Preview

The Mission: Inaccurate Portrayals of the Guarani and Jesuit Relations

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1533 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Mission: Inaccurate Portrayals of the Guarani and Jesuit Relations
The film “The Mission” (1986) was written by Robert Bolt and directed by Roland Joffe. It explores the various relationships distinguished between Spanish Jesuits and Indian (Guarani) civilization situated along the borders of Paraguay, Argentina, and Brazil around 1750. Although, as stated in the beginning of the movie that “The Mission” is “based on true historical events”, Bolt and Joffe distort the portrayal of the Guarani and Jesuit relationships. This essay will examine the distortions of the Guarani tribe and the inaccurate “historical” events that took place within the movie. Although many historical filmmakers alter some events and use fiction as a tool in providing an accurate historical representation, the makers of “The Mission” take fictional aids and factual boundaries for granted. More specifically, Joffe and Bolt falsify the image of Guarani natives in South America as well as the Jesuits of Spain.
The film begins with the first inaccurate depiction of the Guarani tribe. The opening scene of the Guarani sending a Jesuit priest down a waterfall tied to a cross illustrates that the tribe does not look kindly upon Jesuits and is above all, savage. The image of savages and hatred towards Jesuits is an inaccurate assumption. In actual fact, since the 1500s the Guarani tribes accepted the Jesuit missions due to the abundance of iron tools provided to them from the Jesuits . The various knives and axes became extremely valuable to the Guarani for production purposes. The importance of these tools also comes as the real reason why Father Gabriel would be accepted into the Guarani civilization in the first place. In the movie, Father Gabriel entices the Guarani by playing music from a clarinet. Although the Guarani did enjoy music, agricultural tools were of more importance and came as the primary reason why a Jesuit would be accepted amongst the civilization. Even though this scene in the film is very short lived and trivial, it leaves the viewer with



Bibliography: Caraman, Phillip. Lost Paradise: an account of the jesuits in Paraguay,1607 - 1768. London, 1975. Cunnighame, Graham. Vanished Arcadia: being some account of the Jesuits in Paraguay, 1607 - 1767. New York: New York : Dial Press, 1924. Ganson, Barbara. Like children under wise parental sway: passive portrayals of the Guarani Indians in European literature and The Mission. 1994. price, John A. the stereotyping of North American Indians in motion pictures. Duke University Press, 1973. Saeger, James Schofield. The Mission and Historical Missions: Film and the Writing of History. (1995).

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Peruvian politics and government in the mid- to late-1800s contained a back-and-forth struggle between those conservatives who desired to keep with the status quo, and those liberals who wished to move on and develop into a more modern governmental system. In Clorinda Matto de Turner’s novel, “Torn from the Nest,” she portrays characters on both sides of the political spectrum and how they feud with one another in an attempt to either keep or change how the power is distributed. Between the conservatives and the liberals, the overlaying conflict seems to be the disagreement over the customs of the church in relation to the poor – specifically debt and how it is paid off. Therein lies the liberals’ greatest challenge to come out on top over…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the introduction, Thompson explains that the young men who entered the seminaries in Europe were particularly dedicated, “and were for the most part drawn from the aristocracy.” (Thompson xlv) Thus, “the slackening of religious fervor and the mundane attitudes observable in a by no means negligible proportion of the friars and priests in Mexico and Guatemala came as a shock, and in the end was probably, as he notes, one of the factors in his desertion of his old faith.” (Thompson xlvi) Taking into account the emotions of confusion that Gage obviously experienced even during his first moments in Spanish America, it appears that Gage’s questioning and problems with the Catholic doctrine are inevitable, and each event similar to this one compounds his feelings of religious…

    • 3166 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ‘Art and Death in the Colonial Andes’ by Suzanne Stratton-Pruitt centered on various paintings done in the western European style that were used as objects of worship for the push of Catholicism on the Andean people during Spanish colonization. Stratton-Pruitt argues that the paintings depict four main elements. These ‘four last things’ constitute death, judgment, hell, and heaven, and she discussed their appearance in several examples of paintings from Andean colonial churches.…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    This mantra would initially lead a small band of six Jesuits to the shores of Salvador on the Bay of All Saints in 1549 alongside the first Portuguese Governor of Brazil. In the Colonial Latin America: A Documentary History, the focus of Chapter 13 is a series of letters that documents the struggles that the Jesuits faced in converting Tupi Indians to Catholicism. Also the chapter highlights the controversy of unorthodox practices that are used for conversion in Colonial Latin America, and the questionable means used to sustain a Jesuit Society and Catholic infrastructures, both physically and spiritually,. From the surface controversy can be attributed to the Jesuits pushing against the Eurocentric ideas of what conversion practices should be like in Colonial Latin America in comparison to conversion practices on the Iberian Peninsula. However, the Jesuits were not opposing the way that the Catholic Church functioned on the Iberian Peninsula, instead the Jesuits were having to adapt by necessity to the environment, culture and practices in Colonial Latin America and specifically in…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    Colonization.” The Canadian Journal of Native Studies IV, 1 (1984): 85-103. Quoted in Ruben Gold Thwaties. The Jesuit relations and allied documents travels and explorations of the Jesuit missionaries in New France, 1610-1791. New York: Burrows, 1896.…

    • 2423 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the strengths of this book is the historic content. The author recorded a great deal of history about the life of the Pueblo Indians before the Spanish conquest. Customs and rituals were cleverly depicted. The story was told of not just what the Indians did, but also gave some premise as to why. The frequent explanations gave appreciable insight into the lives of the Pueblo Indians. Several traditional stories were included which illustrated what the Indians believed their genesis to be. The stories provided an engaging backdrop to the book. Their traditions were portrayed in a neutral light, without signifying a positive or negative influence on their way of life.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gordon provides a detailed account of da Costa’s life before and during the trials in his investigation, “Confessing Sodomy…Luiz da Costa.” Gordon not only elaborates on his analysis of the trials and da Costa’s life, but includes the actual, translated transcripts of the trials of Luiz da Costa. Gordon, who is an accomplished author, historian, and journalist, is very-well versed in Latin American studies, and begins the account by providing a detailed account of who da Costa was, and what he might have encountered during the trials. Gordon’s commentary and analysis is an excellent way to provide background information for the next segment of the chapter, the transcript of the trials. The transcripts are the materials that were taken directly from the time period of the Inquisition, and translated into English, defining them as a primary source. We can come to the understanding that a primary source is any piece of material that comes directly from the time period of the material of interest. Some may argue that since the material was translated, it is therefore not authentic by definition. However, many prominent sources, including the University of Maryland Libraries, agree that it still maintains its status as a primary source since it is an original material deriving from the time period at…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    [ 11 ]. An Autobiography of Martyrdom: Spiritual Writings of the Jesuits in New France. Translated by Sister M. Renelle, S.S.N.D. Sel. Francois Roustang, S.J. St. Louis: B. Herder, 1964.…

    • 2135 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    It bears witness to the Christian worldview of the Spanish explorers that these two men viewed the Christianization of the American savages as their primary goal in colonizing the New World. De Las Casas, as a friar,…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gonzalez, Justo L. The Story of Christianity, Volume I: The Early Church to the Dawn of the Reformation. Second Edi. New York, NY: HarperCollins, 2010.…

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The explorer narrative of The Jesuit Relations written by Jean de Brébeuf, shows the unique clash of two disparate cultures. Brébeuf’s narrative takes on a condescending tone toward his Huron hosts. It also shows a facetious approach the Jesuits had in their interaction with the Hurons in the contact zone. The narrative’s sole purpose serves to reaffirm the intended reader’s European superiority.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout Castaways, by Alvar Nunez Cabeza de Vaca, and A Land So Strange, the Epic Journey of Cabeza de Vaca, by Andre Resendez, a transformation is seen through the thoughts and actions of the four Spanish survivors. Clearly motivated by curiosity, greed, and religion, at first, a dramatic transformation from explorers and conquistadors into assimilated Spanish Indians and revolutionary idealists occurs. Cabeza de Vaca believed that his peaceful ascendancy over the Indians of North America was achievable through a partnership, creating a more humane kind of colonial occupation (Resendez 207-208).…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. Father juniper Serra was a controversial and significant figure in which he created nine missions…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Religion is a critical part of the development of every known society in history. As soon as civilization begins to develop, one of the first things to occur is that the “shaman” class of priesthealer-magician-leaders diverges, and an organized priestly class begins to develop along with an organized ruling class. Because the development of civilization in Macondo is central to the plot of Gabriel García Marquez’s One Hundred Years of Solitude, and the development of civilization in Santa Monica de los Venados comprises a key part of Alejo Carpentier’s The Lost Steps, the role of the newly emerging religion plays an important part in both works. The role of religion has many similarities between the two works. Because both works are written by Latin American authors, and both cities are located in the South American jungle, the dominant religion in the merging societies is Roman Catholicism. In One Hundred Years of Solitude, it is represented by a series of secular (meaning non-monastic) priests, beginning with Padre Nicanor Reyna. In The Lost Steps, it is represented by a Capuchin friar, the gnarled old Fray Pedro. In both works, the clergymen have come to evangelize to non-Christians: Padre Nicanor to the irreligious town of Macondo, Fray Pedro to the pagan Indians of Santa Monica. Both are invited to their respective towns by the governor, the ruling class: the Adelantado invites Fray Pedro, because he feels the town is large enough to need a church; Don Apolinar Mascote, the magistrate of Macondo, invites Padre Nicanor to Macondo from the nearby swamp to perform the wedding of Rebeca Buendía and Pietro Crespi, and seeing the irreligious state of Macondo,…

    • 1794 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Colonial Latin America

    • 63068 Words
    • 253 Pages

    The material in this book comes from my teaching Latin American history over many years. It does not pretend to be a textbook, although it could form the basis of one. It is more than an outline but much is omitted. This little book contains notes and commentary on important topics. It reflects my interpretation of Latin America in the colonial period. My focus is political and economic; I am more comfortable with such topics. Such topics as art, drama, and music are not mentioned. My expertise does not extend to these very worthwhile subjects. Some chapters are more complete than others because I taught more about them. In a number of instances, I have used lists to make it easier to spot important points. Readers should find that the book covers the essentials but that they might want to read articles and other books to find out more. Colonial Latin America, which lasted for about 300 years for most of the region, was extraordinarily complex and rich in texture. There are enormous differences between Mexico, on the one hand, and Brazil, on the other. The term “Latin America” is not only shorthand but…

    • 63068 Words
    • 253 Pages
    Good Essays