Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Thomas Jefferson and his Slave Dilemma

Good Essays
714 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Thomas Jefferson and his Slave Dilemma
Thomas Jefferson and his Slave Dilemma During the time of Thomas Jefferson, slavery was a difficult topic of discussion. Speaking to Thomas Jefferson about this would have probably gave him feelings of awkwardness and maybe guilt. Being a major defender of the American planter and being a major leader of America, Thomas Jefferson opposed the continuation of slavery for reasons of the looming notions of slave rebellion, yet he did not believe slavery should be abolished immediately nor should the slaves live in America for long should they become emancipated. As a slave-owner himself, Thomas Jefferson said to have studied Blacks. While he made the conclusion that there is much more information needed, he once made the argument that Blacks are intellectually inferior. He said that while Blacks have memories just as sharp as Whites, they do not have the calculative or creative talents as Whites. Thomas Jefferson considers Native Americans to be more worthy of admiration than Blacks, deeming them a more capable race of people. In spite of these negative thoughts, Thomas Jefferson still believes Blacks to be an innocent race. In fact, he doesn’t approve of the agony some other slave owners would deal upon their slaves. With such thoughts of the Black race in mind, what does Jefferson want this race to do? Jefferson essentially wishes the Black race the best despite apparently not having the intellectual capacity his race has; he wants the Blacks to comprehend the concept of work since work is the essential means to live. Being an innocent race to his eyes, Jefferson believes slavery to be a detrimental concept. He had even made a theory that slavery would not last for very long. Being a wealthy planter, Jefferson comprehends the reason for slavery- the reason being that it yielded economic benefit and was a staple for the construction of America. Conversely, Jefferson had known of the evils of slavery. Slaves being battered, whipped, raped, mutilated, executed, etc. ought to have occupied the mind of the likes of Jefferson. And the notions of a rebellion sound all the more terrible for the American planter. Even if slaves are emancipated, he did not believe that the Black and White race would be able to co-exist well in America. Should Blacks become free, Jefferson would have wanted them to be shipped back to Africa or the Caribbean. These thoughts could be the reasons for his opposition to the continuation of slavery. As far as this has went, how much merit does Thomas Jefferson has to qualify a controversial subject as he did, especially being a slave owner himself? This is for anyone’s deduction. Being a founding father, president (dubbed the Negro President), intellectual, writer of one of the most famous and important documents of American History, slave owner, lover of slave women, father of illegitimate children, and arguably deist, what outweighs what? Despite his thoughts and notions of Blacks compared to Whites, he did believe that abolition was a necessity for America to prosper. This shows that while slavery was rampant in these days of old, there was hope that the American mindset would change soon enough. The epic degree of credibility it actually had for a wealthy slave owner revered by many to say that slavery is not right and not good for America should have cause a culture shock. This is one of America’s iconic heroes. Such a stance against what was at that time America’s way might have ruined Jefferson’s reputation. No wonder Jefferson did not wanted his honest viewpoints published. Jefferson was neither the first nor the last to have these viewpoints. Abraham Lincoln, in particular, had similar viewpoints. Despite having a contradicting viewpoint that yield a dimension of hypocrisy on Jefferson’s part, the most important idea out of this is his thought as an American Intellectual that slavery should not last. He said what he thought of Blacks and he said they should go back from where they came, but after all this, he was said to give some of his slaves permission to “escape” his estate while emancipating a few other slaves. If anything was gained from this, Jefferson’s thoughts on slavery was a step in the sequence that led to the abolition of slavery.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Banneker calls Jefferson “sir” multiple times to show him that he respects his opinions and his status as a person. This, in turn, will make Jefferson more open-minded about his argument and take his words into consideration without Jefferson getting too offended by Banneker’s words. Banneker also uses modest language such as “I entreat you” and “suffer me” that will not cause Jefferson to become defensive or completely reject the points of his argument. Benjamin Banneker also proves his respect for Jefferson by validating that he did something good and he gives Jefferson an opportunity to reflect on why he tried to make the lives of the enslaved people better in the first place: “you clearly saw the injustice of slavery which you had just apprehensions of the horrors of its condition, that you publickly held forth this true and valuable doctrine” (15-20). This particular diction proves to Jefferson that Banneker views him as a leader and someone of high status, but also shows him that they are all human beings and everyone deserve the same treatment. He uses certain phrases like “groaning captivity and cruel oppression” so that Jefferson can understand how slaves are treated and the horrors that they experience daily, proving his point that the treatment of slaves is unjust and abhorrent…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Jefferson was very anti-slavery throughout his life. Jefferson would call it “moral depravity” and a “hideous blot”, he believed slavery was one of the greatest threat to the American nation. He knew that slavery was contrary to the laws of nature, which states that every person has the right to personal liberty. Thomas Jefferson held indigenous people in good views, he saw them as subjects of intellectual curiosity and believed they were enemies in war. Thomas Jefferson’s lengthy public career during a formative time period granted him to shape the relations between the United States and the numerous Indian nations during the eighteenth and even the nineteenth centuries.…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Banneker insinuates his oppression of slavery by analyzing Jefferson’s actions towards slavery. He evaluates Jefferson point of view of how he clearly say the “injustice of slavery.” Banneker wants to call attention to the fact that Jefferson is aware…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jefferson treated his slaves in a harsh manner. For instance, he “‘had [James Hubbard, a captured runaway slave,] severely flogged in the presence of his old companions’”(Takaki 56). Jefferson also punished slaves in “ter-rorem” to others and sold them away to slave traders, making it seem as though the slave got killed (Takaki 56). He instilled…

    • 2363 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Jefferson on Race and Slavery Thomas Jefferson writes his plan for how to end slavery within the colonial united states. He believed that slavery was unjust but still kept his viewpoint of whites and blacks being unequal in mind or physical characteristics. Therefore, he believed that because the two were different they could not unify together to form a cohesive nation.…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From history, it is already known that slavery isn’t outlawed for a while after this letter was written, but there is still hope that Jefferson fully considered this letter and acknowledged this man’s education and courage to stand up for his people. Banneker proves through this letter that his rhetorical devices and sophisticated diction make him an equal intellectual to all of the wealthy, educated, white…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Before Thomas Jefferson was known as the third president of the United States he was elected as the first secretary of state by George Washington. He was the second youngest member delegate in the second continental congress at Philadelphia in which he was selected for drafting the Declaration of independence which is a part of our nation’s constitution to which he acquires a lot of his fame. He was also very well known for the three-fifths comprise which is one of the many analytical highlights discussed in the Negro President by Gary Wills. His personal life also became a scandal and his views on slavery which John C. Miller elaborates on events in his life in the book Wolf By The Ears: Thomas Jefferson and Slavery. However his ultimate legacy was the founding of the University of Virginia.…

    • 3223 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jefferson really wanted to move westward and begin to gain all of that land. He was willing to work with the Indians but, they did not want to work with him. They had one way of viewing what they had and the way that they were suppose to live. That was to have as much land as possible so that they could hunt and properly provide for the tribe. Jefferson had the solution of trying to expand their thinking. He wanted to teach them how to be farms and grow things. They did not need all of that land to live. If they would begin to plant things and raise stock they would not have to hunt. It may be nice for them to hunt every now and then but, at that point there was still no need for a lot of land. Jefferson was thinking if he could convince the…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In fact, one of his major flaws was an unfortunate excellence in Hypocrisy. Although Jefferson was one of the main supporters of the anti-slavery movement, he was an avid slave-owner and slave-trader. It is surprising that voters did not see this as a negative trait in Jefferson, enough to the point to vote for the other of the candidates; it must have been Hamilton's strict interpretation of the current matters of the time that pushed voters away from Hamilton and toward Jefferson. While Jefferson was very against slavery, he also was involved in what is now called the ‘Sally Hemings Controversy'. Contained in this scandal is the question of whether or not Jefferson fathered any of Sally Hemings', one of Jefferson's slaves, children. Certain, later discovered, biological evidence would link Jefferson's Y-Chromosome to that of the child(ren) in question. In any event, it is plain to see that Jefferson displayed blatant and ridiculous hypocrisy in that he was so against slavery, to the point where he put a bill that would abolish any new acquisition of slaves in the state of Virginia. At the same time, he had slaves of his own. And to top it all off, he fathered the children of one of his 180-odd slaves. Apparently, Jefferson was also excellent in…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I believe jefferson meant what he said when he said that “all men were created equal.” The reason I believe he meant what he said was because he tried to make living conditions and labor better for slaves. But I don’t…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Inequality

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages

    His argument is that “the real distinctions which nature has made; and many other circumstances, will divide us into parties, and produce convulsions, which will probably never end but in the extermination of the one or the other race”(Jefferson 552). Jefferson is stating that there is a barrier between whites and blacks and sooner or later the superior race will be the only race. This connects to Henrietta because although Hopkins treats African Americans, they are still segregated and are not given the correct treatments and that is the barrier. Jefferson also states “in general, their existence appears to participate more of sensation than reflection” and that is not true because Henrietta's cells were an amazing discovery and has contributed to many vaccines and discoveries regarding medication and illnesses so her participation was more than sensation (Jefferson 553). Another contradiction is Jefferson claims that “...they are inferior in the faculties of reason and imagination, must be hazarded with great diffidence” which is also not true because Henrietta for example was a confident and loving woman who loved to have fun and was far from shy. Jeffersons claims were merely out of racist views rather than actual facts. His claims had no evidence, there was no support for his words and the base of all issues were of race and not actual…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Thomas Jefferson among others shined light on his education in law. When he conjured up the Declaration of Independence. Jefferson used natural rights and religious liberty to enlighten people as he wrote the Declaration. Jefferson presented Americans as self-governing people that “All men are created equal”. Through his importance on equality, Jefferson didn’t agree on slavery and believed that people enslaved were deprived. His views were that all people were equal and his humanism views were not like his other counterparties. Jefferson’s views on the issue was in good remarks however, there was no mention on the equality of slavery or even blacks. This one-sided issue makes you question this truth. Because in fact more than a fifth of the…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The primary writer of the Declaration of Independance and one of the most prominent figures of the early history of America, Thomas Jefferson is one name that almost every American should have at least heard of by now. In the past, I have been taught that Thomas Jefferson was an abolitionist who believed that slavery was immoral, but his racism towards African Americans (and his idea of white superiority) was very surprising to me. He seemingly wants slavery to end (while owning many slaves himself) but also believes that, “It is not against experience to suppose, that different species of the same genus, or varieties of the same species, may possess different qualifications.” He states that African Americans are of a different species, and later remarks…

    • 1933 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The use of slavery to paradoxically define American freedom is first shown by the use of Jefferson, the “slaveholding spokesman of freedom”(Morgan). His attitude toward slavery can be shown in two ways. The first of which is debt. Debt is a force that can hold down any free man and this was why Jefferson hated debt so much. As a planter, he was basically forced into debt and resisted giving up his slaves until he found his freedom from that debt. He did not care about the freedom of his slavery as he did for his own. Jefferson also stated that a nation would be very fertile for tyranny if the men of a nation did not have enough land or money to support their families. This is paradoxical because the slaves live in a world of tyranny where the master is there monarch and the slave has no land or money to support their families. His second dislike was artisans. He stated that they lived dependent lives because they were dependent on the customer and had no other business or land to fall back on. Jefferson, on the other hand, liked farmers because they were very independent and always had a source of income. Jefferson states “the man who depended on another for his loving could never be truly free” (Morgan). This shows that Jefferson is willing to fight for the artisans who are dependent but does not want to forgo his slaves. Although freedom was rising for those who were dependent on others, the same dependent slaves had no improvements in liberty.…

    • 670 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Jefferson had many accomplishments but he is a hypocrite. Thomas Jefferson disagreed with the whole slavery ordeal yet he owned slaves. He didn’t make an effort to change people’s views on owning slaves. Thomas Jefferson had children with a slave by the name Sally Hemmings. She was seven – eighths white and one – eighth black. She had 6 children with Thomas Jefferson. He kept his children and treated them as slaves. He owned around 300 slaves at one point. He set his children and skilled workers as runaways so they can be free in the north. Thomas Jefferson set rewards for the captures of the runaway slaves. This symbolizes that although he freed the slaves they still weren’t totally free. He is a hypocrite for not believing in the ownage of slavery yet he beared slave children.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays