Preview

Where Am I Dennett Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
689 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Where Am I Dennett Analysis
I have been called upon by the government to use my philosophical knowledge to many issues regarding Dennett in “Where am I”. The topic being addressed here, is whether or not Dennett from “Where am I” is two people. Two people meaning that there are two distinct entities that control Dennett, and each entity meets the criteria for personhood. I believe this to be true, and I will present my reasoning for this, which should be sufficient enough for the court to understand that it is highly likely for Dennett to be two people.
Dennett's claim is that his own brain (Yorick) is controlling his body remotely through radio signals, and that a computerized version of his brain (Hubert) is also capable of controlling his body. Dennett has a device with a switch, and flipping this switch will change whether Hubert or Yorick will be the mind controlling his body. At first, Dennett was unable to even detect which mind was controlling his body, as Hubert was created as an exact mind replica of Yorick. Even though Hubert and Yorick were initially qualitatively similar, differing experiences lead to them diverging, meaning they became distinct
…show more content…
This is much easier to do, since Yorick can be shown to be a person whether you are a believer of dualism or materialism. Yorick is the same brain that Dennett always had, it was just surgically removed from his body and given the capability to operate Dennett’s body through wires and radio signals. Yorick has thoughts, desires, beliefs, and gives Dennett the ability to have conversations, which means that Yorick displays first, second, and third-order intentionality, all of which are required for personhood. We don’t have to prove if Yorick is a mind, because that is known, and we don’t have to reply on dualism views, because Yorick is a physical object (a brain) so the materialist viewpoint would also accept Yorick as a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    It is very difficult to attribute characteristics to a mind when we know it does not actually exist in the physical realm. Though, personal identity has been connected to the mind. However, it is tricky to determine what exactly comprises one’s personal identity. Although it is a difficult concept to grasp, philosophers such as Nagel and Chisholm attempt to construct their own position on the characteristics of the mind. By comparing Nagel and Chisholm’s positions on personal identity, it is evident that identity is a development of both body and mind. Nagel shows that we cannot properly identify a mind, and if this is the case then it is impossible to attribute personal identity to a mind. In turn, he attacks the idea that personal identity can be defined in terms of physical attributes. Chisholm shows that although things are constantly changing, they still remain the same. He argues that it is the mind that holds our identity, regardless of physical alteration. In my view, the physicalist perspective of identity is the most logical when contrasted to the mentalist argument simply due to the fact that we do have a self-identity, and Nagel does not attempt to define what it is. Locke’s argument finds a middle ground between Nagel and Chisholm as he argues for a conscious and bodily continuity of the mind.…

    • 1610 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With his brain removed from his body, though still connected and in total control of his body through radio transmitters, he asked one simple question. Where am I? Though at first most people would say, Dennett is where he stands and his brain is now controlling him externally instead of internally. Sure this makes sense, but then the question arises, then which thing is really Daniel Dennett, the brain or the body? Dennett came up with three explanations.…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The view of interest here holds to the objection that personal identity is anything but ubiquitous, but rather the set of characteristics in question form a personality, which a person merely possesses as a holding, a constitutive of personal consciousness. On this view, a person can change their personality without having their identity annihilated in the strict sense implied by Hume, because one’s personality as well as the personality traits is constitutive of personal identity. Based on how this idea has been refined in recent paragraphs, I propose we rename it personality as a constitutive of personal identity or personality as a constitutive for short. The basis for personality as a constitutive has been that personal identity as a static…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What Are We?

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In this section ‘I think, therefore I am’ Alsford looks into human beings as subjects and refers to the philosophy of Rene Descartes concerning human nature. Descartes theorized that if he thought that something is false and he is the one thinking it, he states: “I think, therefore I am.” Descartes philosophy continues to dominate Western thought and culture even to this day.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Due to the fact that there has been and forever will be a debate concerning the level of importance of man, human identity is rendered impossible to completely understand. The direct result of this debate is that there is no conclusion reached as to who the human beings truly are and what their universal importance may be.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There is a human organism located exactly where you are located. Eric Olson argues that you are identical to that organism. This view is known as animalism. His “thinking animal” argument takes the following form: (1) There is a human animal where you are located; (2) If there’s a human animal where you are located, it is thinking; (3) The only thing thinking where you are located is you; and (4) So, you are a human animal. One argument, which exhibits parallel reasoning and boasts premises motivated in the exact same way, may be employed to resist Olson’s argument. In this paper I will show that this argument, which I will now call the Guanilo-Style argument, is structurally identical to Olson’s argument, but which yields a conclusion that is implausible. This will render Olson’s argument unsound, as any objections raised to the Guanilo-Style argument must also be raised to Olson’s argument.…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reid believes that personal identity consists of two things: 1) trying to get a clear interpretation what identity is 2) trying to get a clear interpretation on what a persons is. He thinks that identity is a perfectly clear notion, and is indefinable. Reid's first criticism rest on him interpreting Locke's definition that a person is a subject of thought, which Reid believes is implying that a person is a thinking substance. Reid criticizes Locke's response to the questions that are formed from interrupted consciousness, and that it is possible for a person to be "transferred from one intelligent being to another," or for "two or twenty intelligent beings to be the same person"(Locke). Reid's criticism is not that the cases of transfer or disruption are incongruous, although he does think they are. Instead, that the possibility of a person being the same without thinking the same, as the Memory Theory so blantly allows is contradictory with Locke's interpretation of a person as a thinking being . Reid then concludes this as an absurdity in the Memory Theory. Another criticism Reid uses is the case of the Brave Officer. For this case Reid states:…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Searle Dualism

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages

    John Searle and Rene Descartes both had opinions on dualism. John believe different aspects like mental and physical both are one substance. Rene, on the other hand, believes two different substances like mental and physical are different things. Rene even talked about how thoughts and feelings that are nonmaterial exists in material place.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Fifth Business

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Scientist, psychologist, biologist all pose the question of How the complex human mind develops, Robertson Davies shows the rise, zenith and decent of his character Dunstan Ramsey. The development of Dunstan Ramsey, in Fifth Business, is associated with the psychological rebirth. Jungian psychology identifies this as individuation. Daryl Sharp simply explains individuation in The Jung Lexicon as; “Induced by ritual or stimulated by immediate personal experience, it results in an enlargement of the personality” [Sharp, 4]. In terms of Fifth Business, Diana, Faustina, Mrs. Dempster and Liesl fulfill the role of ‘stimulus’, meanwhile Dunstan Ramsey absorbs this profound knowledge, in his quest to become Fifth Business.…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Each time I gaze into a mirror, or respond to a question or assert a preference that requires a personal perspective, ‘I’ thereby assume an idea of personal identity. As ordinary common sense dictates, that personal perspective is my own insofar as I maintain a sense of ownership of my personal identity. In this view of ordinary common sense, ‘I’ assume ownership in light of the perception of ‘me’, ‘I’, or ‘myself’ (my emphasis). However, in Hume’s view, to have first-person perception of me is to have experiences of bundles of impressions from past experiences that are as temporally distant as my youth, yet as temporally local as now. Accordingly, phenomenal experiences of personal identity occur in constant conjunctions of experiential data…

    • 196 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Philosophy Fifth Edition. John Perry, Michael Bratman, John Martin Fischer. Oxford University Press. 2010. )…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The mind-brain identity theory holds that mental states and processes are similar to that of the brain; in such that mind or consciousness is a mere physico-chemical process in…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    What Is Avram's Identity

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout the novel Yod learned to be a person simply by spending time with Shira and experiencing different emotions and feelings. He had all the knowledge on interpersonal skills and he was extremely capable of giving the specifics on the matter but it didn’t mean anything until he actually experienced all of the things he was preprogrammed to know. If Shira hadn’t spent time with Yod or given him the experiences that evoked emotion and feeling Yod wouldn’t have developed the sense of identity that he had. Yod and Shiras relationship shows how truly important it is to be aware of the people surrounding us, because they are factors that can change or modify our own identities…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “I can remember a single incident at the age of 12 when I clearly saw the formation of one of the other "me's". I was laying in my small bed, in my tiny closet-sized bedroom. I was enduring yet another middle-of-the-night visit from someone who terrorized me for all my childhood and much of the rest of my life. I was praying for him to finish and leave.…

    • 2744 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In his book The Talent Code, Daniel Coyle argues that “deep practice” accelerates skill devel-opment. Coyle states that the quickest way Individuals can achieve talent is through deep prac-tice.…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays