They spent quite a long time there until they met a group of Russian soldiers who told them the war has already ended. They also found out that there is a secret Germany man hide in the church of the village, who is also referred as “Dr. Sick” (81). Samad and Archie know exactly that Dr. Sick is still considered as a Nazi, so they could become hero by killing him. So Samad used his poker skills to win Dr. Sick as the prize from the Russians, and they left the village with him. When Samad was trying to kill the doctor, Archie actually managed to take the doctor with him and walked into a gun spot where he told Samad is a better place to kill the doctor. Then, after one gun shot, Archie came back, bleeding and limping. The book does not provide any clues about what happened behind those branches, readers do not know whether Archie actually killed the doctor or not, but he did came with blood. But from things that happen after, we know that Archie did not kill the doctor. He rather shot himself to lie to his best friend, than killing that Germany doctor. In fact there is lots of ways to think about this scene. In my point of view, although it is generous of Archie for not killing this man, but he failed to be an honest friend or a loyal soldier. As a friend, he betrayed his best friend, Samad, who was faithful to him and believed in him wholeheartedly. I am not stating that Dr. Sick should be killed, but Archie did lie to Samad, and there is a possibility that his this action would cause serious consequences. Archie could totally keep arguing with Samad until they found a solution that both of them agree. Secondly, Archie fights for the English Army, he is obligated to fight against his enemy. If he is truly loyal and do not want to kill Dr. Sick, he could totally take him back to their campus and let his superior to decide. More importantly, he did think or speak
They spent quite a long time there until they met a group of Russian soldiers who told them the war has already ended. They also found out that there is a secret Germany man hide in the church of the village, who is also referred as “Dr. Sick” (81). Samad and Archie know exactly that Dr. Sick is still considered as a Nazi, so they could become hero by killing him. So Samad used his poker skills to win Dr. Sick as the prize from the Russians, and they left the village with him. When Samad was trying to kill the doctor, Archie actually managed to take the doctor with him and walked into a gun spot where he told Samad is a better place to kill the doctor. Then, after one gun shot, Archie came back, bleeding and limping. The book does not provide any clues about what happened behind those branches, readers do not know whether Archie actually killed the doctor or not, but he did came with blood. But from things that happen after, we know that Archie did not kill the doctor. He rather shot himself to lie to his best friend, than killing that Germany doctor. In fact there is lots of ways to think about this scene. In my point of view, although it is generous of Archie for not killing this man, but he failed to be an honest friend or a loyal soldier. As a friend, he betrayed his best friend, Samad, who was faithful to him and believed in him wholeheartedly. I am not stating that Dr. Sick should be killed, but Archie did lie to Samad, and there is a possibility that his this action would cause serious consequences. Archie could totally keep arguing with Samad until they found a solution that both of them agree. Secondly, Archie fights for the English Army, he is obligated to fight against his enemy. If he is truly loyal and do not want to kill Dr. Sick, he could totally take him back to their campus and let his superior to decide. More importantly, he did think or speak