Preview

Was Joan Of Arc A Heretic?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1096 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Was Joan Of Arc A Heretic?
Was Joan of Arc a Heretic?
The Hundred Years’ War provided a backdrop for the power struggle between the French Prince, Charles VII of France and the English King, Henry VI of England for the French throne (Barlow, Andrews and Pickering 2018, p.3). Initially, the English had the upper hand however towards the end of the war, the French were victorious; riding the English from most of France (Cantor 1999, p.233). This was largely due to the leadership of Joan of Arc who believed that she was the recipient of visions from Christian Saints. They would go on tell her to dress as a man and fight for Charles VII to be crowned the rightful king of the French throne and to reclaim France from Henry VI of England who ruled northern France (Barlow, Andrews
…show more content…
The English were humiliated by Joan’s victories against them; a rural farm girl rendering the great English army powerless, they were determined to exact their ‘revenge’ on her. By charging and executing Joan for heresy and witchcraft, the English were ensuring that their reputations would remain intact and that Joan would no longer pose a treat for the throne. Through linking Joan’s leadership abilities to witchcraft and ultimately undermining her success; the English would be able to exploit the publics’ fear of the supernatural and would be able to recover from the humility of being defeated by a girl. And so, these incentives alone would push the English to find any piece of ‘incriminating’ evidence to send Joan to “…suffer a painful public death,”, “…lay[ing] out enormous amounts of money to guarantee that she was burnt,”, all too eager to “…light the fire under her feet when she was finally executed.” (Nash-Marshall 1999, p.22). Despite inquisitorial trials having to be based upon a diffamatio - charges that were established well before the trails was to begin, the basis of Joan’s trial was solely to be based upon her interrogation alone, “…without anyone, including the accused herself, knowing what charge was being brought against her.”; showing just how much the English wanted to prosecute Joan, seeing as they called a trial with no real …show more content…
First was when she went to the French prince, Charles, to convince him to reclaim the whole of France, second was during her trial with the English and the third was in 1456 when a “…papal commission reversed the verdict…” of the English inquisition, 25 years after her execution (Lackland 1999, p.264). Out of all 3 investigations, Joan was only ever deemed a heretic once; when she was on trial against the English inquisition. If indeed, Joan was the “…sorceress, diviner, false prophetess, [and] conjurer of evil spirits…” (Trial ex. 1) that her Promoter, Jean D’Estivet, accused her of being; how was she declared an actual saint in 1920 (Lackland 1999, p.264)? This, I believe, is the most significant evidence in proving that the English’s trial was driven solely on the basis of political gain rather than religious merit; as being condemned as a heretic and being canonized as a saint could not be further

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Joan of Arc- A peasant girl that convinced the French government the dauphin needed to be crowned and to expel the English out of France. She dressed as a man and fought in the war, but was caught and burned at the stake for being a witch.…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1600’s rumors of witchcraft spread throughout England and even more so in New England. Though punishing someone by death for practicing witchcraft was not unheard of, it was all but common; that is, until the year 1692 in Salem, Massachusetts. From the tenth of June to the twenty-second of September, twenty men and women were killed, all by hanging except one, because they were accused and convicted of practicing witchcraft; the convictions escalated in number and frequency. The question at hand is whether or not these convictions came unwarranted and if not, why? What caused such hysteria of witchcraft in this small city?…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It seems that every hundred years or so a new fear develops. Right now, in the 21st century the fear is terrorism and war. In the 20th century it was world expansion and industrialization. Yet all else aside, in the 16th and 17th century, witches were the ones to fear. In this essay I will discuss the characteristics of an “alleged” witch, methods used to insure a person practiced witchcraft, and the treatment of the ones accused.…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Arguably, what we do not understand is how could the community believe every single word the young girls uttered in the first place? Surely, children are known for their imagination, so what was the reasoning behind trusting the girls and many other accusers and the deaths of many? It is peculiar how no one stood up and questioned whether the children should or should not be trusted. So many deaths may have originally been caused by children's...imagination. Document A is a chart of those who were killed on the trials. This shows how the community permitted the witchcraft trials go out of hand. Many lives could have been saved, if only the community had been more wary of the children. It was nothing but the ignorance of the community that led to the hanged deaths. Furthermore in Document C, the examination of Bridget Bishop, subjective words were used to exaggerate actions. This proves that the community, including Samuel Parris, trusted the accusers enough to kill the accused victims without much solid evidence. Worse yet, Document D, a piece of Charles' writing, reveals that they community was blind enough to believe the accusers. "Once or twice they were caught in their own snare; and nothing but the blindness of the community saved the most...from well deserved punishment." This quote determines the populations wrong…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Joan of Arc, nicknamed "The Maid of Orléans," was born in 1412 in Domrémy, Bar, France. A national heroine of France, at age 18 she led the French army to victory over the British at Orléans. Captured a year later, Joan was burned at the stake as a heretic by the English and their French collaborators. She was canonized as a Roman Catholic saint more than 500 years later, on May 16,…

    • 73 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Year of Wonders Quotes

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages

    ‘There was no doubt that she did good... yet her fornication and blasphemy branded her a sinner in the reckoning of our religion,’ p. 55.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Henry Vs Patho

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Sure Henry is a very honorable king but he comes from the state of power and he would have been fine if he didn’t do anything about the french. Joan never was on top. Her pull on the pathos string makes us want to root for her. It's the underdog story that automatically turns her into a hero and the people that try to take her down the villains. When in reality she probably looked like this crazy farm girl who thought she could lead an army. Joan stands for what she believes and that is what makes it such an amazing story. She says, “If you tear me limb from limb until you separate my soul from my body you will get nothing out of me beyond what I have told you. What more is there to tell that you could understand? Besides, I cannot bear to be hurt; and if you hurt me I will say anything you like to stop the pain. But I will take it all back afterwards; so what is the use of it?”(Saint Joan scene VI). This pulls at the pathos string because she is laying into them what she believes and isn’t giving up. Because of this story it makes her more persuasive than King Henry.…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a part of human nature, people tend to feel secure when they can explain an unexpected situation. In the 17th century, people had not yet possessed enough knowledge to explain as many natural phenomena as we do now, and that was probably when the concept “witchcraft” came in as an answer key to all unexplainable things. And, of course, with little knowledge about how “witchcraft” worked, people were generally afraid of this concept. The Trial of Tempel Anneke collects primary sources from that period of time and gives us an idea about so-called “witch-hunt of early modern Europe” and people’s attitude towards witchcraft, most of which was considered harmful.…

    • 734 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During this time, citizens were accused of being witches and were tired and found guilty without having being able to testify on their behalf. All that was needed to accuse someone of witchcraft was a third-party accusation and that was enough to get them arrested. The members of the jury were not impartial and if one person believed the accused was a witch, that’s all that was needed (Urofsky, 2011). Nineteen people were hung, one man crushed to death because he did not confess to be guilty (Carey, 2012) or not and countless others were locked away in jails where some of them died (Carey, 2012). The farmers used this as a main driving point to ensure that a tragedy like this wouldn’t happen…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Joan Of Arc Thesis

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Joan of Arc was one of the most influential and historical females of the 15th century. At the time of Joan of Arc’s birth, France was involved in a long-running war with England known as the Hundred Years’ War. Her journey through this war eventually led France to an astonishing victory over England. But it wasn’t she alone who helped her through this but God himself. She claims at an early age to have heard a Saint of God inform her of her destiny to “drive out the English from France and bring about the coronation of Charles VII to the throne.” (Thurston 1910) Months had passed until finally her visions came into place. She had made alliances with Jean de Metz and Bertrand de Poulengy…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Salem Witch Trials Essay

    • 894 Words
    • 3 Pages

    An infamous episode in American history, the Salem witch trials of 1692 resulted in the execution by hanging of fourteen women and five men accused of being witches. In addition, one man was pressed to death by heavy weights for refusing to enter a plea; at least eight people died in prison, including one infant and one child; and more than one hundred and fifty individuals were jailed while awaiting trial. Due to the survival of many relevant records, including notes, depositions, and official rulings, the main facts of the accusations, arrests, trials, and executions are known. What has always engaged scholars is the search for the causes of the "witch hysteria." The proffered explanations for the witchcraft occurrence are many and conflicting. In this essay I will explain when the Salem witch trials started, how it’s relevant to our lives today, and also what caused it.…

    • 894 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She also lied to get people killed, using her loyal clan of children to follow her orders as so-called ‘proof’ for the court. Our court can also be held accountable as ever since they began relying on the conniving children’s testimonies, it has become unscrupulous. Their declarations cannot be validated because witchcraft is ‘ipso facto,…an invisible crime (Page 90),’ and the officials of the court are so gullible and eager for a scapegoat that they ‘dare not quail to follow wherever the accusing finger points! (Page 68)’ But that is where they are horribly mistaken because every accusation that came out of those children’s mouths are lies, LIES!…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Crucible quotes

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “To deflect punishment from themselves they accused others, and those who listened, themselves insecure their authority, acquiesced, partly because it served their interests to do so and partly because they inhabited a world in which witchcraft formed a part of their cosmology.” vii and viii…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The history of the witch trials is a grime, gruesome, and shocking reminder of what people are capable of. To say living 17th century Europe was miserable would be a gross understatement. The legal system that Cesare Beccaria advocated reform of was plagued in injustice and corruption, this was one of the leading factors for the terrible conditions in Europe. Attributing the witch trials to mass hysteria, socioeconomic problems and division between the people is fair. However, religious zealots should take most of the responsibility. As the first…

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Joan Of Arc Analysis

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The trial of Joan of Arc is well documented and detailed. It lasted approximately 5 months in which the last 2 months “she was under a merciless interrogation by theologians from the University of Paris. The charges against her were sorcery, wantonness, sedition, idolatry, blasphemy, heretical belief, superstitious practices and, most important, her refusal to accept the authority of the church” (Gossman, p.8). The severity of the interrogation shows an evil side of humanity, the way people (even religious people) can twist and contort words and actions to their benefit.…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays