Preview

The Pullman Case

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
903 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Pullman Case
In 1894 a strike known as ‘the Pullman strike’ took place. It was destructive and revolutionary, involving both the employees who protested and their employer, George Pullman. The employees felt that Pullman was taking advantage of them, so they joined the American Railroad Union (ARU). This caused a lot of mixed feelings and many people had different perspectives on the event. Several different views can be observed when analyzing this case and its consequences. All of these views can be analyzed by interpreting first-hand accounts and documents from the time of the incident. Wade Hampton was a former senator and governor of South Carolina. He wrote an article entitled, “Lessons of the Pullman Boycott from a Business Perspective.” Since he was apart of the American government, he was concernered with the labor force breaking what was stated in judicial law during the railroad boycott. His famous article opens with the statement that, “There can be no possible excuse for conduct such as that which has characterizered the acts of the lawless mobs, which, in defiance of all laws, divine and human, blindly and madly struck at the very foundation of all organized society, seemingly only intent on involving the whole country in common ruin.”(Hampton pg. 15). His statements clearly reflect a businessman’s opposition to employees joining a labor union. He believes that by them revolting against Pullman and his company they are being unfaithful as employees and are causing destruction in the country. Mr. Hampton makes a good point – there where better ways that existed for the employees to boycott against Pullman; ways in which they wouldn’t be destructive to railroads and other property than those that Pullman himself owned. Hampton’s own ties to the railroad make his reasons behind his views very obvious – monetarily and in reference to his retaining his reliable labour source. In addition, the audience for his article is the middle and upperclass American


Bibliography: "THE PULLMAN STRIKE. " Ohio Farmer (1856-1906) 12 Jul 1894: 30. APS Online. ProQuest. http://www.proquest.com/.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Altgeld Case Summary

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Pullman placed the blame on the workers who decided to go on strike, faulting them for the community’s suffering rather than admitting to his impossible living conditions. He obfuscates the reality with carefully selected students statistics and reports of monetary distribution through the company, masking the core issue so as to paint himself as merely a professional businessman with no ulterior…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In an 1875 world, run by corporations and narcissistic owners, workers found that as individuals, they were mute to the rest of the nation. They were mere workers in the anthill, ruled by numerous 'queens'. These workers rallied together in an attempt to scare the queens into submission of their demands. At first these uprisings had little to no effect on the corporate leaders, but slowly began to change work hours and average daily wages. Also, workers became less educated and with a reduction of skill in the workplace; the reason, workers didn't need to have a well-rounded knowledge of the product they were making, since they only had to work on specifics in the 19th century, onward. Not only did the strikes and unions bind one worker with another, they helped the workers to grow a substantial sense of audacity and fortitude, strengthening the nation as a society.…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American public supported big business in almost every conflict involving big business and labor unions. Perhaps had the Railroad Strike of 1877 turned out differently, things would have been different for laborers. This was the first major interstate strike in the US, and originally the public had been on the side of the workers. However they collectively “blew it” when they started vandalizing property and blocking the railroad tracks. As a consequence, Americans turned against the strikers, and federal troops were sent in to end the strike (Source B). More importantly, however, the public would from then on acquire a sour taste when someone mentioned “strike.” Things were exasperated in the early 1890s with the Panic of 1893. Although strikes by laborers were a relatively minor cause of the crash, laborers took the brunt of the blame. Being the worst economic crash the US had yet seen, it left Americans smoldering at workers for more than a decade. Newspapers were constantly on the side of big business as well. Thomas Nast, a well-known political cartoonist known for despising big business and exposing political corruption, ridiculed labor unions as well (Source C). The fact that both the American public and newspapers did not support labor unions meant that the American government didn’t either. The Railroad Strike of…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    APUSH DBQ1 Labor Unions

    • 1111 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the mid-1800s, the National Labor Union was formed to unify workers in fighting for higher wages, lowered work hours, and various other social causes. However, this sets the stage for many failing unions to come. One of the first major strikes in this period would include the Great Railroad Strike. In the late 1800s, railroad workers from across the country participated in an enormous strike that resulted not only in mass violence, but also very few reforms. An editorial in The New York Times stated: "[T]he strike is apparently hopeless, and must be regarded as nothing more than a rash and spiteful demonstration of resentment by men too ignorant or too reckless to understand their own interests…" (Document B). This editorial, which was clearly in favor of labor reforms, was acknowledging that this method of reform was unsuccessful for the laborers at this time. A failure of this magnitude so early on in the movement should have been enough cease its continuation; however, year after year, strikes were breaking and little was being done in the workers’ favor. Another major strike would be the Homestead Strike and Lockout. In the late 1800s,…

    • 1111 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As the American Civil War came to an end, an era of phenomenal economic growth was spurred by a second Industrial Revolution. It touched all geographic areas of America, evident in increased farm output and labor efficiency. The magnificent flow of goods generated could be efficiently transported by freshly lain transcontinental railroads made of Bessemer steel. Presiding over these late nineteenth century developments was a new class of extremely wealthy industrialists, the main beneficiaries of the era’s prosperity. They dominated substantial sectors of the new economy such as steel, oil, banking, and rail transportation. While these individuals created and donated outstanding wealth, they also engineered one of American history’s most corrupt and unequally heterogeneous time periods, dubbed the Gilded Age by Mark Twain. Such ambiguity blurs the legacy of these incredible few, who some call “robber barons” and other call “captains of industry”. However, neither polarity is completely accurate. The wealthiest Americans during the Gilded Age had both positive and negative effects on American society.…

    • 2538 Words
    • 73 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dbq Post Civil War

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Prosperous businessmen had immense influence and control over the post-Civil War economy and business in the United States. Even though large corporations led to the decrease in food, fuel, and lighting prices as illustrated in Document A, there were many small businesses and laborers who were left without jobs due to the dishonesty and domination from these large business owners. Document C describes how the manufacturing system has taken away the individualism and uniqueness of the workers craftsmanship. The worker is stuck doing one particular task until it is exhausted and that is the only trade skill they are left with. The system offers the hard worker no freedom or opportunity for advancement keeping them stagnant and stuck in the same place. The new manufacturing system brought about homogeneity and essentially destroyed uniqueness. For example, Henry Ford, the automobile tycoon, used the assembly line technique effectively in order to produce more cars at a cheaper price, which made them more cost effective. But in retrospect, the assembly line destroyed the pride men took in their work. The hours were growing longer, and the workers were bored and worn out. The people resented the long hard hours for little pay. This is what brought about the formation of labor unions. The workers way of fighting back and trying to change the rights of the people was the creation of a new political party and labor unions.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The rise of industrialization in the late nineteenth century saw an increasing need for the labor supply in the U.S. Quickly a division formed between the ownership of new businesses and those who supplied the labor for them. In the novel In Dubious Battle, John Steinbeck focuses on a strike set in the California apple country. Albeit historical fiction, the novel holds true as it represents the countless times ownership has exploited its workers in the avaricious attempt to secure additional revenues. As well, the novel examines the inner workings of a strike and the difficulties that went along with running one. A lack of resources, clearly defined goals, and in-fighting amongst members made an already arduous fight even more so difficult. It was the mistreatment and manipulation of workers that lead to the rise of labor movements and their battles for egalitarianism. Labor unions would come to be, such as the American Federation of Labor (AFL), which fought to advance the interests and basic human needs of workers through sheer numbers. Akin to the novel, these groups of workers took direct action as they participated in events like the Homestead and Pullman strikes. These feats taken by the labor supply demonstrate their motivations and goals, as well as the fact of how quickly problems developed for organized labor, and how those problems could mean the end for their fight. A two sided battle, organized labor faced stern opposition from ownership and the government, as well as from within itself; all making the critical task of obtaining “social equality” one of great significance and adversity.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beginning in the 1860’s, labor unions began to sprout in hopes of making reforms by unifying workers to fight for higher wages, and 8 hour work day, and various other social benefits. The National Labor Union (1866) was the first assembly established to take part in this fight. Strikes would have to be effective in order to initiate any major changes but at a time like this, more harm was being done than good. In 1877, many workers participated in the first great American strike which resulted in mass violence and little reforms. Afterwards, an editorial in the New York Times stated that “the strike is apparently hopeless, and must be regarded as nothing more than a rash and spiteful demonstration of resentment by men too ignorant or too reckless to understand their own interests…” (Document B) This editorial, which clearly favored labor unions, was acknowledging that…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    After being arrested a few days later after the fire in the rail yard, Eugene Debs released a statement about the protest. The Chicago Times issue on July 15, 1894, the headlines stated that Debs still think they could still win and said that battle has yet begun. The article went over his what he planned to do from then on, “I propose to work harder than ever before ,,, We must unite as strong as iron, but let us peaceable in this contest. Bloodshed is unwarranted and will not win. It is not by blood that we want to win” (Pullman Strike pdf, 75). Eugene Debs proposed that from then on he will work with all remaining people in the Union for a better cause for them in a peaceful action and not by violent intentions. With this final proposition he marked this day as an American Hero for labor workers and…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    This was the first industrial union in the united states. His movement was to get better treatment for unskilled workers on the railroad. The American Railway union attracted thousands of members. The workers aimed at the Great Northern railway, where not a wheel moved in 18 days, which lead to the railway to grant the demands of the workers. A couple of months later there was a new union sprung up (against Deb’s) advice to strike Pullman Palace car workers. The strike was aimed at boycotting all the cars in the railroad that were Pullman. There was great effect on the commerce in the western half of the nation from the strike and the Union. The United states military and the federal government got involved, to break up the…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Business was thriving, the economy was growing, and life as a whole was improving. However, there was a growing minority of workingmen whose long, difficult hours of toil were being taken advantage of by greedy, selfish employers. These poor men and their malnourished, destitute families compiled the backbone of the thriving economy. Without them, production as a whole would have been at a standstill and the growing quality of life for Americans would have been dampened. Yet these hard-working people received no recognition. On the contrary, they were sorely mistreated by their employers. Threateningly, this problem was growing vaster, until finally workers began to take a stand. Did they make any impact? Did the movement last? Throughout the decades, labor unions have shaped the state of the American economy and the value of the common…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In 1902 a group of horse and buggy drivers created the Teamsters Union, in that the Teamsters were employed to transport goods. This occupation has played an important part in the economic development of the United States. Although they worked under difficult circumstances at the turn of the twentieth century they began to unionize on an extensive scale. There was no established national organization until 1912 that the teamsters were secure. Back in those days certain crafts and professions were considered as public-interest endeavors, which were licensed and regulated by the town authorities. Included in the teamsters which started with cart-men were; doorkeepers, butchers, and bakers. With the public being so reliant on these crafts they showed a monopoly and the members would join in strikes, to change supply and demand so they could increase prices for their products. In addition, the strikes served the purpose in securing higher wages and fees for services, and to keep outsiders from operating in the same craft. The strikes came about as early as the seventeenth century, although there weren’t any conflicts between labor and management. Instead, the strikes represented demonstrations against local laws and directives and were aimed in influencing the actions of town councils.…

    • 5968 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Throughout the late 1800s, the growing tension between workers and their employers became increasingly apparent. As more and more people in Chicago agreed that they were being taken advantage of, it was expected that soon something would be done about it. On page 73 of Green’s Death in the Haymarket, he explains, “Everyone in Chicago knew that it would only take on bolt of lightning to set off a thunderstorm of protests…”1 This proved to be true as many Chicago socialists and anarchists grouped together and appointed Albert Parsons to compete for city council. While running for city counsil, he was able to meet people of similar interests such as August Spies. With leading men like Parsons and Spies, the workers imagined an optimistic outcome. Labor unions such…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Haymarket riot made a big impact all around the world. It drove people to distrust the labor Unions, but also violated the rights of men who were turned into martyrs by the government. This event caused much controversy, and is still argued about passionately to this day. During that time, there was also controversy over the labor unions. Many argued that they were “unAmerican” and unnecessary although the unions did ultimately reach their goals and are still helpful today.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Non-Violence

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages

    - - -. "The Newsboy 's Strike (1899)." WWW.ows.edb.utexas.edu. N.p., n.d. Web. 15 Jan. 2014. .…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays