The relationship between museums and non-western collections can be viewed as cultural survival, cultural survival is concerned among the non westerners as they have lost their collections to the museums in the west. Museums are among the most successful leisure venues and can provide a social framework for effective and interactive sharing of history and memory. With the non-Western collections been in museum it brings on the debate on how these collections should be viewed. Many might argue whether they should be viewed in a primarily scientific or aesthetic light. When we visit the museums and look these collections we are excepted to learn about the history and the culture of the art, for some it might memory of the culture, which they might have lost if they have moved to the west. The museums does shed some light on the history of the collection and spreads the culture, but how much of the context is interpreted from the collection is up to the viewers.
There are some problems with the non-Westerner collections been in museums. The problems arise from the fact that having the museum provide a sufficient cultural context in museum cabinet can be very difficult, if not impossible. Many of the text that the museums have provided can be outdated and excessive. The effects of museums having non-Western collections can be very devastating for the people in Africa. The removal of some of their sacred pieces not only causes a shortage of their necessary ceremonial objects, but it belittles their religion. With no respect in the handling or removal of their sacred objects it can result in spiritual crises which aid the efforts of missionaries.
There have been some recent attempts to return the artifacts to the people whose ancestors produced them, even though at this time unfortunately there is little legal structure to serve as a guideline for relations between museums and the non-Westerners. A museum in upstate New York along with its staff have long thought that many of there collections were both culturally inaccurate and religiously offensive. The museum did not close its doors, instead it resolve the issue by returning the objects. Some museums in England have reached out to African diasporas to help them with interpreting the context of the art. Museums still have a far away to go in returning the artifacts to the ancestors, but with the collaboration on the non-Westerners, there collections can be give the right context and they can some what re- claim their collections.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In James Clifford’s essay, “Four Northwest Coast Museum: Travel Reflections,” the appearance of tribal art and artifacts, some grouped with modern art, in several museum galleries comes under fire. He very critically addresses such museum’s attempts to classify and reclassify primitive art and modern art into one by pointing out only vague similarities. Clifford also highly objects to one museum’s, the Museum of Modern Art, use of the word ‘affinity’ in a gallery held in 1984 entitled, “Primitivism in 20th Century Art.” The driving force behind this essay is that the status of tribal artifacts has been forced to shift and deviate from their original classification as remnants of an ancient past with anthropological definitions, to those with more modern, aesthetic definitions. The Museum of Modern Art (MOMA) exasperated Clifford on numerous levels. Their 1984 gallery, “Primitivism in 20th Century Art,” coupled so-called tribal artifacts with modern works in order to show a correlation between the two. In particular, the affinity was used,…
- 439 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
When considering cultures in collision a museum is a fine example of a clash of positives and negatives. This can be a troubling idea for the curators and visitors of museums because their collective pursuit of further cultural knowledge is often pure. However, in constructing a museum more often than not items of important significance are transplanted from their original location to be viewed and studied by a foreign people in a foreign land. The concept of the “rightful owners” of history and artifacts is a complicated one that leads to many cultural collisions. This is because multiple cultures often lay claim to the same artifacts leading to conflict among the claimants. With all of these ideas in mind the process of selecting a piece of art from the Cornell Fine Arts Museum for analysis became far more difficult. In examining the thought-provoking piece Lonesome George by Juan Travieso a warning message is telegraphed loud and clear.…
- 596 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
1. Compare and contrast two sculptures from the African chapters in your textbook. Be sure to include an iconographic and iconological analysis in your response. Do not forget to write in your own words. (5 points)…
- 996 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Museums bring history and culture to life by allowing individuals to gain unique hands on experience that is different from learning from textbooks or television. One can never know the reality behind certain artifacts and art until they see it for themselves. The perception of viewing a multitude of replicas and pictures such as the Mona Lisa can be dramatically different from witnessing the painting up close. The interactive experience allows one to engage and immerse ourselves back into time to learn about the truth of different cultures and traditions. The intent of museums is not purely to enthrall historians and scholars, but to create an environment which is welcoming to all individuals. While historians argue that museums…
- 944 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Museums are a perfect way to represent what history has unfolded for the public’s eye. Consideration needs to be made when a person is shopping for fragments of history such as arts or artifacts. A main consideration is profit; however, there are consequences if the museums does not make enough money. If a museum does not make enough money, this could suggest that people are not interested in taking tours throughout the museums anymore,the new age of technology is taking over. What happens after the museums cannot keep their wonderful art?…
- 900 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Certain views, like that of Blythe, a nineteenth century African writer and supporter of African rights challenged the common perceptions of the era but they did not change them. Blythe talks about scientific Europeans ‘giving academic study to the Negro’ but his overall suggestion is that there is a general ‘opinion of some God is everywhere except in Africa.’ (Blythe 1903 in Brown, 2008) Read and Dalton They described both their perception of Benin society and the objects they were studying in a very ambivalent way at the first sight of these remarkable works of art were at once astounded….and puzzled to account for so highly developed an art amongst a race so entirely barbarous as the Bini’ (Read and Dalton 1897 in Brown, 2008).This negative and perception of Benin was a common perception of the whole of Africa at this time . Anthropologists in general struggled to fit explanations of such sophisticated works of art into these commoner held opinions which circulated throughout all major establishments of newspapers, museums and Encyclopaedias. This meant that stereotypical notions were gaining credibility over real facts. Read and Dalton were unfazed and presented their historical version as a prejudiced one, shaped by the society in which they lived, hence they form the conclusion that ‘no hope that a…
- 1714 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
ABSTRACT........................................................................................................................................................... 4 1. BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................................................... 4 1.1 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................................. 4 1.2 MANY HISTORICAL ACCOUNTS ...................................................................................................................... 6 1.3 LIMITED IN NUMBER BUT GEOGRAPHICALLY SCATTERED .............................................................................. 7 1.4 FOCUS ON REPRESENTATION AND ACCESSIBILITY ......................................................................................... 8 2. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK ................................................................................................................ 10 2.1 CULTURAL REPRESENTATIONS: AN INTRODUCTORY NOTE .......................................................................... 10 2.2 THE DEBATE OVER REPRESENTATION .......................................................................................................... 11 2.3 APPROACHES TO EXHIBITING AND DISPLAY................................................................................................. 12 2.4 ACCESSIBILITY ............................................................................................................................................ 13 3. SCOPE AND PURPOSE…
- 15754 Words
- 64 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In Suzanne Preston Blier’s article Enduring Myths of African Art, she articulates seven of the most common myths believed around the world surrounding African art. Of those seven myths, one that stands most true is the myth that African art is bound by place; the idea that African art in particular travels nowhere and its ideas are constrained to just the cultures they are sculpted in. Blier states, “The African art of myth is also frequently presented, incorrectly again, as an art rigidly bound by place.”1 She continues to express how most of the African art objects and styles studied are judiciously ascribed to particular regions and cultures as if they have no ability to circulate…
- 2964 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In this essay, I will argue that ethnographic museums privilege viewing, at the expense of other senses. I will further argue that by privileging the visual, ethnographic museums become problematic in two ways- firstly, by not accurately representing the cultures they are supposed to be exhibiting, and secondly, by limiting the experience of museum-goers who may be visually impaired or otherwise unable to visit museums that are purely mono-sensorial. After outlining and discussing the problems associated with ocularcentric post-colonial museums, I will offer a few solutions to these problems. The majority of colonial museums privileged viewing and the visual. In the 17th and 18th century, Europeans believed reason and sensuality to be opposing…
- 633 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Stibbert museum was originally the collection of Frederick Stibbert located inside his private residence in Montughi near the Florence country side. Stibbert used his large inheritance to peruse a passion for collecting, acquiring a variety of objects such as armor, swords and art from across the world including Europe, the Middle East, and Japan. Following his death in 1906, Stibbert bequeathed his house to the municipality of Florence where the collection was made open to the public for future generations. In order to understand the Stibbert Museum, it is necessary to understand Stibbert’s life, the collection itself, and the way in which the objects are displayed in accordance with Stibbert’s view of the museum mentality.…
- 822 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Art has a long history of being censored by the government, different communities of people, and museums and even through self-censorship. To understand the idea of self-censorship committed by museums, the evolution of censorship is essential. In Christopher B. Steiner words, censorship “attempts to critique or control the dissemination of images or knowledge from an institution which the group perceives to be unilaterally powerful and from which the groups feels excluded.” Using this as a basis to define what censorship is in the context of museums will help expand on the multiple layers of what the issue is and how it is addressed in different countries and cultural institutions. It also needs…
- 176 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Wyatt MacGaffey writes about the relationship between word and image through exploring art, Afrian art, and minkisi, with great emphasis towards the minkisi class and their concept of power objects. (217) In the English language, there is not an equivelnt word to describe Nkisi, however, fetish inadequately is often implied. Minkisi is another name for chiefs of the Congo. Grasping their origins, composition, and ritual context is complex. In Christianity, the crucifix is comparable in that it is spiritually related. Cheifs in a sense were comparable to objects in African cultrure in that they were treated in similar ways. MacGaffey begins by labeling art is a form of communication. We come across the questions of whether art is an effective means of communication and what exactly is communicated through art.…
- 495 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Stored away and hidden from sight; then ultimately left with no source of might. In those two instances, African-American art faces a similar fate when in the hands of modern museums. Once seen as a vibrant form of black expression now slowly ascending into disintegration.…
- 253 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Culture, which is a word that is very difficult to define, is very much engrained in the African people. The culture and art of African people expresses values, attitudes, and thoughts which help to represent the products of their past experiences and it also provides a way of learning about their history. Throughout this paper, you will learn about the culture and art of Africa and its people.…
- 4492 Words
- 18 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The purpose of this paper is to visit The Metropolitan Museum of Art and write a reaction paper about art works at the museum based on my impressions about them. To begin, I will start by giving you a little of background information about this interesting museum.…
- 765 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays