Preview

Tertullian's Arguments Against Hermogenes

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
840 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Tertullian's Arguments Against Hermogenes
In this passage, Tertullian argues against Hermogenes’ argument that God created the world out of the preexisting matter rather than out of nothing. Hermogenes supports his argument by stating that since “God has always been God, and always Lord”, there had to be something to be the lord over, which is according to him the preexisting matter. On the other hand, Tertullian makes a strict distinction between the terms God and Lord: “God is the title of the substance, the divine nature: Lord the title of power.” Tertullian goes on to explain that God has always been God, but he has become Lord only after the creation “just like he could not be father before he had a son; nor a judge before sin was committed.” Felker-Jones agrees with Tertullian …show more content…
Just like Felker-Jones states, that belief makes it clear that without God nothing exists or has ever existed. Since this belief is supported by the Scripture, especially the books of Genesis and Revelation, I believe that its authenticity is unquestionable.
In my discipline, psychology, refuting “creation out of nothing”, which is confirmed by the Scripture and Christian tradition, would be the same as claiming that a patient does not have schizophrenia even though he/she is experiencing all the symptoms of the disorder listed in the DSM-V.

3.14 – Augustine on the Relation of God and Evil – Patristic
In this passage, Augustine argues against dualism. He explains that the evil represents turning away from God rather than a separate deity or God’s anger. God is good and “all good is from God.” On the other hand, a sin is “a defective movement” and “that defective movement is voluntary.” Therefore, a sin does not come from God or some evil deity; it is a result of our free will and turning away from God. Similarly, Felker-Jones states that since God is good, it is impossible for Him “to be mean or grudging about

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Augustine rejected that notion of dualism because he believed that to be good, you have to have substance and make up a being. The idea of absence is equal to evil. This did not exactly agree with Manichean idea of dualism.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the history of western philosophy, men have been attempting to understand the complexities of the human soul. In Confessions, Augustine depicts the well-ordered soul in terms of conversion to Roman Catholic Christianity. For Augustine, the will plays a major role in this process. He repeatedly states that he was taken out of his sinfulness once he decided to align his will with God’s will (Augustine bk. 8, ch. 10, sec. 22; bk. 11, ch. 1, sec. 1). Augustine divides sin into three categories: lust of the flesh, pride of life, and lust of the eyes (bk. 3, ch. 8, sec. 16). He argues that these three sins all exhibit a disagreement between God’s will and his own. In his biography, Augustine reveals that he experiences all forms of these…

    • 1792 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Augustine – Augustine in his book ‘confessions,’ recognise this problem: “Either God is not able to abolish evil or not willing; if he is not able then he is not all powerful he is not willing then he is not all…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The nature of sin awaits in the materials that we strive to achieve for each and every day. Those materials in which entertain us, interests us, and define us eat away at the relationship we have with our Lord. According to Augustine, God is the the path towards all success that brings pleasure to the human soul- the Lord brings joy to those who choose to work in the light of…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This article, written by J. Patout Burns, outlines the development of Augustine’s views on Evil, specifically in connection to God. To begin, the author gives a summary of Augustine’s original thoughts on God and evil, which followed the Manichean principles of binary or dualistic thinking. However, in exchanging ideas with philosopher Plotinus, Augustine’s views shifted to accept a different take on God with a more Platonic perspective. The author also outlines Augustine’s ideas in regard to material and immaterial beings, as well as whether evil may be contained in either. The issue of sins, how they are accomplished and their effects, is discussed too, and the author particularly focuses on Augustine’s writings (On Free Will, Confessions, and other works).…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This dialectic form of writing is reminiscent of Plato’s Meno, where Meno asks Socrates the nature of virtue and they have a cooperative exercise in the inquiry of virtue. Dialectic form seems to be a trend in displaying the two parts of the Socratic Method. The beginning of the text has traces of the ‘developing of the logos’ stage with the initial question of if God is the cause of evil proposed by Evodius (Book One-1). Augustine then asks Evodius to define evil, in the same vain that Socrates asked Meno to define what he means by virtue. A logos of what evil is must be defined even before they try to understand God’s part in it.…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Centered around a conversation between Augustine and his friend Evodius in during the reign of the Roman Empire, “On the Free Choice of the Will” is a philosophical discussion over God and evil with focus onto how evil is defined as well as how humanity's freedom to make choices gives birth to malice. Augustine claims that God cannot be the cause of evil, an all powerful omnipotent and benevolent creator cannot create what is to be defined as evil. He supports his claim by examining how evil is defined and the role that human choice plays in sin and how necessity of free will for the creation of wickedness such that there may be contrast to good. To begin the text he is asked as to the definition of evil, “we use the word ‘evil’ in two senses:…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Augustine’s “On the Free Choice of the Will”, depicts a dialogue between Evodius (the interlocutor) and Augustine himself. In this dialogue, Evodius and Augustine delve into an argument regarding the author or source of evil in the world. Initially Evodius questions Augustine if God is the author of evil and Augustine’s standpoint on this statement is based from a theoretical and existential angle: Evil doesn’t exist because it’s simply the privation or lack of good. Augustine points out that God gave us free will and if we think that God is good then is blasphemous to think that he is the author of evil, given that God punishes evildoers and rewards the good.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Augustine's Limitations

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What I know is evil force people’s mind to do the wrong works. In Islam, the evil is referred to a creature Iblis who was made by God. God gave him power, but he denied to show respect to another creature made by God whose name was Adam. Ibis challenged God that he was superior to everything, but he proved himself to be wrong. Then he became angry with God and became the evil and started to manipulate people’s mind who believe in God. However, from the explanation of the chapter what I found that Augustine sought to resolve the problem of evil by describing evil as a privation of the good. So, we cannot deny that evil exists. Augustine saw the problem of evil as twofold. Natural evil and moral evil. Natural evil is physical things in the created order seem to suffer from defects and limitations and moral evil is when human freely choose to do the wrong thing. Augustine also argues that humanity's capacity to exercise freedom, to freely sin in their fallen condition. However, in Socratic response to the problem, evil is a result of rationally but mistakenly opting for the lesser good or that which is inherently evil. They both believed there are two forces at work in the Universe, namely, the forces of Goodness and of Evil. They explained evil by recourse to the perpetual battle or conflict between the two forces occurring in the cosmos. So, explaining the problem of evil, it depends on what people…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    St. Augustine Free Will

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Free will, in general, is the ability that is not controlled by God or fate. Therefore individuals get to choose how to act and free will is a gift of God. Augustine believed human have the ability to resist temptation and sin in his early years. However, in conclusion, St. Augustine argued that all men were created with freedom to make choices “in perfect image of God” and convey God has no responsibility of evil. St. Augustine believed that humans “abuse” their free will, and the consequences of free will is evil. Accordingly, St. Augustine insisted that free will is not an ideal concept, because starting from Adam and Eve, evil and sin is caused by humans. However, he also realized that people cannot live in properly without free will, and believed that was the reason why God allowed freedom. St. Augustin had a belief that all mankind cannot obey the rules bty their morals because they are so…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Augustine and the Problem of Evil Introduction When St. Augustine wrote Enchiridion, The City of God, and On the Free Choice of the Will he certainly had various reasons in mind and multiple arguments he was seeking to prove. One common thread throughout is the problem of reconciling the existence of evil in a world in which God exists as well. This is the problem of evil. I will show that Augustine attempts to solve the problem by denying that evil exists as such and by saying that what we think of as evil is caused by human free will, which is a good more valuable than a world without evil. I will show that his argument that evil does not exist as such is unconvincing because there is still human suffering, and that his argument that…

    • 2115 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    In order to make sense of St. Augustine’s definition of evil as the absence of good, it is helpful to know how he came up with it. It is true that St. Augustine was a Manichean before he became a Christian. Manichaeism, a Persian Dualist religion, is the belief in both a good and an evil god. According to Manichaeism, the kingdom of light and the kingdom of darkness are engaged in an eternal war against each other. In the process of his conversion, St. Augustine approached Christianity from the perspective of a Manichean. He challenged the existence of the Manichean god of evil, and came up with the conclusion that only a good god exists. This is how St. Augustine came to question the presence of evil. He realized that the Christian teachings about a good god who creates only good things and the existence of evil contradict each other.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Augustine's Decisions

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It was Adam and Eve’s “prideful fascination with the thought that they would became like God” that causes sin to enter the world and infects humanity with a concupiscence for self-indulgent pleasures. But we must not give up because of despair, we now understand that we were created in a supreme act of love and we were created for the purpose of eternal communion with God, the saints, and angels in the common state of divine love, which will bring us complete happiness in eternal life. Augustine is not a stranger to the self-love, self-indulgence, pride, and slavery to all finite things.…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Augustine first tried to offer the idea that evil is the result of an alternative force that exists outside of God's Creation, and which serves as a nemesis to God. Very quickly Augustine discovered the problem with this solution; Christianity states that God is the sole Creator of the world and everything that exists in and outside of it. Obviously this does offer a little bit of a problem in itself, so Augustine moves on to attempt another observation. Augustine then attempts to claim - with the help of Platonic theory - that evil is not real and therefore was not created by God. I completely disagree with this statement; if God had no intention of evil appearing in his Creation, no bad would exist and there would be no reason to doubt God's existence. The problem to me in this solution is that if we had no reason to doubt the presence of God, to in effect see and more importantly feel Him through the basically ugly nature of this world and have faith in Him, then there would be no reason in our existence here. Simply put, everyone has their problems - to me this is the directly influenced effect of evil - and everyone experiences…

    • 1701 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    augustine reflection

    • 573 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Faith itself involves on reflections of events and people in one’s life. During his confessions, Augustine questions and seeks God. At the same time he reflects on the influence of events and people that propelled him to his faith. His mother had a firm belief to raise him as a Catholic. So he was sent to school, but school corrupted him by training him to devote to materialistic pursuits. Not much happened in his adolescent years. Augustine reminiscences the time he wanted to steal pears. He did not steal the pears out of hunger but as an attempt to defy God. Sin is an act of betrayal of God’s love for humans.…

    • 573 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays