Preview

wild salmon vs farmed salmon

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
392 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
wild salmon vs farmed salmon
Wild Salmon Vs. Farmed Salmon 1 Salmon is the third most consumed seafood in the U.S. (2010). Each person eats about 2 pounds a year. The source of this fish is acquired from two places, either a salmon farm or from the wild. There are definite positives and negative to both sources, but farmed salmon benefits both the consumer and the environment, while wild salmon only benefits the consumer.
2 Farming Salmon is very significant to the market demand. Annually, Americans consume 284,000 metric tons of salmon, more than 2/3rds of which is farmed salmon. Many wild salmon are blocked from migrating by damns thus preventing reproduction. If we didn’t farm salmon our supply would not fulfill our demands. Farmed Salmon is exponentially more sustainable than wild because reproduction is supervised. Many people even argue that farming salmon relieves stress on the population of natural salmon.
Wild Salmon is A lot harder to acquire than farmed. Wild salmon has to be caught, transported and distributed while farmed salmon is already caught and only needs to be distributed. Farmed Salmon allows for salmon availability year round. Farmed Salmon is a huge industry, in Alaska, Salmon Farming makes up more than 50 of total direct and indirect statewide employment and is worth one billion in there state economy.
Farmed Salmon is very regulated. Farmers work with professionals that can prevent disease, lice and other toxins from inhibiting the fish and make for a far healthier fish. Farmed salmon also is very high in omega 3 and certain fatty acids, giving certain nutritional benefits exclusively to farmed salmon. Farming Salmon has very little affect on the environment unlike wild salmon fishing, which eventually will wipe out the population. In recent decades the wild salmon population seems to be in a constant decline. The cause is due to numerous things like: lice, damns, natural causes and other marine life. Many would argue salmon are dying

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the 1960s, a species of baitfish called alewife invaded the Great Lakes and started to die off by the millions due to overpopulation. In 1967, the DNR began planting Chinook Salmon, a prolific open water predator, to control the alewife population. In the process, the DNR created one of the best sport fisheries in the world. A fishery capable of bringing billions of dollars a year to the Michigan economy. In recent years the alewife population declined with the last three years being the lowest on record. The DNR had to act fast in order to avoid having the fishery crash, like if did in Lake Huron. The DNR reduced the Chinook Salmon stockings. Reasons the DNR did the right thing is; the alewives will hopefully rebound, Chinook Salmon are not as useful to the lake as other species, and there will be more food for other game fish.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    3) We know that the Bristal Bay watershed sustains one of the most productive fisheries in the world – Alaska’s wild salmon fishery – and that the fishery generates over $400 million each year.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Carl Safina’s writings of Song for the Blue Ocean, he reflects on his and others take on what is currently going on to the salmon across the Northwest. As you can clearly see from his writing he truly admires this animal and so do many of the people he introduces us to. He shares with us the ridicule’s many industries, whom are harming the salmon have laid plainly before us and we fall for without any second thought.…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article, “River Plan Too Fishy for My Taste Buds,” written by Bill McEwen, he express his expectations and concerns toward the river restoration plan on the San Joaquin River. You might wonder how long ago was this? McEwen wrote these concerns in 2009! It has been approximately six years since these articles were published. Now we are able to analyze the results of the river restoration program and how it affected the people and animals involved with it. We can evaluate if the river conditions were unsuitable for the salmon to thrive as previously believed. The river restoration program can also be studied to see if it is boondoggle. In addition, are the farmers greedy when it comes to the San Joaquin River?…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first thing I look for when I buy salmon is quality and to me that means wild-caught, not farm raised salmon. The problem here is the vast majority of salmon sold in stores is sold as being “wild” from the Atlantic Ocean but this is not completely true. The trick here is fisheries are allowed to market their salmon as “wild” as long as the fish is allowed to swim in the Atlantic Ocean. However, they are still being fed processed food pellets. The main difference between wild and farm raised is their diet, which affects the overall quality of the fish. There are even health considerations that should be taken if farm raised fish is frequently consumed. Wild salmon from Alaska are considered by many as the best source of quality salmon available. Since this fishery was based out of Alaska I had some confidence I would be paying for the best salmon out there and they delivered on their promise.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bluefin Tuna Effect

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Some around the world enjoy eating a lot of food; they try to discover some new food from the different countries. Sushi is one kind of food to make people like to eat; it is a famous food in Japan and around the world: America, China, and the others. Sushi has some ingredients: rice, seaweed sheets, seafood, vegetables, and tropical fruit sauce. However Bluefin tuna sushi is the best to make some like the most. As a result, at this time some want to have more Bluefin tuna so that over ten hundred of thousand dollars people can buy a Bluefin tuna (Richardson). Since the high demand and price have stimulated, some fishermen work hard to catch more and more Bluefin. What is the happening? The overall ecosystem and economy the world are influenced…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Frankenfish Summary

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The article “FrankenFish” is an article that expresses the pros and cons of the different impacts Genetically Engineered (GE) Salmon has on our health and environment. However, this particular article has a greater emphasis on cons rather than pros. According to the article GE Salmon has a negative effect on human health. Clearly, we see that it caused kidney impairment in rats fed with GE corn also there are skin and lung problems caused in mice fed with GE foods. Therefore, results in humans may not be very good. GE Salmon may also have a negative impact on wild fish, as they will drive out the wild fish and rule out the fish by taking over food and habitat. However, the positive side of GE salmon is that it will be bigger in size and readily will be available in the food industry as they reproduce faster. The article also talks about how GE Salmon impacts the fishing communities and how it impacts our food system. In the article we are also told about the general ways in which GE Salmon may spread disease if they are released into the wild affecting the natural Salmon. On the other hand the article also shows how Food and Drug Administration is about to approve AquaBounty’s (AB) idea of having GE Salmon. In the article it also states that this fish will be sold without any labels or notifications to show that it is genetically engineered Salmon. In conclusion we see from that article that many factors concerning Humans and the Environment are at risk rather than benefit by the approval of GE…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Over fishing has led to an almost complete wipe out of the mature cod population in the area of Northern Europe. With lack of regulations, the world could witness an entire species of fish destroyed due to rational behavior of man to want more. This is a classic example of a “commons” which Garrett Hardin discusses in his essay “The Tragedy of the Commons” (Hardin, 1968). The North Atlantic Cod is a natural resource that, although regulated minutely, is being overfished and exploited. Even though the fishing industry is an important industry that feeds many third world countries and provides income to most of those countries also, allowing the exploitation is unacceptable. Today’s society is not effectively reducing or efficiently stopping the damage that is being done to the populations and environment. In order to solve the problem of over fishing cod in the Northern Atlantic we must apply a combination of technical and ethical solutions. I would have the United Nations pass specific laws regulating major fish populations which could be an extension of the Third Committee: Social, Cultural, and Humanitarian or (SOCHUM) of the United Nations. I would also have specific incentives put up by SOCHUM to promote research into developing more widespread aquacultures and better fishing technology that better targets older species of fish.…

    • 2073 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Fishing can disrupt food chains. For example krill fishing in the southern ocean is depleting food supplies for whales and penguins. Overfishing of a species can severely deplete its population, sometimes beyond recovery. Overfishing of the patagonian toothfish in the Antarctic is currently a concern. Bottom trawling catches fish by dragging nets along the sea-bed. This disrupts the eco system by reducing light levels thought increasing turbidity and catches other species as well as the target one. Its carried out in the gull of Alaska, the greenland sea and the barents sea. Fishing quotes have been introduced to limit the number of fish caught and prevent overexploitation of the resource.…

    • 338 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Salmon Without Rivers

    • 1998 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The story of the Pacific salmon is a tragic one. Humans have consistently created conditions that threaten the livelihood of the salmon. Yet the salmon continue to fight despite the assault that has taken place on their habitat for over 150 years. In Salmon Without Rivers, Jim Lichatowich (1999) explores this assault as well as discusses man’s attempt to restore salmon to the Pacific Northwest. His detailed analysis of the history of the Pacific salmon sheds light on the plight of the salmon and the response by man to the salmon crisis in the Pacific.…

    • 1998 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The term Northwest Coast is used in anthropology studies to communicate of the groups of Indigenous people living along the coast of British Columbia. The People of the North West Coast People came to BC over 10 000 years ago. This Aboriginal group consisted of several other nations, individually they all had a distinctive culture and political characteristics. On the other hand, they were similar in their traditions and practices of their use of salmon and other ocean animals such as clams, crabs, oysters, mussels, seaweed, seals and sometimes even whales as their way of surviving in this habitat (Canada’s First people, 2007).…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In research by Cook et al., genetically modified salmon were shown to exhibit a 2.14 – 2.62 fold increase in overall body weight, as well as lower protein, energy and lipid levels. Additionally, Cook found that when genetically modified salmon were deprived of food for an extended period of time, they showed increased oxygen consumption, less body protein, and faster lipid and energy consumption rate than wild type salmon. This suggests that the likelihood of genetically modified salmon achieving a maximum growth size, or even surviving in habitats that have fewer resources, are much lower than the wild type of salmon. More importantly, differences in abdominal wall thickness, as well as muscle fibre width and height were observed by Hill et al. in a comparison of genetically modified salmon and wild type salmon. Observable differences in red and white muscle recruitment were also noted by Hill, with genetically enhanced salmon showing more red muscle recruitment and lower white muscle recruitment than the wild type. Red muscle fibres are considered to be fast twitch fibres, specializing in short, anaerobic and intense muscle activity movement. White muscle fibres are slow twitch fibres, which specialize in aerobic, repetitive,…

    • 2891 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, she brings up that wild salmon are in decline because of over-fishing, open water cages, pollution, disease, and consumption. She says that because of how AquaBounty salmon is raised and fed, they would take pressure off wild salmon and make salmon farming more sustainable. She makes a sound point here. Her reasons are that AquaBounty salmon is raised in on-shore recirculation systems that eliminate escapement,…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    A world away from everyday businesses and corporate office cubicles, commercial salmon fishing in Alaska isn’t the ordinary boat ride. Every season, the Alaskan salmon fisherman put their lives at stake in hopes of good pay and the experience of a lifetime. The populations and economy of every fishing village in Bristol Bay flourish during the salmon season. Salmon bring in people from literally, all corners of the globe. The excitement, raw adventure, and potential for a great compensation that commercial fishing possesses is something very few occupations offer. Fishing is a gamble, a new kind of reality. Fisherman are gambling and putting everything on the line: their sanity, body, and life. Only when they’re out on that 32-foot long fishing vessel do they realize how insignificant and small they really are in the middle of Bristol Bay. Fishermen are at the mercy of Mother Nature and all she can throw and propel at you. Commercial fishing in Alaska is not for the weak minded or faint of heart.…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Saving the Pacific Salmon

    • 2652 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Salmon are one of the most important fish species in the world, and in the Pacific Northwest the fish are a way of life for many species of plants and animals, including humans. The major problem that humans are facing is that the population of wild salmon is dangerously low as compared to historic numbers due to over-fishing and human degradation (including dams, chemical pollution and land use impacts.). Pacific Salmon are now extinct in forty percent of the rivers they once thrived in (Four Fish). Zoologist George Suckley stated in 1854, that the Pacific coast salmon were “one of the striking wonders of the region...these fish....astonish by number, and confuse with variety.”(In a Sea of Trouble) and that “The quantities for salmon which frequent these waters is beyond calculation, and seems to be so great as to challenge human ingenuity to effect it in any way.” (In a Sea of Trouble). In order to get a better grasp on the problems humans are causing we need to first understand the salmon's life cycle.…

    • 2652 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays