Preview

The Lesbigay Family: A Comparative Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
547 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Lesbigay Family: A Comparative Analysis
How is polyamorous family and same-sex marriage, families the same ? Can these two both demonstrate alternative families, with hopes of giving legitimacy to “non-traditional family structure?” Both groups are entwined with each other in the fight to alter family narratives, with the hopes of pushing the “ non-traditional” family structure to a nonconformity family. One, that is not seen as non ordain, or moreover, one that holds the same civil rights as the “traditional” family.

To first highlight the connection and difference between these two family structures, one must first describe the definition of both. As described by Sheff, “ Polyamory is a form of relationship in which people openly court multiple romantic, sexual, and/or affective
…show more content…
As described by Sheff (2011) there are four connects that Sheff highlights, “ (1) poly families follow directly in the social wake of the lesbigay challenge to heterocentric family forms; (2) as stigmatized sexual minorities, lesbigay and poly people face similar challenges and use many of the same strategies to navigate family life; (3) conservative politicians and journalists frame arguments against same-sex marriage as leading to a “slippery slope” that inevitably sanctions multiple-partner marriage, bestiality, and incest; and (4) this comparison decenters heterosexual families as the sole comparison point while simultaneously expanding knowledge about lesbigay families. Polyamorists and lesbigays face many similar challenges—disclosure, stigma, custodial issues, and relationships with families of origin—and use comparable strategies to navigate them( Sheff 489).” Nevertheless, both groups are apart of society rather being inclusive or exclusive, however lesbigay groups are now being discussed by the mainstream media. Consequently, this portraying and discussion by the media allows lesbigay groups to become apart of everyday discussion, thus allowing this group a one up on the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    In Green Grass Running Water, university professor Alberta Frank is involved with lawyer Charlie Looking Bear and TV salesperson Lionel simultaneously. Simply, Alberta fears commitment, yet still craves companionship. With both romantic prospects consenting and in the know of the other’s presence, one could question why such a relationship would be regarded as dysfunctional and illegal under the law. So, it is unorthodox, so, it strays far from the ideals of a relationship. However, weren’t homosexual relationships considered perverted even in recent history? What has convinced the majority of society to believe in the opposite, to fight for the right to love over the rules of a holy transcript from two millennium ago? If pledged allegiance to one partner for the remainder of life is a feat unfeasible, and all three parties are consenting adults who agree to such an arrangement, would it not be a relationship much healthier than to one where the polyamorist must sneak around committing dishonest actions behind the mask of a perfect matrimony? What is the purpose of marriage? In the modern world among the common people, marriage is more than a union of families for power, or to procreate. Marriage is about finding happiness in love, and having a loyal support system. In Green Grass Running Water, Alberta is clearly not ready for such a commitment to one person. By disregarding polyamory as an option, no parties benefit. Alberta would likely choose solidarity over Charlie or Lionel, leaving both men miserable as…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The American Marriage in Transition exert explores the views of American couples and the differences in the three types of marriage over the last several decades. “Deinstitutionalization of marriage” is the phrase used by Andrew J. Cherlin to describe American couples in marriage. The examples explored are different types of cohabitation and same sex marriage. Cherlin refers to other historical works that point to shifts in marriage decades before. Those shifts have noteworthy implications for the future of marriage.…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Polyamorists say that their lifestyle’s foundation is built on the theory that love is infinite. An example of this, which can be understood by most, would be how a person feels when his or her second child is born. They do not love that child any less than the first, there always seems to be enough love in a parents’ heart for all the children they have. Taking this theory further Polyamorists believe that they do not need to…

    • 2244 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Lobbying Plan

    • 1696 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The promoters of same-sex “marriage” propose something entirely different. They propose the union between two men or two women. This denies the self-evident biological, physiological, and psychological differences between men and women which find their complementarily in marriage. It also denies the specific primary purpose of marriage: the…

    • 1696 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Although, America believes that we are a nation of equality and acceptance, we are in reality the exact opposite. Not only do major gender inequalities still exist, but society continues to be just as prejudice and discriminatory. With the establishment of the nuclear family, consisting of a heterosexual couple and children, the mentality that heterosexuality is the ideal standard has stayed the same. There have been many criticisms on compulsory heterosexuality and the idea that heterosexuality is the only real natural relationship. In the article, “Compulsory Heterosexuality and Lesbian Existence” by Adrienne Rich, she states that, “heterosexuality, like motherhood, needs to be recognized and studied as a political institution” (Rich 637). She argues that heterosexuality is politically institutionalized because it has been strategically and deliberately carried out by laws and regulations that restrains women and represses…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Polygamy In Canada Essay

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Throughout the research into polygamy there were occasions where interviews were conducted with members of polygamous families, first hand evidence can be very powerful however we see contrasting views here first we will look at those in favour of polygamy. In the paper ‘Polygamy and its Impact on the Upbringing of Children’ by M.Khasawneh et al, we see a mother asked about the impact of polygamy, to which she answers “Did not affect the children” (577). There is also a statement from a child who states “Polygamy is a very appropriate process”. Clearly displays that both the mother and a child of polygamy both seem to support…

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Writing Project three

    • 1642 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The legalization of same-sex marriage is fought strongly by both sides. Those against same-sex marriages fear legalizing them would diminish traditional marriages, along with having other concerns. The main view of those for same-sex marriage legalization is that they see it as a right to gays and lesbians. The question is which side is right? Would the legalization of same-sex marriages take away from traditional marriages or is it a right not being honored? The question of same-sex marriage brings with it the question why. Is it important for same-sex marriages to be legalized considering that same-sex couples can live in cohabitation even in the states where same-sex marriages are illegal? These are a few of the age old questions pertaining to the issue of same-sex marriage legalization. While many American’s view on marriage is that they are between a man and a woman, there are still several who believe same-sex marriages should be legalized.…

    • 1642 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Monogamy In Canada

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Polygamy was first banned in Canada in the late 19th century (these laws can be found under the Canadian Criminal Code in sections 290 [bigamy] and 293 [polygamy]), other laws were passed ( such as section156 – section 158 of the Canadian criminal code forbidding any non paired and 'public' copulation, legally repealed in 1985) though some of these laws have somewhat been repealed the social ramifications have allowed monogamy to officially be the only legal and socially accepted form of relationship within Canadian society. Monogamy is acknowledged world wide and practiced everywhere, even in areas of the world where polygamy is the most prevalent form of relationship. Though humans have had various configurations of relationships…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Polygamy In Canada

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages

    We know in our society today there are many different types of families. They range from nuclear families which consist of a mother, father, and children to blended families which consist of two families coming together following a divorce. For the sole purpose of this essay, however, we will be looking into a type a family which is different than most of the others; which is called Polygamy. Polygamy is defined as “The practice or Custom of having more than one wife or husband at the same time” (Oxford Dictionary). The term polygamy acts as an umbrella term for the simple reason there are different types of this practice. The most common practice of polygamy and the one this essay will be looking into specifically is called polygyny which…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Polyamorous do not want to feel constantly being criticize where they live, they don’t want to continually see monogamous relationships being portray as the only right type of relationship there is, and also they are able to save money by avoiding expenses that monogamous people would…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thesis Statement

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “In the twentieth century, America has undergone vast changes in family styles. Because of the increase in many gays and lesbians speaking out, we see a new emphasis on the word family. "Many gays and lesbians have decided to come out of the closet shaking up an issue that has made a ruckus between Americans”. We find that the Defense of Marriage Act…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The history shown can stand by the other facts given to end polygamy and rights being taken from women. America should protect young girls who do not have a choice because they are under 18. The treatment of the women is greatly shown in this research paper and the facts stand to it being morally and legally wrong. Polygamy needs to be controlled and stopped for good throughout the nation. In order to understand what Polygamy is and why America should not legalize it , one must know, the history of Polygamy, the limit of freedom the young girls have, and the treatment of the…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What Is a Civil Union

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The authors, Jess Henig and Lori Robertson, who wrote the essay “What is a Civil Union?” present three differences between civil unions and marriages as the rights to federal benefits, portability of civil unions, and terminology of marriage. Henig and Robertson introduce the essay with how state and federal laws regarding gay marriage differ in that states allowing civil unions extend state benefits to same-sex married couples however, The Defense of Marriage Act states that for all legal purposes marriage is a union between one man and one woman therefore, federal marriage benefits are not extended to same-sex married couples. States with legalized civil unions including Connecticut, New Hampshire, New Jersey, and Vermont allow same-sex married couples state benefits. The authors go on to describe the differences of state and federal benefits. These include that same-sex married couples are allowed to file a joint state tax return, but must file separate federal tax returns claiming themselves as single. Additionally, if one spouse works for a company whose health care is governed by the state laws that coverage is extended to the spouse, however if the company if governed by federal laws then it is up to the employer if they will extend health coverage to the same-sex spouse. In conclusion, if a spouse were to die, the survivor would have the right to Social Security payments based on the earnings of the married couple. Moving into the middle of the essay, the authors inform us that New Jersey is the only state that allows portability of civil unions meaning that the same-sex partnership is transferable to another civil union state. The controversial issues of the traditional views of marriage conclude the essay with an argument from adversaries including Jenny Tyree with Focus on the Family, expressing that same-sex marriage discourages the traditional views of marriage as man, women, and children.…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Polygamy Culture

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Polygamy is a heterosexual marriage which includes more than two partners, which is a monogamous marriage. When a man is married to more than one wife at the one time, the relationship is called polygyny, and there is no marriage bond between the wives; and when a woman is married to more than one husband at the one time, it is called polyandry, and there is no marrige bond between the husbands. If a marriage includes multiple husbands and wives, it can be called group marriage. Though there are three or more parties to such marriages, sexual activities between the parties are normally only heterosexual.…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Polygamy means a system of marriage where one person has more than one spouse. There are two basic forms of polygamy: polyandry, where one woman has more than one husband, and polygyny, where one man has more than one wife (Merriam Webster dictionary). Over the course of history and at present, polygyny is by far the most common form of polygamy, though there have been some documented reports of the practice of polyandry in isolated societies (Al-Krenaw, 1995). Polygyny appears to be the only type of polygamy practiced in North America. While Polygyny is practiced in several societies in the world it is most common in Middle Eastern and African nations, where cultural and religious background continue to encourage its practice (Agadjanian, 2000). There has been growing concern and controversy about polygamy around the world. In many countries where polygamy has traditionally been practiced, there has been increasing encouragement for the restraint of polygamy to protect women from abuse and support gender equality. In the United States, there is increasing concern about the practice of polygamy and other abuses of women and children in fundamentalist communities (Altman & Ginat, 1996). Furthermore, these communities are composed of Christian, Jewish and Muslim believers.…

    • 2576 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays