Preview

The Gilligan-Kohlberg Moral Theory Controversy

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2159 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Gilligan-Kohlberg Moral Theory Controversy
The Gilligan-Kohlberg Moral Theory Controversy

Ethics, or moral philosophy, as a field of intellectual inquiry developed in the west for well over two thousand years with minimal input from women. Women's voices have been virtually absent from western ethics until this century. The absence of female voices has meant that the moral concerns of men have preoccupied traditional western ethics, the moral perspectives of men have shaped its methods and concepts, and male biases against women have gone virtually unchallenged within it. Feminist ethics explores the fundamental effect of this imbalance on moral philosophy and seeks to rectify it. So the questions we face are: Do women have a distinct moral perspective? How if at all is gender relevant to moral theory? Questions such as these will be answered in this essay.
The concept of morality has long been one of intense interest and debate for many disciplines, from ancient philosophy to contemporary psychology. However, it could be questioned the extent to which we have developed in terms of understanding such an abstract entity. Carol Gilligan follows the cognitive developmental models of Lawrence Kohlberg in her argument concerning female morality, yet can her perspective be supported, or does her theoretical model raise broader issues surrounding the explanation of moral thought and behavior? According to Gilligan, the model of a distinct female moral development is in response to the lack of attention paid to women in previous models of moral development, namely Kohlberg.
I want to begin by comparing two well-known scholars and their debate, Carol Gilligan and Lawrence Kohlberg. My purpose here is to review the Gilligan-Kohlberg controversy and show the relevance of gender diversity in moral theory. I will discuss some of the implicit and explicit philosophical differences between Gilligan's and Kohlberg's out-looks and will then illustrate that Gilligan’s claims that women have a distinctive moral voice

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Margaret Wente’s Globe and Mail editorial entitled “What women can learn from men” argues that gender differences are evident, stating that men are often shamed for being morally inadequate, when, in fact, they have many favorable qualities that women do not possess. Wente bemoans the increased attacks against men in all areas of life and contends that women would do the world a service by mirroring some of the more favourable traits embodied by men. Although Wente employs tone successfully to engage a specific audience and achieve her purpose, her argument is undermined by a lack of evidence and a dependence on generalizations that do not make this an effective…

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our beliefs, outlook of life, and our morals develop from early childhood continually changing throughout our life. Our beliefs of God, the way we should live our lives, and what we know to be right and wrong evolves and is refined as the years go by. Kohlberg created a model of development that provides insight into how our morals progress as we develop increasingly sophisticated thought processes throughout our life. Kohlber’s three levels and six stages of moral reasoning and Piaget's cognitive stages of development are deeply and intimately intertwined. Like two sides of a coin, logic and moral reasoning go hand in hand. In other words, in order to move into the next stage or level of kohlberg’s moral reasoning one must advance intellectually…

    • 161 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Assess the contribution of feminist theorists and researchers to an understanding of society today. 33 Marks…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Citation worksheet

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In a Different Voice was groundbreaking because it revealed the narrow thinking of previous moral decision-making research based only on male subjects (Goldberg, 2000).…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Angelina Grimke’s public appeal for the institution of the human rights of all moral beings is ultimately superior to Catharine Beecher’s doctrine of female supremacy limited to the domestic sphere. Both women are visionaries of their era offering contrasting views of women’s proper place in society as well as their moral duties. History has proven that Grimke is unwaveringly the contest winner of this debate . Compelling reasons for Grimke’s historical success can be seen in the women’s differing contextual arguments, the effective use of rhetorical mediums, and the personal embodiment of beliefs.…

    • 2217 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Tong, R., Williams, N.(2009,May 4) Feminist Ethics. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. (Fall 2009 Edition). Retrieved June 22, 2010, from SEP: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2009/entries/feminism-ethics/…

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Study Guide Hdfs

    • 2524 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Carol Gilligan research - how men and women differ in moral thinking, men are generally approaching moral problems in terms of justice, where women think about having responsibility (oppose each other)…

    • 2524 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Feminist philosophers are then faced with the philosophical tradition that are believed women are unimportant and excluding women from philosophical history. Of course though, women are not entirely absent from the history of philosophy. The philosophical customs such as reason and objectivity have been proven through metaphors or images that it dismisses all ideas associated with women. In response, feminist philosophers have argued the records are incomplete due to the missing of female philosophers or are biased when demeaning the women mentioned. Feminist philosophers feel the philosophical traditions are objective towards the gender male and they yearn in changing the norms and including women in the philosophical “us”. However, feminist perspectives appear to have had greater impact on sciences that involve subjects of inquiry that are understood as gendered in the social and human sciences and, secondarily, on sciences characterized in gendered terms, metaphorically or by analogy, the biological and life…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The long debated question of the importance of men and women and their roles has raged on for years. Should men and women be treated equally, that truly is the question that seems to have more answers than resolution. Applying the question to Deontology and the work of Immanuel Kant, the answer would be all people regardless of gender should be treated equally. However, these theories do not take into account the actions of the male or female in question. The question still remains, should men and women be treated equally or should it be based on the situation, all accounts will be taken into further consideration.…

    • 756 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conclusively, According to a modern school of thought there is a precise female tactic to ethics, which is built not on abstract "male" ethical principles or rules, but on "care".…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Virginia Held is a modern day philosopher with theories on the feminist view in philosophy. All of the major philosophers have always written from the male perspective. As far back as the Bible, most major writings have always been geared towards men. They were considered the predominant species from the creation of Eve from Adam's rib. Many philosophers have described worlds that were based upon men, war, and reason. These theories were based on the experience of man. Women were too emotional and simple to understand the complexity of the world. Philosophers have always focused on man's influence and role in the world. These philosophers have downplayed or ignored the role of women in history. This paper will discuss the gender biased opinions of other philosophers as well as the importance of women in life. Virginia Held states that the history of philosophy has always been in favor of man. All theories have been based upon the male point of view. Philosophers' theories have been based on "assumptions and concepts that are by no means gender neutral". (Morality and Moral Controversies, pg. 89) Held's paper discusses the biased point of views displayed by many prominent philosophers. She has maintained that with the appearance of feminism and feminist ethics, major changes will have to be made in philosophy and theories. It is a fact that men and women have a different view on all things. This can be attributed to the fact that man and woman have different beliefs on what is important. This is not because women are unreasonable, but because of emotion. While women will try to do what is right, their theories of right and wrong are based upon the feelings that they have for the individual. A perfect example of this would be someone close to us was sick and needed medicine.…

    • 2200 Words
    • 63 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    right to steal in order to save a human life. On the one hand, some argue that stealing even if…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This appealed to women because it placed their role outside of the domestic sphere and gave them a sense of control. A letter written in response to men claiming they should be at heart of the reform societies because men work better in a public sphere, stated that women’s “influence is all powerful” (Wright and Sklar). This pointed out that women had a collective responsibility to stop the sins such as licentiousness and this letter again highlighted the maternal influence that women have over the future generation. The “Essay Read at a monthly prayer meeting of an auxiliary Female Moral Reform Society” also highlighted the maternal power women had to protect and influence the next generation to make sound decisions, in order to live a life of virtue (wright and Sklar). In response to the men’s arguments against women being involved, women explained that they were not trying to leave their domestic sphere, but were exerting the “influence of which they are the acknowledged possessors, on the side of truth and virtue” (Wright and Sklar).…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alligator river story

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Kohlberg's theory was researched and interviewed using groups of boys of 10 through 16 years old; he presented them with a series of hypothetical moral dilemma stories. These stories presented a conflict between the two moral values. Kohlberg examined and followed the participants between three and four year spans within 20 years (Berk, 2010). Kohlberg's stages on moral development proved gradual and slow pace. Stage 1 and 2 diminish…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every society has a system of learned attitudes about social practices, institutions, and behavior used to evaluate situations, experiences, and behavior as right or wrong, good or bad. Although, there are known standards of morality within the society in which we live, adults are driven and motivated differently on how they come to make their moral decisions every day. Carol Gilligan, well known psychologist, professor, and author, was the first to claim there are gender differences within the moral development between males and females. She believes that women have different moral criteria and follow a different path in maturation and that our lives are shaped by the moral questions and decisions we make every day (Hekman, 1997). In general, Gilligan’s research noted gender differences in feelings towards caring, relationships, and connections with other people among males and females. More specifically Gilligan noted that women are more concerned with care, relationships, and connections with other people and men are more inclined to think in terms of rules and justice. Gilligan’s alternative theory of development of women proposes three stages of preconventional, conventional, and post conventional where the transitions…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays