Preview

The Pros And Cons Of Tort Reform

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
599 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Pros And Cons Of Tort Reform
It has been an ongoing issue since the 1950s, and as seen in the documentary “Hot Coffee”, most people do not know the real meaning of tort reforms. The reason for these proposed changes are based on the facts that people were getting greedy and wanted to make easy and fast money, thus were suing for anything they considered damaging for them. Simultaneously lawyers were taking up this opportunity to make money out of the lawsuits that were filed by their clients. Based on the publication in the Legal Dictionary on tort law (web), juries have tried to make sure that the petitioner gets compensated for the crime committed against them by the other party. Tort reforms have no been welcomed by many as it does not make it easy for complainants …show more content…
McDonald’s later settled the matter out of court, prior to their appeal’s conclusion, as they were worried that they might have to pay the original amount as was proposed by the jury, and the amount was not disclosed. One of the main areas affected by tort reform is the medical malpractice law. Many states have a cap on damages that victims can claim due to medical malpractice. In the case of the twins, where at birth, Collin suffered from cerebral palsy, which was mainly due to the doctor’s negligence; the parents were not able to get the entire amount for his treatment, which was covered from taxpayers’ money. In this case it can be clearly seen that the amount requested, again like the Liebeck’s case, was to cover for medical and treatment. Tort reform was mainly started by collaboration between major insurance companies and corporations, as they wanted the public to think that the civil justice system was corrupt and their decisions affected the country’s economy and by changing the laws for all cases would limit many personal injury lawsuits and this in turn would then reduce high liability on insurance

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Have you ever followed a court case and been astonished at the outcome and the damages awarded in the case? I believe we have all heard about cases where the plaintiff is awarded a very large sum of money for a case that appears not to warrant the award. Most of these scenarios take place in cases where the tort law applies. According to authors Kubasek, Brennan and Browne (2009), tort law is defined as injury that to a person or their property. Tort law is primarily a state law and stipulations can vary. Tort law was put in place to encourage civility, discourage people and companies from private retaliation and to compensate innocent people who are injured due to the wrongful act of a person or company. According to The Legal Environment of Business A Critical Thinking Approach, there are different types of damages awarded in relation to tort cases. These damages are nominal, which is usually awarded when the plaintiff has not suffered serious damage, compensatory, which include general and special damages, and punitive damages. Punitive damages are usually intended to punish defendants and often go beyond simply compensating the plaintiff. (Kubasek et al.,2009)…

    • 3046 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Case Analysis

    • 1841 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Bibliography: 1. Kerr, Margaret, JoAnn Kurtz, and Olivo Laurence M.Canadian Tort Law. 3rd. Canada: Thomson Reuters, 2009. Print.…

    • 1841 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jones V. Tsige Case Study

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The tort system provides compensation to individuals who have been wronged or injured by the activity of another individual. Until the Ontario Court of Appeal decision in Jones v. Tsige in 2012, resulting in the creation of the tort of intrusion upon seclusion, the common law did not include torts that did not entail a personal or financial injury. It is essential the common law includes torts that do not entail actual injury to provide individuals the means of seeking remedies when they are wronged from the wrongdoer responsible for the action.…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tort Law Case Study

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages

    As three years had passed, Ms. Spears contends that she is a victim of a medical malpractice and of Texas’ newly reformed tort laws. Texas lawmakers unanimously passed a tort reform package in 2003 which topped noneconomic damages that a plaintiff could receive in medical malpractice at $250,000. That became the negligence standard for emergency care. It also required an expert witness to substantiate evidence of negligence before a trial. Tort reform advocates approve the law as a way to reduce frivolous lawsuits against health care providers and organizations. Plaintiffs would be required to find a physician in the equivalent practice to serve as the expert witness. Laws also held plaintiffs accountable for defendants’ legal fees if they are unable to…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The legal issues presented in this film are as follows: the effects of the media on citizens to ridicule lawsuits such as Stella Liebeck’s, the effects of limiting the amount of money that can be awarded by a jury in damages to the plaintiff otherwise known as caps on damages, such as the case of Colin Gourley, the corporations’ influence and power in judicial elections as well as the extent they will go to as experienced by Oliver Diaz, and the effects of mandatory arbitration in the work place, battled by Jamie Leigh Jones, as well as in consumers’ lives. All of these issues are presented to the viewer in order to prove an overall point of tort reform. Tort reform should be questioned and researched by citizens the film suggests, by encouraging a…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many tort cases are frivolous, with some entering the realm of being totally ridiculous. The lawyers are not the only ones thinking of lawsuits as another way to get rich. The common American citizen brings lawsuits as a way of playing against the odds and will have a real chance to win.…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although this did not cure all issues surrounding the courts and right of the accused, it did make it harder for citizens to be treated cruelly through due process. There are still many court cases today that seem unconstitutional to the eyes of citizens. In some cases, people are discriminated against or profiled based off of stereotypes, which leads to a bias when a jury comes to rule the defendant as innocent or guilty. In other cases in the past, there is not even a jury of peers…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A statewide liability cap limits the liability of the doctor at hand. While many argue that these liability caps allow the doctor to make careless mistakes, in reality, it gives the doctor the peace of mind to work to their full potential without worrying about the point of view of the patient. In an office, the patient may always be correct, and the doctor will be at risk of being filed a lawsuit for their “careless help.” With states such as California and Minnesota, OB-GYNS pay about 20,000 for their insurance rates. With the liability cap for all states, the number of medical malpractice suits can decrease immediately. Lawsuits will decrease since they depend on the plaintiff’s advantage to take the case of a trial, and the tort reform statutes is the guess that many of these claims tend to be excessive. The OB-GYN medical practice will always have the highest numbers in insurance, but these claims put into all the states can dramatically assist all of these doctors in the money they have to pull out of their pocket every month, and hopefully not every twenty-one…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The healthcare reform is the process of making sure that healthcare is affordable and accessible to everyone in need and those who are not in need as well. It is a well-known fact that in this economy that more and more Americans either can or can’t afford health care at it’s finest. In fact with that being said nearly 46 million Americans have no insurance and the other half at 25 million are basically underinsured. One factor to take into consideration would be the fact that most employers are not quite offering insurance anymore due the exacerbating costs. In the past the United States had spent approximately 2.4 trillion dollars in healthcare costs alone. It has been replied that healthcare reform platform has very little need, but it needs to be revised and the real question would be how to do it. It has been often suggested that the president should design and implement a program that would be government sponsored for everyone. Another idea was to make sure that prohibitions or discrimination would not be a problem or take place for people with pre-existing conditions. The last thing would be to make sure that clinics would use a given incentive to have the patients practice wellness plans and participate in preventive services. Some officials would say that the Commonwealth Fund was established to help improve healthcare access. The Commonwealth Fund is private foundation that steps in to make sure that the proper measures are taken to improve the quality and greater efficiency in health care. In fact the United States spent twice as much in money as any other country for healthcare in general or to improve the quality but as a mere result 101,000 American citizens still died due to not being insured.…

    • 2111 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medical malpractice lawsuits are startlingly common and result from a number of reasons. Doctors and medical specialists can make medical errors, missed diagnoses, drug errors and miss test results (Lovenberg, 2015). Doctors can also make surgical errors and anaesthesia mistakes (Lovenberg, 2015). Unfortunately, all of these failures can result in serious injury and often death. Malpractice tort law is a Constitutional right and provides a means for individuals who have suffered from medical negligence to receive reparation for compensatory damages (Lau & Johnson, 2014). However, defendants in these numerous cases disagree with the tort laws and have successfully and unsuccessfully argued for reform…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Health care reform has been a budding issue within the United States this past year, and problems continue to surface. At the beginning of this process, Americans wanted the government to ensure that all citizens would be able to have affordable and good health care, no matter what their financial situation. The price for health care was increasing at a rate that people could no longer afford it and a lot of people desperately wanted a universal health care systems like some of their neighboring countries. In a sense, change was needed, but how this change came about is the real issue…

    • 2608 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Health Care Event

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Through the many events that have taken place in the health care industry one that comes to mind is how excessive litigation affecting health care today. Litigation has become so broad that it has become a specialized department in the law industry. When one watches television, listens to the radio, browses the Internet, or looks at other media outlets he or she is bound to come across some advertisements for litigations against health care facilities and professionals at frequent intervals. It is not unexpected to see or hear several of them throughout the day. Law firms have even become specialized in health care related cases and focus on specific conditions caused by some sort of illness, medication, or even procedure. The result of this is that health care facilities close due to the financial burden of payments resulting from litigations, in the long run the amount paid for malpractice insurance rises, insurance premiums rise, and costs of health care increases because of the additional procedures ordered to try to prevent litigation (Satiani, 2004). The practice of defensive medicine is estimated to cost two and a half times average coverage cost and the estimated savings in tort reform is passed in 50 billion dollars…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tort Reform

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Tort reform can do nothing but hurt the average person in America who has suffered an injury due to the negligence of another. There are thousands of cases of experiences where babies have suffered brain injury due to medical negligence, workers have lost limbs because of faulty machinery, construction injury occurs as the result of defective equipment, and spinal injury has occurred due to faulty seat belts or defective tires. I could really go on and on with more stories about badly injured consumers who are forced to shoulder the high costs of medical mistakes in order to provide cheaper malpractice insurance for doctors who have made such medical errors. This would sadly take all day, which is hard to believe that this has gone so far. To me it just doesn’t seem right it makes the average American second guess there trip to the doctor or even just to get a cup of coffee. I like to feel safe, and Tort…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In my opinion, Tort reform will benefit both the patients and the medical practitioners, but it is more favorable for clinicians and health providers. It will benefit the patients because of its promised to reduced health care cost and better health care access. Tort reform has the potential to attract more physicians to continue their practice. According to the report, through tort reform, patients have greater access to specialists in high-risk fields of medicine, and more emergency room doctors are willing to be on call because their fears of lawsuits have been reduced (Roser, 2012). In the article title “Tort Reform Is Associated with Significant Increases in Texas Physicians Relative to the Texas Population”, states that after Texas Implemented…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Essay On Tort Reform

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is all about personal viewpoints. All it takes is one misunderstood detail to blow a case out of proportion. Reporters use facts from cases that can be interpreted in many different ways. These humorous and minute details are used to get publicity and are tarnishing the reputation of civil lawsuits. Lawsuits are very beneficial for the relationship between consumers and companies. It lets the companies know what consumers do and do not want from their company. There is a definite need for the tort reform, but no need to get rid of civil lawsuits all together. Putting caps on rewards should be enough. Getting rid of civil lawsuits would only anger the public. Every citizen has the right to speak his or her mind, even if it may seem petty. Being able to speak their mind is important to most people in society these days. If people received less in punitive damages, but were at least able to continue to file lawsuits, then there should not be that big of an issue. With having the tort reform, a large amount of money could be saved. There are a ton of other strategies to help the justice system save money. Taking out civil lawsuit could save money, but would hurt the economy in many other ways. Limiting lawsuits is not the answer to saving the economy…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays