Preview

The Consequences Of Fighting In Hockey

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
633 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Consequences Of Fighting In Hockey
There are lots of arguments for fighting in the game: It holds players accountable for their actions; protects star players; gives teams a momentary boost of momentum and purpose; attracts and excites fans and keeps the core audience happy; prevents more serious violence, thereby lessening the risk of serious injury.
The case against has always been the same: Fighting is a useless, vicious anachronism providing no benefit to anyone.
The challenge for new USHL commissioner Bob Fallen and all league heads is deciding on a course of action without knowing the consequences: is fighting part of hockey’s culture and integral to the fabric of the game or a sideshow that can be cast aside as an outdated relic?
The problem with making statements that
…show more content…
Most people might not even know who P.K. Subban is. Subban won the Norris trophy in 2013 (award for the NHL’s best defenseman), was tied for the leading scoring defenseman that same year, and was an Olympic gold-medalist in 2014. This year, he is considered one of the front-runners for the Norris trophy again. If that resume doesn’t earn you a spot on the cover of Sports Illustrated across the world, I don’t know what will.
Eighty-two games is a long season, more than five times as long as an NFL season. The sports have many similarities in physicality, and many people (including myself) believe that hockey is a more physical sport than football. Hockey players play back-to-back days most weeks, something that football players don’t do. That said, I absolutely think hockey and its athletes should have more coverage than they do now.
Chris Hagerman, a history professor at Albion College, has studied the role of popular images and how athletes are viewed in sports media. He offered to comment to the Pleiad about hockey’s perceived lack of popularity in the United

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Hockey Faceoff Book Report

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The Hockey East quarterfinals are underway this weekend, and two familiar faces re-ignite a rivalry as Boston University and UMass Lowell meet in the Hockey East playoffs again just one year removed from meeting in the Finals. The CHL’s regular season is winding down, and all three leagues are in action again, as two top 2016 draft-eligibles get another last chance to impress before the draft. Finally, Johnathan Drouin’s infamous story will have a new chapter written in Syracuse, as the Tampa Bay Lightning prospect is back in the AHL after an attempted trade request to finish off a stacked edition of Prospect Faceoff.…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Globe pressed the question “But if the sport became soccer on ice, would that really be so bad?” The answer is yes, it would be terrible, hockey is popular because of its rough, gritty demeanor. The Globe and Mail also debated “The streamlined, beautiful game exhibited at the Olympics every four years proves that a purer version of the sport can exist, once the will to adapt is there.” This sophisticated play comes from bigger consequences, yes, but also from the pressure of representing your country in positive light. Hockey player’s in the NHL however play for themselves, their club, and in present day most importantly, their fans. Fans want to see huge hits, fights and goals - in reality the spectators are who pays the players therefore players must preform to their liking. Discussed was the fact that professional sports do remake themselves to eliminate harmful parts of the game, an example used in the editorial regarding hockey is the banning of spearing, but players still spear which proves adding rules don’t fix everything. Players want to impress their teammates, coaches and fans, sacrificing their own well being to do…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article, Ban Fighting in Hockey discusses the dangers of fighting in the game of hockey. Author Charlie Gillis is arguing the fact that the old saying says, “Hockey needs fighting” should be reconsidered. This journal coming out shortly after the death of rookie senior hockey player, Donald Sanderson, caused the uproar against violence from Gillis. His argument was up against great odds, because when Colin Campbell (who is the director of hockey operations) brought the topic of harsher punishments up, only two General Managers supported the idea.…

    • 638 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Will fighting be banned? The contemplating debate about the future of fighting in the nhl has astonished the National Hockey League fans. Some say fighting will make the game more dangerous others safer.…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    NHL Lockout Rough Draft 2

    • 1042 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The NHL is a multi-billion dollar sports industry. From hot dogs being sold at the ice arenas of professional hockey teams to uniform jersey sales and ticket prices, the NHL has enough revenue coming into those organizations that there is little reason to reason to try to “fix” the business model they have in place when it is not broken. Although owners of NHL teams attempted to change their entire business model for their own profitability, the NHL players decided that it was their time to seize the opportunity and get a bigger piece of the pie when it comes to the money that the owners profit from. In creating this labor dispute, the owners and players of the NHL caused a devastating blow to its credibility among NHL fans and it has disallowed nearly half the games of the 2012-2013 NHL season to be played.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hockey, about the only team sport where fighting is an embraced aspect of the game. Under certain circumstances though, where two players square off and referees are close by to break it up at their discretion. So is fighting considered illegal in hockey? Technically all fighting within a game is illegal and will receive a penalty in which the referee decides depending on the circumstances, but it’s usually a five minute major penalty which sends the players involved to “the box”. Fighting is governed by a complex system of unwritten rules that players, coaches, officials and the media refer to as “the code”. So the question is, when does one cross the line and break this code? There is no definite answer to this question but it is popular belief that when a player maliciously attacks another player with an intent to injure, or acts/commits an act out of the normal realm of a one on one fist fight then it is considered breaking the code. In this paper we shall analyze an incident involving current Red Wings forward Todd Bertuzzi.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Current National Hockey League Commissioner, Gary Bettman has asked many inquiring questions to the governing body of the league along with the general managers of all thirty teams on how to handle this delicate issue. Hockey is a collision sport, not just a contact sport. Rough contact is an essential part of the game. Hockey is also an extremely fast game. During the General Manager meetings in March of 2011 Bettman was quoted, “A full 14 percent of N.H.L. concussions are caused by “legal head shots”; i.e., north-south hits…

    • 3286 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Every year on Boxing Day, the World Juniors tournament for players under 20 begins. The NHL stars of tomorrow compete for their country on the sweaters as well as to create a name for themselves. This generates an intense, excellent quality of hockey which fans love every single year. The one main difference between the World Juniors and the NHL is that fighting is illegal in the World Juniors tournament. There are people who believe that without fighting the game would suffer due to a lack of sportsmanship. Shawn Horcoff, current Dallas Stars centre-man, expresses his feeling toward the issue if fighting was removed from the game: "I think there would be a lot more guys running around, a lot more high sticks, a lot more hits from behind."(Whyno). Horcoff is not alone in believing this; actually, 98% of NHL players in 2011 supported to keep the game how it is, fighting included (Whyno). On the contrary, another highly supported hockey event is the Olympics. NHL superstars get a chance to earn a gold medal only once every four years. A gold medal in the Olympics is considered by many, even current NHL players, to be a greater feat than winning the Stanley Cup. Along with the World Juniors, fighting is also illegal in the Olympics. As far as the quality of hockey being displayed on the Olympic stage, it is second to none. Olympic athletes are not looking to…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though not every sporting event is televised, the ones that are tend to be violent, male sports. One example of a popular, televised sport in America is men’s hockey. Not only is the sport violent in itself, but physical altercations are also allowed and even encouraged. American football also results in violence that can cause serious injury. For example, in 2012 there were 261 reported concussions in the NFL (Garriott, 2014). Research shows that there is a link between masculinity and sports due to the fact that men’s sports not only involve power and privilege, but also display aggression, anger, and domination (Omar, 2011). Fans not only praise the sports, but they also praise the players. Participants of these sports are being idolized for their violence and aggression. This results with having those who are exposed to these sports will then tend to believe that displaying these actions is considered masculine. Therefore, boys and young men who are striving to be “masculine” will then mimic these behaviors in hopes of fulfilling the ideal masculine role that is set by American…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shoulder fake left, head fake right, a sweet inside outside move, and he fires it in top shelf, beating the goalie glove side to win the game. While that may sound like a narrative of a game-winning hockey goal, in reality, it is 1:30 AM on your average Thursday night and I am struggling to find the perfect concluding sentence to finish my history term paper. Often when I am struggling to find an answer to a question or need to concentrate on any given topic, I reach for my worn-out Warrior hockey stick and my dusty orange ball and begin to stickhandle mindlessly. One might never know, that my mind is far away from hockey as I look like a complete fool deking (hockey term for getting past people) imaginary people on my way to an imaginary net.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Walters, J. P. (n.d.). Drug Policy Information Clearing House. Retrieved September 21, 2008, from ONDCP: http://www.whitehousedrugpolicy.gov/publications/factsht/crime/index.html…

    • 3198 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Introduction: My name is Brendan and I am here to inform you about the sport of Ice Hockey. Did you know that it’s one of the fastest sports on earth? It is one of the most overlooked sports in the United States and I am here today tell you all about the origins of the sport, the basic rules,…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are several conflicts that may arise during all sports. From the little league, all the way up to the professional league, there is always going to be conflict, some bigger than others. As the book The Joy of Conflict Resolution by Gary Harper states, “…conflict is a part of life”. Every day people are challenged with new or reappearing conflict, some can be resolved, some are still in the process of trying to be resolved, and others ignore it and hold onto a grudge. A major conflict arising today is about football players and concussions. The game is constantly changing, forming faster, stronger, and all-around better athletes than ever before. This means the players are taking more traumatic blows to head than ever before. As a result,…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This isn’t a football paper. This isn’t a medical paper. This is the modern challenge of breaking from a nation’s traditions for safety. For as long as one can trace back history, humans have always been obsessed with the act of competitive violence. While in the modern age we might have shied away from events such as gladiators and duels, our modern forms of sport tend to take on a brutal nature entirely their own. Of these modern sports perhaps none is more physical then American football. In fact, the sport is largely comprised of and designed around the act of violence, with men of all different shapes and sizes throwing each other around with no regard for physical well-being. However this is where the interest of health and popular appeal contradict each other. While no one player has the intention to hurt another player, the game thrives on its violent nature. For example, if one were to go to a game and only listen, they would hear the crowd become its loudest at two moments during competition. First, more obviously, is when the home team scores points, however second is when one player delivers a blow to another in such a fashion to jar the player off the ground and dismantle him in to the grass. However is that not the American way? Is the wish to see competitive violence not built into every American?…

    • 1656 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Agonistic Behavior

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The benefits of fighting are quite obvious in many cases. The winner can gain exclusive use of a resource such as a food source or may…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays