Preview

The Vatican City State Should not be Recognized as a State

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
775 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Vatican City State Should not be Recognized as a State
The Vatican City State Should not be Recognized as a State Paolo Gabriele, the pope’s ex-butler who was sentenced for 18 months in prison because of leaking confidential documents of the Vatican to the press, was recently released. Pope Benedict XVI, who was both victim and supreme judge in the case, pardoned him for his actions. It seems that the Vatican applies quite a flexible law, different from how we know it, especially because there is no separation of powers: the Pope has not only the executive, but also the legislative and judicial power. Even more remarkable were the cases concerning pedophile priests, who were found guilty of raping children. They were trialed under canon law, which in the worst case means being excommunicated. Often these priests are moved to other countries and let off with an admonition. Moreover, the Vatican courts still use a medieval written procedure for its cases and do not make any use of modern facilities such as DNA-testing. Being a recognized state, the Vatican can make its own decisions. The question is, how the Vatican became a state, what it does as a state and why other countries accept this position. The roots of the Vatican becoming a state, can be found in the deal that was made between Mussolini and the Pope, in the Lateran Treaty, in 1929. Based on that treaty, the Holy See, the executive power of the Vatican, is still recognized under international law as a sovereign state, since it maintains diplomatic relations with 179 states. Though it is questionable if the Holy See indeed fulfills the criteria of statehood. One of the criteria is having a permanent population, yet, the population consisting of Swiss Guards, Cardinals, diplomats and employers of the Vatican all have their own nationality. On top of that, the population is not permanent, and often they do not live in the Vatican City State itself. The Holy See is a member-state in multiple international organizations and participates as an observer in


Cited: Keulen, van, Rosanne. "De macht van het vaticaan, een kijkje achter de schermen."HALO 1 (2011): 6 – 18. Print. Magister, Sandro. "Mission Impossible: Eject the Holy See from the United Nations." Chiesa. Sandro Magister, 21 Aug. 2007. Web. 2 Feb. 2013. . Robertson, Geoffrey . "The case against Vatican power." New Statesman[Blackfriars] 8 Sept. 2010: n.p..newstatesman.com. Web. 2 Feb. 2013. Smith-Spark, Laura, and Saskya Vandoorne. "Pope pardons ex-butler jailed over Vatican leaks." CNN [Atlanta] 23 Dec. 2012: n.p.. edition.CNN.com. Web. 2 Feb. 2013. De verborgen macht van het vaticaan. Dir. Gideon Levy. Perf. Gideon Levy. AVRO, 2011. Film.
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    To What Extend Was the Papacy Successful in Asserting Its Dominance over the Western Church?
    • 2243 Words
    • 9 Pages

    To What Extend Was the Papacy Successful in Asserting Its Dominance over the Western Church?

    The Pope is regarded as the successor of Saint Peter, the Apostle, and is the figure head of the Catholic Faith and as part of this role had a great deal of authority in Catholic doctrine. With this position of power the Pope was able to create and annul laws and decrees at will, which would then be followed by individual kings and states. One very important example of this was the Magna Carta created in 1215 which Pope Innocent III publicly condemned. Clanchy states that Innocent used the Magna Carta to highlight his authority as Pope, “To emphasize the authority of papal monarchy Innocent cited the text from Jeremiah.” From this, one can see how being the Pope means that there are certains aspects in which are automatically under papal control, such as in the case of creating or abolishing laws helping to assure dominance over the church.…

    • 2243 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Protestant Reformation Dbq Essay
    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Protestant Reformation Dbq Essay

    In the textbook, The Western Experience, Mortimer Chambers states, “Although the culmination of these disruptions did not come until the Reformation in the 1500s, the history of the previous two centuries made it clear that the institution was profoundly troubled” (Chambers 347). The Avignon Exile, in which the center of power of the Papacy moved from its historic home in Rome to the French city of Avignon undermined the institution’s legitimacy. Several successive Popes stated that, at the time, the Papacy could not be effectively controlled in Rome, even though they expressed desire to return, showcasing administrative weakness (Chambers 347). Seven months after the return of the Pope to Rome, a second Pope was named, prompting the Great Schism. Although the Council of Pisa succeeded in ending this conflict, there were still long-term consequences. Chambers argues that the Papacy’s close association with Italian politics degraded its universal appeal, particularly in Northern nations, “undermining the centrality of the papacy to the life of Europe” (Chambers 349). The political and cultural influence that the Papacy previously experienced all across Europe had eroded away. Most telling is that nations such as England, France, and Spain issued decrees limiting the Church’s authority in their territory. Chambers notes that these acts clearly, “document the decline of papal control over the international Christian community” (Chambers…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    How Did Christianity Influence Rome
    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages

    How Did Christianity Influence Rome

    In the imperialistic pyramid of power in Rome the Pope was above all peasants, knights, landowners, and patricians, putting him just below the king in power. The Pope slowly overtook individual government officials, basically working his way up the ladder. Now there were two players on the playing field, in a battle of power over the people’s influence, the Pope and the Roman government, the church vs. the state. Now that the Pope had power and influence over the church, the people, knights, landowners, patricians, and some of the government, his next goal was to try to overtake the highest level of government all on his own, the king himself. A Pope that has a great example of this is Saint Gregory VII.…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Ap European History Notes
    • 31049 Words
    • 125 Pages

    Ap European History Notes

    Roman–Catholic Church reformed papacy to exterminate corruption and prove the value in the Catholic Church.…

    • 31049 Words
    • 125 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Gregory VII: Dictatus Papae 1090
    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gregory VII: Dictatus Papae 1090

    Around the time period this source was written, the church was a big part of everyday life in Europe. Due to how highly the church was regarded, the Pope as the head would be the most influential. He was so powerful he could “by his command and consent, it may be lawful for subordinates to bring accusations”. However since today’s world the church is also still a big part of Europe but no to the extent as it was then. Religion has dwelled down and is not as highly regarded in society so not every cares for the church. So no matter the time every society has to control the power therefore there must be rules set. The Dictatus Papae was just that, the restriction of the Pope. Meanwhile in America we have regulations of our most influential person, the president. My problem with “Gregory VII: Dictatus Papae 1090” would be the fact it is unknown who set these rules, and even if we were to know, what gave them the right to declare what the Pope’s obligation should…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Were the Crusades Justified?
    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Were the Crusades Justified?

    In the case of the Crusades, the true jurisdictional limitation of the Church of Rome’s authoritative order was infinite beyond that of state or feudal control. It would seem that an “infinite jurisdiction” by any entity is unjust! The only possible rationale for having such unlimited authority would be an innate belief in “entitlement” or “unrestricted sovereignty.”…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    1776: Vatican City, Papal States
    • 1699 Words
    • 7 Pages

    1776: Vatican City, Papal States

    Vatican City, though relatively small, is swiftly growing and incessantly changing. Located inside the city of Rome within Italy, the Vatican, often referred to as the Holy See, is the world’s smallest state. (Holy See (Vatican City)) Vatican City is not only the world 's smallest independent state, however the workings of its administration and economic affairs are exceptional, similar to it’s non-commercially based economic construction, which does not conform to any model. Its exceptionally inimitable physical features continue to maintain an immense impact towards the country’s people and its great mixtures of customs and mores. (Vatican: The Holy See) Vatican City is the last remnant of the Papal States, which has been shaped by its long history, a history shaped by numerous forces, forces that continue to shape the way of life, and religion in the small state of The Vatican.…

    • 1699 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    The Unification of Italy
    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Unification of Italy

    The fact that the Pope controlled his own areas within ununified Italy without doubt compounded the process of forming a nation-state; who within Italy would invade the Papal…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Hand of God
    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Hand of God

    The documentary “Hand of God” was brisk and eye opening portrayal of child molestation of young boys carried out at the hands of Catholic Priest. For years many children have been quietly molested under the fallacy of protecting the Church. Paul Cultrera keep quiet about his victimization for years, which allowed for Father Birmingham to continue to molest others. There were a couple of theories that I felt applied to certain scenarios in this documentary while there were also others that I felt this documentary disproved.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Indian Givers
    • 86230 Words
    • 345 Pages

    Indian Givers

    National Catholic Reporter, frpr ii t uem t i f m m a ie“ h G ae…

    • 86230 Words
    • 345 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Separation of Church and State
    • 2853 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Separation of Church and State

    Throughout history, this topic has generated much of controversy. Ancient history is full of examples of the state or governing authorities interfering with religion. There were rulers or kings that assumed various “priestly” titles, like the “temporal” titles that their offices command. An example of such state-church mixing and melding, led to the execution of Socrates, for his disrespect for the gods( in Biblical times, like kings of Israel were anointed by Priests, as a sign of God’s approval. This is why separation of church and state is bad for America. For centuries, Monarchs ruled by the idea of divine right. This later metamorphosed into monarchs ruling over church’s administration in a way. There was this catholic doctrine that the Pope, as Vicar of Christ on earth, should have authority over the church on earth and indirectly over the state. This led to claims in the middle ages that the pope has authority to depose Catholic kings and they did try to exercise this authority. Thus in the medieval times in western world, monarch who ruled in secular world tend to encroach on the church’s rule of the spiritual sphere. This led to power struggles and crises. In the 1530s, Henry VIII, rejected the annulment of his marriage with Catherine of Aragon by the Pope. He consequently, formed the Church of England (Anglican Church) and set himself as the ruler of the new church, thus ending the separation that had existed between the church and the state of England. From that period on, the Monarchs of Great Britain have retained ecclesiastic authority in the Church of England with the title Supreme Governor of the Church of England. This eventually led to anti-Catholicism and others who were against The church of England, subsequently religious persecution. One of the results of the persecution was that some fled Great Britain in hopes of religious freedom to the American colonies.…

    • 2853 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    How Can a Church Full of Sinners Be Holy?
    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages

    How Can a Church Full of Sinners Be Holy?

    Catholicism has always been the religion with the highest incidence of followers in the world. The most traditional and one of the oldest beliefs is now so common that one often listens to people saying they are ‘non-practicing Catholics’, that is, one who is baptized in the Catholic Church but is not actively part of it. Non-Catholics are then sub-classified into two groups: those who do not belong to the Christian Society and those who call themselves Catholics as a matter of tradition, but have no knowledge about Christianity and its foundations. Furthermore, a fraction of this non-practicing society is characterized by people who were disappointed, those who are Catholics based on their faith only because they are just so discouraged by the Christian misconduct to commit. These people are not feeling betrayed without a reason. The history of Catholicism is marked by many scandals and questionable conduct adopted by members of the Clergy. Violence, murder and sexual abuse contradict all and every Christian principle and have gradually undermined Catholic faith.…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Vatican Council II: Changes In The Roman Catholic Church
    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Vatican Council II: Changes In The Roman Catholic Church

    In 1959, Pope John XXIII announced that there would be a Vatican Council II, and Vatican Council II would start in 1962 and make tremendous changes in the Roman Catholic Church. Vatican I started in 1869, and it made minimal changes to the Roman Catholic Church. Vatican I only lasted one year. Vatican II started in 1962 and went to 1965 lasting nearly three years. Vatican Council II made numerous changes to the Roman Catholic Church, and most of the changes we still use to this day. Vatican Council II, also known as Vatican II, produced several changes in the Church that consist of the following: The Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy, The Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the World of Today, documents of the duties of the bishop, documents…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    A Comparative Analysis of State and Church Relations in Mussolini's Italy and Hitler's Germany
    • 3599 Words
    • 15 Pages

    A Comparative Analysis of State and Church Relations in Mussolini's Italy and Hitler's Germany

    The unification of Italy saw a restructuring of Italian government and power. Prior to the late 1800’s Italy didn’t function as a nation with a central power base, it was a network of small independent provinces, with Pope Pius IX being the only authority with power extended beyond the province.…

    • 3599 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Papal Visit
    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Papal Visit

    They had been chosen by the papal visit commitee led by the Apostolic Nuncio Giuseppe Pinto and archbishop of Manila, Luis Antonio Cardinal Tagle. Their restaurants was apparently known to Pinto, who would dine at Chef Jessie.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More

Related Topics