the personal growth literacy. It’s to my understanding that their type of writing helps them find themselves. It exercises their imaginations and expresses their feelings. Poems may be a popular type of writing; songwriting maybe. And the last is critical literacy, critical meaning its of the most importance to sound smart and know what your talking about because it’s almost as if it’s a means of power, which makes sense. It isn’t often that you see a CEO or owner of a company using…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    James Gee (19--) challenged the reading profession to think more broadly about reading instruction when he wrote, “’Literacy’ is the mastery or fluent control over a secondary Discourse” (p. 9). As social beings, people belong to a variety of Discourse groups, groups that have very specific identities and “ways of being in the world” (Gee, 19--, p. 6). Our primary Discourse group is that of our home. As our world expands, so do our Discourse groups.…

    • 2148 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    They said about literacy that literacy is one of the engines to get money or profit, and to compete advantages. In addition, people’s literacy skills have less growing in their economy values because of changing in the literacy standers with every new generation of learners.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Literacy Literacy, as we all know is the ability that we have to read and write that includes the capacity that we have to use and learn a language as well as any other things like understanding how to communicate. It is also the most important structure that our parents teach us, without it we would not be able to communicate with each other, we would not be able to learn new skills, such as learning how to use a computer, how to use internet, how to speak properly, without it the world would not be what it is right now, without it we would not be able to achieve our goals. Literacy can be found in newspaper, in books, in articles, in the internet, in the way we socialize with each other, it can be found almost everywhere because is something…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    CIEP 206 Final Reflection

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages

    CIEP 206 Final Reflection: The Role of Literacy in Learning Amparo Vélez Echavarría Loyola University Chicago Looking back onto my life, I always think about the time that I spent in elementary school. I remember feeling my heart clench as I watched everyone reading with ease while I would hide in the play area. I did not think that I was not good at school after I was diagnosed with dyslexia and ADHD. Every recess my classmates excluded me when I asked to play with them. I heard them laugh at me while they walked away screaming “what a dumb weirdo!”…

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A few weeks ago, I was walking downtown, when this random came up to me and said “You in school? That’s good, that’s good. Education is important.” From the state of her hair and clothes, and the smell of her breath, I assumed she was homeless. I didn’t really pay much attention to her, because homeless people are so common in downtown Atlanta. I was just hoping that she wasn’t going to ask me for any money! After a while, I started thinking about what the homeless woman had said; “Education is important.” Growing up, I had always been taught that people who lived in the streets had been afforded the same opportunities as I had, but they had simply chosen to ignore them. So, if this woman had basically thrown away her life, why was she here preaching to me that education was important? How far had she gotten with her education? Was she like my great-grandmother, and lacked the skills to read and write? Literacy isn’t something that I spend a lot of time thinking about, mainly because all of the people that I surround myself and the people they surround themselves with are all capable of reading at proficient levels. Of course, I was always aware that some people had disabilities that made it harder to read, like dyslexia, but it never occurred to me that some of them allowed for the hindrance to completely turn them off to reading. Is it possible that I have been taking my literacy skills for granted? In this paper, I plan to explore literacy in America, and how it compares to the value other nations put on literacy and even our own country before public schools were instituted.…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Literacy is the ability to read and write and allows people to become influential speakers and powerful leaders. Strictly defined, literacy is the quality or state of being literate, having possession of education, and a person's knowledge of a particular subject or field. Literacy is not having or involving ignorance; it is having knowledge or competence. The term literacy is derived from the Middle English and Latin term literate meaning marked with letters. In the story Malcom X Literacy Behind Bars, Malcom X defines how literacy changed his life by introducing new things such as, oral communication, freedom, and helped to become an independent spokesman.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Helping students to learn what society finds to be the most acceptable form of English – Standard English – is a challenge for every teacher. Particularly when the teacher in question doesn’t want to wipe out the student’s home language or make the student resent the teacher for attempting to wipe out their home language. As Gee said, our language or discourse is a part of our identity kit; it is thread in the fabric that composes us as individuals. What Baker referred to as ‘home language’ is the same as our primary discourse – the language we learn through acquisition that is a direct result of who we are and shapes who we become. Needless to say, I agree with Baker in her desire to educate her students without telling them that their home language is wrong. And ultimately, who’s to say it is? Different is not mutually attached to incorrectness; it just is not the same, but as Christianson says “the ‘melting pot’ was an illusion. The real version of the melting pot is that people of diverse backgrounds are mixed together and when they come out they’re supposed to look like Vanna White and sound like Dan Rather. The only diversity we celebrate is tacos and chop suey at the mall.”…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Literacies for Learning

    • 2600 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Gee, J. (1991) What is literacy? In C.Mitchell & K. Weiler (Eds.), Rewriting literacy. New York: Bergin & Garvey…

    • 2600 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    In our society today, literacy is no longer defined as being able to read and write very little just to get by, but it is being able to read, write, and comprehend the information presented to you which you can use in order to be a functional and efficient member of society. Even in one of the wealthiest, most technologically advanced countries in the world, literacy is still a matter of concern in modern day America. It is alarming to know that 1 in 4 children in America grow up without learning how to read and approximately 35 million adults read below the level needed to function in society, many of whom cannot read at all (Kozol 248, "11 Facts About Literacy in America."). How is this even possible? What problems can undereducation and illiteracy bring? Who does this issue really affect?…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays