The introduction has a clear thesis that directly states the paper’s central argument. Use of Evidence / 20 points The essay’s argument is thoroughly supported by evidence (brief quotes) from throughout the assigned sources. The evidence that is presented is relevant and directly supports the thesis, is presented in a clear and effective manner, and is properly cited. The evidence that is presented is representative of the sources and is not taken out of context. All major points are supported by evidence. Paragraph Structure / 5 points Body paragraphs have one topic or central point each. All paragraphs are relevant and focused. Paragraphs have a clear topic sentence that states the main point of the paragraph. Focus, Development & Quality of Argument / 40 points The essay has a central argument that is logical and fully answers the question asked. (No major parts are ignored) The essay is focused, well-organized, and does not wander off-topic. The argument is sound, accurately and effectively answers the question, does not contain any major logical fallacies, and does not ignore evidence that would contradict it. Conventions / 10 points The essay has been proofread and contains a minimum of spelling and grammar errors. The essay is clear, easy to follow, and is written in an appropriate tone. Quotes are presented properly: with quote marks, proper footnotes, and in the block format if over 50 words. All quotes and paraphrased material has been cited and footnotes follow the Chicago Manual of Style guidelines. Conclusion / 5 points The essay has a clear conclusion that effectively summarizes and reinforces the main argument and does not introduce new ideas, topics, or
The introduction has a clear thesis that directly states the paper’s central argument. Use of Evidence / 20 points The essay’s argument is thoroughly supported by evidence (brief quotes) from throughout the assigned sources. The evidence that is presented is relevant and directly supports the thesis, is presented in a clear and effective manner, and is properly cited. The evidence that is presented is representative of the sources and is not taken out of context. All major points are supported by evidence. Paragraph Structure / 5 points Body paragraphs have one topic or central point each. All paragraphs are relevant and focused. Paragraphs have a clear topic sentence that states the main point of the paragraph. Focus, Development & Quality of Argument / 40 points The essay has a central argument that is logical and fully answers the question asked. (No major parts are ignored) The essay is focused, well-organized, and does not wander off-topic. The argument is sound, accurately and effectively answers the question, does not contain any major logical fallacies, and does not ignore evidence that would contradict it. Conventions / 10 points The essay has been proofread and contains a minimum of spelling and grammar errors. The essay is clear, easy to follow, and is written in an appropriate tone. Quotes are presented properly: with quote marks, proper footnotes, and in the block format if over 50 words. All quotes and paraphrased material has been cited and footnotes follow the Chicago Manual of Style guidelines. Conclusion / 5 points The essay has a clear conclusion that effectively summarizes and reinforces the main argument and does not introduce new ideas, topics, or