The 1930’s were a time of despair, poverty and distress and those who lived during this time believed it would be better to die, than to continue to live this way. When Franklin D. Roosevelt came into office in 1932, the United States was in the most disconsolate moments of the Great Depression. However, he brought with him a promise, a promise to make things better through a series of reforms he was planning on implementing known as the New Deal. In the first one hundred days following his inauguration as president, FDR, had already put into place a variety of programs, all with the goal to briskly improve the lives of those that had been most affected by the Great Depression and boost the economy. Through these programs FDR hoped to create jobs, lower the amount of people living on the streets, and most of all, uplift the spirits of the American people which had taken the biggest hit of all. The New Deal was a success because even though many minorities were overlooked, the overall population was influenced in a significant positive manner through job creation and governmental aid despite having negative effects in other areas of the country.
Although the New Deal was an overall success in the United States, a significant amount of the minorities, especially the African Americans and Native Americans were neglected as opposed to the rest of the population. During the Great Depression, 50% of the African American citizens became unemployed, due to the fact that they were the first to be fired, and the last to be hired. Furthermore, many of the programs put into place by the New Deal, by improving the lives of other Americans, would damage and harm those of the African Americans. For example, as the excerpt from the Gilder Lehman Institute of American History online textbook , when the AAA was put into place between 1933-1934, more than 100,000 black workers who made their living as sharecroppers and tenant farmers were forced off the land (document B). When African Americans had a job, such as in the WPA, their working conditions would be incredibly harsh and unmerciful. These men were forced to work under harsh circumstances and if they didn’t they would lose their job. A WPA foreman in the South being interviewed by a questioner from the Federal Writer’s Project claimed that, “As a matter of fact they cannot be sick for more than five days in succession. If they are… they are automatically dropped from the rolls” (document H) demonstrating that these workers cannot afford to be sick if they want to be able to maintain their jobs. Additionally, even though the Black Cabinet was formed during these years, no civil rights reforms became law during the 1930 since the New Deal had no intention of working towards the civil rights movement.
Another minority that was significantly overlooked and even negatively impacted was the Native Americans. As Document G mentions, “Many Indian problems remain unresolved, but every one has been addressed”. Sometimes, by addressing these problems, the government would actually hurt the Native Americans. For example, the Navajo Reduction Program forced hundreds of Indians to kill or sell thousands of their sheep and other forms of livestock; therefore raising the tension between the Native Americans and the government. The New Deal, even though it helped and lessened the economic problems throughout the country, actually weakened the situation of many minorities such as the African Americans and the Native Americans.
The overall population of the United States was significantly enhanced by a number of the programs put into place by FDR through the New Deal. Roosevelt made the purpose of these programs and what he intended to do with them clear through he Fire Side Chats. For example, in one of these many chats, he claims, that “First, we are giving opportunity of employment to one-quarter of a million of the unemployed, especially the young men, to go into forestry and flood prevention work (document B) ” He planned to do this through programs he implemented a short time after such as the CCC and WPA, which gave jobs to young men all over the country, whether they were skilled or not. Slowly, the effect became clear not only in the amount of young men with jobs, but also in the overall attitudes of those in America, which had begun to lose hope. As George Dobbin, he declares that “It’s the first time in my recollection that a President ever got up and said, ‘I’m interested in and aim to do somethin’ for the workin’ man (Document C)” Norman Thomas would have agreed with this whole heartedly since one of this main objectives was to try and support the industrial worker and to improve their conditions. The results of these programs being put into place were obvious, as unemployment statistics were brought to light. In only two years, the unemployment rate had gone down from 20.6 % to a 14.2% (document E). These percentages strongly supported the idea that the New Deal programs were helping boost the country’s economy once more. Finally, many of these programs brought assistance to other areas of living. For example, the WPA brought hot lunches to schoolchildren and would serve 500,000 meals a day (document D). This made it possible for many children, living in detrimental conditions, to eat at least one nutritional meal a day. Huey Long, a past governor of Louisiana, would have agreed with this hot-lunch program due to the fact that he believed in the re-distribution of wealth from the rich to the poor, and in this case the money is being targeted to those of more humble background. Many programs put into place by FDR such as the CCC and the WPA significantly improved the way of life of hundreds of Americans.
Eventually, even though the New Deal brought with it a lot of progress and improved life conditions, there were some areas of every day life it was not able to amend completely. One of these was the spirit of the American people. Songs such as “No Depression in Heaven” performed by the Carter Family showed the true feelings of those that were still struggling to survive. Lyrics such as “out here the hearts of men are failing” or “no orphan children crying for bread, no weeping widows toil or struggle, no shrouds, no coffins, and no dead (document E)” demonstrated how desperate and disconsolate many of the people are still and how they feel that it would be better to die, than to continue to live this way. Other negative impacts of the New Deal on the United States was the continuous discrimination towards woman and the fact that they were paid lower wages by many of the programs put into place such as the WPA or the PWA. Additionally Alden Stevens mentions that, “the New Deal Indian administration is neither as successful as its publicity says it is,” (document G) showing how improvements were not made in all areas of life in the United States. Furthermore, programs such as the TVA destroyed the environment by flooding hundreds of acres of land in order to build dams and reservoirs. The New Deal did not bring with it only positive effects towards the country. It had negative connotations as well, those which could be observed in different, minor aspects of every day life.
When FDR put into place the New Deal, he had three goals in mind. These were reform, recovery and reconstruction. He pretended to do this through various programs he implemented right away, which included the CCC, the WPA, the SSA, and much more. Slowly the effects of these programs began to be seen all over the country and the overall response was that yes, this program was working. People stopped living on the streets and began working, those who had lost everything now had insurance, and unskilled workers were now learning skills they needed in order to get a job. Even though many minorities were overlooked, and not all aspects of life in America were improved, the general impact of the New Deal was a positive one. Therefore, the New Deal was a success, because through this Roosevelt was able to create jobs and provide governmental aid, despite having slight negative effects in other areas of the country.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Franklin Delano Roosevelt became the thirty-second president in 1933, at a time when the United States of America was in a terrible depression. He said, “There is a duty on the part of government to do something about this.” In the first three months of his Presidency, FDR gathered a group of advisers known as the “Brain Trust” to help him. The group included professors, lawyers, and experts on the economy. They helped him put together many types of programs in the first “hundred days” that he was in office. FDR sought to maintain the nation’s finances, lighten the suffering of unemployed workers, revive business and restore industry to help get the United States out of the Great Depression. (Maupin)…
- 1600 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
In the 1930s, times were tough, due to the Great Depression. During the Great Depression, there was not a real plan to help people out. Until Franklin Roosevelt came up with an idea to help people get through the Great Depression. When the people voted him for president, they believed that he would change society for the better. When he became president, to the people’s surprise, Franklin Roosevelt did not do what he said he would do to help the people. Franklin Roosevelt’s plan was criticized for being too vague and for not getting rid of the businessmen from the government, also the plan was completely opposed for not doing its part and for taking control of the whole government.…
- 974 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Ultimately, the New Deal effectively responded to the problems of the Great Depression. After the Depression struck, President Franklin D. Roosevelt played a huge role in providing faith, hope, and a strong structure to the American economy. During F.D.R.’s first term, Roosevelt helped provide programs for The New Deal in an attempt to relieve and reform the economy by putting people to work. Hoping to gain support from the Americans, F.D.R. made sure Americans had hope and faith in him to relieve and reform the economy. Nevertheless, F.D.R.’s main goal was “to put people to work”, and informed the society that the Great Depression “is no unsolvable problem if we face it wisely and courageously.”(F.D.R.…
- 196 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
When FDR was elected into office he was left with quite a mess left by Herbert Hoover, but Hoover had left a very nice foundation to start FDR’s famous “New Deal.” Programs during this time focused on trying very hard to help bring the US out of the Great Depression by…
- 1584 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
THE GREAT DEPRESSION AND THE NEW DEAL, 1929-1939 THE CHAPTER IN PERSPECTIVE By the 1920s, the corporate industrial economy had grown for more than half a century. Along with its strengths, serious weaknesses developed. Few Americans noticed them because of the hot pursuit of material wealth. The consumer culture of the 1920s and a businessoriented government promoted the pursuit not only of money but of debt as well. When mass purchasing power could no longer sustain prosperity, the economy collapsed. The greatest depression in history dawned, bringing massive unemployment, withering prices, and a stagnated economy. Unlike his predecessors, Herbert Hoover took action. No president before him had dared to stimulate the economy for fear of throwing it hopelessly out of balance. But Hoovers policies, for all his good intentions, were too wedded to the old order to make any difference. The New Deal was no revolution in public policy. In many ways it was quite conservative. It sought ultimately to reform capitalism by modifying some of the excesses that led to the Great Depression. If there were a revolutionary aspect, however, it lay in the New Deals willingness to commit government to compensating for swings in the economy and to supporting those in need. The New Deal marshaled the government activism and executive leadership of Progressivism, but with none of the moralizing that often accompanied progressive reform. With the New Deal, the modern liberal state was born. OVERVIEW This chapter opens with federal investigator Lorena Hickok traveling across America in search of the New Deals impact on the lives of ordinary people. The deprivation, anguish, and courage she finds upsets the common stereotype of lazy loafers in search of government handouts. She also discovers that the New Deal is restoring hope and confidence, and because of it Americans are looking to Washington as never before for help. The stock market crash of 1929, one of the worst in the nations…
- 7986 Words
- 20 Pages
Powerful Essays -
During the 1930s to the early 1970s, the United States government discussed highly controversial liberal policies. When Franklin D. Roosevelt was elected the thirty-second president of the United States in 1933, democratic polices began flourishing through the government. Before his presidency, the nation was in the depths of the greatest economic disaster to strike the country, the Great Depression. As the people elected its new leader, they questioned: Will Roosevelt install faith in our system again? Will he provide recovery? Throughout his creations of the New Deal, improvements of communication with the people through his fireside chats, and boundless energy, Roosevelt provided the United States the answer to their questions. With his hope and determination to restore the nation, he sought a new government. Along the way, Roosevelt established a legacy that remains the most controversial of all American Presidencies. Through his…
- 649 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Roosevelt did not manage to end the Great Depression, he did live up to his promise as he made every effort to provide “every man… a right to make a comfortable living” (Foner, GML, 810) through the New Deal. The goal of the first New Deal was on economic recovery and relief. The first New Deal did live up to its promise as banks were recovered. As stated by Foner, “not a single bank failed in the United States [in 1936]” (Foner, GML, 813). Although tenants and sharecroppers were often excluded from the benefits, the first New Deal also improved America’s algriculture through the Agricultural Adjustment Administration. Additionally, the first New Deal provided jobs for millions of Americans through programs such as the Civilian Conservation Corps. President Roosevelt even made efforts to reassure the public through his fireside chats. In one of the chats, he announces that, “...we are moving forward to greater freedom, to greater security for the average man than he hasever known before in the history of America” (Foner, GML, 830). The goal of the second New was on reforming the system and producing economic security to protect Americans from umemployment and poverty. Like the first, the second New Deal also lived up to its promise. The Works Progress Administration managed to support the umemployment and created jobs for many others. Most importantly, Roosevelt kept his promise by creating the Social Security Act during the second New Deal that provided aid for the elderly, disabled, and the unemployed. The Wagner Act of 1935 also provided protection to the labor force and was responsible for the growth of labor movements. While one can argue that the New Deal did not live up to its promise because it did not provide economic recovery and security for all Americans, it is still crucial to consider how Roosevelt, through the New Deal, did create jobs for millions of Americans and provided a new foundation for America’s economy and the federal…
- 610 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Great Depression of the 1930’s was the worst economic period in the history of the United States. Taking over the presidency in 1932, three years after the Depression began, Franklin Delano Roosevelt became responsible for leading America’s quest to escape the Depression. Roosevelt passed the New Deal in an attempt to help the nation recover through a series of initiatives focused on economic recovery. While most people would agree that the New Deal had a definite impact on the United States throughout the early-1930’s, there are some critics that think that the New Deal prolonged the Great Depression. These critics believe that different initiatives could have returned the United States to prosperity much sooner, and that the Depression would’ve continued much longer if not for the start of World War II.…
- 1990 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
This marked the birth of the new deal. With it came new policies that touched on all sectors of the economic and social life. The New Deal promised to rid the country of poverty and pledged to provide well-paying jobs, food and social security. Nonetheless, even before the concept could be put into practice it faced opposition from within Roosevelt’s own…
- 1096 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Herbert Hoover (1874-1964), America's 31st president, took office in 1929, the year the U.S. economy plummeted into the Great Depression. In February 1931, Herbert Hoover lectured the nation on poor relief and insisted that “the basis of successful relief in national distress is to mobilize and organize the infinite number of agencies of self-help in the community” (Edsforth, 2003, p. 47). Franklin D. Roosevelt assumed the Presidency at the depth of the Great Depression as the 32nd President (1933-1945). By 1935 the Nation had achieved some measure of recovery through reform programs which included Social Security, heavier taxes on the wealthy, new controls over banks and public utilities, and an enormous work relief program for the…
- 851 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Until 1935, only a dozen states had old-age insurance laws, but even these few programs were woefully underfunded. The United States was the only modern industrial country where people faced the Depression without any national system of social security. The work programs of the "First New Deal" were solely meant as immediate relief, destined to run less than a…
- 60 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
The Great Depression had a huge impact on African Americans. The Great Depression of the 1930s was catastrophic for all workers. But as usual, African Americans suffered worse, pushed out of unskilled jobs previously scorned by whites before the depression. African Americans faced unemployment of 50 percent or more, compared with about 30 percent for whites. Black wages were at least 30 percent below those of white workers, who themselves were barely at subsistence level. African American prospects at the time were bleak, with next to no chance of getting or keeping a job. Another key moment of the 1930’s that effected African Americans was the New Deal. The New Deal was a series of domestic economic programs enacted in the United States between 1933 and 1936. They involved presidential executive orders or laws passed by Congress during the first term of President Franklin D. Roosevelt. The programs were in response to the Great Depression, and focused on what historians call the "3 R’s": Relief, Recovery, and Reform. That is Relief for the unemployed and poor; Recovery of the economy to normal levels; and Reform of the financial system to prevent a repeat depression. It was black people who suffered the most during the Depression. By mid-1934 over half the black people in the north were dependent on government support. President Roosevelt's New Deal helped black people a little – over a million received support and found jobs. However, the New Deal discriminated against certain groups and did not help everybody. In 1936 many black people voted for the Democrats and, as a result, there was an increase in the number of black people elected to national and local government. By 1940 there were 100 black…
- 809 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
"Pros and Cons of Sanctuary Cities?" Pros and Cons of Sanctuary Cities? N.p., n.d. Web. 9 Mar.…
- 1392 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
During the time of the Great Depression there were many people in dismay. The United States population, as a whole was pessimistic and negatively perceived the situation of the country. Once elected president, Franklin D. Roosevelt started changing the perspective of the country one piece of legislation at a time. Roosevelt was able to turn the negative believes the people once had into many positive and optimistic believes through the New Deal. Although the New Deal brought along problems such as racial discrimination and sexism, it was an overall success due to the social security act, civilian conservation corps, and the bank holiday; all of which were able to change the American people’s perception of the situation.…
- 669 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This Excerpt shows that even though it created millions of jobs it still failed its main goal. Another example of how it was a success is because it Helped with Relief, Reform, gave new roles to women and African Americans (Kantor Website). The New Deal did help and benefit the African American people and the Immigrants from other countries. The new deal over its many years had created over 32 government agencies that helped almost everyone in a way and still do today (Kantor Website). The New Deal even…
- 559 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays