Preview

Why College Athletes Do Not Pay To Play

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
Pay to Play
Are athletes at Division 1-A colleges amateurs or are they really professionals? This question is argued by many people throughout the nation. Some say it’s unfair to others but some also say that it is a necessity for these athletes. With these athletes being full time students while playing sports, they don’t have any opportunities to make money. There are three specific reasons on why college athletes should get paid: It will pay for more than just textbooks, players give up their body for their school, and the NCAA makes money, so the players should too!

A Little Extra Student athletes do not have the free time to make money to support themselves. Michael Polak, a sportswriter for The Charleston Gazette and a resident of Charleston,
…show more content…

College football and men’s basketball generate revenues of more than $6 billion dollars every year. Yet these college athletes, who make this possible, don’t even get a little piece of that money. It only makes sense that since they contribute to the NCAA making all this profit, that they should get a reward for making these sports possible. Many of these athletes do get scholarships, but these scholarships usually do not even cover their tuition. Some of these athletes may have financial problems, and with a little help from the NCAA, they can pay for their tuition and not have to worry about money and focus on their school and athletics (Birkenes). Another problem is that even though student athletes are big part of campus life, the NCAA has created a monster that makes athletes try to focus more on their skill at their sport than trying to improve their education. If these athletes were paid, then they could focus on both and not have to think about their future in sports and try to improve their education in case they do not make it to the professional league (Staudohar and …show more content…

For most of these athletes, a successful educational pursuit will have to wait until their athletic careers are over. The organization of these players may be a good idea if it will provide an even distribution of money to the athletes. Although it is supported by the Steelworkers, it isn’t really considered a union. According to the National Labor Relations Act, rights to unionize only exist for “employees” which under their current status, they aren’t considered “employees” until they receive a wage (Staudohar and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the world, college athletics grows and continues to bring large financial benefits to colleges, universities and even sponsors. This leads to many debates concerning the payment of the athletes. Some people think that scholarship paid to colleges for these student athletes is enough while others claim that the payments might make them to leave the college early for participating in the athletics. Division 1 college athletes should be paid.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some colleges make more money than others. This graph shows the schools with the most profit in their sports programs. Somebody could say that the athletes bring in an enormous amount of money. According to Jeff Dorfman, a professor of Economics at the University of Georgia, only a few collegiate sports actually bring in money. Therefore, an athlete in a sport that isn’t very profitable wouldn’t make nearly get as much as an athlete in a very profitable sport. Along with the sports being very profitable they also have to pay for an even larger variety of different things. Student athletes should not be paid because of the money that would be paid to them. The money that they would be paid could be used to advance other things in the university such as better libraries, science labs, fixing up the dorms, or even improving their athletic facilities. Although the athletes put a lot of time into their schooling and sports the benefits they are given is equal to what they are giving and being…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article “7 Common Sense Reasons Why College Athletes Should Be Paid,” the author, Maurice Peebles conducts an interview with Jay Bilas to get his input on whether college athletes should be paid. He shares how the NCAA is a multi-billon dollar business that limits athletes in particular on earning money. Also, he gives examples of different perspectives that people can relate to in different industries of how this situation would apply to them. Furthermore, he explains that college athletes would benefit more from being paid and it would require them to get a better education by not allowing them to leave college early to go onto the professional stage. The school’s are benefitting much more than the players are because the players are the reason why all of this money is coming in, the schools are just being represented and then paid. The scholarships given do not equal to what some college athletes are worth, because some out there could easily…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The NCAA manages everything in college sports, and is considered a non-profit organization, all of the money they make is redistributed to the colleges that are part of the NCAA. Just football, and basketball generates 6 billion dollars a year, and not one penny of that money would've been made if it were not for the student athletes. In "Pay To Play: Should College Athletes Be Paid?," Adele Birkenes and Akash Bagaria who have written six articles about student life states "It is only reasonable that student athletes have a share in the millions of dollars that their sports businesses bring in." The statements by the authors bring to light this one simple question, why can the athletes be rewarded for making the NCAA and colleges successful? Although paying college athletes is not an easy decision for the people in charge, many support paying student athletes. There has been many proposals dating back to the 1950's, but there are five proposals that have a very good chance of getting passed, and used. In the article "Point/Counterpoint: Paying College Athletes," Dennis Johnson states "...former NCAA President Miles Brand's suggestion and allocate athletes include a $2,000-$3,000 cost of living increase to full scholarships...This would provide the athletes with the needed income for clothes, laundry, sundries, travel,…

    • 1883 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    The notion of paying college athletes has been an ongoing and controversial debate for student-athletes, coaches, schools, media and most certainly the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). Many would argue that playing major college sports is more like a job versus an extracurricular activity. As with the majority of many student athletes, some attend college with the aspiration of becoming professional players thereby college is seen as a means to end. Although student-athletes already receive compensation via full and partial scholarships to participate at the college level, passionate conversations will continue to be a topic of debate because of the enormous revenue generated by college sports.…

    • 3400 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why should kids be paid for doing a professionals job? The debate on whether or not to pay college athletes is a debate that has been argued for quite some time. Due to the lack of positive results, and a surplus of negatives, this should not take place. There is no way to muster up a fair system to pay the athletes while keeping everyone happy. Also, paying players will distract them from their academics due to them knowing that they can make money playing sports. Lastly, the athletes already have an opportunity for money with scholarships. Therefore, in order to keep college athletes happy and focused on school while still giving them an opportunity to receive scholarships, the students should not be paid for their athletic performances.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Several issues are involved in the heated debate on whether student-athletes should be paid by their institutions for their athletic services. Some believe that student-athletes receive more than enough compensation through their awarded scholarships. Others believe that student-athletes should be rewarded for hard work and the revenue they bring to their colleges and universities. To further the debate, the authors would like to review a few comments from both proponents and opponents of pay for collegiate student-athletes, to help readers gain a better understanding.…

    • 2489 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    We often look at college athletes as miniature stars. The question is, why should student’s athlete get a paycheck for playing amateur level sports? Athletes complain about how they do not get enough for playing a sport. They are forgetting that they are being rewarded with a half or full scholarship. The main goal for these athletes is being academically successful. Not who has the best jump shot or who fumbled a ball, that does not matter. The essence of playing college level has been taken out of place, now replaced with the mindsets of professional athletes. Did they forget? You are not professionals. The love of the game has been through extortion for the love of money. Paying college athletes will lead the students astray from what they attended the institution to accomplish in the first place, that is, to earn a degree, not to gain a compensation.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “...there is an obvious lack of appreciation of a college degree from those in favor of paying athletes,” quote by Dennis A. Johnson (Johnson 3). Athletes are supposed to focus on being a student first and an athlete second, and the payments would put the focus on athletics over academics (Terp 33). Finding a strategy to pay all college athletes would be very difficult, whereas the amount and method would be highly debatable. College athletes are provided with “...remarkable opportunities to get an education at the finest universities and to go professional if they want to,” stated by NCAA president, Mark Emmert (“Should” 3). Statistically shown, less than 2 percent of college athletes carry their athleticism into an actual career (“Should” 2).…

    • 1344 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    “The college sports industry generates $11 billion in annual revenues. Fifty colleges report annual revenues that exceed $50 million. Meanwhile, five colleges report annual revenues that exceed $100 million,” (Mitchell & Edelman). The money collected by the NCAA, goes towards the sports and the programs, not the players themselves, however, the NCAA says that “Student-athletes are at the heart of the NCAA’s mission,” (NCAA). “Some athletes and their supporters believe that college athletes deserve some type of financial payment for their services and contributions to their institutions, an opinion that has lead to player-initiated lawsuits, court cases, and strikes,” (Garcia).…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In some cases,a college’s athletic program is its main source of income. For example they can make money on selling items that show the athletes’ names or pictures on them; they sell tickets to the sporting events; and they get many donations from alumni and other fans and companies which want to support the athletes. Even though the colleges make money on all these things, they share none of it with the athletes. If it were not for the athletes, the school would not make money on any of those things. The college would not suffer financially if they gave each athlete a small salary in addition to their scholarship.The salary might make the athlete happier about playing the sport and they would try harder while playing or practicing. The practices or training that are required of the players consume most of their time – even in the off season they still have some sort of training.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Student athletes should be compensated for their work, as they are the sole reason for the Athletic Program’s surplus in revenue. These athletes are working for the schools and are doing a service to the college that seems to go unnoticed. Colleges are using these athletes to boost their respective reputations and bring in revenue while not compensating these athletes for their work. Everywhere else athletes are paid, so why shouldn’t college students too? Some critics may argue that these student-athletes are amateurs, and if paid then are becoming professional athletes. The minor league for baseball could be considered an amateur sport, although they do receive pay according to the team’s revenue.…

    • 872 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    College athletes have made over two billion dollars for colleges all over the country. Over the years, college athletic programs have been a growing business for colleges to make insane amounts of money. Being a player at a Division I university can be an emotionally fulfilling experience; however, universities see it as an opportunity to profit more than multi-million dollar companies. College athletes should be paid. The way college athletes are so electrifying on and off the court or field should be worth something, but all they are worth is a $58,000 scholarship. Duke University made over four million dollars being in the final four tournament in the 2015 season. In the 2015 article written by Nicole Pence, it states, “There have been a few schools in the NCAA who have adopted Obama's idea of paying college athletes 5,000 dollars a year plus their scholarship.” The growing business of college athletics will soon be bigger than the NBA. Colleges are all struggling with the decision to either spend more money on payrolls for athletes or lose good players. The college athlete is a fine tuned…

    • 2721 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Playing a college sport is like a full time job, except the lack of financial benefits. College football and men’s basketball generate revenue of more than $6 billion every year, yet no money goes toward paying the people that make the sports possible (Bagaria). College sports would be non-existent without the devoted athletes who work hard and spend countless hours each and every day. Whether practicing, training, or playing in games, these athletes are involved in their sport all seven days of the week. College athletes put in almost the same amount of work as professional players do, but instead of making millions, rather they are receiving no financial benefits (Bagaria). College athletes deserve to be paid because they sacrifice so much for their team and deserve compensation. Secondly, college athletes not only deserve money because of their devotion, they also need it for their everyday life. During their athletic season, they do not receive any sort of payment for their efforts which would aide them financially and in everyday life (Bagaria). Most scholarships cover cost of housing and textbooks, but leave out basics such as food. Logically athletes need food, but their time and energy is spent on a “job” as an athlete…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    "More than 460,000 college athletes make up the 19,000 teams that send more than 54,000 participants to compete each year in the NCAA's 90 championships in 24 sports across 3 divisions" (NCAA). This statistic is imprinted on the cover page of the National Collegiate Athletic Association’s (NCAA) official website. These teams are watched closely by many fans all year and bring in a large amount of money. The issue with the NCAA is that even though these 460,000 college athletes play their desired sport, none of them are payed for the job they are doing. It has been an American tradition for many years that people get payed for the job they do. However, colleges are failing to do this with their athletes. This problem is only getting worse as…

    • 2183 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays