Preview

The Cider House Rules

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1426 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Cider House Rules
TITLE (supplied by the customer): "The Cider House Rules"
DESCRIPTION (supplied by the customer): The Doctor offers 2 incongruous services ... how can these services coexist? Answer the following questions: What is the moral dilemma posed in the story? A Birth occurs in the story ... how does this affect the main character's view? What happens to change the main characters view? What are the Cider House Rules and what are they a metaphor for? Who broke the Cider House Rules? What is the moral of the story? What does it mean to be the hero of your own life? What other issues arise in this story that are relevant to the reproductive and overall health?
PROJECT DEVELOPED:
The Cider House, an orphanage hospital at St. Cloud's, is one of the two poles or hemispheres the entire plot builds upon. The story poses quite a bit of a challenge to the unsophisticated onlooker's mindset trained primarily to distinguish between, and judge, the clear black and the clear white. Dr. Larch, one of the central protagonists, is a far more complex profile. It's not so much about his personality or character as it is about his moral stance. As a licensed physician, he assists at childbirth. The outside world formally knows him as helping a new life happen. The other side of the man is his second practice amounting to exactly the opposite: abortions, or life taking. He takes life away from infant and totally helpless human beings having little say in their parents decision not to grant them life. It might just be uncomfortable and awkward for these young mothers, pressed by their ambitious husbands, to grant life at this particular point. They are not prepared nor willing to pay that price for their right to have a fulfilling sexual life outside the bonds of marriage. However, the story is less moralizing than that. The author does not seem disposed to judge the heroes very strictly, because another part of the story is that these are for the most part inexperienced young men and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “As a surgeon you have to have a controlled arrogance. If its uncontrolled, you kill people..” In “The Case of Lady Sannox” Lord Sannox is angered with his wife’s, Lady Sannox, infidelities. When he learns of the Lady’s latest affair with Douglas Stone, a skilled surgeon, he hatches a revenge plan. His plan could potentially ruin the lives of everyone involved. In “The Case of Lady Sannox” both arrogance and regret are emotions that drive the action of the story.…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Victoria’s comment on autonomy was helpful in seeing the importance of the role of the doctor. Victoria clarified that the doctor made the right ethical decision because the patient had a clear understanding of the negative impact of not telling her husband Paul or reporting the crime. Thus, Barbara had the mental capacity at the time to make a decision. Furthermore, Victoria gave insight on how individuals in the story had the right to autonomy, however, the doctor needed to respect Barbara’s decision because of the relationship between the physician and patient. This is important because it demonstrates the duty the doctor had to their patient.…

    • 184 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    First, Do No Harm

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Patrick Dismuke was a young African American boy, at the age of fifteen when the story starts, and a regular patient at Hermann Hospital. Patrick was born with a severe case of Hirschsprung’s disease, a disorder of the digestive tract, and was unable to digest his food. Throughout Patrick’s life, he spent more days in the hospital than out and came to be quite comfortable with the environment and staff at Hermann. Due to his disease his only way of nutrition was through a feeding tube, unfortunately these tubes often got infected. Since Patrick’s immune system was also weak, the infections were almost as bad as the disease itself. The doctors were forced to put the boy through surgery multiple times to replace infected tubes, each time making him weaker and bringing him closer to death. Once the he became too weak for the surgeries, the doctors were faced with a dilemma- to do surgery or not? The surgery to place a new tube directly into his heart would be risky and potentially kill him, but if the surgery did not occur, the infection would slowly destroy his body and block the tube causing him to starve to death. Before any decisions could be made, the doctors needed to consult the patients mother, Oria Dismuke, was a single mother who worked extensive hours at whatever jobs she could find sometimes working as many as three at a time. Oria was a quiet and didn’t have much to say about her opinion, it’s not that she didn’t care; she was just exhausted and wanted her son to be both happy and comfortable. Along with the mother, the doctors also had to meet with a hospital ethics committee before taking action. The committee met many times throughout the book and made many contradictory decisions depending on his progress at the time of the meeting. First, the committee decides to make Patrick DNR but he began to get better, so after consulting him, they ended up doing another risky surgery. The committee seemed…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    3. Describe potential conflicts or dilemmas that may arise between the duty of care and an individual’s rights.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pember's Case Summary

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Page

    Pember faced many problems as her time as a nurse in a soldier’s hospital. They range from liquor to visitors and from rats to shortages. The problems that Pember faced towards the liquor aspect of the job numerous. One problem was that the monthly barrel of liquor that she could draw from was under the guardianship of the apothecary and his clerk. Quarts and pints were issued through any order coming from the surgeons and their substitutes, because of that, the contents of the barrel would be long gone before she was entitled to draw more. That problem led to the suffering of her patients because that were in want of the liquor (Pember, 10-11). The way that Pember solved this problem was that she consulted the hospital bill that was…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One big thing that Dr. Larch was doing that was illigal at this time was abortion. Holmer did not like the fact that Dr. Larch was doing…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Apple Cider Rough Draft

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Apple cider has been around for many years. Even though apple cider can be purchased in the local grocery stores, it’s best to make apple cider homemade. Why? Because the store bought apple cider cannot compare to the taste of fresh homemade apple cider. Drinking apple cider can have many benefits since apples are good for lowering cholesterol and improving lung health. Therefore, having fresh and homemade cider can be very healthy and inexpensive.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Seeking a safe and legal abortion in Canada has been an ongoing journey that has taken over one hundred years to trek. Abortion is defined by major medical dictionaries as the “termination of a pregnancy or premature expulsion of the products of conception by any means, usually before fetal viability.” Termination of a pregnancy can be spontaneous, often referred to as a miscarriage or it can be deliberately induced. This essay will focus on the deliberate termination of a pregnancy. In addition, this essay will outline the history of abortion in Canada, including varying access of care across the country, the barriers and challenges pregnant women face when seeking abortion services, social stigma attached to abortions and finally the physical and psychological effects an abortion has on men and women. This paper will attempt to lay a foundation for the basic understanding of the complexity surrounding abortion services.…

    • 3794 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most common ethical dilemmas arises in the balancing of beneficence and non-maleficence. This balance is the one between the benefits and risks of treatment and plays a role in nearly every medical decision such as whether to order a particular test,…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Call the Midwife” is a BBC television series that focuses on the lives of midwives and nuns living and working in the poverty-stricken area of London in the 1950’s and 1960’s. Episodes focus on all kinds of issues, ranging from interracial relationships to birth defects and poverty. Season 2, episode 5 is centered around abortion. One of the nurses, Jenny, has a patient, Nora Harding, who realizes that she is pregnant with her ninth child. The family already struggles as it is, and Nora is distraught with the idea of trying to feed yet another child. When this episode is set, abortion is illegal in England, so Nora turns to other avenues to terminate the pregnancy. She tries many homemade tricks, such as taking Epsom Salts. Nora is not allowed to become sterilized, even though she fully consents to it, and cannot afford and does not have access to proper contraception. Jenny warns Nora that she is “more likely to hurt [herself] than the baby [she’s] carrying” by trying to perform a self-abortion. But, Nora tells her husband that “I’m gonna get rid of it if it kills me. Because if I can’t get rid of it, I’m gonna get rid of myself.” Eventually, she pays money that she can’t spare to an abortionist who ends up making her sicker by using unsterilized instruments. Nora suffers from blood loss and a perforated uterus, but her life is saved in the end. The midwives tell the doctors that Nora had a miscarriage, instead of letting on that she had an illegal abortion.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Medical Ethics Abortion

    • 3197 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Has a woman sole rights over what to do with her own body? Considerer this question in relation to abortion…

    • 3197 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Consultations in a general practice are commonly adorned with difficult decisions that require the doctor to balance competing moral values.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Health workers like nurses have the responsibility to provide health services to patients. By doing so, nurses are expected to contribute to the preservation of health, and thus save the lives of their patients. Health workers like nurses are tasked to save the lives of their patients, however, as lifestyles are rapidly changing, there are instances in which health workers have to deal with cases which involve life taking like abortion. In this regards, nurses could not avoid from entering the moral and ethical dilemma of this issue when the therapeutic value of nursing brings into question. Abortion violates the traditions and values that exist in nursing (Laabs, n.d.), whereby from the perspective of nurses, protecting…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leaving the past

    • 764 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Granny weatherall has lived a long life and was an amazing woman and being able to live up to the age of 80 and beating pneumonia at a very hard time to survive that sickness. which is why she is such an angry person with the doctor. “ i’ll call for you when i want you . . . . where were you forty years ago when i pulled through milk-leg and double pneumonia?”(7). She does not want to be seen by a doctor when she believes this will blow over like her past sickness to her the doctor is doing nothing but wasting her money. “i pay my own bills, and i don’t throw my money away on nonsense.”(7). She thinks that fighting this sickness like she did the last time but its different she has gotten old and her body has been fighting for so long. Granny Weatherall still is thinking that she will see tomorrow and is planning on doing so many things the next day to feel happy. She was going to tell her children about her past life and finally face her past and accept what had happened in her past life, but she still had it planned for tomorrow because she still was not ready for this.”Yes, that would be tomorrow’s business. no use to let them know how silly she had been once.”(17) Granny Weatherall is still scared to go back and re live her past by telling her children. This is what she had been avoiding and trying to replace and forget about instead of accepting what had happened and being happy to move on.…

    • 764 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This report will plan to address Kopparberg Cider issue of high price inflation and importing and exporting costs that is due to Brexit (Hull Daily Mail, 2017). Due to brexit Kopparberg Cider will be facing higher fee’s of importing their goods into the UK, which may result in Kopparberg increasing their prices of their products which can cause customers to look for alternatives and their competitors which will lead to their sales decreasing (Telegraph, 2017) (Express, 2017). Kopparberg will lose supply deals with companies in the UK, such as J.D. Wetherspoons and will cause their sales to decrease (Express, 2017) (ECHO, 2017). This will cause to Kopparberg also lose supplier power with companies in the UK. (Porter’s five…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays