The story is set in late afternoon to early evening in a park in Paris, France. It concludes in the later evening in the individual homes of the characters. What is interesting about these settings is the opportunity for a romantic liaison. The reader has to wonder if it doesn't come to pass because the characters are older, "In younger people it might have been a day for a chance encounter-secret behind the long barrier of perambulators with only babies and nurses in sight. But they were both of them middle-aged, and neither was inclined to cherish an illusion of possessing a lost youth,"¦" Or if it was because of the time period the story was set in (late 70's?) and the free love movement had never hit their age bracket. "Modesty and disillusion gave them something in common' though they were separated by five feet of green metal they could have been a married couple who had grown to resemble each other.
This story is told from an omniscient third party's point of view. The narrator presents a few different conflicts throughout the story, but the major one is the conflict each character has within themselves. For Henry, does he tell Marie-Claire of his wife who tries his patience "" Patient? Does he maybe take the chance of being physical with Marie-Claire? Does she even want him to be anything but the gentleman she perceives him to be? For Marie-Claire, she finds herself in a horrible sham called a marriage. Does she confide in Henry? Does she linger over cocktails at the end of the evening to prolong what has probably been one of the happier evenings of her life in recent memory? The narrator also hints at the sex lives of these characters. Did Henry just make love to his wife that morning? "You want me to sleep so that I won't expect anything. That's it, isn't it, you're too old now to do it twice." (Is it making love or just having sex?) Poor Marie-Claire is married to a man who seems to prefer men to her. Even in the late 70's, people had to be worried about AIDS; I doubt she would let him touch her! There is really interesting language in this story. As mentioned earlier, the tone is sad and goes hand in hand with pitiful, as you feel sorry for these two characters. The first example of language crosses over between symbolism and irony. Each of them goes home to sleep in a twin or single bed, yet both of them are married. The single bed symbolizes the passionless relationships they both exist in. The irony also lies in the sexual aspect where, because they wouldn't delve deeper into each other's lives "" even though it was obvious they wanted to "" they both missed out on a romantic interlude. Maybe, if they had realized they had so very much unhappiness in common, they could have changed their situations.
Symbolism also mixes with imagery in this story. The obvious imagery is in the beginning where they describe Henry's moustache. ""¦with his silky old-world moustache like a badge of good behavior"¦" You can imagine a big, but neatly trimmed, busy moustache as the center feature of his face. Maybe similar to an English gentleman of yesteryear. But the imagery and symbolism I really like are the words Graham Greene paints for us as they each enter their domicile. "Marie-Claire walked through the self-opening doors and thought, as she always did, of airports and escapes." The imagery shows us that long before she even meets the charming Henry, Marie-Claire has had thoughts of escaping her unhappy life. Airports, especially, symbolize escape as one usually does not get on an airplane unless they are taking a longer trip then one might undertake by car. As she enters and the first thing she sees is the abstract painting she seems to detest, we see imagery of her feelings reflected in the narrator's description. "An abstract painting in cruel tones of scarlet and yellow faced the door and treated her like a stranger." Marie-Claire only feels like a stranger in this house/flat. Because the picture was painted by one of her husband's many assignations, Marie-Claire feels that it mocks her. It seems to symbolize all she dislikes of her life in that place. Interesting also, is the "little stone phallus with painted eyes that had a place of honor in the living-room." It symbolizes her husband's preference for penises as opposed to the soft curves of a woman.
Henry greets his wife, Patience, and ironically puts up with her impatient tone and sarcastic imaginations. The cigarette burns on the pillow make the reader believe this woman very seldom leaves her home, let alone the bed. She obviously has an elixir to help her sleep and he mixes it up with water encouraging her to drink it. Their dialogue is telling, "You want me to sleep so that I won't expect anything. That's it, isn't it, you're too old to do it twice." These words tell the reader that even if they have a sex life, Henry is in no hurry to repeat the deed that was apparently done in the morning. He would rather sit back and relive his evening with Marie-Claire. ""Luckily this would not be one of their worst nights, for she drank from the glass without further argument, while he sat beside her and remembered the street outside the brasserie and how "" by accident he was sure "" he had been called "tu"." The ultimate irony is how Marie-Claire and Henry come together, once again, in the end of the story. This time their chance meeting is esoterically in their minds. Henry sits back and thinks, "I was only thinking that things might have been different," he said. It was the biggest protest he had ever allowed himself to make against the condition of life." Marie-Claire, as she inserts her earplugs to block her dallying husband, ""¦and she shut her eyes and thought how different things might have been if fifteen years ago she had sat on a bench in the Parc Monceau, watching a man with pity killing a pigeon." Where were you when I could have loved you"¦"¦..?"
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
As I said above this is a classical love story where two girls fall in love with the same guy. The setting of this story was taken place in the fictional town of Starkfield, Massachusetts on the coldest days. The days were cold and dark just as Ethan and Zeena were sad and apart from each other.…
- 426 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the story Henry’s father stops speaking to him after he finds out about Henry’s friendship with Keiko. Henry’s mother tries to go along with her husband, but she still acknowledges Henry’s existence by bringing him letters from Keiko and making his favorite foods. In the text it says, “After a few days his mother did acknowledge his existence, in her own way. She did his laundry and packed him a lunch” (Ford 186). This shows that even though she knows that Henry has disobeyed his father and done something unforgivable, she still loves him and is willing to take care of him. His father has completely shut him out. She is willing to go against him to help…
- 569 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Margot’s relationship with her husband, Raleigh, mirrors Franny’s relationship with her boyfriend, Lane: distant not-exactly lovers, “prestigious” males that don’t understand their partners. When Raleigh…
- 500 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Henry is independent and takes care of himself along with his wife. He is slowly losing his independence due to health related issues. He is alert and oriented x3. He had a stable job in his past. He is also making responsible plans for him and his wife’s future that will benefit them.…
- 451 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Point of view helps display the ‘situation’ or ‘baby-problem’ that corrupted their relationship. This story is narrated in third person which gives the readers information and insights of the couple. For example, “the woman came out through curtains… ‘Train comes in five minutes’ she said… ‘What did she say’ asked the girl?” Both the stage directions and scenery description released an insight that the man is older than the girl by years and appearance might express the obvious. The story quoted, “did not say anything but looked at the bags against the wall of station. They were labels on them from all the hotels where they had spent nights”. Specifically, ‘spend nights’ were mention instead of ‘spend days’ top conclude that they had ‘slept together’ consistently with a mutual agreement. It wasn’t a public and emotional relationship but a physical, sexual one. It seems like this story was a simple girl who looks for love in older man because she must have not receive or had a ‘father figured’…
- 689 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The relationship with his father allows him to think for himself. Growing up without a strong parental figure teaches him to become an independent man. The close bond Henry shares with Keiko teaches him to cherish those close to him. The final relationship that has an impact on Henry is the one he shares with his son, Marty. They endure numerous life changes together starting with the loss of Ethel and continuing with arrival of Samantha. Through it all, they regain the close bond which was missing from their lives. The relationships that Henry encounters have their ups and downs. He learns many life lessons from them, much like children learning to use a…
- 1179 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In chapter fourteen lt. Henry's relationship with Mrs. Gage proves that Henry doesn't love Catherine, but is lustful for what she is capable of sexually, and nurturingly, and believes this to be love. Within the first paragraph Lt. Henry recalls looking at a woman , mrs. gage, and although he does claim that she is "not so pretty" by drawing his attention to her looks in the first place, involved with Catherine or not, one can note that he is on the prawl for something he does not recieve in his relationship wih Catherine. While peering into the conversational difference in the dialogue between Lt. Henry and mrs gage, and lt Henry and Catherine,…
- 1317 Words
- 6 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
7. Henry told her not to write notes, but the whole time he wanted her to he was just testing her to see if she would do what another person told her to do. He wants her to be her own man.…
- 863 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
have had a knock, somehow." In this parts of story we can see that Miss Brill might be…
- 905 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the short story, “Wilhelm” by Gabrielle Roy, true love is put to the test and undergoes great scrutiny. Through perseverance and the power of love, true love can conquer all obstacles in its path. The story starts with the main character, a daughter of oppressive parents who has forbidden her to see and talk to Wilhelm, an immigrant employed as a chemist in a small paint factory. Her stern parents went to great lengths to prevent communication between Wilhelm and their daughter and implemented various tactics to thwart their plans of crossing paths with each other. The inspirational story of perseverance is told through the eyes of the daughter, the main character, making it in the first person point of view. The story takes place in Quebec, on the streets, at the main character’s home, and it all started at the O’Neills’ residence, a large gabled house located on Rue Desmeurons. One evening at the O’Neills’ house, the main character meets Wilhelm. It was a typical, musical night at the residence and the main character was asked to play Paderewski’s “Minuet”; and was then followed by a performance by Wilhelm on his violin. Over time, their relationship developed until one day, Wilhelm started accompanying and escorting her home from school. When her mother discovered who it was accompanying her daughter home, she forbade her from returning to the O’Neills, so long as she had not got over the chivalrous Wilhelm. Wilhelm, being as intelligent as he is, now finishes work earlier and waits for the main character at the covent door. Upon her coming through the door, he carried all her homework and books – including music sheets, and metronomes all the way to the corner of her street. Soon enough, her mother finds out about Wilhelm accompanying her home and carrying her books and prohibits her daughter from ever seeing Wilhelm again. Attempting to defend herself, she tells her mother that she can’t prevent him from even walking on the same sidewalk as her. Upon…
- 657 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The narrative essay "A Strange Love Affair," written by Jan Myrdal takes place during the 1940's however, it wasn't until the 1960's that it got published. Myrdal writes about a married man that reconnects with his first love. Not only that, he almost commits adultery in having sex with this women, but turns down B because of the reason that he loves his wife. He tries to cover up his doubts by saying that his feet stink because of a long journey through Sweden.But in the end the B understands and they have a long talk about self soul and love. The author makes a clear message towards a younger audience about marriage and the importance of commitment and also the overall consequences of love. Myrdal was also successful in appealing to his expected audience.…
- 634 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Henry bullies his cousin Mark by forcing him to do things he does not always think are right. This is even demonstrated the first night Mark was at Henrys house, by repeatedly kicking him…
- 1284 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
This book has been structured into 2 parallel stories, and they both collide into each other story. In Henrys life he breaks down in his car outside of Strattford where Andy used to live before going to war and passing away. Henry meets and becomes very close (in the end) with Andy’s great granddaughter, Janine, who introduces him to Andy’s diary, written whilst in war. Henry also meets and is very interested with her stories, Miss H who is at a very old age, which is also known as Cecelia in Andy’s story as he fiancé but they have problems and call off the engagement due to Andy knocking up another women named Francis-Jane. At the end Henry and Janine go to visit a cemetery in France incorporating Andy’s grave where he attended the World War one and was shot dead.…
- 477 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
4. The perspective of a 40 year old amidst a mid-life crisis is displayed in Woody Allen’s ‘Midnight in Paris’, and the themes of belonging to time and place are expressed throughout the film. The themes express to the audience that many people (in this case Gil) can feel confined in the time period or situation in life that they may be in. Gil needs to escape from his life, and is able to do this at midnight in Paris by entering into a perhaps imaginary world…
- 1608 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Living with his wife and the doll Henry, the narrator becomes more and more jealous and starts hating both of them, especially Henry with his well-bred smile. He is very aware of the fact that his wife loves and appreciates Henry the doll more than him and that Henry is better looking than him, which he himself says, "In our tiny kitchen he towered above my puny height of five foot nothing. He looked handsome and smart with his green vinyl suit and firm jaw" (ll. 13-14 p. 2). You can tell by her tone when she speaks with her husband that she does not love and appreciate her husband as much as she loves and appreciates Henry. This is also seen in the quote "HERE, LET ME DO IT. You’re useless"(ll. 3 p. 2)”. She says that he is useless, which she also mentions several times through the story.…
- 1155 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays