Preview

What Is Karen Dill's Theory Of Procedural Justice

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1145 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Is Karen Dill's Theory Of Procedural Justice
These two political theorists have very contrasting notions of justice in a procedural sense. John Rawls believed that justice is based upon the fairness of the process, for all, and that not outcome justifies evil means. Justice as fairness is the main theme throughout his work, Machiavelli, on the other hand, argued that the means are immaterial when the outcome benefits the ruler. Justice is based upon the absolute rule of the Prince. Death Note depicts many of the theories that these two theorists had. There is a narrative of a lack of procedural justice and whether it is justified to attain world peace. The two main characters have contradictory views of justice and spend most of the series mentally and philosophically battling each other. …show more content…
In one of her chapters, she discusses how aggression in the media tends to seep out into the lives of the viewer. She's says that “The more you see people hurting each other, disrespecting each other, and treating each other poorly, the more that makes its way into your consciousness. That’s especially true with the way aggression is generally portrayed in the media—as cool, gratifying, fun, and without consequences.”(Dill pg.67) Although her analysis mainly focuses on the way video games increases the level of aggression, the same could be said for any form of popular culture. DeathNote is a perfect example for how aggressive nature affects the psychology of it’s target audience. The depiction of a main character who at first seems like he’s trying to do good, but uses very aggressive means, like murder, to accomplish them influences the viewer's notions. There have been certain cases, throughout the globe, where students replicated death notes and list names of people in them. In Connecticut, a death note was found containing students’ names in it (WMUR news). The impact of students is significant, because there is a fine line between copying what is seen in fictional shows and actually acting upon it. This show is detrimental because of the way that it depicts a lack of procedural justice, framing the narrative as one person who gains the power to murder, and tries to use that power for good, but ends up as

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Maggie Cutler’s essay, “Whodunit- The Media?” the author communicates how media violence influences children in a real life state persuading them to become more violent (Cutler 684). Individuals do not realize that children not only become aggressive because of their home atmosphere or certain life situations, but also because they are easily influenced by the media. The media plays a major role in childrens’ lives, even if the situation just involves watching innocent cartoons on the television. Movies can pressure children to become more hostile as a person. Maggie Cutler analyzes in her essay, “Whodunit- The Media?”, how media affects children, demonstrating that children who are involved in violent media are more susceptible to practice it.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A popular topic for authors lately seems to be the decline of humanity and morals. Dystopian novels are one of the most popular genres right now. However, authors haven’t just begun to write about violence recently. Many past authors ushered in this generation by using character traits to express themes and morals. An example of this is The Most Dangerous Game by Richard Connel. Connel uses character choices and tone in the story The Most Dangerous Game to express a theme of “ignorance leads to violence.”…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violent video games, violent music lyrics, movies, and cartoons cater to young, impressionable minds and implant value systems which we would consider quite inappropriate in them. Some of these societal influences are the ones that shape a child’s behavior. Insensitivity to the value of life, to ethics, to ethical practices is held in high esteem by the media we encounter every single day of our lives. This passes on to children and invariably they end up believing in things that can lead them to get themselves involved in anti-social activities. The protagonist in a movie might kill a villain and harp about this as a great achievement. Here the value of life is understated and not given due importance. Minor, everyday things like these build up, starting small but growing into something quit big and sinister.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In US, people believe violent media corrupts the minds of the youth and provokes violent actions and behaviors. Whenever there is a violent crime or act being committed by children, the first culprit the media turns to are violent video games or TV shows. In the case of one of the most infamous school shootings, Columbine, the news immediately blamed the shooting on played violent video games and music. There was no conclusive evidence for this statement, but the public still believed it. Gerard Jones, author of several works of fiction and nonfiction, writes the article, “Violent Media is Good for Kids”, to counter this popular belief that violent media is the cause of violent behavior. He brings up points on the topic that states that creative…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author Dave Grossman, in his essay “We Are Training Kids To kill, talking about how he believes that media and modern day technology and violent video games are reasons for child violence worldwide. Grossman goes on to relate and use his experience in the military to the violence in the youth and younger generation as emphasis. In the article Grossman is very disturbed regarding today’s youth. He starts off by mentioning about the cluster of suicides that occurred in the 1970’s due to local TV reporting numerous teen suicides. This led to numerous copycat suicides by teenagers that had seen the stories on the news. Once they researched this and discovered the rises in suicides were linked to the news articles, the networks pulled it from the air. As a result, the suicide numbers went down. Grossman goes on to say that the average child watches way too much TV in the home on a weekly basis. So they learn more from TV than they do their parents and teachers combined. Due to this fact, we need to be careful what we put on TV. Children are very impressionable and vulnerable and can be persuaded very easily by what they see.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this short essay about violence in television and video games it starts off talking about a very popular TV show at one point the sopranos. the author then goes on to talk about how in one of the episodes of sopranos Tony television and video games it starts off talking about a very popular TV show at one point the sopranos. the author then goes on to talk about how in one of the episodes of sopranos Tony Soprano murders one of his associates and dismembers the body and dumped the body parts. then the author talks about a few months later to brothers where caught for strangling and cutting her head and hands off and the only reason they were caught is because…

    • 322 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rudhra Mathiarasan MLA

    • 771 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Only 16% of all broadcast programs show the long-term negative effects of violence. (crisis connection.inc). This activities has been disturbing the cultural values of our society and this sets a bad example for the next generation.…

    • 771 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Prince

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One of the major themes in The Prince was Statesmanship and Warcraft. Much of The Prince describes precisely how to conduct a good war. Another major theme in The Prince is Goodwill and Hatred. Machiavelli shares his beliefs that being hated can be the cause of a prince’s downfall and that goodwill is just a political tool to assure the prince’s ruling. The last theme in The Prince is freewill because the success or failure of a prince is caused by his own free will.…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Due to this fact, the connection between violence and aggression is self-evident, and the continual stream of violence through these forms of media do not help the matter in any regard. This is supported by Nancy C. Cornwell’s statement that “research supports a correlation between media violence and aggression.” Media can send many messages to those who are exposed to it, but this statement suggests that a less than savory ideal may be sent to younger audiences who happen to be exposed to it. As is evidenced by the fact that this influence from a form of media can be found in many cases where someone from a younger audience took the ideals portrayed too far. This is shown to be fact instead of speculation due to copycat crimes that can lead to devastating reenactments of fictionalized drama and horror being implemented in reality. There are many examples that support this statement like this given statement from Cornwell’s article “violence in Media,” “The numerous anecdotal examples of copycat rapes, suicides and violent crime, closely mimicking television drama, movie scenes and provocative song lyrics” (Cornwell). With the added perspective derived from this statement supplied by Cornwell, these ideas show the realistic evidence supplied by the facts given, which garners a far more vast well of knowledge, that leads to the…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violent media influence the psychology and society. Many teachers, parents, and scientists blame the violent media that bring negatively affects. For example, a lot of news have reported the violent media cause violent incidents so far. Parents restrict their children away from the violent games because they assume violent games, which affect their children unhealthy psychology while they are growing up. However, violent media also can bring advantage: developing coping skills, taking away stress, and entertaining fun moment.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    TV's True Violence

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In her Newsweek article “TV’s True Violence” Meg Greenfield argues that excessive fictional violence desensitizes viewers to the image of violence they see on television. Her discussion about this subject “generates hypocrisy and confusion”: the coarsening impact of violence on viewers, the effect on children, the volume of the violence, and the harm of dulling our response to the real thing. Everyone knows that there is too much violence on Television and that the networks must take action. Sex and violence are mixing on the screen and are becoming a “single phenomenon” and everyone knows that this phenomenon can have negative effects on the viewers’ behavior. Greenfield reveals that this “coarsening” makes “the unthinkable just a little less unthinkable, a little more OK.” Two objections Meg Greenfield has, the first is not to the violence itself, but to the volume and the way it is presented on Television. In the history of art violence has frequently played a role in , literature, art, and for example in Shakespeare’s plays, but violence back then had actually meant something. The second objection to TV’s fictional violence is that it will affect the viewer’s reaction to the real thing, for instance, the images of the wounded kids in “Sarajevo” and in other massacres and wars. Greenfield believes that We need to be able to respond appropriately to the images of violence. While every thinking person would agree there is too much violence on TV, the solution Greenfield offers is flawed. Watching more real violence on TV would complicate the issue, because real violence can be biased, desensitizing and manipulated.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the movie “Natural Born Killers” by Oliver Stone, a couple goes on a killing rampage over a three-week course road trip. After its premiere, there were multiple murders that the movie was blamed for inspiring. (9) This movie illustrates how dangerous this group of people is and the power of the media. One of the primary questions this movie raises is why do we as a society allow a movie that is so disturbing and likely to induce heinous crimes to be shown. Although we have freedom of speech in this country, we do not have the freedom to make a movie that will most likely induce murder. (10) A system needs to be developed that will limit these types of media programs. Research as to how this group can be controlled and handled is also needed. Life long sentencing in high security facilities may be is required for this group. There is not much information available on the cause of this condition. (11) If early detection is possible, then teachers and other professionals should be on the lookout for this personality type. This is probably the only group of people that society may not be able to help and needs to be locked up under tight…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Most importantly, violent role-playing games are unbeneficial to teenagers because they teach students to engage in violent acts. Killer has violent themes involved with the activity. Students are forced to engage in violent acts in order to win. These acts may include shooting each other, killing students, and suggesting violence in order to win. The rules of the game are, in order to win, students must shoot each other with water guns. There is a chart for how many kills the groups achieve. The groups are called assassins, and each team must kill others. This game can also, with the suggested violence, make students fear the real world, as the school is a safe ground. This makes the real world seem more violent than it actually is, as portrayed…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In other words, the author tries to talk about the disadvantages of violent movies. Watching TV and movies are common ways to relax; however, they are filled with violent scenes. Like UFC, a competition of wrestling. In my opinion, I really hate this show, because it is too cruel, and I can not see the humanity in here. Whenever one player punch as an other player’s face, I can hear applause and laughter; this makes me uncomfortable. Another scary show is The Walking Dead. When I first heard this name, I was not interested in it. Then I watched a little bit, and I figured out I did not like it, because all I could see are blood and kill, all I could hear was scream. I even had a nightmare when I watched the walking dead. However, there are 11.5 million people watch The Walking Dead. Through watching violent movies, children may not care about human beings, may not know how to respect other people. The International Society for Research on Aggression (IRSA) concluded that evidence shows that media violence consumption can act as a trigger for aggressive thoughts or feelings already stored. It is a useless way for children to grow up; therefore, we should choose the movie and TV shows carefully, not letting violence cover our…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Manifestations Of Violence

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Soon after, this was disregarded by the judge because there was no way to prove that that was the reason for the shooting. Manifestations of violence in many forms of media are believed to be not a new phenomenon, but an “example of history repeating itself” (Richardson and Scott 3). Studies show by the time an average American reaches the age of 18, they’ve witnessed 16,000 simulated murders and 200,000 acts of violence (Richardson and Scott 4). Cartoons have contained as much as 80 violent acts per showing as well as commercials for children’s television portray 50-60 times more violence than adult television programs since 2000 (Richardson and Scott). Also, rap musics profound and violent language doesn’t stop its sales, for Americans “purchased over $1.5 billion [in 1999] and rose up to “$1.8 billion in 2000”…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays