Preview

The Cowboy And His Elephant Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
954 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Cowboy And His Elephant Analysis
The Cowboy and His Elephant: The Story Of a Remarkable Friendship was written bye Malcolm MacPherson, and was published in 2001. The story begins by describing what a cull is and that the lone survivor of the cull is called "The Storyteller". The first chapter is not accurate as nothing is known of what happened to the elephant until the point of the cull. It simply describes basic behaviors of other elephants in the same region. Later in the first chapter the cull begins, which is the slaughter of an entire group of elephants, however, one man had made a promise to save one elephant from a cull. Save he did, he saved the newborn elephant. Later that week that baby and five others were to be shipped to the United States, Buck Devries, the …show more content…
I disliked that the introduction of the book was dragged on and on. The first two chapters were seventy- five of the 240 pages of the book. I understand they have to introduce a story but, I believe that guessing what happened to the baby elephant weeks before the story began is a little too much detail, that is unnecessary. I also dislike how they guess emotions of Amy during the entire story, even though the emotions are just to add humor or sadness to the story. However I like that the book describes Bob's past before he meets Amy(pgs. 37-74). This is important because we learn that Bob likes to do the unexpected, and that he really loves animals. I also like that Bob was able to return to his cowboy ways after his days as the famous Marlboro man. I like that this book isn't just facts about elephants, or facts about Bob, they mixed facts in to a storyline. I also like how the storyline isn't straightforward but that it is mysterious at times. I did enjoy that Malcolm MacPherson, the author, didn't stop when Bob visited Amy in the circus. When it stated that Amy did remember Bob(pg. 210). I like that the book also introduces more elephants other than those in the circus and Amy's family. The book also introduces Randall Moore, a self trained and observed African elephant trainer, and then was challenged to train three wild African elephants(pgs. 216-217). Randall Moore successfully trained these wild elephants, and then started

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In our discussion on Friday, no one else read the book so I was stuck trying to piece together what they knew, what happened in the book, and how to write a decent report on what has happened so far. So far in the book, we read about Jacob living in the retirement home and coming in contact with a fellow who claims he carried water for elephants. Elderly Jacob flashes back to when he was twenty-three. His parents had just died in a car accident; he skipped out on his veterinarian final exam, and hops a train out of Norwich in hopes of finding work somewhere new. The train is for the “Benzini Brother’s Most Spectacular Show on Earth”. He joins the circus, does a variety of petty jobs until he lands in the circus…

    • 293 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sarah Gruen’s Water for Elephants is an account of ninety-something year old Jacob Jankowski’s life, both in the present day, where he resides in a nursing home, unhappy with his living conditions and the old age that has robbed him of his freedom, and through flashbacks of when he was young, traveling with the circus. Just a few days away from getting his veterinary degree from Cornell University, Jacob’s mother and father were suddenly killed in an automobile accident, sending Jacob’s life spiraling out of control; with his parents’ debt having left him with no home and no money, he hops aboard a circus train for the “Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth,”…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leader reported that “Ranger” Jones and his men were attacked at his ranch on July 30 on the Platte River, near Casper, Wyoming. The Indians had driven Jones and his men into a make shift dugout for two days and on August 1, Jones and his men made their way to John Iliff’s ranch which was about forty miles farther up the Platte River, were they were able to get rest, fresh horses and needed supplies before heading back. What is so ironic about the meeting of these to is that such a large and powerful cattle baron such as Iliff in the next sixteen years would have great conflict with ranchers such as Jones. Unknown assailants assassinated Ranger” Jones and fellow ranger John Tisdale, fifteen years later under accusations of rustling, just four months prior to the Johnson County invasion. It leads to early speculation why a cattle baron of Illiff’s stature and prestige allowed Jones to take refuge in his home if he there was speculation of cattle rustling over thievery of any sort. Even though Iliff would not live to see the invasion of Johnson County, the satire of his crossing paths with “Ranger” Jones makes the Cattle Baron story much more intriguing.…

    • 2087 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story “Juicy and Delicious” written by Lucy Alibar and its film adaptation “Beasts of the Southern Wild” directed by Benh Zeitlin follow the life of a young child named Hushpuppy in a home she calls “the Bathtub.” Throughout the play, Hushpuppy learns how to love and care for others with examples given by the characters Miss Bathsheba, Joy, Birfday cake, and Daddy. Hushpuppy is portrayed more as dependent and in need of some protection in the play’s version of her story, while in the film her character is adapted to be seemingly more independent, assertive and courageous. ((the so what, what’s the point of that))…

    • 206 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I agree with Medhurt’s Interpretive Perspective it makes the most sense to me. I agree with his allegory and the significance the elephant represents in the story. Though both Sparks and Medhurst share this view. I feel because advertising is geared towards the immediate instinctive reactions. The elephant does not want to be “big†or unacceptable and would…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Water for Elephants

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages

    I chose the book Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen. I chose this book because I had watched the movie a long time ago and everyone says the book is always better than the movie. I knew I was going to like it because I love animals and I have always wanted to be a veterinarian just like Jacob in this book. I thought it was very inspiring how even after Jacob learns that his parents have been killed in the car crash and their home has been mortgaged to pay for his tuition and the house is not to become his home, he leaves his college right before he has nearly graduated. He jumps on a train, not knowing it is a circus train belonging to the Benzini Brothers. Jacob is nearly kicked off of the train but when the owner of the circus, Uncle Al finds out about Jacob’s training as a vet, he hires Jacob to take care of his circus animals. I believe it is was a miracle. Jacob is hardworking and does whatever he can to protect what and who he loves. Unlike some people Jacob was aware that August was a mean man that abuses the animals and the people around him, but comes off as a charming man, he felt he had to develop a guarded relationship to protect Rosie and Marlena. Jacob was an all around caring person, he helped people as much as possible like when he helped Camel who became paralyzed and the circus had no need for him anymore, Jacob knew August would kick him off the train so he took care of Camel until the circus got to the providence, which is where Camel’s son was located. I think that the message in this book is that when there is no hope left in you that you need to just keep moving because whether you believe it or not things will get better. That is what happened to Jacob numerous times in this book, he had a lot of tough times but he got through them eventually. I like that you can imagine what is happening in your head the whole time you are reading this book, but for example “Rosie stretches out her trunk, reaching for…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This book was very different than anything I have ever read. I am still deciding whether I liked it or not. It was hard for me to follow because it kept jumping back in forth in time. The first three chapters I hap kept re-reading to focus and grasp what was going on. I was extremely confused and it went from the opening scene in 1931 to Milkman being four years old in one paragraph. I do feel this is a book you need to read over and over again to fully gain an understanding of the messages and symbols the author was displaying through each character. I thought the book was interesting that although it dealt with racial issues and focused on how characters such as Guitar and Milkman had different views of status and discrimination, their was very little mention of white characters in the book. The majority if not all the characters were black decent and it was purely one sided view on how the black race dealt with racial issues in a small town at that time. I think Pilate was a crazy character and I didn't like how long it dragged out to find the true nature of why her relationship was the way it was with her brother Macon Dead Jr. I feel like the author was changing the subject and jumping around so much that you never fully get to know any one character. I didn't like how the author killed Milkman in the end, it was as if you finally made some self discovery and then he jumps to his death. The book just builds and layers and builds, and when you finally feel like you might understand where it's leading three of the main characters die within the last pages. Aside from racial views and Milkmans self discovery from his life as his fathers son, to discovering his family history and where he wants to be in the future, I didn't really connect with any other character in the book, or understand their significance in his discovering…

    • 353 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Elephant Run Summary

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Introduction: Reading the book Elephant Run by Roland Smith was amazing, and I always wanted to know what was going to happen next. Also, it was a very compelling and thought-provoking read, because the author managed to incorporate some true events into the story.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “The Beast in the Jungle” portrays the eerie, the unnerving, and the unnatural. Additionally, Marcher’s unwarranted perception of pride, and his habit of talking and thinking about himself unduly this was his beast in the jungle or in other words his ideology, and instead of plunging into life, he lived life on the edge. Consequently, Marcher had a narcissistic personality disorder, and he did not need May stroking his ego, professing to know the truth about his destiny. I think that by during this May kept Marcher coming back. She wanted him, but he was consumed with himself, and this was the only way that she could have him. I guess this story is about feminism in a creepy, disturbing…

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When I was younger, I compared my grandfather to that of an elephant, 13 feet tall, 15,400 pounds, and a heart weighing up to 46 pounds. A big, broad, vulnerable creature, towering over the rest of the family. Ten months of hairy cell leukemia, a rare strand of the already rare strand of chronic lymphotic leukemia claiming his body made him so small, just skin and bones. My best friend sat 205 miles away over Skype and asked: “How do you get rid of an elephant in a room?” I imagined an elephant squeezing itself like a balloon into my nine-foot-tall living room. “You have to eat it,” she said, “Do you know how eat an elephant? One bite at a time.”…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native Americans used myths to keep traditions alive from generation to generation. They educated their tribes on the experiences and lessons learned from their ancestors in the past. The culture of the Native Americans that was used in these stories are still alive in societies around the world today. In The World on the Turtle’s Back the culture is balanced by the good and bad in the world. The movie “Brother Bear” presents the respect for animals that is still alive and appreciated today, as well as many years ago. The way the word works is similar to the way it worked back in Native American times, which is described in the short myth The Coyote and the Buffalo. The cultures that were portrayed in Native American…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although many people believe that racism has disappeared from our minds after all those solutions of trying to set equal rights in the world’s history, it still exists today, and will probably never vanish from our thinking. Some may clearly express it, whereas others may express racism unnoticeably, even to themselves. George Orwell, in “Shooting an Elephant”, tells a story of his past when he killed an elephant in order to please the Burmese crowd. At the time, Orwell was a white Indian Imperial Police officer who was disliked by the country's natives due to the fact that he was European. One day, he heard of an elephant's doing of ravaging the town, so he ran to the scene with a rifle. When he finally arrived, he found himself observing a peacefully feeding elephant while a huge crowd of Burmans gathered excitedly to observe his future action. Even though he does not feel it right to shoot the elephant, he has this huge, unavoidable pressure from the Burmese crowd. Eventually, his final decision was to shoot the elephant and…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In “An Elephant Crackup?”, Charles Siebert partly attributes the belligerence of the recent generations of elephants, the animals considered to be among the most intelligently advanced, to the lack of a matriarch, a powerful female figure. He takes an example of the case of the last elephant survivors at Queen Elizabeth National Park, where the elderly female elephant was the one who “gathered the survivors together from their various hideouts”, “led them back out as one group”, and “held the group together [as] the population all the while slowly beginning to rebound” (Siebert 358). The idea that the sustainability of the group is dependent on its leading female is rather surprising, in the sense that in the wilderness, where the determination of roles among the members of the herds is largely, or even solely, influenced by physical ability, it would be more logical that the males are in control. Surprisingly, there are several researches that prove the opposite, that despite lacking physical advantage, female leaders are vital to the behavior and existence of the group itself. This phenomenon is not only interesting, but also very useful and fundamental to the effort of improving the aggression of the elephants, and through that, the relationship between elephants and humans. Also, there are certain ways that the “political” and social order of the matriarchal societies in elephant can be held accountable for the sake of this process.…

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    An elephant to me isn’t just an elephant it’s a beautiful big animal with the biggest heart and open mind. They are represented in many cultures as multiple significant meanings and some that I identify with. The structure of an elephant is obvious to the human eye it’s a huge ass animal with big ears and little tiny eyes, but if you take time to research the background and the reason for their structure you would hopefully become as obsessed with an elephant as I am. Their memories are unbelievable never forgetting the path they went through proving to be wrong and dangerous to them. Although they never fear because they travel in groups that allows them to have each other’s back like a protector. The best part of an elephant is their obedient, careful and calm nature most of the time, for example when the leader of the elephant group calls upon them to do a task they immediately obey and destroy whatever is in their path that could potentially stop them from their duty as well as become blind to the hardship and pain that it is causing them to get there. One main religion that pops up related to an elephant is Hinduism. Hinduism doesn’t worship the animal itself but rather the significance that the elephant represents, obedience to the dharma (the master’s call), ability to not repeat past mistakes, and respect and care towards their peers. The perfect disciple acts like an elephant devotes complete obedience to their master and has small eyes for he does not use the eyes of the actual body but the eyes of the sprit, and has big ears because they listen more than they speak. As well as informing others about their dangerous encounters towards the path of enlightenment. The most interesting part of this whole meaning of one huge animal along with many other animals, personal just minds blows me because I think I’m an elephant on many leaves as weird as that could sound to many people. Although it really shouldn’t for the simple reason that if people thought of…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    POACHING

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The story was write by David hands. He was video taping some elephants, with some men armed from social antipoaching unit.Everything was fine until one of the men shoot at the elephants.the elephants started to run towards them the men kept shooting.Some elephants where killed others were injured .lots of the men there were hurt.…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays